Opinion Piece on Xi Jinping Thought and China’s 19th Party Congress

= October 28-29, 2017 D COMMENT OPINION ChinaDaily chinadaily.com.cn/opinion Robert Lawrence Kuhn New era on the road to 2050 witnessed history sitting in the Great Hall of the People during the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China. I listened raptly to Xi Jinping, general secretary of the CPC Central Committee, when he delivered his new-era-defining report. I heard the amendment to the Party Constitution that enshrined “Xi Jinping Thought on Social- ism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era”. I watched members of the new Stand- ing Committee of the Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee walk out on stage. I was awed by the presence of the leadership, past and present. And I was overawed by Xi’s grand vision for China and the country’s increasing, radiating confidence. Most of all, I marveled at the remarkable and historic transformation of China, which means so much to the Chinese people and which in this new era will mean so much to the rest of the world. Having departed the Great Hall of the People, I reflected how I, an American, found myself caught up in the welling Chi- nese patriotism of the 19th CPC National Congress. Certainly, I was experiencing first- hand this inflection point in Chinese histo- ry, when China envisions itself becoming a fully modernized country and taking pro- active part in international affairs, and regaining its leading seat at the high table of great nations. What have I just witnessed? Following are some personal observations. Ageneral consensus describes four pri- mary outcomes of the 19th Party Congress: Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chi- nese Characteristics for a New Era; a new “contradiction” that defines China’s princi- pal social challenge; a China that takes “cen- ter stage in the world”; and the Party enhancing its leadership of society, includ- ing maintaining, indeed intensifying, its anti-corruption campaign. To me, however, a highlight was the speci- ficity of Xi’s vision of China, not only estab- lishing policies for the next five years, but also framing the agenda and setting the strategies for the next 30 years. This congress, Xi said, is the “confluence” of the “Iwo Centenary Goals”: a moderately prosperous society by 2020 (2021 being the 100th anniversary of the CPC), which will likely be fulfilled within the term of the 19th Party Congress, and a great, modern, socialist country by 2050 (2049 being the 100th anniversary of the Peo- ple’s Republic of China), which is being planned by the 19th Party Congress. Ina multi-meaning refinement, the path to mid-century is now designed in two sta- ges. In the first stage, from 2020 to 2035, the Party states it will build on the foundation of the moderately prosperous society such that, after “15 years of hard work’; the country will basically realize “socialist modernization’: Inthe second stage, from 2035 to 2050, the CPC states it will build on a basically achieved modernization, “work hard for a further 15 years” and “develop China into a great mod- ern socialist country that is prosperous, strong, democratic, culturally advanced, har- monious, and beautiful’: China portrays its mid-century self as a global leader in every area of human consequence: economics and trade, science and technology, military and defense, culture and governance. But Chinese leaders, and officials in gener- al, seem to have a different highlight. While the “Two Centenary Goals” are certainly vital, especially with new stages and specificity, they focus on the amendment to the Party Consti- tution: “Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era”. “The (Xi’s) thought is the biggest high- light of the 19th National Congress of the CPC and a historic contribution to the Par- ty’s development,” said Zhang Dejiang, the third-ranking member of the Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the 18th CPC Central Committee. Liu Yunshan, the fifth-ranking member, said the elevation of Xi’s thought to the Party’s guiding princi- ple is of great political, theoretical and prac- tical significance. I take a closer look at Xi’s thought: first by examining each of its elements, then by con- sidering its unified significance. “Xi Jinping” is the “core” of the CPC Cen- tral Committee and of the whole Party, and he thereby at the top level provides the “cen- tralism” of the Party’s cardinal principle of democratic centralism. The “Thought” is the totality of Xi’s fun- damental principles. I see four broad cate- gories: people orientation, national rejuvenation, comprehensive development, and Party leadership. In his report, Xi listed 14 categories: Party leadership over all aspects of society; peo- ple-centered policies; deepening reform comprehensively; new concept of develop- ment (innovation, coordination, green, open, and sharing); people as masters of the country; adherence to rule of law, compre- hensively governing the country by law; socialist value system and cultural confi- dence; protecting and improving people's livelihoods; harmonious coexistence of man. and nature (ecological civilization); national security; the Party’s absolute leadership over the military; “one country, two sys- tems” and promoting reunification with Tai- wan; international community of a shared. future for all humanity; and comprehensive and strict Party governance. The term “thought” in Chinese has special meaning because before this it had been associated only with Mao Zedong — “Mao Zedong Thought”. “Socialism” is a set of political ideas with a complex history, unified by public or com- mon ownership of the means of production and concern for the masses. “Chinese characteristics” is the phrase, originating with Deng Xiaoping, that adapts Marxism to China’s special conditions — the Sinicization of Marxism in modern China — which includes the market playing a decisive role in the allocation of resources and the encouragement of non-public, for-profit busi- nesses, while at the same time State-owned enterprises still playing a dominant role. “New Era” is a new idea in the constitu- tional amendment, and it is designed to profoundly transform the essence of social- ism with Chinese characteristics into the vision, concepts and strategies that com- pose Xi’s way of thinking. The more I reflect, the more I see “New Era” as a conceptual lens with which to view the 19th Party Congress. Semi-official Party analysts say the new era answers five ques- tions. hensiveness of the cate- gories were clear, amplified by the commit- ment to deepen reform. Here, by category, are what stood out. The Party and the fight against corrup- tion. Confidence in socialism and the increasing role of the Party in managing all aspects of the country is unequivocal, and. the increasingly strict governance of the Party, by reforming and purifying itself, is unambiguous. Moreover, the anti-corrup- tion campaign not only continues but also will be enhanced. Economy. After more than three decades of rapid growth, China’s economy has been transitioning to slower but higher-quality growth. Supply-side structural reform has been written into the Constitution. No GDP growth targets are set. The country focuses on the real economy (as opposed to specula- tion, such as in the real estate sector). China is not backing away from State-owned enterprises, rather it will support State capi- tal in “becoming stronger, doing better, and growing bigger, thereby turning Chinese enterprises into world-class, globally com- petitive firms” Consumption is fundamental in driving economic growth. The framework of regula- tions must be improved, prudent macroeco- nomic and monetary policy maintained, and interest and exchange rates made more Robert Lawrence Kuhn ‘Xi said, an example of his plainspoken can- dor. “It will take more than drum-beating and gong-clanging to get there.” The speculations of China watchers, and the focus of the international media, have been on the new Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the CPC Central Commit- tee. Because everything in China reports to astanding committee member, composition. and balance determine the vision, strategies and policies that will shape China. This remains true today, but less true today. It is hard to overstate the signifi- cance of Xi Jinping’s name written into the Party Constitution. Xi is now, officially, the originating designator and overarching arbiter of “Thought” as it relates to “Social- ism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era’, which is the guiding political theory of China and encompasses, essentially, every- thing in China. For Xi to be named in the CPC Constitution is the ultimate in authori- ty, surpassing even “core” (which already had superseded all other leaders), thus set- ting into perpetuity Xi’s predominant sta- tus and assuring his preeminence in the country’s political life. That said, to know China is to know the members of the Standing Committee. They are a highly competent, highly experienced group: six of the seven have run provinces or province-level municipalities, many of which, in terms of population and GDP, are the equivalent of major nations. Traditional norms of balance and age are respected. It’s a diverse group — by geogra- phy, education and political career. They What “road” to take? Socialism with Chi- nese characteristics under new historical conditions. ‘What kind of country to build? First, a moderately prosperous society and then a modernized socialist country. ‘What development to realize? Better life and common prosperity for all. ‘What goal to achieve? The great rejuvena- tion of the Chinese nation. What contribution to make? Facilitate world peace and prosperity (exemplified by the Belt and Road Initiative of building infrastructure in developing countries). Thus, Xi Jinping joins only Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping in having his name affixed to a political philosophy in the Party Constitution, a blazing sign lost on no one. It then would follow that the “New Era” into which China is now entering is the third era of the CPC and by extension of the People’s Republic of China. Aseemingly subtle but significant change is the Party's judgment of what con- stitutes the fundamental “contradiction” in Chinese society. (“Contradiction” is a Marx- ist term expressing a particular way of political thinking — dialectical materialism. — which identifies “dynamic opposing for- es” in society and seeks to resolve the resulting tensions). The principal contradiction has evolved from one between the ever-growing materi- al and cultural needs of the people and backward social production to that between “anbalanced and inadequate development and the people's ever-growing needs for a better life,” Xi said. The needs for the people to live a better life are increasingly broad and have to be met. Not only have their material and cultural needs grown; their demands for democracy, rule of law, fairness and justice, security, and a better environ- ment are increasing. This “New-Era” contradiction, replacing quantitative GDP growth with qualitative improvement of life, is what will drive Chi- na’s policy. The mission of a CPC congress is to review and assess achievements of the previous five years, and to forecast challenges and set tar- gets for the subsequent five years (and beyond). Overall, for the 19th Party Congress, the ambition of the goals and the compre- market-based. For economic development, innovation leads, especially in science and technology. Poverty alleviation. Xi has made the elimination of extreme poverty in China by 2020 a cornerstone of his domestic policy. After all, how could China claim to have achieved a moderately prosperous society by 2020 if millions of its citizens would be still living in extreme poverty? Opening-up. China reasserts its com- mitment to become more open, including easing market access and protecting the rights and interests of foreign investors. China’s economists see foreign competition as upgrading the quality and cost efficiency of Chinese companies, thus better serving Chinese consumers. Rule of Law. Strengthening and institu- tionalizing the rule of law, and weakening arbitrary rule of officials, is a priority. Reflecting Xi’s commitment, the Party is set- ting up a central leading group for advanc- ing law-based governance in all areas, coordinating the activities of judicial organs. The goal is to complete the transfor- mation of China’s legal system by 2035 with theoretical foundations and practical enforcement. Ecology. Beautiful China is one of the country’s main descriptions for its second centenary goal by the middle of the century. This modernization is characterized by har- monious coexistence between humanity and nature (such as nature parks) and it requires substantial bolstering of regulatory agencies and their enforcement powers. Armed forces. China's goal is to trans- form the People’s Liberation Army into a world-class military by mid-century, basical- ly completing military reform and moderni- zation by 2035, with information technology/cyber applications and strategic capabilities prioritized. Especially significant for Xi’s mission are the two “anti’s” — anti-corruption and anti- poverty — the former to support the Party’s continuing leadership, the latter as a prime example of what the Party has delivered. Xi does not downplay a realistic appraisal of problems, including social imbalances, industrial overcapacities, financial system risks, endemic pollution. “Achieving nation- al rejuvenation will be no walk in the park,” ZHAI HAIJUN / FOR CHINA DAILY have worked together, in various combina- tions, for years. With much now being writ- ten about each member, I’ll just offer some personal reflections. First, of course, is Xi Jinping, general sec- retary of the CPC Central Committee, whose prior experience included governor of Fuji- an province and Party secretary of Zhejiang province and Shanghai. In 2005, I was advised to study the “Zheji- ang model” which promotes entrepreneur- ship to generate economic development. I met Xi, who was then Zhejiang provincial Party secretary, and he recommended that I study China both “horizontally” across diverse regions and “vertically” through the history of its development. “To understand our dedication to revitalize ‘the country, one has to appreciate the pride that Chinese people take in our glorious ancient civilization,’ Xi said. “This is the histor- ical driving force inspiring people today to build the nation. The Chinese people made great contributions to world civilization and enjoyed long-term prosperity,’ he said. “Then we suffered over a century of national weak- ness, oppression and humiliation. So, we have a deep self-motivation to build our country. Our commitment and determina- tion is rooted in our patriotism and pride.” But he cautioned that pride in China’s recent achievements should not engender complacency. Second, premier of the State Council, is Li Keqiang, who was Party secretary of Hen- an and Liaoning provinces. When I visited Liin Liaoning, he explained the complex challenges of revitalizing State-owned enterprises while creating a fertile environ- ment for private businesses. Li shared the same experience of Xi as educated youths in the countryside in the 1970s. The experience gave them the chance to know better rural China and the lives of rural people and thus fostered their people-orientation. The following members are new: Li Zhanshu, who was governor of Hei- longjiang province and Party secretary of Guizhou province, has been director of the general office of the CPC Central Committee since 2012. ‘Wang Yang, vice-premier, is former Party secretary of Chongqing municipality and Guangdong province. At the height of the global financial crisis in early 2009, he argued it was imperative to restructure Guangdong’s economy, so that it can move up the ladder of industrialization and pro- mote more knowledge-based, high-tech, low- polluting businesses. ‘Wang Huning, secretariat, is director of the Policy Research Office of the CPC Central Committee. Wang is well known for provid- ing intellectual vision and sophistication in support of practical strategies and policies, ranging from political philosophy to interna- tional relations. Zhao Leji, new chairman of the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection, has served as head of the CPC Organization Department, and before that, as Party secre- tary of Qinghai and Shaanxi provinces. In addition to his responsibilities for Party and government officials, Zhao provided strong support for the poverty-alleviation mission. Han Zheng is Party secretary of Shanghai. Under his leadership, Shanghai has become arecognized leader in trade, logistics and finance. What is the impact of all this on China’s international relations? There is no need to speculate. Xi himself, in his report, openly and boldly tells all who will listen. China, he says, “has become a great power in the world” China's global engagement is proactive, confident and growing. Economics and trade drive China’s power, exemplified by the much-needed Belt and Road Initiative, but diplomacy, the soft power of culture and media, and the hard power of a blue-water navy projecting power, are developing rapidly. As Xi said, the new era sees “China moving closer to center stage and making greater contributions to mankind” The country is now offering “Chinese wisdom” and “Chinese solutions” to the international community — the experiences and lessons of China’s remarkable development, especially to devel- oping countries. Regarding Taiwan, which exemplifies Chi- nese sovereignty, Xi painted a bright red line. “We will resolutely uphold national sover- eignty and territorial integrity and will never tolerate a repeat of the historical tragedy of a divided country;’ Xi emphasized. “We have firm will, full confidence, and sufficient capa- bility to defeat any form of Taiwan independ- ence secession plot.” China has asserted again that it is no threat to any country. No matter how power- ful China becomes, China’s leaders say it will never seek hegemony or pursue expansion- ism. Nonetheless, some foreigners remain. suspicious, wary of China’s long-term ambi- tions. Who knows future circumstances, they worry? Who knows how China may change? Although I fear self-fulfilling prophecy, I am encouraged that China appreciates such sen- sitivities and works to build confidence. The 19th Party Congress, especially Xi’s report, is an epic narrative of what China has accomplished, what China has yet to achieve, and what China envisages as necessary to be a great nation. Xi, now, carries the authority; he also bears the burden. Setting that new target date of 2035 for China to achieve basic modernization, Xi sees China as standing at a new historic starting point and socialism with Chinese characteristics as exploring new horizons. China has entered a new era and the road ahead leads, apparently, to great nation sta- tus by 2050. The author is a public intellectual, interna- tional corporate strategist, and China expert/ commentator. He is co-creator (with Adam Zhu) and the host of China Global Television Network's Closer to China with R.L.Kuhn. CONTACT US China Daily 15 Huixin Dongjie Chaoyang, Beijing 100029, News: +86 (0) 10 6491-8366; [email protected] Subscription:A36 400-699-0203; [email protected] Advertisement:A36 (0) 10 6491-8631; [email protected] Phone app: chinadaily.com.cn/iphone China Daily USA 1500 Broadway, Suite 2800, New York, NY 10036 +1 212 537 8888 [email protected] China Daily Asia Pacific China Daily Hong Kong Room 1818, Hing Wai Centre 7 Tin Wan Praya Road Aberdeen, Hong Kong +852 2518 5111 [email protected] [email protected] China Daily UK 90 Cannon Street London EC4N 6HA +44 (0) 207 398 8270 [email protected] China Daily Africa PO.Box 27281-00100, Nairobi, Kenya +254 (0) 20 522 3498 (Nairobi) [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023685