DS9 Document EFTA00623172

tip Dershovalz ON APPEAL to. Iva amass. LAM' openions.pleasevbadoltybusIneurevasw.com It's Boies vs. . by Noreen Marcus An unusuai offshoot of a high-profile case is pending in the Fount District Croat of Appeal. The appeal piggybacks on a two-way defamation action settled last year by Alan Dershoattz, the retired SA • d lawyers for . 34, A° say M ires by billionaire Jeffrey 'Epstein and others in his circle when she was a teenager. The appeal conrems David Boles, the power= head of rides Schiller Elmer. Ms law palter. Sigrid I1. McCavdey, who repro- . - sec= Roberts, wants • - Dershowitt sanc- tioned kit contempt ur court for allegedly vio- latingthe confidential- ity of settlement talks between Boles and Dershowlm She said in a court filing that Drnhowitz displayed `flagrant bad-faitb liti- gation conduce during his deposition In the defamation case and in an interview with theNeleYork lines. Dershowita. B . friend of E'psteires. helped Begot" a controversial plea deal for Epstein with federal prceecutors. • Isdiceawley attended Dershowitz's Oa 15, 2015, deposition in Fort landerthde and heard Derahowitz claim Bo= told Dershowirt didn't believe aCCI-SatOnS about an Epstein underage sex ling. - -Mr. Dersbowttis description of what was said is not tme," Boles said in a statement released after the deposidon. At the deposition. BeCawley objected to Dershowitt recounting his talk with Boies. &award Uralic Judge 'Thomas Lynchbeld abearit the tk6unalion case was settled. Lynch dismiwat McCawley's to the Fourth. District. never for motion for sanctions. went dbr dailybusinessreview.cool MIL/ AV, AVAIL 6,101: Dershowitz in Fourth District Appeal • .. . `'saiassrbin 'The general role Is,gyon want to be heard Ina lawadt,you haw to fwmallyinterveneato thatlawnitt, and Hyatt.* sumepiplaleetWEt somebodyvAxts inthat tenuity= have to sue hinf said Miami appellate tweyerlool Pone= in the defamation case. has standing to appeal. Depending on what the court do- odes about standing. it could dtsroissthe appeal colt= the oral argtnnent to this preliminary question, or glide past it and have both sides address the conformal-of court claim.. NO STANDING ALLOWED? The Daily Bate= Review asked Miami appellate lawyer' 'Joel Penvin, who is not invoked in Dionne, for his take on standing didn't to Dershowim the respondent .. he explained !sty in a December are Bradley Edwards of Jaffe 2015 interview with the New York Weissing Edwards Fistos &Lehrman in— .11triels. "'Ibis is very serious. It involves Fort Lauderdale and Pad Cassell a law cerebra my legacy, my caroocsanahlstaty. Utah. They are lawyers Ina The Breward Circuit Court defama- professor and filial Judge from ray reputaten." West Palm Beach cowl challenge Eon case startodvt filing an to die plea bargain that put Epstein be- s0ldmit derailing claims about hind bars — only at night -for about a Dershowitz in Thep lawsuit year when he might have faced decades Dershowitz responded by persuading In prison. Dozens of vemade. , 13.5. District Judge Kenneth Marra to allegations similar to . , . ; . strike the allegations and vowing to get. Since McCauley represents .'..E.dwards and Cassell disbarred forrnak-. EFTA00623172 ;Cmgroverstial pea deal for )3pstain with - :Sera prosecute* McCa.veleyettaseled leothewhes, i>ct., 15.. 2015, *poste —no in Feit Umbra& =a Lend De‘Mhowitz clabn Wes bid Persistent &Int believe . accusations an (mnh' it' Epstet underage sex trerednivitt's description4*bn was 'Mad is not ltne," Boles said in a statenaint relented after tho deposition. At ibia. Md2a5viay °Fleeted to Dtwb . romtmt* his talk with Bola£. Cirputt.h.4e fynchbeidabatwitisdetansation case lAdS S9tdelt kaatb to n for senetonamSodywont to Fourth Dl$ld never for- in7 vinedhitho wan . • e appellate court se oral argument for May 9 but recently requested briefing on the issue of how Roberts, a nonparty I LD ARDS ET AL. a . - lis Oral argurnent 9:20b' Case tYpet(outeilpt of. Court:nottinDistripill of . LaveyeitOrptinienai:. McCain' neskleiles Fori Blu4Rcoartfoilargi . , BrneeS.gonowF'A. 4, IQrzherd5intpson. Ltor aj:r odadlessi n,or ttootemptnie. : tese• limy am Theentsitainiajs,IftjainsnetMtetkeerdietiNestainottbnetofoonsilyintenerrerriath awmit and if w.O'.2,o-t.orttentobteFtt‘ ie. • - , sorneb5ely 44:1nethitikentiOctuhree to soehkersaktMlarre appellate levyer)84: astral. In tho defantanceasesc.haa gnuiding to einem to Dashowit the rekPadideeits ....s. ,9e ex-pampa vit... Jo a DomuMer mpeaat DePendiegekistat the courtdet- are Bradley Edwards of FtenliekeW:Ainterttiew with the; Netcria abetttleakthatitaoilld Osmise the i Weltahrg Edwards Macs danhitaitilOt7. glue IS verF.4040‘.4 .16400 appeal woke* oraltngtiment to the' ,Fortlauderdale mod Pauicareerateev rat moist% mygariOviii#0, . ix r and Wetralca Bow:bed , pallor& &fp ase startod meaarditillinft,tan NO onliatreghf abanti MitehOwRz. the==;; 11:: Fh9t ban— :hal eutat 16134- eltaats-ft The DePosintienRevIew eskod year when he might have 4tisede#:‘151*thowitt'resFendod Jq PeenMdteg. btazd ap Perw‘in. in pry. Dozens of tiele::;113S.,_ District Judge lainietirldeirit to bmtipd ft . . for Ills gdlegationssimilar to ••' tie aileastMnsanctivvoingm get; 'aap want Mat m *looks Poi a to for avraitinba „1,.XteralletWitz 'Minna . er.-2 you nosseatUess dy. l" r i as a misleading , ... , , fi eltac media ,Mputittion: character' o Cals311:. interiene whos is gibidi. yottimve vex . drew from a leSeiforto*ft . tcleidordieg to • • 191ra*c., . laitatronn sat .- - .. '. -'-' Permit He notedEdwards and pinnomhz flied a 3341er:claim, : . -. i Ho oxpladnen iho underttring palsy. sued PemhowItx on thier own beltilt-',;! Ten= of the seteleaset leached In' Tao structetsiof the lawsuit is defined • not for their dont, and said IvicawlocCi.AprO 201.6 worecordIdeinfaL ', ' '-• by the peopidielio ore suing' and who bad to tst them m to we the that .., Boles has wen 8 yrealidaary round' must accepk the :result There may be manor case as &whir?. • . ',, In the Fourth Distente DershoWitt ' an otteption if, a court order impacts a ' 'Thera many no signiarance te4nt:'1 charged McCawley breeched an an.: meparty 'bit otherwne mere going to fearbat the plates in this lawsdirer 4 Renate court rule by slatting with; rortinethe Proems. the rightto bo hoard iesei ti Roberts In some other lawitthaa)' out record, evidence that Dorshowira and the outcome, to the ,parties to the my option; Ferwin said. -. .••• ' 41 -'Intentionally and wrongfully' Mod a lawsuit:Pens-In said. • . .'. false affidavit In the donamation case. interests la the privacy of it. Tbees no confusion about the hos- description of the talk ho had with. • ideCtewley is representtog DERSNOVitiE Oti OFFENSE The atndant reiterated Dershowitis: meet discussion between Dershovdte tility between Boles and DmshowIta tie Rotes. which Is at,the. center of the- and Bolen $he's also representing Bobs what vital inte.msts Dorshowitg is fight- appeal. . -by extension?. she suggested in court The court mbd again De/shunts pa . Motawley did not return a call has accused Detrain:mitt. . on Jan. 10. oanintentby.deadano. aleag pstetn,ofsecuallyassaulting . What happens next Is up to the Fourth Distda A carnal °teener reading tho Fourth bet when she was a teenager* District .docket might be peopieuted turn of the httgatlen involving noreephiercushatntelannentherkt.. -,.-.. , about wiiii fighting whom herein ad- zind Cisienatirsa","4 EFTA00623173