Skip to main content
Skip to content
Case File
efta-efta01177252DOJ Data Set 9Other

DS9 Document EFTA01177252

Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
efta-efta01177252
Pages
18
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available

Summary

Ask AI About This Document

0Share
PostReddit

Extracted Text (OCR)

EFTA Disclosure
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
UBS UBS Investment Research UBS Business Jet Update Business jet inventory slightly lower ■ Available inventories slightly lower in April Available for sale business jet inventories moved I% lower in April and are now 18% below the peak from May 2009. We estimate available inventories represent 13% of the installed base of business jets, in-line with the historical average and below recent peak at 18%. Young available aircraft inventories (0.10 years old) moved I% lower this month leaving them 32% below the peak, but at 9% of the installed base are still above the 5.6% level seen during the last upcycle. ■ Embraer, Europe most for sale; North America relatively low Of the major manufacturers, Embraer has 15% of its in-service fleet available for sale, followed by Bombardier/Cessna at (4%, Dassault/Hawker at 13% and Gulfstream at 11%. At the end of April, Europe had the largest percentage of its installed base available for sale at 17%, followed by North America at (4%, LatAm/Middle East both at 11% and Asia/Pacific at 9%. However, when considering only young aircraft (0-10 years old), North America has only 7% of its installed base available for sale as compared to Europe at 13%. ■ See positive risk-rewards for stocks We believe North America bizjet is improving, driven by replacement demand postponed during the downturn. While the bizjet stocks have moved higher, we still see positive risk-rewards as we don't think stocks incorporate much for bizjets at current levels including Buy rated TXT/COUGD. Chart 1: Available Aircraft Listings - Total and Young (0.10 years in-age) a 3.600 3,200 2.800 2400 2000 1.600 1.200 800 400 0 78 8 8 & 8 0 8 8 4 8 4 4 4 8 2 0-10 Years 11111 10. Years —% of Fleet Available for Sale 18% 16% 14% 12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% % of Installed Base Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Global Equity Research Americas Aerospace Sector Comment 15 May 2012 mviv.ubs.cominvestmentnasearcii David E. Strauss Analyst [email protected] +1-212.7136185 Darryl Genovesi Analyst [email protected] +1-212-713 4016 Matthew Akers Associate Analyst [email protected] +1.212.7134881 This report has been prepared by UBS Securities LLC ANALYST CERTIFICATION AND REQUIRED DISCLOSURES BEGIN ON PAGE 13. UBS does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. EFTA01177252 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Investment Summary We believe the used business jet market serves as a leading indicator of the new business jet market. We closely monitor several key indicators of activity in the secondary market, including: 1) inventory of available for sale aircraft including new delivery positions listed for sale, 2) age distribution of available aircraft and 3) pricing of available for sale aircraft. Available for sale business jet inventories were 1% lower sequentially in April and remain roughly 18% below the peak from May 2009. We estimate available inventories represent 13% of the installed base of business jets, in-line with the historical average and below recent peak at 18%. Chart 2: Sequential Change in Available Aircraft Listings Chart 3: yly Change in Available Aircraft Listings 10% 5% .5% 0 1 01 e O.) el et IS) CO N. CO Of 0) 0) 01 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 *2 C<C<CCCCCCCCCC Source: JETNET and UBS estimates 75% 50% 25% Cri 25% II IN- CO 01 01 01 01 O lit ill wino I iislp Si if( III! O OJ .3. CO 15'C0 I.-- CO I? Of e Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Young available aircraft inventories (0-10 years old) moved 1% lower this month leaving them 32% below peak, but at 9% of the installed base are still above the 5-6% level seen during the last upcycle. Chart 4: Sequential Change in Young Aircraft Listings Chart 5: yly Change in Young Aircraft Listings 5% 0% .5% le% - $ 1.“?$$ ?3$4g;$ :“+' 150% - 125% - 100% - 75% - 50% - 25% - 0% -25% - •50% I~,lllil 1 it III '&3888 a 88888ra 8 .= Source: JETNET and UN estimates Source: JETNET and UBS OSIAMOS UBS 2 EFTA01177253 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2912 Average asking prices for the 39 newer used models we track continue to bounce along bottom, roughly unchanged in April and still 30-40% below peak levels. Average asking prices moved higher for large cabin this month with midsize lower and small cabin pricing roughly unchanged. Chart 6: Sequential Change in Average "Newer" Used Jet Asking Prices .5% 8 Of Of Of 0 0 0 0 11* N O 8 Small Cabin Midsize Cabin Large Cabin O e S. —Total Source: JETNET and UBS estimates We believe North America bizjet demand is improving, driven by replacements postponed during the downturn. While the bizjet stocks have moved higher, we still see positive risk-rewards as we don't think stocks incorporate much for bizjets at current levels including Buy rated TXT/COL/GD. Chart 7: GD and TXT Forward PIE Multiples Forward PE Multiple/ 35x- 30x- 20x - 15x 10x 5x Ox 5 sssssssssssssssssss —GD — TXT Source: UBS estimates UBS 3 EFTA01177254 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Available Inventory Levels We count 2,512 business jets available for sale at the end of April (2,464 used aircraft and 48 new delivery positions), 1% lower from the prior month. We estimate available inventories represent 13% of the installed base of business jets, in-line with the historical average and below recent peak at 18%. Chart 8: Business Jets Available for Sale and as a Percentage of the Installed Base 3.600 - 18% - 16% - 14% 3.200 2.800 to 40 2,400 - 12% a a- 2,000 10% 8 1.600 - 1.200 - -8% 6% -g -1 I{IAlr 1~1rm,.. 800 - fifTPI111 - 4% am 400 - - 2% 0 0% 6: 4'3 4 '43 !•, Source: JETNET and UBS estimates We have grouped available-for-sale business jets into 5-year age classes. We estimate the 0-5 and 6-10 year classes now have 8% (479) and 10% (329) of their respective fleets available for sale compared with the 7-8% historical average. Meanwhile, business jets 20-30 years old have roughly 21% of their fleets available for sale, roughly in line with average historical levels. Chart 9: Available Inventory by Age Class and as % of Fleet in Age Class I of Available Inventory 600 500 400 300- 200- too - 0 479 531 33% 25% 0.5 6-10 11.15 16-20 21.25 26-30 304. Age Class (Yrs.) Available Aircraft —% of Age Class NN co aE Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Young aircraft (0-10 years) constitute 32% of total available inventory, above the historical average at 20-25%, but lower than the in-service fleet at 49%. Available business jet inventories are coming off record highs UBS 4 EFTA01177255 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Chart 10: Available for Sale Inventory by Age Class (in years) Chart 11: Installed Fleet by Age Class (in years) 30+ 30+ 0-5 Source: JETNET and UBS estimates 26.30 9% 21.25 6% 16-20 7% 14% 11-15 14% 18% Source: JETNET and UBS estimates We estimate young available aircraft inventories (0-10 years old) moved 1% lower this month leaving them 32% below peak levels, but at 9% of the installed base are still above the 5-6% level seen during the last upcycle. Chart 12: Young Aircraft Available for Sale (0-10 years) and % of Total Available po 1.400 - 1.200 - 1.000 - 800 - 600 - 400 - 200 - 0 2r, '41 .1;i1 S 0-5 Years 6-10 Years % at Total Available - 45% - 40% - 35% 30% 25% 20% -a 15%e 10% Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Of 479 0-5 year old aircraft available for sale, 48 are new delivery slots, 8% lower from the prior month, and 74% below the 2009 peak (ex Eclipse). By manufacturer, we count 26 Embraer delivery slots available for sale, along with six Cessna slots, ten Bombardier slots and six Boeing/Airbus bizliner slots. Chart 13: Historical New Aircraft Delivery Positions Listed for Sale Delivery Slots for Sale 240 200 - 160 - 120 80 40 0 milpillfilliffill111111, Eclipse Ch. 7 Liquidation 99 0 999 0 999 0 999 c..,i c..4 49 V a S V aass 4 .M t; 42.M 15 sT, '45.M V a‘m ETobl Ex Eclipse Eclipse 500 Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Table 1: New Delivery Positions Listed for Sale at Apr 30 and Mar 30 Model Mar-12 hence, 3t0 13 16 Legacy 500 4 hence, MO 5 5 Altus AGJ3I9 4 4 Global 5000 3 4 Comm Mustang 3 3 Comm CH 2 Been° BEM 2 2 Global Express %AS 2 2 Chace, G.G. Global 6000 2 Lineage 1000 Chaim XLS. Legacy 450 Challenger COS Glynn C.J2 Global 7000 Challenger 300 Tots 48 47 Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS S <0 CO CO II, n t••• IN• CO CO CO CO OI Of co Of EFTA01177256 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Of the major manufacturers, Embraer has 15% of its in-service fleet available for sale, followed by Bombardier/Cessna at 14%, Dassault/Hawker at 13% and Gulfstream at 11%. Chart 14: Available Inventory by Manufacturer Used Inventory as %of Fleet 18% 16% 14% 12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% 13% 16% Bombardier Cessna Dassault Embraer Gulfsteam Hawker Other Beechcrall Inventory by Manufacturer — — Industy Average Source: JETNET and UBS estimates When considering only young available aircraft inventories (0-10 years old), Embraer had the largest percentage of its installed base available for sale at 15%, followed by Bombardier at 11%, Hawker at 9%, and Cessna/Dassault at 8%. Chart 15: Available young (0-10) inventory by manufacturer LLz 18% 16% 14% - 12% 10% 8% - 6% 4% 05f 8% - r - Bombardier Cessna Dassault Embraer Gultsteam Hawker Otter Beechc rat kw entry by Manulackser — — Indust, Average Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS 6 EFTA01177257 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Europe Nadi America Mille East Lain America Asia/Paciic Mica By Geography At end of April, Europe had the largest percentage of its installed base available for sale at 17%, followed by North America at 14%, LatAm/Middle East both at 11% and Asia/Pacific at 9%. Chart 16: Total Inventory as % of Installed Base 17% 14% Source: JETNET and UBS emanates When considering only young available aircraft inventories (0-10 years old), Europe again had the largest percentage of its installed base available for sale at 13%, followed by the Middle East and Latin America at 10%, North America at 7% and Asia/Pacific at 6%. Chart 17: Young (0.10) Inventory as % of Young Installed Base Europe Not America Mitle East Lain America Asia/Paciic Mica Source: JETNET and UBS estimates By Range Class At the end of April, the short and mid-range classes both had 14% of their respective fleets available for sale, followed by long-range at 10%. During April, we estimate available-for-sale long-range aircraft inventories moved 3% higher, while available mid-range aircraft moved 4% lower and available short- range inventories were roughly unchanged. UBS 7 EFTA01177258 UBS Business Jet Update IS May 2012 Young short-range aircraft represent 31% of total short-range available aircraft. Chart 19: Available Short Range Aircraft Listings • Total and Young (0-10 years in age) Inventory Level 1,600 1,200 800 400 0 `73 O `73 1 O O O 8 A 2 C 18 01 al A' 2 0.10 Years 10+ Years — of Installed Base 20% 15% 10% 5% % of Installed Base Note: Includes available aircraft with range below 2.000 nmi. Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Chart 18: Age Distribution of Available Short-Range Aircraft Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Young mid-range aircraft represent 29% of total mid -range available aircraft. Chart 20: Age Distribution of Available Medium-Range Aircraft Chart 21: Available Medium Range Aircraft Listings • Total and Young (0.10 years in age) 900 600 300 - - cy, 15° - 109 - S% rat. Q eig. ;272.11am ,1 ," c. cr. O 0 0 O4 Oj .$' O AI U.ct 010 Years 10+ Years — °I of fristaled Base % of Installed Base Note: Includes available aircraft with range below 2.000 nmi. Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Young long-range aircraft represent 46% of total long-range available aircraft. Chart 23: Available Long Range Aircraft Listings • Total and Young (0.10 years in age) 500 400 300 200 100 0 0 0 0-10 Years im 10+ Years — N of fristaled Base 04 0 2_ 16% 12% 8% 4% 0% % of Installed Base Note: Includes availab!e aircraft with range below 2.000 nmi. Source: JETNET and UBS estimates 30+ 19% 2630 21% 21-25 10% 0.5 17% 610 12% Source: JETNET and WS estimates Chart 22: Age Distribution of Available Long-Range Aircraft 26-30 11% 21.25 15% 16-20 6-10 11.15 18% 30+ 0.5 28% 19% Source: JETNET and MS estimates UBS 8 EFTA01177259 MIS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 A Look at the Newer Models Of the 39 newer models that we track individually, 17 have at least 10% of their installed fleets available for sale. Of these 39 models, 13 showed sequential inventory increases in April, while nine were flat and 17 declined. Compared with the prior year, 24 models had higher levels of available inventory, one model was unchanged and 14 declined. Table 2: Available Aircraft Listings and Average Asking Price for Newer Models Arcrah Model Manulaceser Installed Avanable Base in Airaaft% Model hst. Base Availthle Ingmar Apr-12 Apr-12 lAar.12 Charge Apr-11 plvge Long Range Global Express %RS Borrbarder 161 7% 11 10 10% 6 8196 Global Express BD-700 Bombardier 148 12% 18 18 0% 17 6% Gugstream 6-550 Gullstream 340 4% 15 15 0% 14 7% Falcon 7x Dassault 136 6% 8 8 0% 6 33% Super Large Guestream G-V Gullstream 192 7% 13 12 8% 6 117% Guestream G-450 Gugstream 226 4% 9 9 0% 6 50% Guestream G.1VSP Gullstream 286 7% 20 23 -13% 12 67% Gkba15000 Bortbarder 114 10% 11 7 67% 10 10% Lineage 1000 Emttaer 14 29% 4 4 0% 300% Falan 900E% Bass/kit 236 8% 20 19 5% 15 33% Large Falcon 2000 EX 1LX Dassault 233 9% 20 23 -13% 16 25% CteIcoger 8001 850 Borrbarder 76 14% 11 11 0% 8 38% Chalenger 605 Bombardier 177 6% 11 11 0% 10 10% CteIcoger 604 Bombardier 363 IS% 54 53 2% 45 20% Legacy 600 Emtraer 174 16% 26 31 25 4% IfeoVern Large Gugstream 6.200 Gullstream 245 9% 23 24 016 .4% 21 10% Falcon 2000 Dassault 235 11% 26 28 .7% 27 .4% Hawker 4000 Hawker Beechaaft 56 13% 7 40% 2 250% Ctelenger 300 Bombardier 343 7% 24 25 .4% 21 14% Cheep X Cessna 307 6% 16 17 6% 24 -33% Medium Cgancn Sovereign Cessna 324 6% 19 20 .5% 29 -34% GA' Proem G-150 Guttman, 94 3% 3 5 -40% 40% GAtream 6-100 Gutlneam aa 13% 10 9 11% 10 0% Learrel 60 f 60XR Barbarder 406 16% 64 66 .3% 61 6% Hawker 800XP Hawker Beechaaft 423 11% 47 61 .8% 66 -29% Hawker 750/850/900 supertight Hawker Beechaaft 364 8% 30 27 11% 32 Chaco XLS1XLS, Cessna 430 6% 26 29 -10% 23 4% Citabal Ertel Cessna 369 8% 28 27 4% 30 .7% Learjet 45 / 45XR Bombard., 426 12% 61 47 9% 44 16% Light Learjet 40 / 40XR Bombardier 130 12% 16 16 7% 15 7% Hawker 400XP Hawker Beechaaft 250 7% 17 16 6% 26 -36% Chaco Encore !Encore. Cessna 230 4% 9 9 0% 16 -44% Chaco CJ3 Cessna 378 7% 26 29 -10% 27 -4% Entry Level Hawker Premier Hawker Beectaalt 283 11% 31 33 .6% 28 -14% Chaco Mustang Cessna 394 8% 32 30 7% 28 14% Cita:Dal CJ2l CJ2. Cessna 433 12% 53 57 .7% 61 4% Chaco CJ1 /CJI. Cessna 299 13% 33 41 .5% 48 -19% Pherom 100 Emtraer 241 9% 22 23 4% 31 -29% Pherom 300 Emtraer 78 24% 19 19 0% 24 -21% Average Used Askrig PrimIV.1) Apr-12 Apr-11 Max Clarlge Change $ 42.1 S 47.7 $ 27.7 S 26.0 $ 34.9 $ 38.1 $ 43.5 $ 48.9 $ 24.4 $ 25.0 $ 26.2 $ 27.8 $ 11.3 $ 15.0 $ 331 $ 31.5 nh na $ 22.8 $ 26.1 $ 21.2 $ 22.4 $ 18.0 $ 15.3 $ 18.2 Na $ 10.2 3 11.4 $ 15.4 $ 17.3 $ 8.5 $ 9.8 $ 9.7 $ 15.8 $ 14.2 $ 18.8 $ 14.2 3 152 $ 8.1 3 8.8 $ 11.0 $ 113 Wa $ 102 $ 3.3 $ 4.5 $ 5.9 $ 6.0 $ 3.7 $ 4.6 $ 8.0 $ 7.7 8.3 $ 7.9 $ 4.2 $ 4.9 5.3 $ 5.8 5.3 $ 6.1 3.1 $ 32 $ 4.1 $ 3.6 $ 5.6 $ 6.0 $ 2.7 $ 3.0 $ 2.2 $ 2.4 $ 4.1 $ 42 $ 2.9 $ 3A $ 3.2 $ 3.1 $ 8.0 $ 8.7 -12% 7% -8% -11% -2% -6% 44% 7% da L -1M -5% 18% da -10% 11% -13% 49% -24% -7% I . 4 % 46% 3% 40% I 4% -14% -14% 4% 12% -7% $ 580 -27% $ 48.9 -43% $ 59.9 -42% 48.9 -11% 460 -46% $ 422 -38% $ 31.5 64% 614 -34% na nra S 39.5 -42% S 33.0 -36% S 18.0 0% S 31.0 41% $ 22.3 -54% $ 24.5 -37% $ 183 -53% S 220 -56% S 188 -24% S 24 8 -43% S 188 -57% $ 166 -33% $ 138 nra $ 104 -68% $ 110 -47% $ 107 -66% $ 121 -34% $ 11 8 49% $ 9 -56% $ 9.S -44% $ 82 -36% S S -43% 8.5 -52% 80 -33% 52 -48% 28 -20% 5.9 -31% 43 -32% 3.S -9% 87 -8% Notes: Available inventory figures Mclode new aircraft deivery positions: geeing figures do not. Max column represents the maximum average mon0ly listed asking pica since 2005. Gullstream G-100 also includes Astra 1125SPX.: Hawker 800XP also includes 800XPi. Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS 9 EFTA01177260 UBS Business Jet Update IS May 2012 Pricing Trends in the Secondary Market Rather than look at average pricing for the entire population of available aircraft, which can be distorted by monthly composition changes, we monitor six models that we believe capture pricing trends in their respective categories. Light We estimate the average asking price for a Citation CD moved 2% lower in April, and is 30% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 28% below their recent peak after a 10% decrease this month. Chart 24: Citation CA Rolling Three-Month Average Asking Price O 50 40 so 20 10 0 0.I 8 1. 8 1. 8 1. 8 1. 8 ib 8 1. 8 $8.0 $7.5 $7.0 $6.5 $6.0 $5.5 —Avelab* hv envy R3M Average Asking Price (RHS) R3M Avg Asking Price ($M) SOUICO JETNET and UBS eurnates Super Light We estimate the average asking price for a Citation Excel moved 2% lower in April, and is 56% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 40% below their recent peak including a 4% increase this month. Chart 25: Citation Excel Rolling Three-Month Average Asking Price Used Inventory Level O Av delia—e hveniory R31.1 Average Asking Price IRHS) R3M Avg Asking Price ($M) Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS 10 EFTA01177261 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Medium We estimate the average asking price for a Hawker 800XP moved 2% lower in April, and is 66% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 35% below their recent peak including an 8% decline this month. Chart 26: Hawker 800XP Rolling Three-Month Average Asking Price Used Inventory Level Avaiabb hyena), R3M Average Asking Price (RHS) R3M Avg Asking Price ($M} Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Medium Large We estimate the average asking price for a Citation X moved 5% lower in April, and is 57% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 57% below their recent peak including a 6% decline this month. Chart 27: Citation X Rolling Three-Month Average Asking Price S' 0" oc" 0 0 0 0^ 8 .=.`" C•J 4 —Avaiade hvenbry R3M Average Asking Price (RHS) Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS 11 EFTA01177262 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 Large We estimate the average asking price for a G-IVSP moved 3% lower in April, and is 64% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 49% below their recent peak including a 13% decline this month. Chart 28: Gulfstream CrIVSP Rolling Three-Month Average Asking Price Used Inventory Level so ao 30 20 10 0 1 11 4; 2 7. .1- .1- - Available hvenbry R3M Average Asking Price (RHS) $35 $30 $25 $20 $15 $10 R3M Avg Asking Rice (SM} Source: JETNET and UBS estimates Ultra Long Range We estimate the average asking price for a G550 was roughly unchanged during April and is 42% below its recent peak, while available inventories are 52% below their recent peak although unchanged this month. Chart 29: Gulfstream G•550 Rolling Three•Month Average Asking Price Used Inventory Level 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 1/43 1/4 3 o . . . . 8 Av abbe) Wendy R3M Average Askiig Price (RHS) Vtli§§Vg 2 Source: JETNET and UBS estimates UBS 12 EFTA01177263 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 ■ Statement of Risk The business jet market is cyclical in nature, largely driven by the general economic environment. Business jet manufacturers' earnings and cash flow are dependent on end-user demand, availability of customer financing, program execution and inventory management. A weak market for business jets could negatively affect General Dynamics, Textron, Bombardier, Embraer, Rockwell Collins, Honeywell, B/E Aerospace, Rolls-Royce and United Technologies. ■ Analyst Certification Each research analyst primarily responsible for the content of this research report, in whole or in part, certifies that with respect to each security or issuer that the analyst covered in this report: (1) all of the views expressed accurately reflect his or her personal views about those securities or issuers and were prepared in an independent manner, including with respect to UBS, and (2) no part of his or her compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed by that research analyst in the research report. UBS 13 EFTA01177264 UBS Business Jet Update IS May 2012 Required Disclosures This report has been prepared by UBS Securities LLC, an affiliate of UBS AG. UBS AG, its subsidiaries, branches and affiliates are referred to herein as UBS. For information on the ways in which UBS manages conflicts and maintains independence of its research product; historical performance information; and certain additional disclosures concerning UBS research recommendations, please visit www.ubs.com/disclosures. The figures contained in performance charts refer to the past; past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Additional information will be made available upon request. UBS Securities Co. Limited is licensed to conduct securities investment consultancy businesses by the China Securities Regulatory Commission. UBS Investment Research: Global Equity Rating Allocations UBS 12-Month Rating Rating Category Coverage' IB Serviced Buy Neutral Sell Buy Hold/Neutral Sell 51% 40% 9% 34% 35% 15% UBS Short-Term Rating Rating Category Coverages IB Sonia& Buy Sell Buy Sell less than 1% less than 1% 25% 17% 1:Percentage of companies 2:Percentage of companies the past 12 months. 3:Percentage of companies 4:Percentage of companies within the past 12 months. under coverage globally within the 12-month rating category. within the 12-month rating category for which investment banking (IB) services were provided within under coverage globally within the Short-Term rating category. within the Short-Term rating category for which investment banking (18) services were provided Source: UBS. Rating allocations are as of 31 March 2012. UBS Investment Research: Global Equity Rating Definitions UBS 12-Month Rating Definition Buy Neutral Sell UBS Short-Term Rating Definition FSR is > 6% above the MRA. FSR is between -6% and 6% of the MRA. FSR is > 6% below the MRA. Buy Sell Buy: Stock price expected to rise within three months from the time the rating was assigned because of a specific catalyst or event. Sell: Stock price expected to fall within three months from the time the rating was assigned because of a specific catalyst or event. UBS 14 EFTA01177265 UBS Business Jet Update 15 May 2012 KEY DEFINITIONS Forecast Stock Return (FSR) is defined as expected percentage price appreciation plus gross dividend yield over the next 12 months. Market Return Assumption (MRA) is defined as the one-year local market interest rate plus 5% (a proxy for. and not a forecast of. the equity risk premium). Under Review (UR) Stocks may be flagged as UR by the analyst. indicating that the stock's price target and/or rating are subject to possible change in the near term, usually in response to an event that may affect the investment case or valuation. Short-Term Ratings reflect the expected near-term (up to three months) performance of the stock and do not reflect any change in the fundamental view or investment case. Equity Price Targets have an investment horizon of 12 months. EXCEPTIONS AND SPECIAL CASES UK and European Investment Fund ratings and definitions are: Buy: Positive on factors such as structure. management, performance record. discount: Neutral: Neutral on factors such as structure. management. performance record, discount: Sell: Negative on factors such as structure. management, performance record, discount. Core Banding Exceptions (CBE): Exceptions to the standard +/-6% bands may be granted by the Investment Review Committee (IRC). Factors considered by the IRC include the stock's volatility and the credit spread of the respective company's debt. As a result. stocks deemed to be very high or low risk may be subject to higher or lower bands as they relate to the rating. When such exceptions apply, they will be identified in the Company Disclosures table in the relevant research piece. Research analysts contributing to this report who are employed by any non-US affiliate of UBS Securities LLC are not registered/qualified as research analysts with the NASD and NYSE and therefore are not subject to the restrictions contained in the NASD and NYSE rules on communications with a subject company, public appearances, and trading securities held by a research analyst account. The name of each affiliate and analyst employed by that affiliate contributing to this report. if any, follows. UBS Securities LLC: David E. Strauss: Darryl Genovesi: Matthew Akers. Company Disclosures Company Name Reuters 12-mo rating Short-term rating Price Price date BE Aerospace Inc. ' BEAV.O Buy N/A US$44.45 15 May 2012 General Dynamics Corp.te GD.N Buy N/A US$65.73 15 May 2012 Textron Inc B°• r. 18' 1" TXT.N Buy N/A US$23.52 15 May 2012 Source: UBS. All prices as of local market close. Ratings in this table are the most current published ratings prior to this report. They may be more recent than the stock pricing date 2. UBS AG. its affiliates or subsidiaries has acted as manager/co-manager in the underwriting or placement of securities of this company/entity or one of its affiliates within the past 12 months. 4. Within the past 12 months. UBS AG. its affiliates or subsidiaries has received compensation for investment banking services from this company/entity. 5. UBS AG. its affiliates or subsidiaries expect to receive or intend to seek compensation for investment banking services from this company/entity within the next three months. 6a. This company/entity is. or within the past 12 months has been. a client of UBS Securities LLC. and investment banking services are being. or have been, provided. 6b. This company/entity is. or within the past 12 months has been. a client of UBS Securities LLC. and non-securities services are being. or have been, provided. 7. Within the past 12 months. UBS Securities LLC has received compensation for products and services other than investment banking services from this company/entity. 16. UBS Securities LLC makes a market in the securities and/or ADRs of this company. 18. The U.S. equity strategist, a member of his team, or one of their household members has a long common stock position in Textron Inc. 22. UBS AG. its affiliates or subsidiaries held other significant financial interests in this company/entity as of last month's end (or the prior month's end if this report is dated less than 10 working days after the most recent month's end). UBS 15 EFTA01177266 UBS Business Jet Update IS /Jay 2012 Unless otherwise indicated, please refer to the Valuation and Risk sections within the body of this report. BE Aerospace Inc. (US$) Price Target {US$) — Stock Prim 013$1 60D 501) 40D 30D 20D 101) OD Buy 2 BIY Neutml No Rating I- 01 I I sI jr, 9 4 PI 4 # 4 25 4 # ▪ 4 4 # f rn Source: UBS; as of 15 May 2012 General Dynamics Corp. (US$) I I I Fi r-- 9 co ?.. -9 / j?" G g o G I 1 1 I Buy 2 Biy Neutml No Rating 01 lite Target MI Sock Rim MS/ I I co 9 4 4 •It G 01 I I 1 I I I 9 cn a o o o .— :b3 I 7 t I # 7 I I Source: UBS; as of 15 May 2012 Textron Inc. (US$) Rice Target (US$) Stock Prim CM/ OD r Buy' Eby Neutral No Rating Source: UBS; as of 15 May 2012 UBS 16 EFTA01177267 UBS Badness Jet Update 15 May 2012 Note: On August 4, 2007 UBS revised its rating system. (See 'UBS Investment Research: Global Equity Rating Definitions' table for details). From September 9, 2006 through August 3, 2007 the UBS ratings and their definitions were: Buy 1 = FSR is > 6% above the MRA, higher degree of predictability; Buy 2= FSR is > 6% above the MRA, lower degree of predictability; Neutral 1 FSR is between -6% and 6% of the MRA, higher degree of predictability: Neutral 2 = FSR is between -6% and 6% of the MRA, lower degree of predictability; Reduce 1 = FSR is > 6% below the MRA. higher degree of predictability; Reduce 2 = FSR is > 6% below the MRA, lower degree of predictability. The predictability level indicates an analyst's conviction in the FSR. A predictability level of '1' means that the analyst's estimate of FSR is in the middle of a narrower, or smaller, range of possibilities. A predictability level of '2' means that the analyst's estimate of FSR is in the middle of a broader, or larger, range of possibilities. From October 13, 2003 through September 8, 2006 the percentage band criteria used in the rating system was 10%. UBS 17 EFTA01177268 UBS Business Jet Update IS May 2012 Global Disclaimer Ths document has been prepared by UBS Secunbes LLC. an affiliate of UBS AG. UBS AG. as subsidiaries. branches and abates are referred to herein as UBS. This document is for cistribution only as may be pernitled by law. It is rot directed to. or intended for dist-bit:in to or use by. any person or tray who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality. Halt country or other jurisdction where such jurisdiction, pubtcalion, availability or use would be contrary to law or regulation u would subject UBS to any registration or Licensing requirement within such Miscidon. It is pubished solely for intimation purposes. it is not an advertisement nor is it a sdicilation or an offer to buy or sell any financial iratriments or lo partici:ale in any partied& trading strategy. No represerdation or warranty, ether express or implied, is provided in relation to the accuracy. completeness or ratability of the information contained in this document rem except with respect to Infomation concerring UBS. The Information is net intended to be a compete statement or summary of the securities. markets or developments referred to in the document. UBS does not undertake to update or keep cured the Information. My clarions expressed in this document nay change without notice and may tiller et be contrary to opinions expressed by other business areas or groups of UBS. Nothing in this document constitutes a representation that any investment strategy or recommendation is suitable or appropriate to an investor's nolvidual circumstances or otherwise constitutes a personal recommendation. Investments involve risks and investors should exercise prudence and thee own julpenvert in making their investment decirions. The financial instruments descnbed in the document may not be algble for sale in all jurisdctions or to cabin categories of investors. Options, derivative products and futures are not suitable for SI investors, and Iradng in these in:aliments is considered risky. Mortgage and assetibacked securities may involve a high degree of risk and may be hgNy volatile in response to fluctuations in interest rates or ether market conditions. Foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely ailed the value, price or income of any security or related instrument referred to in the document. Fir investrnenl ackeice, trade execution or other enceinte. dients should carted their local saes representative. The value of anyinvestment or income nay go down as well as up and investors nay not get back the lull amount invested. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. Neither UBS nor any of its effectors. employees or agents accepts any fiabitty for any loss (noludig investment loss) or damage arising out of the use of all or any of the Information. My prices stated in !Ns document are for information purposes only and do not represent valuation indvidual securities or other financial instnarents. There is no representation that any transaction can or could have been affected al those prices and any prices do not necessarily retied UBSS internal hocks and records or theoretical model-based valuations and nay be based on certain assumptions. Mitered assunptions by UBS or any other source may yield substantialy different results. Research will initiate, update and cease coverage solely at the discretion of UBS Investment Bank Research Management. The analysis obtained in this document is based on numerous assumptions. Differed assumptions could result in materially different rests. The analysts) responsible (or the preparation of this document may interact with trading desk personnel. saes personnel and other parties ter the purpose of gathering. applying and interpreting market information. UBS relies on information barriers to stead the low of intimation contained in one or more areas within UBS into other areas. units, groups or affiliates of UBS. The conpensation of the analyst who prepared this document is determined exclusively by research management and senior management (not includng investment banking). Analyst compensation is not based on investment banking revenues. however, compensation may relate to the revenues of UBS Investment Bark as a while, d which investrnenl banking, sales and trading are a part. Fa financial instruments admitted to Iradng on an EU regulated market: UBS AG. its agitates or subsidiaries (excludng Lan Securities LLC) acts as a market maker or ticsiday provider (in accordance with the interpretation of these terms in the UK) in the financial instruments of the issuer save that where the activity of tquidty provider is carried out in accordance with the defiribon gym to 4 by the laws and regulations of any other EU jurisdictions, such information is separately disclosed in this document. Fir financial instruments actnaled to tracing on a non. EU regulated market: WS nay act as a market maker save that where this activity is carried out in the US in accordance with the definition given baby the relevant laws and regulations, such activity will be speciticaly &closed in this document. LEIS may have issued a warrant the value of which is based on one or more of the financial nstruments referred to in the document. UBS and ha affiliates and employees may have long or short positions. !rade as principal and buy and sell in instruments or derivatives identded herein: such transactions or positions nay be inconsistent with the opinions expressed in this document. United Kingdom and the rest of Europe: Except as otherwise specified herein, this material is distrbded by UBS Limited, to persons We are eligible counlerparlies a professional dienls. UM Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Muttony IFSAI. France: Prepared by UBS Limited and distributed by UBS Limited and LIDS Securities Franca S.A. LEIS Securities France SA is regulated by the Adore& des Marches Financiers IALOF). Where an analyst of UBS Securities Franca S.A. has contributed to this document. the document is also deemed to have been prepared by UBS Securities France S.A. Germany: Prepared by UBS Limited and distributed by UBS Limited and UBS Deutschland AG. UBS Deutschland AG is regulated by the Bundesanstati fur Finanzdenstleiseingsaufsicht (DaFin). Spain: Prepared by UBS Limited and dstributed by UBS Limited and UBS Securities Espana SV. SA. UBS Securities Espana SV. SA is regulated by the Corns& Nacional del Mercado de Valores (CNIXV). Turkey: Prepared by UBS klenkul Datialar AS on behalf of and distributed by UBS Limited No information in this document is provided for the purpose of offering. marketing and sale by any means of any capital market instruments and services in the Repubic of Turkey. Therefore, this document may not be considered as an offer made or to be made to residents of the Republic of Turkey. UBS AG is not licensed by the Turkish Capital Markel Beard (the GIB) under the provisions of the Capital Market Law (Lew Na. 2499). Ageordingy neither this document nor any other offering material related to the insturrentseavices nay be utilized in connection with providing any capital market services to persons within the Republic of Turkey without the prior approval of the C1.03. IlianI2VOI, according to article 15 (d) 01 of the Decree No. 32 there is no restriction on the purchase or sae of the securities abroad by residents of the Republic of Turkey. Poland: Distributed by UBS Limited (spolka z oganiczona Cdpewiedzidnoscia)Oddzial w Polsce. Russia: Prepared and di:lib's:id by UBS Securities CJSC. Switzenand: Distributed by UBS AG to persons who are institutional investors orly. Italy: Prepared by UBS Limited and distributed by UBS Untied and UBS Italia Sim S.pA. UBS talia Sim S.P.A. is regulated by the Bank of Italy and by the Commission* Nationale per b Social a la Boma (CONSOB). Where an analyst of LOBS Italia Sim S.pA has corarbuted to this document the document is also deemed to have been prepared by UBS Italia Sin Sp.A. South Anita: Di:lib's:id by UBS South Africa (Ply) Limited, an authorised user al the JSE and an authorised Financial Services Provider. Israel: UBS Limited and its affiliates incorporated outside Israel are not licensed under the Investment Advice Law. This material is being issued oily to ardror is directed only al persons who are Sophisticated Investors within the meaning of the Israeli Securities Law and this material Mal not be retied or acted upon by any other persons. Whist LIDS Limited holds insurance for is activities, il does not hold the same insurance that would be required for an investment advisor or investment marketer under the relevant Investment Mita Law Regulations. Saudi Arabia: Ths document has been issued by UBS AG (and or any of its subseliaries, branches or alfilalest. a public company imbed by shares. incorporated in Switzerland with its registered offices al Aeschemerstaill 1. CH.4051 Basel and BaMholstrassa 45. CH.8001 Zurich. Ids publication has been approved by LIDS Saudi Arabia (a subsidary of UBS AG). a foreign closed joint stride company incorporated in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia under commercial register number 1010257812 having as registered office al Tatum,. Towers. P.O. Box 75724, Riyadh 11588. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. UBS Saudi Arabia is authorized arid regulated by the Capital Market Authority to conduct securities business under license ranter 0811337. United Stales: Distributed to US persons by either UDS Securities LLC or by UDS Financial Services Inc.. subsidaries of UBS AG: a by a group, subsidary or &Male of LIDS AG that is not registered as a US broker-ceder (a 'nen.US affiliate, to major US institutional investors only. UBS Securities LLC or UDS Financial Services Inc. accepts responsbitty for the content of a document prepared by another nen-US aidedwhen distributed to US persons by UBS Securities LLC or UBS Fnancial Services Inc. All transactions by a US person in the secudies mentioned in this document must be effected through UBS Securities LLC or UDS Financial Services Inc.. and not through a non'US agnate. Canada: Distributed by LIBS Securities Canada Inc.. a repstered investment dealer ih Canada and a Merriber-Cwsnadian investor Protection Fund. or by another affiliate el UDS AG what is registered to cencluct business in Canada or otherwise exempt from registration. Hong Kong: Distributed by LIDS Secerities Asia Limited. Singapore: De4nbuted by UBS Securities Pte. Ltd. (mica (p) 01011/2011 and Co. Reg. No.: 19856084801 or UBS AG. Singapore Branch. Please coded UBS Securities Ple. Ltd.. an exempt financial advisor under the Singapore Fnancial Adesars Act (Cap. 110): or UBS AG, Singapore Brandi, an exempt financial adviser under the Singapore Financial Advisers Act (Cap. 110) and a wholesale bank licensed under the Singapore Banking Ad (Cap. 19) regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. in respect of any matters arising from. or in connection wth. the analysis or document. The recipients of this document represent and warrant that they are accredted and institutional investors as defined in the Securities and Futures Ad (Cap. 289). Japan: Distributed by LIDS Securities Japan Co.. Ltd. to institutions investors oily. Where this document has been prepared by LIDS Securities Japan Co.. Lid, Lies Securities Japan Co.. Ltd. is the author, publisher and distrbutor of the document. Australia: Distributed by LEIS AG (Holder of Australian Financial Services License No. 2310871 ands UBS Securities Australia Ltd (Holder of Aectralan Financial Services License No. 231098). The Intimation in this document has been prepared without taking abase any investor's objectives, financial studon or needs and investors should. before acting on the Information. consider the appropriateness of the Information. having regard to their objectives, financial stuffier. and needs. II the Information contained in this document relates to the acquisition. or potential acquisition of a particular financial product by a 'Retail* dent as defined by section 76IG of the Corporations Act 2001 where a Product Disclosure Statement would be required, the retail dent should Nolen arid consider the Product Disclosure Statement relating to the product before making any decision about whether to acquire the product. New Zealand: Distributed by LOBS New Zealand Ltd. The information and recommendations in this pubic:sten are provided for general information purposes only. To the extent that any such information or recommendations consduta financial achice, they do no lake into account any person's particular financial stualion or goals. We recommend that recipients seek advice specific to their circumstances from their financial adviser. Dubai: The research prepared and dstriouled by UBS AG Dubai Brarch, c intended for Professional Clients city and is not for lather 6:tribunal within the Urited Arab Emirates. Korea: Distnbuted in Korea by UDS Securities Pte. Ltd.. Seoul Branch. This &current may have been *cited or centrbuted to from lime to time by affiliates of UBS Securities Pte. Ltd.. Seoul Branch. Malaysia: This nuterial is authorized to be dstributed in Malaysia by IRS Securities Malaysia Sdn. Bhd I253825.x). India: Prepared by UBS Securities India Private Ltd. 2/F. 2 North Avenue. Maker Manly. Sandra Kuria Omelet. Sandra (East). tiAurnbai dude) 400051. Phone: 412261556003 SEBI Registration Numbers: NSE (Capital Markel Segment): 048230951431. NSE (F80 Segment) INF230951431. BSE (Capital Market Segment) M010951437. The disclosures contained in research documents produced by LIDS Limited shod be governed by and construed in accordance with English law. UBS specifically prohibits the redstibution of this document in while or in part without the written permission of LIDS and LIDS accepts no lability whatsoever for the actions of third parties in this respect. Images may depict objects or elements Much are protected by third party copyrigN, trademarks and other nteleclual property rights. 0 UBS 2012 The key symbol and UBS are among the registered and unregistered trademarks of UM MI rights reserved. UBS UBS 18 EFTA01177269

Technical Artifacts (10)

View in Artifacts Browser

Email addresses, URLs, phone numbers, and other technical indicators extracted from this document.

Domainnen.us
Domainwww.ubs.com
Phone+1-212-713 4016
Phone+1-212.7136185
Phone+1.212.7134881
Phone19856084801
Phone2310871

Related Documents (6)

DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown

From: NYTimes.com <[email protected]>

5p
DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown

• Menu

15p
DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown

Florida Office

Cr 1) '.1.d Florida Office Bradley J. Edwards *Ol Seth M. Lehrman 't Brittany N. Henderson *0 Matthew D. Weissing EDWARDS POTTINGER LLC October 21, 2020 FOIA PRIVACY EXEMPTION VIA E-MAIL AND FEDEX The Honorable Geoffrey S. Berman United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York Assistant United States Attorney 86 Chambers Street, Third Floor New York. New York 10007 Dear New York Office J. Stanley Pottinger j Admitted in California 0 Admitted in I>istrict of Columbia • Admitted m Florida t Admitted in New York Beard (:crtified Civil Trial lau)rr Re: Re tuest for Tangible and Documentary Evidence (Touhy Request) Doe v. Darren K. Indyke, et al., SDNY Case No. 1:19-cv-07773 Victim: In follow up to our previous communications, please accept this as our formal written request for documentary and tangible evidence currently in the in the possession, custody, and control of the Department of Justice by way of the Southern District of New York relatin

3p
DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown

NYC DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE

NYC DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE OFFICE OF THE CITY REGISTER This page is part of the instrument. The City Register will rely on the information provided by you on this page for purposes of indexing this instrument. The information on this page will control for indexing purposes in the event of any conflict with the rest of the document. 20 1 1 2270073600 1004E0B 2B RECORDING AND ENDORSEMENT COVER PAGE PAGE 1 OF 4 Document ID: 2011122700736001 Document Date: Document Type: DEED Document Page Count: 3 12-23-2011 Preparation Date: 12-28-2011 PRESENTER: TITLEASSOCIATES - PICK-UP/ AGUSTIN AS AGENT FOR STEWART TITLE 825 THIRD AVENUE - SSR-11-01-9136 NEW YORK, NY 10022 RETURN TO: ERIKA ICELLERHALS, ESQ 9100 HAVENSIGHT, PORT OF SALE, SUITE 15/16 ST. THOMAS 00802 VIRGIN ISLANDS, US PROPERTY Borough Block Lot Unit Address MANHATTAN 1386 10 Entire Lot 9 Property Type: DWELLING ONLY - 1 FAMILY DATA EAST 71ST STREET CROSS REFERENCE CRFN or Document ID or Year

22p
DOJ Data Set 10OtherUnknown

EFTA01313625

4p
DOJ Data Set 9OtherUnknown

From: "Jeffrey E." <[email protected]>

2p

Forum Discussions

This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.

Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.