Skip to main content
Skip to content
Case File
efta-efta00224253DOJ Data Set 9Other

Montle Ju 16. 2007 12-01 PM

Sent: Montle Ju 16. 2007 12-01 PM oy er Here is the thumbnail version: At the time of the execution of the state search warrant on Epstein's house, they found printers. keyboards. and computer screens. but no CPU's. We thought that the property manager had destroyed the corn ut •rs. He was interviewed pursuant to a Kustigur letter and said that he didn't do anything with them, and a private investigator came and took them away. Based upon his description. we determined that the private investigator was Paul Lavery. We subpoenaed Paul Lavery. who tried to assert a blanket attorney-client privilege/work product immunity. I informed his attorney that he would need to file a Motion to Quash. so he backed down and we did a brief interview with Laver). Lavery stated that he did get the equipment from Epstein's house and he gave it to William Riley, another private investigator. We then subpoenaed Riley. both in his individual capacity and as custodian of records for Riley Kiraly

Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
EFTA 00224253
Pages
2
Persons
3
Integrity

Summary

Sent: Montle Ju 16. 2007 12-01 PM oy er Here is the thumbnail version: At the time of the execution of the state search warrant on Epstein's house, they found printers. keyboards. and computer screens. but no CPU's. We thought that the property manager had destroyed the corn ut •rs. He was interviewed pursuant to a Kustigur letter and said that he didn't do anything with them, and a private investigator came and took them away. Based upon his description. we determined that the private investigator was Paul Lavery. We subpoenaed Paul Lavery. who tried to assert a blanket attorney-client privilege/work product immunity. I informed his attorney that he would need to file a Motion to Quash. so he backed down and we did a brief interview with Laver). Lavery stated that he did get the equipment from Epstein's house and he gave it to William Riley, another private investigator. We then subpoenaed Riley. both in his individual capacity and as custodian of records for Riley Kiraly

Tags

eftadataset-9vol00009

Ask AI About This Document

0Share
PostReddit
Review This Document

Extracted Text (OCR)

EFTA Disclosure
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
Sent: Montle Ju 16. 2007 12-01 PM oy er Here is the thumbnail version: At the time of the execution of the state search warrant on Epstein's house, they found printers. keyboards. and computer screens. but no CPU's. We thought that the property manager had destroyed the corn ut •rs. He was interviewed pursuant to a Kustigur letter and said that he didn't do anything with them, and a private investigator came and took them away. Based upon his description. we determined that the private investigator was Paul Lavery. We subpoenaed Paul Lavery. who tried to assert a blanket attorney-client privilege/work product immunity. I informed his attorney that he would need to file a Motion to Quash. so he backed down and we did a brief interview with Laver). Lavery stated that he did get the equipment from Epstein's house and he gave it to William Riley, another private investigator. We then subpoenaed Riley. both in his individual capacity and as custodian of records for Riley Kiraly (his private investigator firm). The subpoenas and attachment are attached. The subpoenas ask for the computer equipment removed from Epstein's house and information related to his employment by Epstein (billing records, etc.) so we know when the items were removed from the house. Before I issued the subpoena to Lavery, I talked with the Duty Attorneys at OEO and at the Computer Crimes Section in DC. OEO advised that. as long as the private investigator had a separate office/business (i.e.. was not housed within an attorney's office and did not work exclusively for u particular attorney), OEO approval wasn't required, it should be treated like any other subpoena. This morning I re-reviewed the U.S. Attorney's Manual and it is clearly applicable only to attorneys' offices. I asked Computer Crimes if there was any prohibition on subpoenaing computer equipment. and the duty attorney said that would be fine if we did not believe that the computer evidence would be tampered with. Before the Fourth of July. Lilly Sanchez called to ask for an extension of time to respond to several subpoenas. including the one for Riley. I granted an extension to tomorrow, July Ir. After that, another attorney filed a notice of appearance representing Riley. Late on Friday. July I3n'. Roy Black filed the attached letter. demanding to know which Deputy Attorney General approved the subpoena. Andy and I met this morning and crafted a response (attached), which we sent to Roy and Lilly. I also sent a letter directly to Riley's attorney of record (also attached). Lilly faxed Andy asserting that my letter did not address their concerns. We just had a conference call and the end result is that they are going to file their motion to quash by 4:00 tomorrow afternoon. Black tetter.pdf El El CI CI William Fusty lacy attachment Pity 16raly 070716 Richey Personal.wpd A.wpd .stockao of Reco. Itr.wpd 57 EXHIBIT 62 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-0 I 4026 EFTA00224253 Tracking: se 08-80736-CV-MARR.A P-014027 EFTA00224254

Related Documents (6)

OtherUnknown

:ate: 7/19/06

DOJ EFTA Data Set 10 document EFTA01333133

88p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown

EFTA Document EFTA01733753

0p
House OversightFBI ReportNov 11, 2025

Extensive FBI & Palm Beach Police Investigation Links Jeffrey Epstein to Underage Sexual Abuse, Payments, and High‑Profile Associates

The compiled documents provide a wealth of actionable intelligence: detailed victim and witness statements describing under‑age massages and sexual assaults; financial transaction records (cash paymen Victims (girls aged 14‑17) were recruited with promises of $200‑$300 per massage and were repeatedly Trash pulls from 358 El Brillo Way yielded message books containing names, dates, phone numbers, a

240p
DOJ Data Set 9Financial RecordUnknown

:4/17/2007

:4/17/2007 :4L FM Mal: 1/1 Y 1, am L. Richey, P Yiliiaa L. Richey, P.A. TO: 5 PAGE: 002 OF 00; UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA FGJ 07-103 (WPB) IN RE GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS DUCES TECUM NUMBERS FILED UNDER SEAL OLY-63 & OLY-64 REPLY OF WILLIAM RILEY AND RILEY KIRALY TO THE GOVERNMENT'S RESPONSE TO THE MOTION TO INTERVENE AND TO QUASH GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS AND CROSS MOTION TO COMPEL William Riley and Riley Kiraly ("Riley"). by and through undersigned counsel, file this Reply to the Response of the United States to the Motion of Jeffrey Epstein to Intervene and to Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and Cross Motion to Compel to respond to the Government's assertions that Riley failed to appear before the grand jury.' The Government is mistaken. Riley's appearance before the grand jury was originally scheduled for July 10. 2007. By the agreement of the parties. that appearance was rescheduled for July 17, 2007. The day before that scheduled appearance, i.e

267p
House OversightUnknown

Palm Beach Police Incident Report Links Private Investigator Paul A. Lavery to Multiple Phone Calls Involving Unidentified Victim and Potential Clients

Palm Beach Police Incident Report Links Private Investigator Paul A. Lavery to Multiple Phone Calls Involving Unidentified Victim and Potential Clients The passage provides specific phone numbers, names (Paul A. Lavery, Kiraly & Riley Private Investigators, attorney Roy Black) and a timeline of calls that could be traced, offering a concrete investigative trail. However, the identities of the victim and the significance of the calls are vague, limiting immediate impact. The lead is moderately useful for follow‑up but lacks clear novelty or high‑level political linkage. Key insights: Phone number 305-710-5165 is registered to private investigator Paul A. Lavery (Hialeah, FL).; Calls occurred on 2/6/2005 onward, with multiple short calls between an unidentified victim and a 'BBB' residence, then a call to 'BI' residence at 5:50 pm.; Lavery’s license and prior arrests for cocaine possession and solicitation of prostitution are noted.

1p
Dept. of JusticeOtherUnknown

EFTA Document EFTA01334239

Date/Time: 12/21/05 / 16:43:46 System: HTE PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Progrm: CHFOO4P Narrative Print Page: 1 Case Number: 1-05-000368 *********** ****** *** ***** ***NARRATIV E # 28 ********** * ***** ********** NA Reported By: Entered By.: 12/21/05 12/21/05 On December 20, 2005, I contacted ASA in an attempt to subpoena the Epstein former houseman, Alfredo Rodriguez. Rodriguez, who resides in Miami, had eluded the process servers previously and was not served the investig

2p

Forum Discussions

This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,500+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.

Support This ProjectSupported by 1,550+ people worldwide
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.