Case File
efta-efta00610311DOJ Data Set 9OtherREPORTS'
Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
efta-efta00610311
Pages
4
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available
Extracted Text (OCR)
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
REPORTS'
Fig. 3. Drag coefficient as
a function of wind speed. CD
is shown for an observation-
based resistance coefficient,
r = 0.02 an 54. The red
open circles are the eval-
uated CD from the current
and nind Observations, the
solid red line is a fitted
quadratic curve to the CD
estimates, and the red
dashed lines are the 95%
confidence limits for this
quadratic curve. The black
dotted tines represent the
window for CD reported in
(6), whereas the blue dots
represent CD reported in (4).
I
nos
as
w
a0
40
Mind Wiwi (wf0, m C')
speeds below 30 m
are somewhat noisy as a
result of measurement uncertainty and the need
to calculate a velocity derivative, which tends to
enhance noise. However, they consistently
show a decreasing trend of Co for wind speeds
greater than 32 m s-I, the lower threshold for a
category I hurricane on the Saffir-Simpson Scale.
It is also apparent that the CD values are weakly
dependent on the choice of the resistance co-
efficient and are larger for increasing values
of r. The drag coefficient estimates evaluated
for r
0.1 cm s n are, on average, 20% greater
than those calculated for r
0.001 cm s I from
Erg- 3-
To produce the best representation of CD for
each r, a second-order curve (a function of the
wind speed) was fitted by a least-squares
technique to all estimated values of CD. The
curves are displayed in Figs. 2 and 3. Addition-
ally, the 95% confidence limits for the fitted
curve are shown in Fig. 3. The pattern of the
relationship between Co and the wind speed is
robust, but the curve coefficients are determined
by the value chosen for r in Eq. 3. However, all
curves clearly show an initial increase of the drag
coefficient and monotonic decrease as found by
recent studies (3—B) after reaching a maximum
value at —32 m s-I. Some of these studies (3, /9)
imply that the decreasing drag at high winds
seems to be related to the spray, foam, and
bubbles from breaking waves that reduce the
drag and allow the hurricane to slip over the sea.
With the nearly full water-column ocean cur-
rent measurements. the only unknown term left
in the simplified equation of motion is the wind
stress. Thus, the behavior of the drag coefficient
(CD) can easily be estimated for a range of strong
winds. Despite the fact that the drag coefficient is
evaluated dittbrently here, estimates of Co
determined "bottom-up" reasonably replicate
the values determined "top-down" in recent
studies (3-7). Results from our research show
that CD peaks at a wind speed near 32 in s-I and
ea
then steadily decreases as the wind speed
continues to rise. Our values for CD are in a
range of Co values found using meteorological
observations (4) for wind speeds greater than
32 m 5-I but are higher for lower wind speeds.
These differences may be attributed to uncertain-
ties in the wind measurements and the applica-
bility of the simplified ocean dynamics at the
lower wind speeds.
References and Notes
1. K. Emanuel, Notate 436, 686 (2005).
2. 5. E. Larsen et oL, In Mod Stress Over the Ocean,
I. S. F. Hoes,Y. rota, Eds. (Cambridge UMV. Press,
New Wet 200U, chap. 7.
3. M. A. Damian et of, Geophys. Rex fa 31, 118306
10.10291200461019460 (2000.
4. M. D. Powell, P. J. Vickery, 1. A. Reinhold, Nature 422,
279 (20031.
5. E. D. Fernandez et oL, J. Geophys. Res. 111, C08013
10.1029/2005)(003018 (2006).
6. I. LA:saki. Ginis,I. Hara, J. Armos. SW 61,2334 (2004).
7. J. A. 1. Bye, A. O. Jenkins, I. Geophys. Res. 111, C03024
10.1029/2005jC003110 (2006).
B. K. Emanuel,?. Armes. Sri. 60, 1420 (2003).
9. M A. lAncheR, W. J. Teague, E. prow, D. W. Wang,
Geophys. Rn. Lela 32, L11610 10.1029/2005GL023014
(2005).
10. 0. w. Wang, O. A. Mitchell, W I. Teague, E. faros,
M. S. Hulbert, Some 309, 896 (20051.
IL W. J. Teague, E. prom, 0. W. Wang, O. A. Michell,
). Phys. OreoftogL, m press.
12. W. J. league, E. Jarosz, M. R. Carnes, D. A. Mitchell,
P. J. H09311, Coot Shelf Res. 26, 2559 (2006).
13. J. F. Price, t. 8. Sanford, G. Z. Fcenstall,
Phys.
Oreonogr. 24, 233 (1994).
14. Matenals and methods are available as supporting
material on Science Online.
15. G. T. Mitchum, W. Sturges, I. Plot Deettooge. 12,1310
(1982).
16. 5. 1. LenD, L Phys. &mow. 24, 2061 (1994).
17. 5.1. LenD, L Phys. Greasy,. 31, 2749 (2001).
1B. J. M. Mart
Phys. Ocean*. 32, 3101 (2002).
19. E. L Andreas, ). Phys. °alma". 34, 1029 (2004).
20. We thank M. S. Hulbert, A. J. Quaid, and W. A. Goode
for mowing support. We also thank the crews of the
research vessels Seward Johnson I and II. This sot was
supported by the Office of Naval Research as a part of
the Naval Research Laboratory's basic research protect
'Mope to Shell Energetics and Exchange Dynamics
(SEED)' under program element 0601153N, through the
Minerals Management Service Environmental Studies
Program Technology, and by the Minerals Management
Service technology Assessment and Research Program on
Nurticane Ivan.
Supporting Online Material
wvrtscierxemag.orgfcgikontentilull/315/5819/1707/DC1
SOM Tea
Fig. S1
References
1B October 2006; accepted 10 February 2007
10.1126Ndence.1136466
CRISPR Provides Acquired Resistance
Against Viruses in Prokaryotes
Rodolphe Barrangou,' Christophe Fremaux,2 Hake Deveau,3 Melissa Richards,'
Patrick Boyava1,2 Sylvain Moineau,3 Dennis A. Romero,' Philippe Horvath's'
Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) are a distinctive feature of the
genomes of most Bacteria and Archaea and are thought to be involved in resistance to bacteriophages.
We found that, after viral challenge, bacteria integrated new spacers derived from phage genomic
sequences. Removal or addition of particular spacers modified the phage-resistance phenotype of the
cell. Thus, CRISPR, together with associated cos genes, provided resistance against phages, and
resistance specificity is determined by spacer-phage sequence similarity.
B
acteriophages are arguably the most
abundant biological entity on the planet
(1) Their ubiquitous distribution and
abundance have an important impact on micro-
bial ecology and the evolution of bacterial
genomes (2). Consequently, bacteria have devel-
oped a variety of natural defense mechanisms
that target diverse steps of the phage life cycle,
notably blocking adsorption, preventing DNA
injection, restricting the incoming DNA, and
abortive infection systems. These antiviral bar-
riers can also be engineered and manipulated to
better control phase populations (2. 3).
Numerous bacteria have been selected by
humans and used extensively for lemrentation
and biotechnology processes. Unfortunately. do-
mesticated bacteria used in industrial applications
are often susceptible to phage attack including
Downloaded from www.sciencemag.org on November 2, 2008
wxfw.sciencemag.org SCIENCE VOL 315
23 MARCH 2007
1709
EFTA00610311
IREPORTS
genera and species widely used as dairy cultures
(4). Accordingly, the industry has devised various
strategies to combat phage based on strain di-
versity, bacteriophage-insensitive mutants, and
plagnids bearing phage-resistance mechanisms.
Streptococcus thermophilus is a low G+C
Gram-positive bacterium and a key species ex-
ploited in the formulation of dairy culture sys-
tems for the production of yogurt and cheese.
Comparative genomics analyses of closely
related S. thennopinlus strains have previously
revealed that genetic polymorphism primarily
occurs at hypervariable loci, such as the cps and
qac operons, as well as two clustered regularly
interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)
loci (5-7). CRISPR loci typically consist of sev-
eral noncontiguous direct repeats separated by
stretches of variable sequences called spacers and
are oftentimes adjacent to cuts genes (CRISPR-
associated). Although the function of CRISPR
loci has not been established biologically, in
silico analyses of the space's have revealed se-
quence homology with foreign elements, includ-
ing bacteriophage and plasmid sequences (7-9).
Based exclusively on in silico analyses, several
hypotheses have been put forward proposing
roles for CRISPR and am genes, which include
providing immunity against foreign genetic ele-
ments via a mechanism based on RNA inter-
ference (/0).
We analyzed the CRISPR sequences of vari-
ous S. thernwpItitus strains, including closely
related industrial strains and phage-resistant var-
iants (fig. SI). Differences in the number and
type of spacers were observed primarily at the
CRISPRI locus. Notably, phage sensitivity ap-
peared to be correlated with CRISPRI spacer
content. Specifically, spacer content was nearly
identical between parental strains and phase-
resistant derivatives, except for additional spacers
present in the latter. These findings therefore
suggest a potential relation between the presence
of additional spacers and the differences ob-
served in the phase sensitivity of a given strain.
This observation prompted us to investigate the
origin and Auction of additional spacers present
in phage-resistant mutants.
First, we tested the hypothesis that CRISPR
loci are altered during the natural generation
of phage-resistant mutants. A phage-host model
system was selected, consisting of a phage-
sensitive wild-type S. thermophilus strain widely
used in the dairy industry, DGCC77I0 [wild
type (WT)j and two distinct but closely related
virulent bacteriophages isolated from industrial
yogurt samples, phase 858 and phase 2972 (//).
'Danisco USA Inc., 3329 Agriculture Drive, Madison, WI
53716, USA. iDanisco France SAS, Bate Postale 10, F-86220
Dange.Saint.Romain. France. -tepartement de Bi3chimie et
de fAiaolnolegie, Faculte des Sciences et de Genie, Groupe
de Recherche en Frolcoie Buccale, lactate de Medecine
Dentaire, Felix
Reference Center for Bacterial
Viruses, Universite Laval, G1K 7Pa Quebec, Canada.
*To whom c
hould be addressed. Email:
Nine phage-resistant mutants were generated
independently by challenging the WT strain with
phage 858, phage 2972. or simultaneously with
both (12), and their CRISPR loci were analyzed.
Differences were consistently observed at the
CRISPRI locus, where I to 4 additional spacers
were inserted next to the 32 spacers present in
the WT strain (Fig. l). The addition of new
spacers in response to phage infection seemed to
be polarized toward one end of the CRISPRI lo-
cus. This is consistent with previous observations
of spacer hypervariability at the leader end of the
CRISPR locus in various strains (9. 13). Se-
quence analysis of the additional spacers inserted
in the CRISPR I locus of the various phase-
msistant mutants revealed similarity to sequences
found within the genomes of the phages used in
the challenge (Fig. 2 and fig. S2). Interestingly.
similarities were observed throughout the phage
gentles. in most finictional modules, both on the
coding and noneoding strands. No particular se-
quence, gene. or functional gmup seemed to be
targeted specifically. Them results reveal that, on
becoming resistant to bacteriophages, the CRISPRI
locus was modified by the integration of novel
spacers, apparently derived from phage DNA.
Surprisingly, we observed that some strains
were resistant to both phases, whereas others
caa5
cast cash
cas7
repeetfspecer region
ORF
.
'' 5
7 e 9 l0 11 12 13 14 16 16 17 It 19 20 21 22 23 24 26 26 27 26 29 30 31 31`r
L 4421 WT
.i412.
Wrom*SIS2
LL .41C
Wrats.S3
0.#141;011 Wroem'S.
CL .41•2I
Wroem'S5
Cc 44I
Wron,7246
Wro2072'
EL
• I .<5*.Z.54.
1•
21
I fa.ii.;C
WT4.20,2•40
WT,m6. 2977411610.611412
Wrimwte9,24.513311
Sensitivity to 0658
Sensitivity to 02972
fie'la tIO te. BP PM HO I
.0,10.
.0.10,
I
1 1 1
I.!• 1 1 1
1 1
Fig. 1. Streptococcus thermophilus CRISPR1 locus overview, newly acquired spacers in phage-
resistant mutants, and corresponding phage sensitivity. The CRISPR1 locus of DGCC7710 (WI) is at
the top. The repeat-spacer region of WT is in the middle: repeats (black diamonds), spacers
(numbered gray boxes), leader (., white box), and terminal repeat (T, black diamond). (Bottom left)
The spacer content on the leader side of the locus in phage-resistant mutants is detailed, with
newly acquired spacers (white boxes, 51 to 514). (Bottom right) The sensitivity of each strain to
phages 858 and 2972 is represented as a histogram of the efficiency of plaguing (EOP), which is
the plaque count ratio of a mutant strain to that of the wild-type.
4,858
packaging
02972
S9 S11
Sti
eitpsW
morphogenes
49S
57
S10
Mil morphogenesis
S3 S12
SS
sr,
noar
les is
314
$7
410
42'
se
se
43 412
$5'
41 44 413
Se
replication
"riser
*"
; regulation
SP S41 S13
1 kb
Fig. 2. S. thermophilus phase genome maps with the position of sequences similar to the acquired
CRISPR1 spacers of the phage-resistant mutants. Spacers shown above and below the genome maps
indicate that the spacer matches a sequence on the (+) and on the (—) strand, respectively. An
asterisk indicates the existence of a SNP between the spacer sequence and that of the phage
genome (fig. S1). The genome sequences of phage 2972 (accession number AY699705) and phase
858 are 93% identical.
Downloaded from www.sciencemag.org on November 2, 2008
1710
23 MARCH 2007 VOL 315
SCIENCE
www.sciencemag.org
EFTA00610312
REPORTS'
were resistant only to the phase used in the chal-
lenge (Fig. I). The phage-resistance profile
seemed correlated to the spacer content, such
that strains with spacers showing 100% identity
to sequences conserved in both phases were
resistant to both phases, such as spacers 53, S6,
and S7. In contra* when nucleotide polymor-
phians were observed between the spacer and the
phase sequence [from I to 15 single-nucleotide
polymorphisms (SNPs) over 29 or 30 nucleo-
tides], the spacer did not seem to provide re-
sistance, such as spacers SI, S2, S4, S5, and S8
(Fig. I and fig. S2). In addition, when several
spacers were inserted (S9 to 514), phase re-
sistance levels were higher. These findings indi-
cate that the CRISPR I locus is subject to dynamic
and rapid evolutionary changes driven by phase
exposure. Altogether. these results reveal that
CRISPR loci can indeed be altered during the
generation of phase-resistant mutants and also
establish a link between CRISPR content and
phase sensitivity. These findings suggest that the
presence of a CRISPR spacer identical to a phase
sequence provides resistance against phases
containing this particular sequence.
Iv•
To determine whether CRISPR spacer con-
tent defines phase resistance, we altered the
CRISPR I locus by adding and deleting spacers
(/2) and tested subsequent strain sensitivity to
phases. All constructs were generated and inte-
grated into the S. thermaphilas chromosome with
the system developed by Russell and Klaenhanuner
( / 4). We removed the spacers and repeats in the
CRISPRI locus of strain WT,/,,014-sis2 and replaced
them with a single repeat without any sparer (12).
The resulting strain Art,„„s- I s2ACRISPR l was
sensitive to phase 858, which indicated that the
phase resistance of the original phage-resistant
mutant (WT.:45045152) was probably linked to
the presence of SI and S2 (Fig. 3).
Further, to address the critical question of
whether adding spacers provides novel phase
resistance, we replaced the CRISPRI locus of
strain WT02972.
with a version containing only
spacers SI and S2 (12) and tested whether the
phase sensitivity was affected. Remarkably, the
resuhing strain WT,/,29724s4::pS1S2 gained re-
sistance to phase 858, which suggested that
these two spacers have the ability to provide
phase resistance de novo (Fig. 3). Altogether,
COCOS.
Cast 0986 caul..
ORF
the
rot,
ant case cas7\
ORF
toss
19
cast cast cas7
poRi
ORF
CI
cast cast
ficV
pau
cat cast 44997.....:
V.
114±.
VI.
C4SIC;646
4D
Sensitivity to ease
Sensitivity to 02972
19,
114 1,1 ir I
ly
.0. tO•
i
i
i
I
I
I
i
t
L
WLesesINN
N.
WiessesleteiCRISPR1
NI.
WT
•ets2::pR
IV.
WT,„
44::pS1S2
V.
WTeases122::pcas.5—
vi.
WT
•sis2::pcas7—
Fig. 3. CRISPR spacer engineering, cos gene inactivation, and corresponding phage sensi-
tivity. I, mutant WTItts' s
2; II, mutan WT,pess• sis2ACRISPR1 in which CRISPR1 was deleted;
Ill, mutant WToesan '::pR in which CRISPR1 was displaced and replaced with a unique repeat;
IV, WT.2972' 5°::p5152, mutant of strain WT4,25,72' 5° in which CRISPR1 was displaced and re-
placed with a version containing 51 and 52; V, favass.sis2::pcos5— with cosy inactivated; VI,
Wfsesa' sis2::pcos7— with cas7 inactivated. pORI indicates the integrated plasmid (12). The phage
sensitivity of each strain to phages 858 and 2972 is represented at the bottom as a histogram of
the efficiency of plaguing (EOP).
0
ORF
these observed modifications establish the link
between the CRISPR spacer content and phase
resistance.
In the process of generating strain
WTinsx' sls2ACRISPRI, we created
WTosso-sis2::pR, a variant that contains the inte-
gration vector with a single repeat inserted be-
tween the cats genes and the native CRISPR I locus
(Fig. 3). Unexpectedly, strain WT,/,1,3x' sis2::pR
was sensitive to phase 858, although spacers
SI and S2 remained on the chromosome (Fig. 3).
Similarly, the WT029724S4::pS1 S2 construct lost
the resistance to phase 2972, although spacer
S4 is present in the chromosome (Fig. 3). These
results indicated that spacers alone did not
provide resistance, and perhaps, that they have
to be in a particular genetic context to be
effective.
Although initial work suggested involvement
in DNA repair (15), the current hypothesis is that
eves genes (5, 16) are involved in CRISPR-
mediated inununity (JO). Consequently, we in-
activated two car genes in strain WT,t45,,,esis2
(12): cars (00G3513) and am 7. which are equiv-
alent to No66571.0O657 and str06601sta0660,
respectively (6, 7). The cars inactivation re-
sulted in loss of the phase resistance (Fig. 3),
and perhaps Cas5 acts as a nuclease, because it
contains an IINII-type nuclease motif. In con-
trast, inactivating clis7 did not alter the resist-
ance to phase 858 (Fig. 3). Interestingly, we
were repeatedly unable to generate CRISPR I
phage-resistant mutants from the car? knock-
out, perhaps because Cas7 is involved in the
synthesis and/or insertion of new spacers and
additional repeats.
When we tested the sensitivity of the phage-
resistant mutants, we found that plaque formation
was dramatically reduced. but that a relatively
small population of bacteriophage retained the
ability to infect the mutants. We further analyzed
phase variants derived from phage 858 that
retained the ability to infect Ari.Nom S I S2. In par-
ticular, we investigated the sequence of the ge-
nome region corresponding to additional spacers
SI and S2 in two virulent phase variants. In both
cases, the genome sequence of the phase var-
iant had mutated, and two distinct SNPs were
identified in the sequence corresponding to
spacer SI (fig. 53).
Overall, prokaryotes appear to have evolved
a nucleic acid-based "immunity" system where-
by specificity is dictated by the CRISPR spacer
content, while the resistance is provided by the
Cas enzymatic machinery. Additionally, we spec-
ulate that some of the cats genes not directly
providing resistance are actually involved in the
insertion of additional CRISPR spacers and re-
peas. as part of an adaptive "immune" response.
Further studies are desired to better characterize
the mechanism of action and to identify the
specific function of the various my genes. This
nucleic acid-based system contrasts with amino
acid-based counterpart in eukaryotes through
which adaptative immunity is not inheritable.
Downloaded from www.sciencemag.org on November 2, 2008
www.sciencemag.org
SCIENCE VOL 315
23 MARCH 2007
1711
EFTA00610313
IREPORTS
The inheritable nature of CRISPR spacers sup-
ports the use of CRISPR loci as targets for evo-
lutionary. typing, and comparative genomic studies
(9, 17-19). Because this system is reactive to
the phage environment, it likely plays a sig-
3.
nificant role in prokaryotic evolution and ecol-
ogy and provides a historical perspective of
phage exposure, as well as a predictive tool for
phage sensitivity. The CRISPR-cos system may
accordingly be exploited as a virus defense mech-
animn and also potentially used to reduce the
dissemination of mobile genetic elements and
the acquisition of undesirable traits such as anti-
biotic resistance genes and virulence markers.
From a phage evolution perspective. the inte-
grated phage sequences within CRISPR loci may
also provide additional anchor points to facilitate
recombination during subsequent phage infec-
tions, thus increasing the gene pool to which
phages have access (20). Because CRISPR loci
are found in the majority of bacterial genera and
are ubiquitous in Archaea (5, 13,21), their study
will provide new insights into the relation and
codirected evolution between prokaryotes and
their predators.
1.
2.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
to.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
References and Notes
M Brenban, F. Rotates, fiends Microbic[ 13, 278
(2005).
S. Clbarn-Chennoull, A. &won, fa.-L Diroann, H. Bdosav,
1. Beetroot 186, 3677 (2004).
). M. Stoma, T. R. Klaenhammer, Nor. Rev. Mktobiol. 4,
395 (2006).
H. Brasses, AMA Rev. Mirtabtot. 55, 283 (2001).
R. Jansen, J. 0.A. van Embrien, W. Gaasva, L. M. Scholl,
Mot Whatnot 43, 1565 (2002).
A. gelatin er a., Not Madinat. 22, 1554 (2004).
A. Solaa, B. (Moguls, A. Sorokin, S. D. Ehrlich,
Mkrobiofogy 151, 2551 (2005).
F. J. M. Mona, C. Ellez-VIUasencr, I. Garda-Manfnez,
E. Soda, 1. Ala! for. 60, 174 (2005).
C. Poured, G. Salvignol, G. Yergnaud, AlIClabiology 151,
653 (2005).
K. S. Makarova, N. V. Cabin, S. A. Shabalina, Y.1. Wolf,
E. V. Koomn, &of. Thera 1, 7 (2006).
C. Levesque et at, Appl. fortiori. MktobioL 71, 4057
(2005).
Information on matenals and methods for the generation
of phage-resistant mutants, engineering of CRISPR
spacers (figs. 54 and 55), and inactivation of cm genes is
available on Selena Online.
R. K Wiest'', P. Redder, R. A Gantt, K. flrigger,
erchoro 2, 59 (2006).
W. M. Russell. 1. R. Klaenhammer, Ant &Sion aunotoot
67, 4361 12001).
K. S. Makarova, L marina N. V. Grishin, I. B. Rogow,
E. V. KOOMII, maker ones Rel. 30, 482 (2002).
16. 0. H. Haft, J. Selengut, E. F. lIcogodin, IL E. Nelson,
rad Cookout. Biol. 1, e60 (2005).
17. P. M A. Greener), A. E. Ilunuhoten, D. van Soolingen,
J. O. A. van EmbOen, mat microbe:et 10, 1057 (1993).
18. E. F. mengodm at al, J. &trend. 187, 4935 (2005).
19. R. 1. Deem, E. F. Mongoohn, I. 8. Emerson, K. E. Nelson,
Beetenot 188, 2360 (2006).
20. R. W. Hendrix et of., Proc. Nod. Arad. Sc!. II.S.A 96,
2192 (1999).
21. J. S. Godde, A. Bickerton, J. MaL Eva. 62, 718
(2806).
22. We thank L. Bayer, C. Vos, and A..C. Codti.Mcovoisin
of Caruso) !moaner', as well as J. Laboot6 and
0. Tremblay of Universne Laval for technical supporL and
E. Beth Hansen for diuussion and critical review of
the manuuript. Also, we thank 1. R. Klaenhammer for
providing the integration system. This work was
supported by holing from Danisco erS. Also, S. AL would
like to acknovAedge support from the Natural Sciences
and EnMneenng Research Council of Canada (NSERC)
Cnscovery Program. Sequences sere deposited in
GenBank, accession numbers Et434458 to 0434500.
Supporting Online Material
iwm.sciencemag.orgfcgikonteouluW315/5819/1709/DC1
Materials and Methods
Fags. 51 to 55
References and Nam
29 November 2006: accepted 16 Fetguany 2007
ronzurnerde.rustoo
A G Protein-Coupled Receptor Is a
Plasma Membrane Receptor for the
Plant Hormone Abscisic Acid
Xigang Liu,1*3 Yanling Yue,' Bin Li,3 Yanli Hie/ Wei Litz Wei-Hua Wu,3 Ligeng Ma"
The plant hormone abscisic add (ABA) regulates many physiological and developmental processes
in plants. The mechanism of ABA perception at the cell surface is not understood. Here, we
report that a G protein—coupled receptor genetically and physically interacts with the G protein
a subunit GPA1 to mediate all known ABA responses in Arobidopsis. Overexpressing this receptor
results in an ABA-hypersensitive phenotype. This receptor binds ABA with high affinity at
physiological concentration with expected kinetics and stereospecifidty. The binding of ABA to the
receptor leads to the dissociation of the receptor-GPA1 complex in yeast. Our results demonstrate
that this G protein—coupled receptor is a plasma membrane ABA receptor.
A
bscisic acid (ABA) is an important
hormone that mediates many aspects of
plant growth and development, particu-
larly in response to the environmental stresses
(1-3). Several components involved in the ABA
signaling pathway have been identified (4). Two
recent reports have shown that the nuclear RNA
binding protein flowering time control protein
(FCA) (5) and the chloroplast protein Mg
chelatase II subunit (6) are ABA receptors (6).
'National Institute of Biological Sciences, 7 Science Park Road,
2.tiongguancun Life Science Park, Beijing 102206, China.
/Laboratory of Molecular and Cellular Biology, Hebei Normal
University, Shipathuang, Hebei 050016, China. 'State Key
Laboratory of Plant Physiology and Biochemistry, College of
Biological Sciences. China Agricultural University, Beijing
100094, China.
'To whom coat
nOence should be addressed. Email:
In contrast, several earlier experiments had sug-
gested that extracellular perception is critical for
ABA to achieve its functions (7-9). Thus, other
ABA receptors, especially plasma membrane-
localized receptors. may be the major players for
perceiving extracellular ABA and mediating the
classic ABA signaling responses.
Ligand-mediated signaling through G protein-
coupled receptors (GPCR5) is a conserved
mechanism for the extracellular signal percep-
tion at the plasma membrane in entrap/one
organisms (10). The GPCR-mediated signaling
pathway plays a central role in vital processes
such as vision, taste, and olfaction in animals
(11). IlOwever. the higher plant Arubidopsir
thulium has only one canonical Ga (GPAI)
subunit, one G0 subunit, and two Gy subunits
(12-16). The significance of these subunits in
plant systems is poorly understood; only one
Arubidoµsis putative GPCR protein (GCRI ) has
been characterized in plants (17-20), and no
ligand has been defined for any plant GPCR.
To identify previously unrecognized GPCR
proteins in Arubidopsir, we started by searching
the Arabidopuis genome and found a gene
(GCR2, GenBank accession code At Ig52920)
encoding a putative GPCR. Transmembrane
structure prediction suggests that GCR2 is a
membrane protein with seven transmembrane
helices (fig. SI, A and B). The subsequent cel-
lular localization analysis confimied its plasma
membrane localization in the transgenic plant
root (fig. SIC). GCR2—yellow fluorescent pro-
tein (YFP) is detected in the membrane fraction
isolated from the GCR2-YFP transgenic plant.
Similar to GCRI (19), GCR2 is mostly asso-
ciated with the membrane fraction (fig. SID).
Furthermore. even after washing with detergent
or a higher pH buffer, GCR2 is retained with the
membrane fraction, suggesting that GCR2 is an
integral membrane protein (fig. SID).
One feature of the GPCR is its ability to
interact with G protein to form a complex. To
confirm the physical interaction between GCR2
and Ger. we used four different approaches to
detect their interaction. We first used surface
plasmon resonance spectroscopy to investigate
the interaction between GCR2 and GPAI. For
this purpose. we expressed and purified recom-
binant GCR2 and GPAI proteins in bacteria
(fig. S2). This in vitro assay clearly indicated
that GPAI is capable of binding to GCR2, where-
as no binding activity was detected between
GPAI and bovine serum albumin (BSA) (fig.
S3, A and B). The dissociation binding con-
stant (Kd) for GCR2 and GPA I is 2.1 x 10-9 M
(fig. 53C).
Downloaded from www.sciencemag.org on November 2, 2008
1712
23 MARCH 2007 VOL 315
SCIENCE
www.sciencemag.org
EFTA00610314
Technical Artifacts (7)
View in Artifacts BrowserEmail addresses, URLs, phone numbers, and other technical indicators extracted from this document.
Domain
www.sciencemag.orgDomain
wxfw.sciencemag.orgIPv6
44::Phone
2977411610Phone
5045152Wire Ref
ReferenceWire Ref
ReferencesForum Discussions
This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.