Case File
efta-efta00610276DOJ Data Set 9OtherDeutsche Bank
Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
efta-efta00610276
Pages
26
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available
Extracted Text (OCR)
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
Deutsche Bank
Markets Research
Global
Foreign Exchange
FX Spot
FX Blueprint
Thin end of the wedge
Theme #1: Holler for dollars: Buy USD vs. NZD, CHF, SGD, buy EUR/USD risk
reversal
Theme #2: Play it again, san: Buy USD/JPY
Theme #3: Home Counties trump Mounties: Buy GBP/CAD
Theme #4: Swiss
-Out: Sell CHF/NOK
Theme #5: Dingo unchained: Buy AUD/NZD
Theme #6: SEK to score with thaw: Sell EUR/SEK, buy EUR/NOK put
Theme #7: Trend not bitter end: Follow trend in JPY and CAD
Theme #8: Balti not faulty, China still finer: Buy USD/INR put, buy USD/SGD,
sell USD/CNH, sell JPY/KRW
Theme #9: Pole dances, TRY trips: Sell EURIPLN, sell USD/ILS, sell EUR/HUF,
sell EUR/RUB, buy USD/TRY
Theme #10: Pesos no prickly pair. Buy MXN vs. USD, CLP, RUB, buy CLP/COP
Theme #11: Vol to roll: Buy EUR/USD FVAs, USD/JPY vol swaps and risk
reversals, AUD/USD puts
r4
9 January 2014
'Research Team
London
Bilel Hafeez
James Malcolm
Henrik Gullberg
George Sarevelos
Siddhanh Kapoor
Oliver Harvey
Nicholas Weng
New York
Alan Ruskin
Daniel Brehon
Dreusio GiacomoIli
Guilherme Marone
Singapore
Sameer Goel
Ma'like Sadie!eye
Perry Kojodjojo
Sydney
Adam Boyton
Tokyo
Teisuke Tanaka
Head of FX Strategy
Bilel Hafeez
Deutsche Bank AG/London
DISCLOSURES AND ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS ARE LOCATED IN APPENDIX 1. MICA(P) 054/04/2013.
EFTA00610276
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin and of the wedge
Overview
Sticking to regime change; dollar uptrend
2013 marked a fundamental regime change from the
crisis-prone 2008-2012 period. The dollar's correlation
to equities flipped, the euro-area avoided a crisis and
the Fed announced a rolling back, rather than an
expansion, of QE. If there was a locus of crisis it was in
emerging markets, which felt the shock of Fed taper.
This could hint that the 1990s dynamic of first half
dollar weakness and developed market crises and
second half dollar strength and emerging market crises
could be repeating itself.
We therefore remain committed dollar bulls. If last year
was all about the US long-end being re-priced on taper,
2014 will mark the re-pricing of the US short-end.
December's Fed decision therefore represents only the
thin end of the wedge for US interest rate
normalization and its effect on markets. This should
allow the USD to strengthen against the core European
hold-outs to dollar strength, the euro, Swiss franc and
pound. The equity flow picture should finally move in
favour of the US as slow-moving capital adjusts to the
new DM regime. Our favourite expression of dollar
strength would be to buy it against the three most
over-valued currencies in the world, the New Zealand
Dollar, Swiss franc and Singaporean dollar.
Yen trend still down
While we are looking for a reversal in core European
currency trends, on the yen we remain firmly in the
bearish camp and look for a trend extension from last
year. What adds to our confidence is that major yen
turns tend to see the yen move by 43% on average,and
we're nowhere near such a move yet. On fundamentals,
the BoJ is also conspicuous amongst the major central
banks in ramping up QE, the basic balance of
payments is heavily negative and foreigners have yet to
unwind their safe-haven inflows to Japan that were
accumulated in the crisis years.
Rest of G10
We underestimated UK growth in 2013, but for 2014
we intend not to miss the changes in the UK economy.
The starkest one will likely be the pick-up in inflation,
which will only add to expectations of a more hawkish
Bank of England. The pipeline for FDI into the UK also
looks good. The main weakness for the pound remains
the current account deficit, so as a FX trade we like to
buy the pound against another current account deficit
currency, the Canadian dollar. Helping the bearish CAD
case is that expectations of a hawkish Bank of Canada
appear overdone given the disconnect between the US
and Canadian economy, the likely reversal of the surge
of bond inflows seen since 2008 and a turn lower in
commodity prices.
A neat way of playing the lead-lag between different
segments of the market to the normalization in
developed markets is to buy the Norwegian krone and
sell the Swiss franc. The former saw a large unwind of
post-crisis safe-haven inflows last year, while safe-
haven flows to Switzerland have yet to be unwound.
We should start to see this happen in 2014. Elsewhere
in Europe, the Swedish krona should do well as the
Swedish economy finally catches up to German and US
economic strength.
Asia-Pac winners and losers
In the Asia-Pacific region, one of the largest cross
moves in 2013 was AUD/NZD, but we expect a major
reversal this year. Aside from attractive valuations, the
rates markets will likely price a more hawkish RBA
compared to an already aggressively priced RBNZ.
We'd look for the Korean won to outperform the
Japanese yen on an improving current account, a pick-
up in global growth and a robust domestic financial
system. The Singaporean dollar will struggle as
valuations are stretched, household debt is elevated
and the currency is closely tied to the overall dollar
trend. Finally, we'd still buy CNH as the current
account, inflation and likely capital inflows are
supportive, though we remain wary of the carry
unwind dynamics seen in the currency.
Fragile EM; strong EM
The Indian rupee is the only 'fragile five' currency we
like to be long. Current account improvement, portfolio
inflows after last year's reduction and beneficial policy
action adds up to a bullish case. By contrast, the
Turkish lira and South African rand should continue to
struggle as their current account dynamics are poor.
While both Indonesian rupiah and the Brazilian real also
suffer from rickety current accounts and domestic
dynamics, better valuations and high carry may prevent
excessive weakness. Not all EM is bad. We like the
Polish zloty, Israeli shekel and Mexican peso. The first
on growth, the second on commodities and third on
expected FDI and cyclical pick-up.
Last year's Blueprint's Trades
Our trades from the last Blueprint were mixed. Our best
trade was going long MXN/BRL (+7.1%) while our
worst was being short TRYIZAR (-3.6%). Overall, 6 of
the themes made money while 4 lost money. Overall,
our 10 themes made a 0.47% average retum.
Bi!al Hafeez, London
Page 2
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610277
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #1: Holler for dollars
▪
We expect the Fed and a recovery in US equity
inflows to be the two main pillars of support for the
dollar in 2014. Buy USD vs. NZD, CHF and SGD on
cycle and extreme valuation.
e
The Euro-area current account remains supportive
for the euro, but tight liquidity is fully priced, the
risk of negative rates is material, portfolio inflows
are peaking and we are reaching the 20% FX over-
valuation bound. Buy 12m EUR/USD 1.4011.31 risk
reversals for zero cost.
Don't Rely on Fed Dovishness
Last year was all about pricing out QE, even though
tapering is just beginning. The overwhelming message
is that the market front-runs major events, and that the
timing of re-pricings is very unpredictable. Just as 2013
was about QE unwinds and higher long-end yields, we
think this year will be about the re-pricing of "low for
long" and higher short-end yields.
First, US short-end expectations are exceptionally
benign. The market is not pricing the first rate hike until
Q3 2015, just in line with FONT projections, and by
which time a simple linear extrapolation of the US
unemployment rate takes us well below 6%. Second,
the US yield curve is close to all-time steepness
extremes. On the one hand, this means that the risks
are skewed towards flattening, historically one of the
most supportive yield curve environments (chart 1). On
the other hand, the forwards are extremely high,
suggesting that even if these are realized, the US dollar
will climb up the carry ladder and drop-out of the
bottom-3 yield ranking by year-end.
Foreigners to Come Late to the Party
The second building block to our bullish USD view is
our positive outlook on growth and by extension US
equity inflows. 2013 stood out for large dollar cash
accumulation, on the back of UST liquidation and an
adjustment of USD hedge ratios (chart 2). The year has
also stood out for record outflows from US equities as
Americans have invested large amounts offshore and
foreigners have refused to engage in the S&P 500 rally.
But looking at relative valuations, outflows have
overshot what is a relatively benign valuation picture
for US stocks. Using the average P/E ratio of Hong
Kong and UK stocks as a global proxy, we find that
valuations are close to the medium-term average (chart
3). The odds therefore seem skewed towards higher
equity inflows into the US, which combined with a
flatter US curve should see an improvement in portfolio
flows that was lagging this year.
'Curve Flattening Very Bullish USD
ChingelnDAYerounicifferent moves in 2yr-10/rUSyleidcufve
20ra 19804orisy
2096
15%
10%
6%
0%
-10%
'Growth'
•15%
-2096
-25%
I I
Beer
Twist
Flatten
linen
Sourer Ocuadre Sank iMf
But
Flatten
'Etetbtlorr
Beer
ai
TNSt
Steepen Steepen Steepen
'UST Selling Last Year Offset By Cash and Hedging
2000
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
C..sourative US short-term ponfoho flows Immlo & ST
loans, Do USD)
94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12
SOU/014 Ditatitho Hunk abentre RAMC* LP, ONIStehat
Equity Valuations Not Extreme, Inflows Should Recover
—Relative P/E ratio, US vs world•, 12m lead Ohs
1.2
Net equity inflows Ohs, % gross flowsl
f 120%
1.t
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
70%
20%
-30%
-80%
0.5 I
130%
96 97 98 99 00 01 03 04 05 06 07 08 10 11 12 13 14
Swear thvescne Bonk lleaming Mime t0 'we pan *odd by the ME end *op Sang
I
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 3
EFTA00610278
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Hard to See EUR Story Get Any Better
The EUR was the star performer in 2013, despite a
strong dollar elsewhere. The Euro-area's large current
account surplus has helped, which has pushed the
basic balance into positive territory and in the past has
been associated with broad-based EUR-appreciation. It
is for this reason that we expect the EUR to continue to
hold up relatively well against many G10 FX. Looking at
drivers more relevant to EUR/USD however, the
positive factors that have driven strength versus the
dollar have peaked.
First, interest rate differentials should turn lower over
2014. Looking across different tenors as well as bond
versus implied forward yields, we find that the euro is
most sensitive to short-dated forward-implied yields.
Last year short-end European yields moved higher not
only on the back of ECB LTRO liquidity withdrawal, but
as the cross-currency basis also moved back to flat for
the first time since 2008 (chart 1). For this year, the
risks are skewed the other way. There is less than
200bn EUR of excess liquidity left, EONIA is back to the
refi rate and cross-currency basis is flat, so there is no
room left for higher short-end European yields. In
contrast, the ECB retains a strong easing bias and
negative rates or additional liquidity injections remain a
strong possibility.
On the flow side, the best is behind us as well. Portfolio
inflows into the Euro-area have been dominated by
equity, but cumulative purchases are now back to
trend and on a relative valuation basis Euro-area
equities are at a 10-year high. On the outflows side,
European offshore investment remains very pro-cyclical,
so an improving cycle should lead to a pick-up in Euro-
area outflows (chart 2). Add to that the peak in the
current account surplus on the back of recovering
domestic demand and the risk of additional ECB easing,
and we like buying a 1.42p/1.34c EUR/USD risk
reversal for zero cost.
(a) Other Dollar Crosses to Short
Looking outside of EUR/USD, NZD, SGD, and CHF are
our top shorts. The Swiss franc is a higher beta version
of EUR/USD, with valuations more stretched and
greater potential for capital outflows. NZD and SGD are
the most over-valued currencies in the world, having
lagged all other FX in the USD appreciation that has
materialized so far. We therefore like buying USD vs.
NZD, CHF and SGD. This basket has a steady —80%
correlation with both the narrow and broad USD trade-
weighted indices over the last ten years.
George Saravelos, London,
Bilal Hafeez, London,
I EUR/USD Still Tracking Rate Differentials
1.0
EUR/USD Ohs)
mplied 2yr E R/USD yields (rhs)
1.38
1.36
1.30
1.32
1.3
1.28
1.26
1.24
1.22
1.2
Jun-12 Sep-12 Dec-12 Mar-13 Jun-13 Sep-13 Dec-13
0.1
Sono Damen, &trot Consenws economy, tr ancectormegotions
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
IPortfolio Inflows Into Euro-Area Peaked
400
300
200
100
0
-100
-200
300
-400
-500
Euro - World Business Surveys (Ihs)
Net Portfolio flow, inveretd
outho
08
08
10
11
12
13
&am basset* (WA Scoarteg fa no, 0'
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
I NZD, SGD, CHF Most Expensive FX in the World
30
PPP valuation adjusted for productivity
I
20 -.
and terms of trade (BEER)
10
JIllrrr
-10 -
-20
-30
00
-50 ou_occ<noomm-zleceoavo>-zei.oiln-a.ler4r4ticca
,..aaD D..cE,cr.dpeori Ea-ni optuE-lozo
zvmw ev, r2v mo mgvo.mucen vz
,c d
Somas OwitstAo Byµ libonits7 Fiume fit
Page 4
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610279
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #2: Play it again, san
We always suspected 2013 would be special, and in
this publication a year ago urged investors not to wait
for a dip in USD/JPY to buy. We highlighted the
ongoing deterioration in Japan's balance of payments
and huge pent-up energy in risk-averse short-term
capital flows post-GFC. We noted how sentiment was
shifting but investors seemed overly cautious, and
pointed out that trend turns are typically worth 20.25%
on a first-year basis - basically what ensued. It didn't
matter that we couldn't anticipate the BoJ's radical
departure or mixed Fed signals on QE. The associated
swings in risk appetite and positioning created some
bumps in the road. But a single-minded focus and
conviction ultimately paid off big time.
Last year's gain now appears to be this year's pain. The
yen posted its largest percentage point loss in 34 years
and the Nikkei its biggest rally since 1972. Both go into
the New Year on their highs, even as WY JGB yields
are within 5bp of their end-2012 level. Few savor the
prospect of chasing or fighting such markets.
The trend is yet young
Still, outsized (10%+) moves in USD/JPY have extended
in the following year twice as often as they retraced: 12
times versus 6 since 1971 (top chart).1 We think this is
a multi-year-trend, and historically such moved have
cumulatively been worth 43% (log terms) with a
standard deviation of 20%, typically lasting for just over
three years (see chart 2). Mechanically speaking, that
would take spot to 116 in December, and well through
most conceptions of 'fair value.' One should not shy
from forecasting such things, because overshoot is
very much the norm for FX (chart 3).
Base money differentials matter, will grow
As far as the eye can see policy settings also imply it.
Deputy Govemor Iwata argued in October that past
experience both in the US and Japan show QE works
mainly via changes in the money stock. (Hence the
importance of the BoJ's commitment to doubling the
monetary base; he asserts 'the current level of the
monetary base is irrelevant.') Time lags in transmission
mean its impact - including on the yen (top chart over
page) -- will build even as the initial expectations boost
from 'shock and awe' ebbs. Consequently, markets
need not fear the absence of further easing by the Bank
if, as seems likely, the consumption tax hike in Q2
passed smoothly. Governor Kuroda has also made clear
that Japan's massive money expansion will continue
until the 2% core CPI target is not only achieved but
deemed secure on a sustainable (medium-term) basis.
xFor the Nikkei the same stets using a 20% threshold are 5 and 10, i.e.,
only halt as many large moves continue.
'What happens in year after big" USD/JPY move?
6
Trend reverses
s -
4
2 •
0
Trend continues
-25%-301-15%-10%-5% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 50% 35%
Scum.: &vow,. Bent Boor nn Faience UP. • &.c. N/ ass POSt Sot kg ego
ILong-term trends in USDJPY
Date
Rate
13/01/1971
358.44
Log chg
Months
14/03/1973
254.45
-34%
26.0
08/12/1975
306.84
19%
32.8
30/10/1978
177.05
-55%
34.7
04/11/1982
277.65
45%
48.1
25/11/1988
121.10
-83%
72.7
17/04/1990
160.20
28%
16.7
19/04/1995
79.75
-70%
60.1
11/08/1998
147.66
62%
39.7
26/11/1999
101.25
-38%
15.5
31/01/2002
135.15
29%
26.2
17/01/2005
101.69
-28%
35.6
22/06/2007
124.14
20%
29.2
31/10/2011
75.35
-50%
52.3
Abs avg
43%
37.7
Stdev
20%
16.7
20/12/2014
116.00
43%
38.6
San Ammo. Gant &bombe. Memo UP
IFair value contestable, overshoot is not
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70 •
60 •
REER (2005*100)
— — — Polynomial trend (3)
—
Linear trend
71 74 77 80 83 86 89 92 95 98 01 04 07 10 13
Scurry Oeinschr Bret 8bombeep 'mane LIP
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 5
EFTA00610280
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
External accounts highlight major vulnerability
Japan's balance of payments still promises a brisk
tailwind for yen weakness. The trade account has
deteriorated further, against most expectations of
stabilization. This is overwhelmingly an oil and gas
story, though lackluster external shipments and
strengthening domestic demand are supplementary
issues. Net FDI outflows a similar-sized drag that is
only likely to get bigger even if the current account
gradually improves. That reflects a massive cost-of-
funding advantage spurring catch-up after Japanese
corporates have been risk averse and lagged their
competitors in overseas expansion over the last two
decades. Overall it leaves Japan's 'narrow basic
balance' in a pretty neutral state (middle chart).
Cross-border portfolio flows have also had little impact
on the yen thus far. Foreign equity inflows seem to
have been largely hedged and new bond outflows were
limited to banks' offshore treasury activity. Henceforth,
real money inflows to Japanese stocks should pick up,
but will probably be balanced by growing Japanese
outflows into foreign bonds and stocks - the latter
encouraged by the new NISA scheme and more
aggressive GPIF portfolio adjustment away from JGBS.
That would leave the financial account's short-term
loans balance as largest swing factor again. It captures
carry trades and foreign asset hedging activity and
responds to risk aversion and investor's perception of
long-term interest rate differentials. It is several orders
of magnitude larger than other BoP components and
seen in stock terms retains scope for several hundred
billion dollars of yen-selling unwinds (lower chart).
Abenostics abound
Conventional market tops are characterized by hubris
in the mainstream which creates unquestioning
acceptance of a 'new status quo.' By contrast, most
forecasts for Japanese asset prices strike us as
intensely
conservative
as
there
is
tremendous
skepticism that the country's long-term prospects have
really been changed by the advent of Abenomics.2
Inevitably there will be bumps along the way, and
nobody should expect a free lunch. But until the basic
tenets of what remains a uniquely favorable backdrop
of fundamentals and potential flows are challenged or
overshadowed (geopolitics, anyone?),
encourage
investors to replay last year's template as this year's
basic game plan. We expect FX-equity correlations to
remain extraordinarily high and volatility to stay
elevated. Our end-2014 and 2015 USD/JPY forecasts of
115 and 120 are reiterated with upside risks.
2 For a convincing exposition of this assertion, see Kuroda's recent speech:
https://www.boi.or.iaten/announcements/pressAoen 2013/clata/ko131225
alacif
'Relative base money growth will only point higher
30
20
10
0
-10
-20
-30
-no
—
ease money Pp
(%YoY.1N-LtS)
-
USCUPY (RHS)
00 01 02 03 04 OS 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14
Santa Oaercaraant abaft." &Awe CP
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
'Narrow basis balance still under pressure
JOY aril, 3mma
3.0 !
2.0 -
1.0
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
3.0
l
iTransfe s
ncome
i'
Goods & services
II
—1
m(6nvina)
04
06
08
10
12
02
Same' Dana* awe Seam:Keg "'nano, CP
'Financial account's 'other investment balance' is key
30
20
10
0
•10 •
-20
—
Short-term loans
Ise foreign asset
(WY aril, commutative)
hedge demand
-
USD1PY (RHS, inverted)
Carry trade extends.
-30
150
96
98
00
02
04
06
08
10
12
14
and
unwinds
&Knee' Deutsche aset 8boftwg 'nine.> CP
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
190
140
James Malcolm, London, (+44)20754 50884
Taisuke Tanaka, Tokyo
Page 6
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610281
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #3: - Home Counties trump Mounties
•
Inflation risks and potential FDI inflows should
keep sterling supported this year, but a widening
current account deficit and stronger USD will
constrain gains versus the euro and dollar. We are
moderately bearish
EUR/GBP and GBP/USD,
forecasting 80p and 1.54 by end-year respectively.
•
As an outright trade we prefer buying GBP versus
CAD, on which we are more bearish. It remains
vulnerable to an equally-large current account
deficit, QE-flow unwinds and unwinding internal
imbalances.
The UK domestic demand cycle has kicked in quicker,
stronger and more sustainably than anticipated. We
see inflation and FDI inflows as being the major source
of upside risk for GBP next year.
Inflation, not deflation to be theme in 2014
Last year was all about UK growth expectations. This
year, the risk is attention turns to prices. First, even
though recent inflation prints have surprised to the
downside, pipeline pressure is building. Productivity is
not recovering as quickly as the BoE is expecting,
leading to a much faster than expected drop in the
unemployment rate. In turn, wage inflation could
accelerate sharply in 2014 (chart 1). Second, the
starting point of inflation is much higher in the UK than
the rest of G10. Any turn in the trend will focus minds
much more quickly than elsewhere. With the first BoE
rate hike still only priced for mid-2015 (a bit earlier than
the Fed), there is plenty of potential for near-term yield
support as price pressure builds.
Outside of monetary policy, FDI is another source of
support. Excluding the Verizone-Vodafone deal, UK
inbound
has been muted by pre-crisis standards.
But UK deal-flow is pro-cyclical, tracking the broad
trends in equities and global
transactions well.
Our equity analysts are positive on both this year. Add
to that the UK government's increasing dedication to
attracting foreign investment - particularly into the
publicly-owned banks - (chart 2) and FDI stands out as
a potential additional source of support for GBP in 2014.
Current Account Deficit Will Constrain Gains vs. EUR
On the flipside, the UK recovery is happening for the
"wrong" reasons. Domestic demand, not exports are
driving the cycle. The current account deficit is
deteriorating and stands in contrast to the US and
Euro-area. This goes a long way to explain the lag in
EUR/GBP versus cyclical indicators (chart 3). This is
reflected in our conservative EUR/GBP forecasts: we
see a slow grind lower to 0.80 by the end of the year,
with GBP/USD revisiting the low 1.50s on the back of a
strong USD.
IInflation Could Be Here Sooner Than Market Expects
58.0
56.0
54.0
52.0
50.0
48.0
46.0
44.0
42.0
40.0
,
Emplyt PMI, 9m lead
—GBP AWE reg pay, priv
Jan-01 Mar-03 May-05 Jul-07
Sep-09 Nov-11
San' Saba f Afars Itpreway. 1W
I FDI Upside Risk To GBP Next Year
so
so
40
0Budget ler UK Trees end wwwww. hived IndtritMent. MAO GBP
30
20
10
0 —
2008
2000
2010 1
Souses Asses &int Doemeerd 'Mang LIP 1
2011
2012
2013
I EUR/GBP Holding Up Better on Back of Flow
EUR/GBP (6m lag, Ms/
—RICS House Price Balance (rhs, inverted)
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
94
96
98 00
02
04
06 08
10
12
Soutar Disney Gant ow-vow guano, LIP
1 90
130
30
-20
12(
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 7
EFTA00610282
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
CAD Flow Picture Very Negative
We are more bearish CAD. Speculative shorts are
building, but on the portfolio flow side, the balance of
payments is characterized by a large overhang of fixed
income inflow positions as a by-product of Fed QE
(chart 4). Canada benefitted from close to 280bn of
"excess" inflows over the 2010.2013, which have
plugged a sharply wider current account deficit similar
in size to the UK. The UK, in contrast, has suffered from
a lack of inflows in recent years (chart 4). While FDI
and underweight fixed income positions have the
potential to "plug" the UK deficit, the risks appear
skewed the other way in Canada.
On the monetary policy side, Canada doesn't appear
well placed to benefit from an improving US cycle
either. Rate expectations are already running ahead of
the Fed and BoE by a quarter, and given the BoC's
renewed dovishness there is limited potential of these
happening sooner. Indeed, the correlation between US
and Canadian data surprises has dropped off sharply
over the last few years, pointing to the divergent trends
in local housing markets and domestic leverage. To
boot, Canadian terms of trade have clearly peaked
(chart 6), with the currency moderately expensive
versus non-energy commodity prices and supply glut in
North America oil production providing an additional
headwind.
Big picture, GBP/CAD is a dollar-neutral cross, with
correlations with other USD crosses all lying below 50%
over 1-3 year time horizons and zero correlation with the
broad USD TWI since 1995. The relative performance
between UK financials and Canadian stocks does a decent
job of explaining big picture turns since the early 1990s.
The cross remains more than 20% below its pre-crisis
average suggesting plenty of potential for upside as the
respective domestic stories play out.
George Saravelos, London,
Oliver Harvey, London,
IGBP/CAD a Beta Neutral Cross
2.8 i —GBP/CAD Ohs)
—UK fina cials/Toromo stock index (rhs)
2.6
2.4
2.2
2
1.8
1.6
1.4
Sewn Amuse-ftBIM
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
IUK Inflows Could Improve, Opposite of Canada
1100
Cumulative bond inflows,
1000
local currency, bn
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Sown. a* it. r later Rea &Ye.: Nig
-750bn
(UK)
1
+280bn
(Canada)
change relative
to trend
2500
2000
1500
1000
0
!GBP/CAD 'Current Account Neutral' Cross
10
Current account deficits., (my bn
90 91 92 93 95 96 97 98 00 01 02 03 05 06 07 08 10 11 12
Source' °math, eant atiOntteep Aveiro UP
IUSD/CAD Following Commodity Prices Lower
95
97
99 01 03
05
07
09
11
13
0.85
0.95
1.05
1.15
1.25
1.35
1.45
1.55
1.65
45(
40(
35(
30(
25(
20(
—
USD/CAD (Ihs, inverted)
—
BoC Non-energy Commodity Price Index irhs
15(
Soutar Akan» &Mc &bombers Fran. UP
Page 8
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610283
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #4: - Swiss
out
We can think of three reasons to go short CHF/NOK.
1. The relative cycle is supportive of rate differentials.
Inflation is at a much higher starting point in Norway
than in Switzerland, leaving the Norges Bank much less
room to manoeuvre than the SNB in the event of
upside surprises to import prices or stronger European
growth. Market pricing in Norway has evolved rapidly
from three months ago, with the first hike now
expected in Q3 2015 rather than Q1 2014, more or less
in line with the Norges' own projections. NOK is also
much better placed to benefit from a stronger US cycle
with one of the strongest correlations to US growth,
and CHF one of the weakest. One risk is house prices,
which have risen precipitately in Norway over the last
five years, a sharp reversal of which could weigh on
domestic demand and prompt Norges' dovishness. We
think the risks of this are slim, however, (see theme #6),
and moderate falls will be welcomed by the central
bank as skimming froth from the market.
2. Swiss safe-haven unwind should follow Norway's.
Like Switzerland, Norway experienced large-scale safe
haven inflows as a consequence of the financial crisis,
helping to pause customary current account surplus
recycling. In the latter's case, these inflows have
largely reversed, to the tune of NOK 190bn on a 2y/2y
basis). This has been one of the primary recent drags
on the krone, but appears to have largely run its course,
in contrast to Switzerland where it has yet to begin.
3. CHF also more vulnerable to domestic outflows.
As well as the foreign inflow, Norway and Switzerland
both saw significant repatriation of domestic assets
from abroad. Again, this flow has long turned in
Norway but not yet in Switzerland. One possible
catalyst will be stronger price pressures next year on
the back of more robust growth. This should erode real
returns Swiss domestics have enjoyed on already some
of the most expensive assets in the world. Historically,
Swiss capital flows have been counter-cyclically related
to prices (chart 3). Indeed, CHF performance closely
tracked changes in real yields last year. By contrast,
while conventional Norwegian outflows have resumed,
NOK is more protected by surplus savings being
invested by the oil fund.
Along with the above, CHF/NOK appears fundamentally
misaligned with traditional drivers like oil/gold. Finally,
the trade benefits from being USD and EUR/USD
neutral (with a 15 year correlation of 16% and -11%
respectively).
Oliver Harvey, London,
I NOK one of highest betas to US cycle, CHF lowest
35%
FX correlations to quarterly US GDP
Ekon 1990
30%
ARom2000
25%
20%
15%
la%
4%
-10%
AUD
sec
NOK
1420
GaP
CAD
EUA
01f
JPY
San O.41tithe Sent Scone., name, LP
'Norway flow reversal nearly done, Swiss yet to begin
not 00,110P4 1yµ9. % GDP
5%
9,titualend. not path:. flows
0%
5%
-36
.40%
-30%
J96.99 4000 M.042 OCI-03 May-0500006 Jul-013 Feb.m 500-11
San Dames bee. /900M00/0 rename LP
IMore Swiss inflation means CHF weakness
40000
20000
0
-20.000
-40.000
40.000
40.000
-1000r=
-120.000
.140.000
J0400 A.900 514102 04103 KUrf05 Occ.c5 Ja.ce Feb.10 Sip 1 1
San 0.34rti Ore Seat abaft.. name, 1.1
-
S'et knitted NM Pt.ddio DAWNS
—
$wesCn yin. inverted ths
.1
Ob
0
06
2
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 9
EFTA00610284
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #5: Dingo unchained
•
2013 saw the largest fall in AUD/NZD in over 28
years. Behind the fall in the cross was a significant
move in interest rate differentials.
•
With the cross near record lows we think the risk /
reward from here favors AUD/NZD upside. As a
result we would be long AUD/NZD at current levels.
As shown in Figure 1, 2013 marked the 'worst' year for
the AUD/NZD cross since at least 1986. Interestingly, in
prior years when the cross has fallen over 10% the
subsequent year sees a significant bounce back. The
13.5% fall in 1987 to 1.0959 was followed by a bounce
of 23.5% in 1988; while the 12.7% fall in 2002 (to
1.0727) saw a 6.7% bounce in the following year. With
the cross ending 2013 at 1.0850 after a 14.0% decline,
history would suggest some likelihood of a significant
move higher in AUD/NZD over 2014.
Of course there is much more to FX than history. From
a more fundamental perspective we see a number of
reasons to expect a move higher in the AUD/NZD cross
through the course of 2014.
The first is valuation. As Figure 2 shows, the AUD/NZD
cross has traditionally found a base around 1.05 (with
just below here therefore likely to serve as a good level
to set any stop). Our valuation metrics (as published in
Exchange Rate Perspectives) also find NZD the most
over-valued of the G10 currencies on a PPP and BEER
basis. The NZD is around 33% 'expensive' on a PPP
basis, versus the AUD which is 26% 'expensive'. On a
BEER basis the NZD is 22% 'expensive', versus the
AUD which is only 5% above 'fair-value'.
As far as 'big picture' drivers of the AUD/NZD cross are
concerned, it is hard to go past interest rate
differentials as shown in Figure 3. Looking a little more
closely at the last few data points in that chart it also
appears that AUD/NZD has 'overshot' interest rate
differentials to the downside.
Indeed, the current
interest rate differential would appear to be more
consistent with the cross trading around 1.13 versus its
current level.
We should not, of course, rule out
interest rate differentials 'catching up' to the cross.
That would require, however, markets to price even
more tightening for the RBNZ, and/or easing from the
RBA.
On the outlook for the kiwi central bank our central
view remains that we will see 75bps of policy
tightening over the course of 2014. Market pricing is a
little more aggressive than that, with a little over
100bps of hikes priced for 2014. On the RBA the
market is essentially priced for no change in rates in
Australia over the coming year - something consistent
Figure 1: Large declines in AUD/NZD usually see
bounces
AG
200
160
lae
bet
00
60
100
-160
-200
Annual Amp In AUD/NZI3
„Ir i_ta
'II.-
i
1
IS
Iwo
tOM
WA
'Oct
2010
2014
Savertv Da en. amt lkentarg Fano, ty
'Figure 2: The cross is also at an extreme
AUD/N213
106
PAA36
MAN
MO93
WV
UN 01
Mr OS
Vs CO
UM 13
&wet DivetAOLIS.M. 1160nodat Mann LP
IFigure 3: Interest rate differentials are the key driver
AUO/N20 ar4 interact rate offactit,ats
~4tcnlm 1e]1
--4in MAW. 41111eGnIar PPM
1.06
54006
50207
54409
54000
Sao 10
Sep 1 1
Sao 12
Sp10
Sep 1
J
SWAY Data@ Sont Stowlarg foam CP
2.50
ZO2
1.50
I.00
050
0.00
020
Page 10
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610285
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint Thin end of the wedge
with our own view. That said, the Australian rates
market has a tendency to sell off considerably once it
becomes clear than an easing cycle in Australia is over.
(Figure 4). As to what might spark such a sell-off; an
improvement in the labor market stands as one clear
possibility. RBA action - and market pricing for the
RBA - is often driven by conditions in the labor market.
As Figure 5 shows, our tracking of 11 different monthly
indicators of labor demand and sentiment suggests a
pick-up in the pace of employment growth over
coming months. All up, we therefore see the risks
being skewed toward a narrowing of the front end
interest rate differential between Australian and New
Zealand, something that would be supportive of our
long AUD/NZD stance.
Finally, it would be remiss of us not to consider the
outlook for China when discussing any view on AUD,
either against the USD or crosses. Our house view
remains quite constructive on China, with GDP growth
expected by DB to continue its recovery towards 8.6%
in 2014. Despite the modest decline in the December
PMI reading, our local economists note that the PMI's
Q4 average reached 51.3, O.5pts above the Q3 average
which suggests that Q4 IP and GDP growth are unlikely
to have decelerated from that seen in Q3. Looking
forward, stronger external demand should see an
acceleration of GDP growth over 2014. If this view on
China is correct, then it should be supportive of the
AUD given the tendency of the market to see the
Aussie as a China proxy (see Figure 6).
We are; however, a little cautious about overplaying
any impact that stronger growth in China may have on
the AUD, given that Australia's key commodity export
to China (iron ore) is likely to be moving into an
oversupply situation this year. We should note here
that while many analysts focus heavily on relative
commodity prices when considering the AUD/NZD
cross; we are inclined to think that the true importance
of commodity prices is captured through the influence
on interest rate differentials. In other words, we take
the view that the impact of divergent commodity price
trends is likely to have already been captured by
interest rate differentials.
All up, some recovery following the sham fall in 2013,
the favorable valuation backdrop, and the risk that the
interest rate differential moves in the AUD's favor over
coming months has us long AUD/NZD.
Adam Boyton, Sydney,
Figure 4: Once the RBA is 'done' easing, Australian
rates usually (and often incorrectly) price a lot of hikes
112001
1100.
1003
sop
St*
20,
Jan 116 An 16 Jm01 Janie .1m01 Jor.00 MIPS JMO: Ante -Sill Jan',
Mat* pdong anus the RBA cab ire
AM.." Loh.
one el 00 C. th< Jm to* to I •a Y, t
Ww4
Spar' Dena &w* Scoateg Faroe:CP
'Figure 5: The labor market might be the catalyst
Momay newspaper end 'cameo:poss.business kinnkis and
consumes nnys canted to Australian amslayrnont growth
Sown Macho 8sat, Stoomberg flan* f* .414 Ara M4& Oeltelt. W8C-Aff
Figure 6: Stronger growth in China could also help
AUD
12
—0-Ms nSBC PM13rnih *mg*
8
4
0
-4
2009
2011
2013
2005
2007
SMANV Dana* &rot Scoartarg Fnlnro ffr
r 26
16
5
4
-15
-26
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 11
EFTA00610286
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #6: SEK to score with thaw
•
The krona is not the main culprit of a lukewarm
Swedish recovery. Rather the latter reflects a
broader trend of DMs losing market share to EMs.
▪
But global recovery still positive for the high beta
Swedish economy and SEK. Moreover, global
growth is equity supportive which is bullish SEK.
Swedish growth numbers have disappointed repeatedly
over the past 6-9 months, causing market participants
to scale down their expectations for growth and policy
normalization. This has in turn resulted in a gradual
weakening of the SEK from around 8.40 vs. the EUR
back in March/April last year to current levels around
8.90. Disappointing growth numbers are a reflection of
subdued industrial activity, which in a small open
economy like Sweden has also been weighing on
consumer sentiment, job growth and domestic activity.
However, blaming the disappointing industrial activity
on a strong krona is difficult when the currency is
undervalued on all metrics (PPP, BEER, FEER), and the
SEK REER not historically strong. Instead, the country
breakdown of imports in Germany and Norway,
Sweden's key export markets, shows developed
markets continuing to lose market share to developing
countries, suggesting the latter can now compete in
major Swedish export areas like "machinery &
transport equipment" where they previously have been
small players. This is backed up when looking at hard
data, with rising German imports mainly benefitting
Central and Eastern Europe. The CE-4 market share of
total German imports post-crisis has risen by 50% to
around 12% of total. Meanwhile Norwegian imports are
showing
a
similar
but
broader
trend
towards
developing countries (including Asia) and away from
the rest of the Nordics, Eurozone, US and UK. This of
course very much goes against the popular view that
DM imports might be decoupling from EM exports.
Nonetheless, whilst losing market share means an
ongoing global recovery will be less of a driver of
Swedish GDP growth, it will still be growth supportive,
and given the degree of openness in the Swedish
economy, more so than in most of the rest of G10. This
is SEK positive, partly because it will mean market
participants will have to re-assess the policy outlook,
but more because it should translate into similar
growth in corporate revenues. With Swedish stock
valuations only in line with the longer- term average,
this should also translate into higher equity prices.
Global growth and higher equity prices are typically
associated with a stronger SEK, and are factors more
important than [an orderly] tumaround in the interest
rate cycle in the US. Target a gradual move to 8.55 in
EUR/SEK, with a stop @ 9.15. In options a3m EUR/SEK
8.65 put costs an indicative 52bp, and can be largely
financed by selling a 3m EUR/SEK call with a strike
around the more than 2y highs @ 9.15.
Figure 1: Albeit with a lag, the Swedish PMI is likely to
follow USD and DEM PMIs higher
70 -
65 -
60 —
55 —
50 —
45 —
40 -
35 -
30 -
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 '2010 I 2011 '2012 I
San Detach. Bart &bombs" Rare LP
IFigure 2: Exports of Goods & Services, Percent of GDP
oe
FUR
50
JK
130
20
10
P-IMCAD 4101
40
GB
0
2011
sows. amanita Bat &owners Ramos LP
Figure 3: SEK trade-weighted (TCW) & the US ISM
2000 2002 2009 2M6 2008 20111 2012 2014
— US ISM mfg
— Sweden TON Index. Thy (inverted site lower Sex = stronger SEK.I. ns
awn. Gewalt S,.,& 8bomOtvg 'awe CP
Page 12
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610287
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint Thin end of the wedge
•
Norges bank to continue to balance falling house
prices vs. sticky CPI.
•
NOK cheap, but investors wary of jumping back in
untess/until Norges Bank and/or crude provide
support supportive.
In Norway, the mainland economy has been growing
around 2.0-2.5% YoY for most of the last couple of
years, with the recent PMI and manufacturing output
suggestive of continuing improvement going forward.
Norges Bank's focus is balancing the declining housing
market against sticky inflation at the consumer level.
With house prices having slowed to largely flat on the
year, representing a 3-3.5% drop from the peak in Q3
last year, and headline CPI back in line with the Bank's
2.5% target (from 3.2% YoY in August), Norges Bank is
erring on the dovish side, arguing that the rise in [core]
inflation is transitory. Indeed, according to the Bank's
projections, core inflation is expected to drift back up
over the next few months, reaching a peak just above
the inflation target of 2.6% in April/May, before
dropping down and remaining just below 2% up until
the end of 2015. House prices meanwhile, are seen
slowing further, to -2.5% to -3.0% YoY in H1 2014,
before returning to positive YoY growth in early 2015.
The risk to Norges Banks's finely balanced outlook for
inflation and housing is twofold. First is a scenario in
which past and current FX weakness feeds through to
imported
inflation,
thus
preventing
core
from
moderating in line with Norges forecasts. If the Bank
then feels compelled to hike rates at a time when
house prices already are declining, that would
exacerbate the decline and not be currency supportive.
An alternative risk scenario is if the house price falls
feeds on themselves. With policy rates already as low
as 1.50%, and with core CPI projected at or above
target over the next 3-6 months, there would be limited
scope for policy to provide a stopgap. While the above
scenarios are not our baseline, they will continue to be
a key factor in the Norges Bank's decision-making
process, with monetary policy likely to be stuck
between a fear of adding to the decline in house prices
on one hand and sticky inflation on the other.
Meanwhile crude is likely to continue to flatline in the
relatively tight $90 to $110 range of the past few years.
Monetary policy and crude are therefore unlikely to
provide much in terms of direction in the NOK.
However,
given recent
depreciation cannot
be
explained by fundamentals, with the Norwegian unit
arguably oversold even when taking into account the
market's now very dovish outlook for Norges Bank
policy and flat oil prices, we are cautiously constructive.
On balance we anticipate very gradual downside in
EUR/NOK from current levels. A 3m EUR/NOK put @
8.25 costs an indicative 76bp. Alternatively, finance it
by selling a 3m EUR/NOK 8.65 call.
Figure 4: Norway, Real Estate Prices, All Residential
Buildings, Total & YoY
20 -0
15 -I
to
# 5
0
-5
-10
2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013
Swat LIPataltil0 Beak IMF
35000
30000
25000
200000
isocioa
t0000
5000
0
20 5
'Figure 5: EUR/NOK and Crude oil
lob
9.5 -
9.0 -
8,5 -
2 to -
7.5 -
7.0 -
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
—010,04 Brent, Close, USD, its —EUR/NOIC actual. Ito
&wore DeoYene Bork Eitiomewg Fount* CP
30
40
50n
60c
70
80c
90 7gi
100
1102.
120
130
Figure 6: Core inflation - actual and Norges Bank's
projection
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
JMS/MSJstSJ IMMS
,I biSJM
2038
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
We 2.5% Mete target
- CPI-ATE (adjusted for taxes and exch.:Jog energy). YoY
NO, GIGS BanKs paecbon
&wow dissent &mit elocintlxvg finance to
Henrik Gullberg, London,
194/
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 13
EFTA00610288
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #7: Trend no bitter end
In 2007 we replicated a RBA study that claimed non-
commercial "profit seekers" made money on their IMM
positions at the expense of commercial "liquidity
seekers".3 The striking conclusion is that currency
speculators generally know the correct direction of G5
currencies and investors can profit from knowing their
positions (although these signals are less useful in
practice since IMM data is lagged three days).
In a sense, money is "left on the table" by commercial
foreign exchange users, and to a lesser extent by
foreign bond and equity investors, which can be earned
by non-commercial actors that provide liquidity to
currency markets. These profit seekers collect FX risk
premia in the same manner Keynes first identified
when describing risk transfer in commodity markets.'
Profit Seekers Made Money in Every Year since 2003
By our calculations, non-commercial positions made
money in every year since data was first released in
1993, mainly at the expense of commercial users
(dealers also made money).' In recent years profits
have come from timing big EUR/USD moves (2010-11)
and catching last year's USD/JPY rise.
These MI
numbers more closely resemble pre-crisis profits than
the outsize gain in 2008 (reflecting higher FX volatility)
and the nearly flat 2009 period (probably due to an
unexpected GBP rebound).
IS MI Eroded As Speculators Accumulate Positions?
Our analysis rests on the crucial assumption that profit
seekers accumulate positions over the course of the
week at the average price. By contrast, live trading
metrics such as the Parker Index of currency manager
returns show a loss since 2011 as currency volatility
has overwhelmed macro trends (with the exception of
USD/JPY in 2013) even as the correlation between
weekly IMM In and Parker returns remains positive.
It is possible that intra-week volatility causes profit
seekers (especially momentum traders) to "buy high
and sell low" relative to WVAP and that IMM
is
eroded when currencies trade in a choppy range.
Fortunately for investors FX volatility continues to fall
and promising trends (JPY, CAD) have emerged.
Daniel Brehon, New Yor;
3 See Kearns and Manners (2004), "The profitability of Speculators in
Currency Futures Markets-. Reserve Bank of Australia: and Bilal
Hafeez 120071, "Currency Markets: Is Money Leh On the Table?"
4 Keynes. M. 11930). ilise
on Money". London: Macmillan,
5 We calculate weekly
by determining the notional value of
positions on Tuesday and assuming longs and shorts are accumulated
(or squared) at the average price over the course of the week.
Figure 1: Absolute =
($mil) of Profit-Seekers and
Liquidity-Seekers Using G5 IMM Data (1993-2013)
18 -
E 12"
4,,
o.
8 -
O
0
4
-12 -
USD mm (1993-2013. except euro 1999-2013)
oNon-Commercial /Profit-seekers
aCommercial/Liquidity-seekers
Cs.
93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13
Soutar Daunts &M. lboomberg Feigned LIP
Figure 2: Speculators had the correct EUR positions in
2 01 0-1 1 and a large JPY short in 2013
12
8
0
USD mm (1993-2013. except euro 1999-2013)
• Non-commercial /Profit-seekers
• Commercial / Liquidity-seekers
AUD
GBP
CAD
JPY
CHF
Source DArtne.he BanA. Stomotvg Foram UP
EUR
Figure 3: The Parker Index of currency manager returns
has lagged IMM
in recent years despite continued
positive correlation between them
Average IMM Cum P&L (5100m. 810
—
Parker Index Uan-2003 = 0.1hs)
—
IMM P&L v. Parker (12m corr, rhs)
45
40
35
25
20
IS
10
5
-5
-'
:•••••'*"..
" -F
03 04 05 06 07 08
Sarre' Oeutsche Bre* 8bomberg Amino> ELP
09 10 11 12 13
100%
- 90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
- 20%
10%
0%
Page 14
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610289
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #8: Balti not faulty, China yet finer
2013 saw Asian FX fracture into a North and South
complex. Relative sensitivity to the yen, the EM debt
bubble, and the developed world equity/growth cycle
all served to discriminate the two intra-regional groups
at different points during the year. Ultimately, the North
emerged fairly unscathed, while the South cheapened
significantly. Indeed, much of South Asia FX still faces
a host of challenges from political instability (THB),
offshore debt holding overhang and weak commodity
prices (MYR, IDR). However we refrain here from
adding to shorts against most of this group, given a
mix of large valuation adjustments, expensive carry,
and/or improving policy responses that is shifting the
risk-reward. We concentrate instead on currencies like
INR where fundamentals have improved sufficiently to
go long, and on SGD, where persistent overvaluation
and exposure to a broadening in USD strength out to
low-yielders favors a short bias. In North Asia, we stay
short USD/CNH, but are mindful of the large build up in
positioning. We favor a short JPY/KRW position to
express our positive view on Korean fundamentals.
The rupee has had a makeover
After spending three years as one of the world's worst
performing currencies, the rupee should fare better in
2014 for three main reasons. First, India has seen large
improvement in her external balances. The trade deficit,
which is the only driver of the CAD, has almost halved
from its peak. While gold import compression has
driven most of the trade improvement and could face
slippage, exports and services have also been bright
spots.
Second, even as India's portfolio flow
dependence is falling, both debt and equity flows could
see positive swings. After aggressive debt outflows
between May-Nov 2013, offshore holdings have fallen
to *core levels; indeed, foreigners returned as buyers
in December. With large unallocated limits, a more
positive duration view, and the possibility of index
inclusion and/or Euroclearability, India could attract
money. The key swing factor for equities will be
general elections in May. To be sure, this is a binary
event; but hopes of a pro-growth stable coalition could
boost inflows in the run-up to elections. Third, RBI's
swap activities have been a success adding to reserves.
Concerns about oil USD demand appear exaggerated,
and its return to the market in November did not raise
volatility. Majority of their obligations to buy USD
ahead of imminent swap repayments have been met.
We are long a 6M USD/INR 62 put with an RKO at 57.
SGD no longer king
We have seen a long USD/SGD view as a good 'long-
haul' trade to play for USD strength and US yield re-
pricing. However, the lesson from 2013 was that
USD/SGD took its cues more from the USD/G10 TVVI
than its USD/Asia peers which often behaved
Indian exports have been a bright spot in Asia
15
10
5
-10
YoY expons growth
3mma 1981
Jan-12
—Noah Ave %Ft 1W, CH/
-India
&sacs &wadi. Bonk Illoomfrarg Finance it
Jan-13
Jul-13
[The outlook for debt flows is asymmetric in India
140
INR aoae
120 -
— — — 0uota Iron tor G-Sees
100
40
—
Fil hdcings of Indian GSecs
Swear Octants. Bruit COSt SUM
IBroad consensus on SGD's overvaluation
30%
%OverM)/Unden-lvaluaticu vs. USD
20%
10%
0%
-10%
-20%
-30%
SGD
CNY
PHP
HRelatIve PPP
ofteladve FEER
• BEER
• Average
TH8
MYR
KRW
Swat Owititilo Beak Ilbonthirp 'nano. U.P. CSC
TWD
IDR
INR
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 15
EFTA00610290
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
differently. Our view that USD strength will broaden
out to G10 low-yielders like EUR, and continue to gain
ground against the JPY is thus an important tailwind
for USD/SGD. SGD is also one of the most overvalued
currencies globally, with consensus across a broad
range of models. Moreover, domestic vulnerabilities
have built up in Singapore over the QE years from high
household debt to bubbly property prices that leave her
exposed to inevitable short-end rates normalization.
We are long USD/SGD looking for a move above 1.30
this year.
Inflation trajectory to guide USD/CNY fixings
12.0%
10.0%
8.0%
8.0%
4.0%
2.0%
0.0%
RMB appreciation remains in play
-2.0%
-2
We expect RMB appreciation to persist in 2014 despite
a strong USD environment. With global growth
gradually recovering and Asian exports likely to catch
up, we look for a healthy current account surplus for
Sweat DatarS GEC
China ($220bn, 2.2% GDP). In addition, expectations of
further increases in offshore investment quotas (i.e.
RQFII) on the back of capital account liberalization,
I Positioning is short USD/CNY and likely more in CNH
should mean that portfolio inflows pick up, putting
further appreciation pressure on RMB. With the
1.0
Long USD/CNY
appreciation trend intact, and carry potentially set to
0.6
become more attractive as authorities push forward
DO
with interest rate liberalization; we are likely to see
speculative flows into China persist. Inflation will be a
-0.6
key driver of the pace at which this appreciation is
-1.0
permitted by the authorities. The main risk to our view
is from the sizeable nature of short USD positioning in
1.6
this pair - both in the offshore and onshore markets. In
-2.0
the event of weaker economic data driven by tight
monetary conditions and reforms, we could see a
.2s
Shaft IJSCUCNY
pickup in volatility. For now though, we stay short 12M
3.O
USD/CNH with a target of 5.95.
Jan-10
Jan-11
Jan-12
Jan 13
Jan-1.
SD/CNY positioning
JPY/KRW heading back to single-digits
The won's fate in 2014 remains a struggle between
strong underlying fundamentals, and the defensiveness
of the central bank in the face of concerns about a
weakening yen. The fundamental story is supported by
1) continuing improvement in the current account; 2)
high leverage to the global growth/trade upturn; and 3)
strength of the domestic financial system as a result of
the macro prudential policies implemented post-2008.
Given the strength in export orders in construction and
shipping and the resulting hedging pressure, as well as
the record levels of USD deposits held by Korean
corporates, there is likely to be persistent pressure on
the currency to appreciate. BoK on the other hand is
unlikely to abandon its conservative stance on the won,
given concerns about upside to exports being
competed away by a cheapening yen. We have seen
such concerns drive the policy response function in
2009, in mid-2012 and again last year. Given the
expected strength in the broader dollar, and the BoK's
reaction function, we see better risk reward to express
the view of fundamental strength in KRW via JPY/KRW
downside. We target a clean break of the psychological
10 level, with a near-term target of 9.75.
sourer &IOWA. &a* AMP] paY
[Korean shipping and construction orders remain strong
120.0
aShipbuilding orders
LISObn
• Overseas coretruction orders
1997
2000
2003
2006
2009
1
I
1
I
1
I
I
1
2 1
40.0 •
0D -
100.0
80.0
60.0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
•••••
•CtstY appreciation vs USD IPBoC fixings)
Chirta CPI RHS)
OD
Source °AMOY Bahl, GEC
Melillo Sachdeva, Singapore, +65 6423 8947
Perry Kojodjojo, Hong Kong, +852 2203 6153
Page 16
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610291
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #9: Pole dances, TRY trips
Go long PLN and HUF, buoyed by competitive
REERs and proximity to strong German demand,
and stay short TRY, as reserves are insufficient to
act as a buffer and where external deficits require
further adjustment to restore competitiveness
Aggregated EMEA FX correlation (3m rolling correlation
of daily changes) have dropped to levels only seen once
post-crisis (prior to the Fed opening the door to
tapering last May). The stand-out underperformer is
TRY, undermined by risk spreads on both sovereign
and corporate bonds having widened on domestic
political instability that has already claimed the jobs of
a few ministers. At the other end we have ILS and PLN
outperforrnance, but HUF has also has performed
reasonably well, largely unchanged vs the USD over the
past month. More divergence with idiosyncratic factors
playing a greater rote is something we have argued for
some time, and although disrupted by the 'taper
tantrum' in O2/Q3 2013 in particular, the trend is intact.
With the Fed pushing fewer (but still a lot) of dollars
into the global economy, it still makes sense to avoid
currencies with large C/A deficits, and/or those where
indebtedness has risen substantially (be that public
and/or private). However, in economies where FX
weakness in 2013 was more a function of weak
growth/policy rate cuts, higher yields should not be
damaging as long as the rise in yields is orderly and
reflects improved growth prospects. Export oriented
economies with competitive real exchange rates and
limited balance sheet risk should benefit from a
sustained global recovery.
In EMEA this is likely to translate into more divergence
between PLN & HUF (benefitting from relatively
competitive REERs, a strong German economy and
export led recoveries), and the ILS (where the BoP
effect will maintain appreciation pressures) on the one
hand, and on the other CZK (sustained CNB
intervention) plus TRY & ZAR (vulnerable to a
tightening of global liquidity on insufficient FX reserves).
The Russian RUB meanwhile, will be stuck somewhere
in between, supported by low balance sheet risk and
attractive carry but undermined by the threat of lower
oil prices and the lack of credible reforms.
From red-hot to stone cold
Growth is picking up. Poland will benefit not only from
strong German demand but also a healthy banking
system, with domestic credit now grinding higher. Any
sign of demand-led inflation will make the NBP
uncomfortable so Poland is likely to be one of the front-
runners in this tightening cycle. Also, longer-term
valuation points to 'fair-value' around 3.80, suggesting
that in an environment of stronger demand the Bank is
unlikely to be sensitive to zloty appreciation. Go long
PLN vs EUR, target 3.95 with a stop @ 4.30.
(Average correlation within EMEA FX (daily changes)
0.8 -
0.7 -
0.6 -
0.5 -
be 0.4 -
0.3 -
02 -
0.1 -
0.0
Sam' pastas, &nit lawnIxeg "'nano, LP
2003
2008
2013
'Cheap & cyclical EM FX
X
r..20 •
0
car
Pre
cs
•
•
•
SRL
PEN
Cl•
•
RUB
•
*
1011
• * •
ZAR •
too.
i
•
vizt
•
TRY
RON
•
•
•
TRO
Mfg
WNW and cyclNal EN FX
•
HUT
•
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Exports % of GDP
Santa. Lit•agno dalµ abom's• Fano. LP
'Polish competitiveness helping market share
80 -
70 -
60 -
50
40 -
3° -
a) 20 -
0 to -
0 -
-10 -
-20
5pAs:ims .ims .ims:ims
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
— Total German Imports — German imports from Poland
Swat Datserso Bonk abornfrarg Amine* IP
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 17
EFTA00610292
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
History provides us with good templates of economies
where oil/gas findings resulted in a significant
contribution to the BoP and persistent appreciation
(NLG & NOK). Also, Bol governor Flug acknowledged
as much on Nov 19h when she argued that the current
intervention policies are only "acting to give the
business sector time to adjust to the trends derived
from [long term economic] forces". Buy ILS vs USD,
targeting 3.35 with a stop @ 35750.
Having reduced rates aggressively since mid 2012, the
NBH adopted a more conservative policy approach,
with financial stability moving back up the agenda.
Real yields remain among the most attractive globally.
retail sales are growing YoY, the PMI firmly is in
expansionary territory, unemployment has fallen and
the C/A balance is in surplus. Be long HUF vs EUR,
targeting 290 with a stop 0 305.
While the ruble trend has been highly negative over the
past few months, favourable seasonality going into
Feb/Mar and bearish positioning make us cautiously
constructive around current levels. The relatively low
balance sheet risk, attractive carry, CBR's strong anti-
inflationary policy stance, and a robust surplus in the
goods balance are other supportive factors. Buy RUB vs.
EUR, targeting 43.10, stop @ 45.90.
ZAR is cheap but arguably not yet sufficiently, and in
the absence of any meaningful improvement in the
external balances there is scope for further weakening
in a rising interest rate environment. C/A fundability
remains the key risk, with exports so far showing few
signs of improvement from past currency weakness.
Even so, there has been some response to stronger
demand from abroad and with global growth
continuing to improve this should be reflected in
gradual rand stabilization. Key levels are: a) 10.85,
where price action according to our metrics would be
severely stretched and thus raise the probability of a
significant snap-back, and b) 10.40, which represents
the lower end of the more recent channel. On a break
of either, target a 3% move in USD/ZAR to 10.50 or
10.10 respectively.
Turkey's lira remains vulnerable to a tightening of
global liquidity due to its sizeable C/A deficits and/or
short-term external debt repayments in an environment
of rising global yields. Add to that ongoing domestic
political uncertainty and TRY should remain under
pressure. Stay long USD/7RY, target 2.250, stopping at
2.1350.
Henrik Gullberg, London, +(44) 20754 59847
'Strong and persistent FDI inflows into Israel
4 -
2004
2006
2008
2010
2012
40-
• -1
— Net Transactions. Direct Investment
• Israeli Direct Investment Abroad
• Foreign Direct Investment
&tom Clerttene EWA Eitone>crg r'once EP
'Hungary C/A in surplus and growing
1.0
g 0.5 -
2 0.0 -
f -o.s
-
g -1 5 -
0
-2.0 -
III
-2.5 -
1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012
— 12m MA • Balance
Santo' Darnel* Bort 8bonecry bream EP
'Turkey's narrow & broad basic balances (12m rolling)
1
go
a:3
g-4
8-5
-6
2005
2007
2009
2011
2013
— TRY NEER. ens
•
Broad Basic Balance (CIA • FDI • Palbea flows), Its
• Narrow Bow Balance (CIA + FOB Ills
Source Douteaso Sank avec...Lew 'ewe,. LP
130
120
110
100i-
90
80
70
Page 18
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610293
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #10: Pesos no prickly pair
e
Cyclical Lat Am FX offers value in an environment
of strong US/global growth.
e
Stay long MXN vs. USD, COP and RUB on back of
FDI inflow pre-pricing and oil production prospects.
Long CLP/COP should benefit from terms of trade
and political uncertainty in the latter. Stay cautious
on BRL because of structural concerns, weak
fundamentals and less BCB intervention appetite.
After 2013's annus horibills, we anticipate Lat Am FX to
offer more value over the coming months. The reaction
to December's Fed tapering decision suggests markets
have fully incorporated expectations of higher long-end
US yields. Going forward, we expect currency
performance to be closer to fundamentals and less
sensitive to the re-pricing in US rates. That said,
successful forward guidance, at least in the short term,
is a necessary condition for La Am performance in
2014. Growth surprises in the US should then in
principle
benefit
currencies
with strong
export
exposures that have already seen considerable
adjustment. From this point of view, CLP, PEN and
MXN have the highest betas to the global cycle with
the latter particularly well placed to benefit from an
upturn in the US economy.
Despite more favorable valuations and possible upturn
in some of the local economies, structural concerns
and balance of payments dynamics remain headwinds
for the region as whole. Where export-orientated
growth is more elusive, such as in the more closed
economies of Brazil and Colombia, domestic demand
may not be sufficient to provide attractive rates of
return for foreign investment against a backdrop of US
rate normalization. At the same time, export growth will
be insufficient to close current account deficits.
Renewed falls in commodity prices also present a risk
for COP, PEN and CLP, although our base case is that
better China growth will provide a boost for the latter.
Tuming to individual currencies, we remain bullish on
the Mexican peso. First, the energy reform passed in
December is more ambitious than expected. Licenses
and production sharing contracts, rather than the
originally proposed profit sharing regime, increase the
potential for FDI inflows. While we do not expect the
first inflows until 2015, academic research into IME
flows and the relationship between exchange rates and
commodity prices suggest that FX markets may 'pre-
price' expected capital flows meaning that continued
momentum over secondary legislation will be more
important than deal announcements per se" It is worth
noting that Mexico has foregone the bonanza in FDI.
IA better starting point for valuations
Savor &lathe Bak
ICLP to benefit most from global growth bounce
70%
GO%
50%
40%
30%
20%
'0%
0%
.10%
-20%
NON*
LUSA
Centre
aw:asas % GDP
I
FX correlations to yoy GDP
I
I
COP
WIZ
PUN
PEN
CLP
salcce. aura* am*
'Mexico should begin to close FDI gap
0.40 1 —Average Latin America, cum/ague FIJI inflows
Mexico, cumulative FDI inflows
Jan-03 Apr-04
Jul-06
Oce06 Janal Apr-09 Jul-Ill °cell
&wee. dissent &wit atom:Km Aran, CO
e See, for example. D8 Commodities Quarterly, Trading industrial metals
ratios in a rising USD environment, Aso Fu, June 2013.
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 19
EFTA00610294
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
enjoyed by its neighbors over the past decade, a result
of onerous regulation and weak productivity growth.
We anticipate that this FDI gap will begin to close as
2013's reforms bear fruit.
Second, growth is set to be sharply stronger. Our
economist has noted that the main reason behind the
disappointing performance of Mexican manufacturing
relative to the US this year was the lack of growth in
high-value sectors to which the Mexican economy has
become more sensitive. We do not anticipate this
dynamic to continue. At the same time, the drag
caused by last year's lack of government spending will
end, with the IMF showing Mexico to possess one of
the most positive fiscal impulses in EM next year. We
therefore like to be long MXN against USD, targeting
12.50. Given the positive outlook for oil production and
FDI, we also like playing MXN strength against other oil
producers, in particular COP and RUB.
In contrast, the Brazilian real will likely face another
challenging year. The current account has only
improved modestly in spite of significant FX adjustment
and the income balance remains a concern as a decade
of large scale FDI inflows are 'paid back.' Moreover,
while FX reserve coverage remains ample, the BCB has
signaled it will adopt a more cautious stance over FX
intervention over the course of the coming six months,
as the central bank's swap book grows to up to 25% of
total reserves. Finally, the upcoming election is unlikely
to result an improvement in positive sentiment around
the govemment's fiscal policies. We expect USD/BRL
to trade in a high (2.25-2.50) range, ending the year at
2.40.
Regarding the Andeans, we foresee a difficult period
for COP and a better backdrop for CLP and PEN. With
respect to COP, the upcoming election year also
represents a concern, with President Santos facing a
strong challenge from the populist right. There are also
question marks surrounding the outcome of peace
negotiations with the FARC. Exports are expected to
suffer as Venezuela's economic crises drags on.
Combined with a muted outlook for oil prices, this
suggests the COP will likely be the best short among
Lat Am currencies next year. We like to play this versus
a rather depressed CLP, which should benefit from a
possible upturn in China and possible lower oil prices.
PEN should also be helped by the uptick in growth
(especially after last year's slowdown) and spillover
effects from the expected increase in copper
production.
Altogether we like to be long MXN vs COP and RUB,
long
CLP
vs
COP, long
PEN
and
see
BRL
underperforming the forwards while possibly trading in
a 2.25-2.50 range.
Guilherme Marone, New York,
Oliver Harvey ,London,
Basic balance suggests still scope for BRL downside
—
B.nilbwad basic balance, % GDP
-
USD/B1% Ohs, matted)
7%
0%
-2%
Oct-99 Aug-DI Jun-03 Apr-06 FS-07 Dec-08 Clet-10 Aug-12
swam Dames: exit leogratelg Monte LP
1.30
I80
2 30
280
130
'Elections not good for BRL and COP
10%
0%
-10%
-20%
-30%
-40%
-50% -
-60%
-70%
FX returns, 6m prior to general election
1
Il• '
■Colombia is Brazil
1994
1999
2002
2006
2010
Saucca. Damen. &me Stoareergfrence LP
Page 20
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610295
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Theme #11: Vol to roll
•
We see relative value opportunities in vol surface
distortions; specifically buying EUR/USD FVAs,
USD/JPY vol swaps and risk reversals, plus
AUD/USD puts cheapened with AUD/CAD KOs
Trade 1: Hedge against event-risks with EUR/USD
FVAs: Despite potential catalysts such as the US
fiscal impasse and EU political uncertainty, EUR/USD
implied vol remained subdued in 2013, and was
predominantly driven instead by rates volatility. With
the USD10Y Treasury note yield expected to touch
4% on growth acceleration this year EUR/USD
implieds should be supported. Correspondingly, this
suggests that owning EUR/USD vol remains a useful
blunt hedge against tail risks with significant impact
on rates volatility in the US and EU. Potential
catalysts include growth momentum deceleration in
the US, an excessive rates rise following the tapering
process forcing the Fed to backpedal, and ECB
easing in Q1 on falling inflation expectations.
Currently, outright long the vol swap is less attractive
given implieds have been well bid since December.
Instead, consider owing a 3M in 6M EUR/USD FVA at
—8.50% on the USD vega notional to exploit the
flatness of the implied volatility slope (chart 2).
Trade 2: Long JPY volatility on model valuation:
Another approach in analyzing volatilities relates to
longer-term model valuations. On our framework,
USD/JPY 1Y realized vol is estimated at 10.6% (chart
3) but could potentially trend higher. Among its core
parameters are the Japanese current account (+ve
beta), commodity prices (-ve beta), US core inflation
(-ve beta) and the cyclically adjusted P/E ratio for US
equities (+ve beta). With the falls in commodities and
some eventual improvement in the current account
and a higher P/E ratio as the base case for this year,
risks to volatility tilt to the upside. Consider owning a
1Y vol swap, offered at —10.70% of USD notional.
Note also that white we have been consistent
advocates of AUD and CAD vol over the past year on
our analysis of volumes, policy divergence and
growth rebalancing these arguments are gradually
becoming less attractive from a valuation perspective.
Switching to long USD/JPY vol would seem to offer a
better risk/reward payoff.
'Changes in 3M implieds over the past year
3%
2%
-0.6%
-1%
0
0
0
0
gw ;
2.40
=
sy
a
Swett Dame!. Bmtl. Bloont0e0 Anne. LP
'Vol slope for EUR/USD is historically flat
16
Is
14
13
12
11
10
9
7
6
T T
T
0
9M
12M
Sweat Moon,
RaanatLP Chas 4,0021..waspols 10 tb• xi. 25% Si% 75% wx, 95%
pLecoartin Paw OS pal t WM yaws bilse "*1 Inplasert ewax roar,*
'Modeled 1Y realized USD/JPY vol versus implied
22%
20%
18%
16%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
Y Realised Vol (Model)
Y Implied Vol
90
92
94
96
98
00
02
04
06
08
10
12
14
Samar Anarch, &at 8bombeettirnme LP
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 21
EFTA00610296
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Trade 3: Leverage the USD/JPY skew: The supposed
stalling
of
Abenomics
'third-arrow'
reforms,
uncertainty on tapering and likely poor investor
timing in the USD/JPY trade has seen risk reversals
diverging from spot for much of the second half of
2013. The current level of divergence, at <1.5%
percentile over the past decade, is nearing historical
extremes (chart 4). Since the '08 financial crises there
had been only two episodes where this occurred, in
Q1 2012 and Q1 2013, each time followed by a
strong reversion of risk reversals to spot.
Beyond historical precedent, we see two drivers that
may propel risk-reversals higher. A steepening of the
US yields and further traction of Abenomics would
argue for a firmer spot-risk-reversal correlation in the
near term, as uncertainty in both whiplashed riskies
for much of H2. Furthermore, if spot moves higher in
line with our forecasts, the impact of hedging of
structured notes should then become a stronger
driver of mid to back-end risk-reversals. The most
important driver here is outstanding 25.30Y Power-
Reverse Dual Currency notes, of which we estimate a
sizable portion with knock-outs are centered around
the 112.5-120.0 bucket. Risk reversals should then
find support as demand-supply imbalances are
reduced from lesser hedging requirements.
We thus recommend USD/JPY options that buy the
risk reversal targeting the 6M-12M tenors. Consider a
9-month USD/JPY 109 call funded by selling a
102/91.50 RKI put for zero cost, off spot ref 104.40.
Trade 4: Lower USD-CAD beta Implied correlation
between AUD/USD and AUD/CAD has remained
elevated (-86% percentile), which provides sizable
cheapening to AUD/USD puts by selling correlation.
This relationship relates to CAD being perceived as a
USD substitute, which we think will not be the case
as Fed tapering spurs bond repatriation and
underscores policy divergence between the two.
Thus, consider a 6M AUD/USD 0.86 put with an
AUD/CAD 0.83 cross knock-out indicatively for
136bps versus 190bps for the vanilla, off spot refs
0.8920 (-3.6% from strike) and 0.9580 (-13.4% from
the barrier).
Empirically, since the 1983 AUD floatation AUD/CAD
dips have been more constrained than AUD/USD,
unsurprisingly given the broad dollar response and
cyclical co-sensitivity of commodities (see highlights
in chart 3). Historically, a -3.6% AUD/USD put with
an -13.4% AUD/CAD KO would have been in-the-
money 26.2% of the time, and knocked out 2.7% of
the time.
Nicholas Weng, London, (+44) 20754 76615
James Malcolm, London, (+44)20754 50884
'Weekly change in spot versus risk reversal at extreme
0.18
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
0.00
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
-0.02
04
OS
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
Salvor MO. diporMenioXnp 3M Neve m'n Stair spar nnotAimnao in wile* 6.04 Met nwisai
'Spots diverge but implied correlation near highs
1.10
120%
AUD/CAD
1.00
110%
0.90
100%
0.80
GM implied
90%
0.70
correlation
AUD/USO
80%
0.60
70%
0.50
0.40
60%
0.30
50%
0.20
40%
Jan-03
Jan-05
Jan-07
Jan-09
Jan-11
Jan-13
Salver Dome* &S. licamityp Fawn LP
'When returns fall AUD/USD underperforms AUD/CAD
40%
AUD/USD 6M retum
AUD/CAD 6M return
AUDJUSI) strike
AUD
KO brinier.
30%
20%
10%
0%
-10%
-20%
-30%
-40% ttt
ttt
84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14
&knew Dana* &test Scoralwg Amnia, CP
Page 22
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610297
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Trade Recommendation Update
Trades from September 24 2013 to January 8 2014
Trade
Theme
Gain/Loss on trades
Gain/Loss on theme
Long USD TVVI
1
1.14%
0.33%
Short EUR/USD
1
-0.48%
Long USD calls vs. MYR, BRL,
2
TRY
1.05%
1.05%
Long USD/JPY
3
6.3%
6.3%
Short CHF TWI
4
0.5%
Short GBP/USD
4
-2.5%
-1%
Long AUD/NZD
5
-3.6 (-4.49%)%
-3.6%
Short EUR/NOK
6
-1.1% (-3.2%)*
Short EUR/SEK
6
-1.6% (-2.19%)
-1.35%
Short SGD/INR
7
-1% (5%)
Long USD/MYR calls
7
2.9%
0.95%
Long PLN/CZK
8
7%
Long PLN/HUF
8
1.1%
Long RUB vs. basket
8
-1.5% (-4.37%)
Short TRY/ZAR
8
-3.6% (1.83%)
0.75%
Long MXN/BRL
9
7.14%
Long CLP/COP
9
-2.44%
2.35%
Long EUR/USD vol swap
10
-1.3%
Long GBP/USD vol swap
10
-0.8%
-0.8%
No. of winners:
8
6
No. of losers:
11
4
Hit Ratio
42%
60%,
Average gain/loss:
0.38%
0.47%
*Indicates MN without risk management
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 23
EFTA00610298
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Appendix 1
Important Disclosures
Additional information available upon request
For disclosures pertaining to recommendations or estimates made on securities other than the primary subject of this
research, please see the most recently published company report or visit our global disclosure look-up page on our
website at
Analyst Certification
The views expressed in this report accurately reflect the personal views of the undersigned lead analyst(s). In addition,
the undersigned lead analyst(s) has not and will not receive any compensation for providing a specific recommendation
or view in this report. Bilal Hafeez/Alan Ruskin/Henrik Gullberg/James Malcolm/Sameer Goel
Page 24
Deutsche Bank AG/London
EFTA00610299
9 January 2014
FX Blueprint: Thin end of the wedge
Regulatory Disclosures
1. Important Additional Conflict Disclosures
Aside from within this report, important conflict disclosures can also be found at
under the
"Disclosures Lookup" and "Legal tabs. Investors are strongly encouraged to review this information before investing.
2. Short-Term Trade Ideas
Deutsche Bank equity research analysts sometimes have shorter-term trade ideas (known as SOLAR ideas) that are
consistent or inconsistent with Deutsche Bank's existing longer term ratings. These trade ideas can be found at the
SOLAR link at
3. Country-Specific Disclosures
Australia and New Zealand: This research, and any access to it, is intended only for 'wholesale clients" within the
meaning of the Australian Corporations Act and New Zealand Financial Advisors Act respectively.
Brazil: The views expressed above accurately reflect personal views of the authors about the subject company(ies) and
its(their) securities, including in relation to Deutsche Bank. The compensation of the equity research analyst(s) is
indirectly affected by revenues deriving from the business and financial transactions of Deutsche Bank. In cases where
at least one Brazil based analyst (identified by a phone number starting with +55 country code) has taken part in the
preparation of this research report, the Brazil based analyst whose name appears first assumes primary responsibility for
its content from a Brazilian regulatory perspective and for its compliance with CVM Instruction # 483.
EU
countries:
Disclosures
relating
to
our
obligations
under
MiFiD
can
be
found
at
Japan: Disclosures under the Financial Instruments and Exchange Law: Company name - Deutsche Securities Inc.
Registration number - Registered as a financial instruments dealer by the Head of the Kanto Local Finance Bureau
(Kinsho) No. 117. Member of associations: JSDA, Type II Financial Instruments Firms Association, The Financial Futures
Association of Japan, Japan Investment Advisers Association. This report is not meant to solicit the purchase of specific
financial instruments or related services. We may charge commissions and fees for certain categories of investment
advice, products and services. Recommended investment strategies, products and services carry the risk of losses to
principal and other losses as a result of changes in market and/or economic trends, and/or fluctuations in market value.
Before deciding on the purchase of financial products and/or services, customers should carefully read the relevant
disclosures, prospectuses and other documentation. "Moody's", 'Standard & Poor's", and "Fitch" mentioned in this
report are not registered credit rating agencies in Japan unless "Japan" or "Nippon" is specifically designated in the
name of the entity.
Malaysia: Deutsche Bank AG and/or its affiliate(s) may maintain positions in the securities referred to herein and may
from time to time offer those securities for purchase or may have an interest to purchase such securities. Deutsche Bank
may engage in transactions in a manner inconsistent with the views discussed herein.
Russia: This information, interpretation and opinions submitted herein are not in the context of, and do not constitute,
any appraisal or evaluation activity requiring a license in the Russian Federation.
Risks to Fixed Income Positions
Macroeconomic fluctuations often account for most of the risks associated with exposures to instruments that promise
to pay fixed or variable interest rates. For an investor that is long fixed rate instruments (thus receiving these cash
flows), increases in interest rates naturally lift the discount factors applied to the expected cash flows and thus cause a
loss. The longer the maturity of a certain cash flow and the higher the move in the discount factor, the higher will be the
loss. Upside surprises in inflation, fiscal funding needs, and FX depreciation rates are among the most common adverse
macroeconomic shocks to receivers. But counterparty exposure, issuer creditworthiness, client segmentation, regulation
(including changes in assets holding limits for different types of investors), changes in tax policies, currency
convertibility (which may constrain currency conversion, repatriation of profits and/or the liquidation of positions), and
settlement issues related to local clearing houses are also important risk factors to be considered. The sensitivity of fixed
income instruments to macroeconomic shocks may be mitigated by indexing the contracted cash flows to inflation, to
FX depreciation, or to specified interest rates - these are common in emerging markets. It is important to note that the
index fixings may — by construction -- lag or mis-measure the actual move in the underlying variables they are intended
to track. The choice of the proper fixing (or metric) is particularly important in swaps markets, where floating coupon
rates (i.e., coupons indexed to a typically short-dated interest rate reference index) are exchanged for fixed coupons. It is
also important to acknowledge that funding in a currency that differs from the currency in which the coupons to be
received are denominated carries FX risk. Naturally, options on swaps (swaptions) also bear the risks typical to options
in addition to the risks related to rates movements.
Deutsche Bank AG/London
Page 25
EFTA00610300
David Folkerts-Landau
Group Chief Economist
Member of the Group Executive Committee
Guy Ashton
Global Chief Operating Officer
Research
Marcel Cassard
Global Head
FICC Research & Global Macro Economics
Richard Smith and Steve Pollard
Co-Global Heads
Equity Research
Michael Spencer
Regional Head
Asia Pacific Research
International Locations
Ralf Hoffmann
Regional Head
Deutsche Bank Research, Germany
Andreas Neubauer
Regional Head
Equity Research, Germany
Steve Pollard
Regional Head
Americas Research
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Securities Inc.
Deutsche Bank Place
Grog° Gallusstra8e 10-14
Filial° Hongkong
2-11-1 Nagatacho
Level 16
60272 Frankfurt am Main
International Commerce Centre,
Senna Park Tower
Corner of Hunter & Phillip Streets
Germany
1 Austin Road West,Kowloon,
Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-6171
Sydney, NSW 2000
Tel: (49)69 910 00
Hong Kong
Japan
Australia
Tel: (852) 2203 8888
Tel: (81) 3 5156 6770
Tel: (61) 2 8258 1234
Deutsche Bank AG London
Deutsche Bank Securities Inc.
1 Great Winchester Street
60 Wall Street
London EC2N 2E03
New York, NY 10005
United Kingdom
United States of America
Tel 04) 20 7545 8000
Tel:
Global Disclaimer
flu ifganicitha and 0011010 II PM faMulenua guaearedbh DeuiSehttBanii AGO. ana011tS agates ICOliternegy teutlehe Bark". Tlu itilanweban linenIS behold tuba Moth and has beat attained ham talc
Sanaa Unwed Kobe rehab& Martha Bags mane nh areea•Weaelln as M BO OCOureCy Of eiSmgahargos al Mth irdOrmatial.
CoursCha Bank may OrigNia la Wallas brumeginfa, One prOpriatily Wain at datable in a intoner enOnsistent with the Vert than in this richarCh haat h adde% atherS wino DansChe Bank, inguding
sicategisti YO SAMS SNP, wily lake a view dial is inalikailtatt with dial 41kat in the canard, opal.
Option. aserrods and {ea.:Klan in this opal CansMula the Conant tudgemird al to; mita , Oa Of tha deal alibis apart Thy Oa nal niMinelariy renal !ha OpirsOns 01 DiurSava Bank and are gibbet SO thing.
withal NNA. Datesehe Bank has re *Meehan to update. mahly Ct Inkind Nis Moan Ct to Whinnied, nobly a cairiant Mamal in the anal Chit any apinet fo4Oal at anima. sal lanh Mein, Chinon. 04
Subsemerny beCtunis iroammis Peals Ira aralablity 01 Inman irnirtrards are wheel to Change imitate noon This ripen is praidad 10f inlikonOnnal puiplea any. It it net an oat at a SalategOn 01 an
bore US toy a sal any timing/0 ins/Jumada at CO pantipele in Om potholer Wang Strategy. Target miCeemeinteeently imprerkai and a prOckia Of VW analyst judgernaM.
Foreign Matangi, truninCliOro Card 'Al and may nog ba ApptipoilidefOr MI COMO. ParliOpand in foreign Withenga Canine On, may incur asks Caring Iran Swag faCiark inebding the lolOwep11 Waal nattang.
NOW ten be ‘011,110 Mel at. haat CO large RuCluenats. 21 Na wlatiff Cum:raid mei beafktdd by nunienhe motet thanes inciting nee and ealiOnei 0:000iniC, patiliail and regulehly Could. Wards in Oda
and bond markets and Magni n intenlil Mies YO 31 CurrenCi<6 nay be wheel to dinnamOOn at felmienmard npOsed Gallant* COniras whip 00,44 negtiesay *heel the value el Na Curreney. [Minis an/
Ons:Ouraged Pinata that ono inlarrod irm1sztarag andge Wang dahhisOna PAM polanwenik* is net naCigianly Marlin/ Ottawa Notate Dalattet Bank may with Nivea to swages ahead by the Meat sell 10
or buy ban grammars en a magpie basis. and eihnsehif this ripen natant
10 Ueda an a ManinarY teak
Dalyetwe UmmettiOm awaw numarOus asks inducting, among Oaras. medal. Cauniarparly default and illguigh !risk. The IropPainfewie of 0:banyanOf Owl* padas la use by inoilays n dalandeni On tha
inviolate' Own tiotiernianCist inCludnt pain ar whiten, Owe nowt/gory ashirorrant and the Masa 01 that other Minh and liablaie and as sadth iniuloloot sishuU Una aspen lags a d finanCia *dear betas
ending into any braneatiOn going to o ahead tri Pm Contents of Nis p.briCiatiOn. TOO, in OpiOnS irmgots Rik and ii net surt/b/a fa al irm1stas. POO, N bu0ng at siding as OptiOn nyeaten must renew tha
tharaehalline and RIFT. Of Slandlaleal OplOns.' el
Sinai Me moth to awes tha abate please 006140 Deulaha Bar* ADM—.
for a COW
011hil inifnitan1d0Cionint
Tim FA Of PM in tubing. trading /ma Opitne, laragn Oa doming. an be sutalantal. As a Ma Cd Iha tap degral of amp age Obtainable in future* ar0Opiens trading. bliss may be oatmeal that at. meat than
TO amount Of lands nieatyonMsited,
WPM °Marring law payees Oihanyi90. al Irarniatheti thald be fognigad Ovaugh Oa Dhrodia Bank entity in Ow in...Liars her. jura6CliOn In Oa U S. Nis Maul a append arab. dislobned by CouthCha
Bank SOCuMint Ins„ a manna al W NYSE. the SARIS NFA end SIP.
Connany this sport o apathy' andge COmmuni0M/0 by CUMWEM Bank AG Frankhon auto:wind beg O. Bin, In Ow United Koggan this
'Mal is IgalaCmid Andra anninuniated by 00ASChe Barg AG Landon. a member in tha London StOCI, (Whinge said agitated by Iha Financial CranduagintiOrity fa tha 00r4M1 01 inwientent Nina*, in the UK
and aulhonhad by OM Bann. Th. mean n dalitiolad in Hone Kano tn 0Oulahl, Dank AG. Nang Kea BfanCh, n Korea by Oetilltha Saurian Korea CO. The anal is clibibuted in Sing/pOretri Oiluistb0 Bank AG.
Seanioni Branch a 00.tisCto Situated, Asia tinging Siricaplee Brandi (Oro WOW Ouni 018.00 South Tana Sager:an 001503, .6.5 6423 BLOM and cairient. n SWOON of the Maul are CO eihnreCt Oadahe
Bank AG. Singahre Stirlen 04 Wulsdia SOW gas Asia tingled, Sokopara Banal in ',Nara 04 -
mailers aching from, of in 00rineliOn with. this Moen. Wheat Pie anal a issued Or prOniulcia/d in Sngapots la
patron Labe
net an Xeredigid inyeela. awan inwslor of Wahl:an/I imasstr as Whig in Na apolialbe Simomaa lawS ad
Diurodia Bank AG. Singapore Branch at Malabo Seepage AAA
Limited. Singapore Brandi ae0aprO Nag wahrotiley to oath parson fin Na fantails 01 the swat In Japan this swan is apes:wed fedi}, distrbuted by Deutian &Cunha hie, lima iillarmnian eOrdared in the
septa &WS not 00ratilisa the pinyon. of nyealmeril Adige,. In Armenia fetal dente Ma-4d obtain a cops Of a Padua Oistbowe Shlternent OkOSI refiring to Om granail Sitelint Marra, a in Nis Meal and
COnSida, the POS DOOM irobng env dagifiOn About &Kepi to enquire On Medea, Deutsche Bank AG JOttannitaturkp G inamptichad in the Pectoral BipubliC Of Germany Minh Register Number n South ACP..
1998023298/10). Add/Mehl inkeynegan Wawa tO scannas. Oltor wain saghttl of (duals detaches:I in this MOOR a Crallatig ran aawal, The report may net be resonduaid. diseamial Cr putlahad by pee
paean lair any pupal. withOut Malabo Barts pail ninon amain PIMPS ate Santa San gearing.
COpONM 62014 DiutiChi Bank AG
GRCM2014PROD031109
EFTA00610301
Technical Artifacts (18)
View in Artifacts BrowserEmail addresses, URLs, phone numbers, and other technical indicators extracted from this document.
Flight #
OS06Phone
(852) 2203Phone
+44) 20754 7661Phone
+44)20754 5088Phone
+65 6423 8947Phone
+852 2203 6153Phone
258 1234Phone
545 8000Phone
8023298SWIFT/BIC
APPENDIXSWIFT/BIC
DISCLOSURESTail #
N20Tail #
N213URL
https://www.boi.or.iaten/announcements/pressAoenWire Ref
referenceWire Ref
reflectedWire Ref
reflectingWire Ref
reflectionRelated Documents (6)
DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown
Filing # 33747975 E-Filed 10/27/2015 04:45:57 PM
91p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown
EFTA Document EFTA01659028
0p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown
EFTA Document EFTA01655731
0p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown
EFTA Document EFTA01658887
0p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown
EFTA Document EFTA01659529
0p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown
EFTA Document EFTA01656010
0p
Forum Discussions
This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.