Skip to main content
Skip to content
Ghislaine Maxwell renewed bail applicationMaxwell 12.28.2020
Case File
dc-20433076Court Unsealed

plenty of perjury

Date
December 21, 2020
Source
Court Unsealed
Reference
dc-20433076
Pages
35
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available

Summary

 .(#-,--,#,-+#-).+-()+-"+( #,-+#-) !)+!# -&(-#/#,#)( & &#(0)) $+ ?D:?L?:K7BBO          *B7?DJ?<<       L         #/#&-#)( #&()     ++ (,*+!+ ?D>?IE<<?9?7B  97F79?JO7I,;9H;J7HOE<,J7J;E<J>;,J7J;  E<!;EH=?7+( ,.&&#/(   ?D>;HE<<?9?7B97F79?JO7I/?9;>7?HE<  J>;!;EH=?7,J7J;B;9J?EDE7H:   /#$ 0)+&2 ?D>?IE<<?9?7B   97F79?JO7I7';C8;H

View on documentcloud.org
Ask AI about this document

Search 264K+ documents with AI-powered analysis

0Share
PostReddit

Extracted Text (OCR)

EFTA Disclosure
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
 .(#-,--,#,-+#-).+-()+-"+( #,-+#-) !)+!# -&(-#/#,#)( & &#(0)) $+ ?D:?L?:K7BBO          *B7?DJ?<<       L         #/#&-#)( #&()     ++ (,*+!+ ?D>?IE<<?9?7B  97F79?JO7I,;9H;J7HOE<,J7J;E<J>;,J7J;  E<!;EH=?7+( ,.&&#/(   ?D>;HE<<?9?7B97F79?JO7I/?9;>7?HE<  J>;!;EH=?7,J7J;B;9J?EDE7H:   /#$ 0)+&2 ?D>?IE<<?9?7B   97F79?JO7I7';C8;HE<J>;!;EH=?7   ,J7J;B;9J?EDE7H:'--"0   ',".+( ?D>?IE<<?9?7B97F79?JO7I  7';C8;HE<J>;!;EH=?7,J7J;B;9J?ED  E7H:7D:("& ?D>;HE<<?9?7B   97F79?JO7I7';C8;HE<J>;!;EH=?7   ,J7J;B;9J?EDE7H:       ;<;D:7DJI      666666666666666666666666666666666666              )',()0*B7?DJ?<<& &#(0)) $+  W*B7?DJ?<<X 8O7D:J>HEK=> J>;KD:;HI?=D;:9EKDI;B <?B;>?I/;H?<?;:ECFB7?DJ<EH;9B7H7JEHO7D:#D@KD9J?L; +;B?;< J>; WECFB7?DJX  7D: IK; J>; 78EL; 97FJ?ED;: ;<;D:7DJI  H;IF;9J<KBBO I>EM?D=J>?I"EDEH78B;EKHJ7I<EBBEMI Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 1 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 2 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 3 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 4 of 35  %" "#"*!*/.60*(2#0(-+$/&+*+#/%" "+-$&("$&.(/0-"6. .//0/+-4)&(&*."*/""((+/.&$*/0-"1"-&#& /&+*,-+ "!0-"  ->;<?HIJKD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BFHE9;:KH;7J?IIK;?DJ>?I97I;?DLEBL;IJ>;KDB7M<KB 7D:?CFHEF;HFHE9;II?D=E<C7?B ?D87BBEJI ->;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;I;J<EHJ>J>; C7DD;H <EH >7D:B?D= I?=D7JKH; ?:;DJ?<?97J?ED L;H?<?97J?ED E< C7?B ?D LEJ;I 8O ?D:?L?:K7B9EKDJOH;=?IJH7HI7D:9B;HAI )  !  RR  7B      ->EI;?D:?L?:K7BICKIJ<EBBEM79B;7HFHE9;:KH;<EH9>;9A?D=I?=D7JKH;IJEL;H?<O J>;?:;DJ?JOE<C7?B ?DLEJ;HI?DJ>;C7DD;HFH;I9H?8;:8OJ>;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH; .FEDH;9;?FJE<;79>378I;DJ;;487BBEJ 7H;=?IJH7HEH9B;HA(!!MH?J; J>; :7O 7D: >EKH E< J>; H;9;?FJ E< J>; 87BBEJ ED ?JI ;DL;BEF;  ->; H;=?IJH7HEH9B;HA(!!J>;D9ECF7H;J>;?:;DJ?<O?D=?D<EHC7J?EDEDJ>; E7J>M?J>J>;?D<EHC7J?EDED<?B;?D>?IEH>;HE<<?9; (!!9ECF7H;J>; I?=D7JKH; EH C7A; ED J>; E7J> M?J> J>; I?=D7JKH; EH C7HA ED J>; 78I;DJ;;;B;9JEHILEJ;H97H:EHJ>;CEIJH;9;DJKF:7J;JEIK9>78I;DJ;; ;B;9JEHILEJ;HH;=?IJH7J?ED97H:7D:7FFB?97J?ED<EH78I;DJ;;87BBEJEH7 <79I?C?B; E< I7?: I?=D7JKH; EH C7A;H J7A;D <HEC I7?: 97H: EH 7FFB?97J?ED 7D:(!!?<J>;?D<EHC7J?ED7D: I?=D7JKH;7FF;7HJE 8; L7B?:7D:EJ>;H?:;DJ?<O?D=?D<EHC7J?ED7FF;7HIJE8;9EHH;9J IE9;HJ?<O 8OI?=D?D=EH?D?J?7B?D=>?IEH>;HD7C;8;BEMJ>;LEJ;HIE7J>  )  !  R  7B;CF>7I?I7::;:   KHJ>;H )  !  R  ;IJ78B?I>;I7D;GK?L7B;DJFHE9;:KH;<EH7FEBB MEHA;HJE L;H?<OJ>;?:;DJ?JO E< 7D?D F;HIED LEJ;H )D; FEBBMEHA;H L;H?<?;IJ>; ?:;DJ?JOE<?D F;HIEDLEJ;HI   ->;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;7BIE;IJ78B?I>;:79B;7H7D:;<<?9?;DJFHE9;IIJE8; KI;:8O7FEBBMEHA;H?<>; I>;:;J;HC?D;IJ>7J7D;B;9JEH>7I<7?B;:JEI?=DJ>;E7J> EDJ>;EKJI?:;;DL;BEF;;D9BEI?D=J>;C7?B ?D78I;DJ;;87BBEJEHJ>7JJ>;I?=D7JKH; Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 5 of 35  :E;IDEJ9ED<EHCM?J>J>;I?=D7JKH;ED<?B;?DJ>;H;=?IJH7HIEH9B;HAIE<<?9;7 :;<;9J?L; 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ   )  !   R   7B  0?J> H;IF;9J JE :;<;9J?L;78I;DJ;;87BBEJI  ."&.),"- #&.)-#!(.")."),# ."-#!(./,)-(). **, .)  0&# EH ?< J>; ;B;9JEH >7I <7?B;: JE <KHD?I> H;GK?H;: ?D<EHC7J?ED),#( ),'.#)(-) /,(#-")-().)( ),'1#.".".)( #&#(." ,!#-.,,- ), &,%- ) # EH ?< J>; ;B;9JEH ?I EJ>;HM?I; <EKD::?IGK7B?<?;:JELEJ; J>;H;=?IJH7HEH9B;HA-"&&MH?J;79HEIIJ>; <79;E<J>;;DL;BEF;+;@;9J;: =?L?D=J>;H;7IEDJ>;H;<EH ->;8E7H: E<H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HA-"&&FHECFJBO().# 2."&.), ) -/",$.#)(79EFOE<M>?9>DEJ?<?97J?ED-"&&8;H;J7?D;:?DJ>; <?B;IE<J>;8E7H:E<H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HA<EH7JB;7IJED; O;7H  )  !  R  7B;CF>7I?I7::;: ->;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;9B;7HBO 9EDJ;CFB7J;: J>; KI; E< MH?JJ;D DEJ?<?97J?ED 8O J>; 9EKDJO H;=?IJH7H EH 9B;HA ?D DEJ?<O?D= J>; ;B;9JEH E< J>; H;@;9J?ED  ->?I M7I J>; B;=?IB7J?L;BO I;J '((, E< L;H?<O?D= LEJ;H?:;DJ?JO <EH 78I;DJ;;C7?B?D 87BBEJI <EHJ>; ;B;9J?EDI <EH ;:;H7B E<<?9;?D!;EH=?7 ?D9BK:?D=J>;HKDE<<   #DEH78EKJ'7H9>  ;<;D:7DJI ,;9H;J7HO+7<<;DIF;H=;H 7D:J>;,J7J; B;9J?ED E7H:  M>E 7:C?D?IJ;H J>; IJ7J; ;B;9J?EDI 9EBB;9J?L;BO J>; :C?D?IJH7JEHI ;DJ;H;: ?DJE 7 ECFHEC?I; 7D: ,;JJB;C;DJ =H;;C;DJ 7D: +;B;7I;J>;&?J?=7J?ED,;JJB;C;DJE<B?J?=7J?EDJ>;;CE9H7J?9*7HJOE<!;EH=?7  #D9  J>; ;CE9H7J ,;D7JEH?7B 7CF7?=D ECC?JJ;;  7D: J>; ;CE9H7J?9 ED=H;II?ED7B7CF7?=DECC?JJ;;J>;;CE9H7J=;D9?;I?D?J?7J;:7=7?DIJ  ;D79J?D= .).&&2 # ,(. -.(,- .)  )&&)1  *)&& 1),%, *,)--#(! Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 6 of 35  -(. &&).- #( ),!# ,;; '),.# ,.2 )  ),!# ( . & 0  (-*,!, . & ?L?B 9J?ED ?B; (E   9L   0'+  .D?J;: ,J7J;I ?IJH?9JEKHJ<EHJ>;(EHJ>;HD?IJH?9JE<!;EH=?7 JB7DJ7?L?I?ED E9     BJ>EK=>J>;,),?I7KJ>EH?P;:JEFHECKB=7J;HKB;I7D:H;=KB7J?EDIJ>7J7H; 9ED:K9?L;JEJ>;<7?H B;=7B 7D:EH:;HBO9ED:K9JE<FH?C7H?;I7D:;B;9J?EDI 7BB IK9>HKB;I7D:H;=KB7J?EDICKIJ8;9EDI?IJ;DJM?J>B7M )  !  R    +KB;IC7ODEJ9ED<B?9JM?J>;B;9J?EDIJ7JKJ;I   (EJM?J>IJ7D:?D= KD:;HJ>;&?J?=7J?ED,;JJB;C;DJ J>;:C?D?IJH7JEHI7=H;;: JE9>7D=;J>;IJ7JKJEH?BOFH;I9H?8;:FHE9;IIE<>7D:B?D=78I;DJ;;87BBEJI?D7C7DD;H J>7J M7I DEJ 9EDI?IJ;DJ M?J> J>; B7MI FHECKB=7J;: 8O J>; !;EH=?7 &;=?IB7JKH;  *7HJ?9KB7HBO &?J?=7J?ED,;JJB;C;DJFHEL?:;IJ>7JJ>;,;9H;J7HOE<,J7J;MEKB:?IIK; 7D )<<?9?7B B;9J?ED KBB;J?D JE EKDJO )<<?9?7BI EL;HH?:?D= J>; FH;I9H?8;: IJ7JKJEHOFHE9;:KH;I ->;KD7KJ>EH?P;:&?J?=7J?ED,;JJB;C;DJFHE9;:KH; I;J <EHJ> 8;BEM  ?I CEH; 9KC8;HIEC;  7D: 9ED<B?9JI M?J> J>; B;=?IB7J?L; <H7C;MEHA M?J> H;IF;9JJELEJ;H?:;DJ?JOL;H?<?97J?ED7D::;<;9J?L;78I;DJ;;87BBEJI   .D:;HJ>; &?J?=7J?ED ,;JJB;C;DJ J>; <EBBEM?D=B7D=K7=; M?BB 7:: 7D: >7I 7BH;7:O 7::;: JE J>; FH;IIKH;I 7D: 9ECFB;N?JO E< FHE9;II?D= :;<;9J?L; 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI C7A?D=?JB;IIB?A;BOJ>7JJ>;OM?BB8;?:;DJ?<?;:EH ?<?:;DJ?<?;: FHE9;II;: <EHH;@;9J?ED EKDJOH;=?IJH7HI7D:78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HAI,,+/#,KFEDH;9;?FJ E<;79>C7?B ?D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ JE9ECF7H;J>;I?=D7JKH;EHC7A;E< Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 7 of 35   J>;;B;9JEHEDJ>;C7?B ?D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ;DL;BEF;M?J>J>;I?=D7JKH;I EHC7HAI?D;(;J7D:EDJ>;7FFB?97J?ED<EHJ>;C7?B?D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ  #<J>;I?=D7JKH;:E;IDEJ7FF;7HJE8;L7B?: H;=?IJH7HI7D:9B;HAI7H; H;GK?H;:JE<EBBEMJ>;FHE9;:KH;I;J<EHJ>?D)  !  R  7B  0>;DH;L?;M?D=7D;B;9JEHII?=D7JKH;EDJ>;C7?B ?D78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ;DL;BEF; J>;H;=?IJH7HEH9B;HACKIJ9ECF7H;J>;I?=D7JKH;ED J>; C7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ ;DL;BEF; JE ;79> I?=D7JKH; 9EDJ7?D;: ?D IK9> ;B;9JEHI LEJ;H H;=?IJH7J?ED H;9EH: ?D ;(;J 7D: J>; ;B;9JEHI I?=D7JKH;EDJ>;7FFB?97J?ED<EHJ>;C7?B ?D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ  ) '()'' $' (#) !!$)!'  )'"#()))+$)'( (#)*'$#)"!#(#)!!$)#+!$%$(#$)")#- $ ) +$)'( (#)*'( $# ! # ) $' $# ) (#) !!$) %%!)$#)'()''$'(#)!!$)!' "*()( '+, '$"),$$)''()''(%*)-'()''($'(#)!!$)!' ( "!#(#)!!$)(!!#$)')*#!(("$')-$ )'()''(%*)-'()''($'(#)!!$)!' ('+,# ) (#)*' ' )) ) (#)*' $( #$) ") #- $ ) +$)'( (#)*'( $# ! # ) $' $# ) (#) !!$) %%!)$#)'"#)$#(")))!)$'((#)*' $#)"!#(#)!!$)#+!$%$(#$)")#$) +$)'( (#)*'( $# ! # ) $' $# ) (#) !!$) %%!)$# ) '()'' $' (#) !!$) !'  (!! ,') ) #"($))'!)$#($!(,$$#*))(#)*' '+,'$(()$)(#)!!$)#+!$%,(!! #)$#)$,')#)#)'($#$')')$#( '&*'*#' .    !->;D J>;H;=?IJH7HEH 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ 9B;HA I>7BB 9ECC;D9; J>; DEJ?<?97J?ED FHE9;:KH; I;J <EHJ>?D)  !  R  7B7D:,J7J;B;9J?EDE7H:+KB;       I I>EMD ED J>;?H <79;  J>; FHE9;:KH;I 7FFB?978B; JE LEJ;H ?:;DJ?<?97J?ED L;H?<?97J?ED?D9EDD;9J?EDM?J>J>;79JK7BLEJ?D=FHE9;IIJH;7J?D F;HIEDLEJ;HIB?A; *B7?DJ?<<  :?<<;H;DJ <HEC C7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; LEJ;HI  *KHIK7DJ JE )  !   R   7  7D?D F;HIED LEJ;H CKIJ WFH;I;DJ FHEF;H?:;DJ?<?97J?EDJE 7 FEBB MEHA;HX 8;<EH;J>;?HLEJ;C7O8;97IJ ;CF>7I?I7::;:  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 8 of 35    ,?C?B7HBO J>;LEJ;H?:;DJ?<?97J?EDFHE9;:KH;FHEL?:;:8O)!,;9J?ED  FHEL?:;IJ>7J78I;DJ;;87BBEJIMEKB:8;H;9;?L;:7D:H;L?;M;:8OW7H;=?IJH7H EH9B;HA X,;;)  !  R  7 #<J>;I?=D7JKH;:E;IDEJ7FF;7HJE8; L7B?:EH:E;IDEJ9ED<EHCM?J>J>;I?=D7JKH;ED <?B; WJ>; H;=?IJH7HEH9B;HAI>7BB MH?J;79HEIIJ>;<79;E<J>;;DL;BEF;W+;@;9J;:X=?L?D=J>;H;7IEDJ>;H;<EH; X,;; )  ! R  7   IIK9> 8;<EH;J>;;<;D:7DJI;DJ;H;:?DJEJ>;KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BI;JJB;C;DJ 7=H;;C;DJ ED;FEBBMEHA;HM7I9>7H=;:M?J>L;H?<O?D=J>;LEJ;HZI?:;DJ?JO8;<EH; J>;?H 87BBEJM7I 97IJ H;=7H:B;II E<M>;J>;HJ>; LEJ;M7I?D F;HIED EH 8OC7?B ?D 78I;DJ;;87BBEJ   ->;;<;D:7DJIJ>KI9>7D=;:J>;9B;7H IJ7JKJEHO FHE9;:KH; <EH9ED<?HC?D= LEJ;H?:;DJ?JO7JJ>;J?C;E<LEJ?D= IEJ>7JH7J>;HJ>7DED;FEBBMEHA;HH;L?;M?D= I?=D7JKH;I  7 9ECC?JJ;; E< J>H;; FEBB MEHA;HI ?I 9>7H=;: M?J> 9ED<?HC?D= J>7J 78I;DJ;;87BBEJI?=D7JKH;I7H;:;<;9J?L;8;<EH;H;@;9J?D=787BBEJ   KHJ>;H J>?ID;MFHE9;:KH;JH;7JI?D F;HIEDLEJ;H?:;DJ?<?97J?EDL;H?<?97J?ED :?<<;H;DJ <HEC C7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; LEJ;H ?:;DJ?<?97J?ED L;H?<?97J?ED 7J J>; J?C; E< 97IJ?D=J>; LEJ; O :;I?=D7J?D= 7 9ECC?JJ;; E<J>H;;JE 9>;9AC7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; LEJ;H ?:;DJ?<?97J?ED 8KJ >7L?D= 7 I?D=B; FEBB MEHA;H 9>;9A ?D F;HIED LEJ;H ?:;DJ?<?97J?ED  J>; 9>7BB;D=;: FHE9;:KH; <7LEHI J>; 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI  JH;7JI J>; 78I;DJ;;LEJ;HI:?<<;H;DJBO<HEC?D F;HIEDLEJ;HI7D:L7BK;I78I;DJ;;LEJ;ICEH; Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 9 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 10 of 35   ->; I;9ED: KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B FHE9;:KH; 7J ?IIK; ?D J>?I 97I; H;B7J;I JE J>; KDB7M<KBEF;D?D=7D: EHL?;M?D=E<78I;DJ;;87BBEJIC7?B ?D87BBEJI?D7:L7D9;E< J>;IJ7JKJEHO:7J;I;J<EHIK9>EF;D?D= IM?J>J>;?:;DJ?JOL;H?<?97J?EDFHE9;:KH;I :;I9H?8;:78EL; J>;;<;D:7DJI>7L;7BIEKIKHF;:J>;!;EH=?7!;D;H7BII;C8BOZI FB;D7HOFEM;HEL;HJ>;C7DD;HE<9ED:K9J?D=;B;9J?EDI8O?CF;HC?II?8BO9>7D=?D= J>;B7MIH;=7H:?D=J>;J?C;<EHEF;D?D=7D: EHL?;M?D=E<J>EI;87BBEJI   *7HJ?9KB7HBO  J>; &;=?IB7JKH; FHECKB=7J;: )  !   R  7 M>?9>FHEL?:;IWJ>;8E7H:E<H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HAI>7BBA;;FI7<;BO  /()*(  7D: IJEH;:?D 7C7DD;HJ>7J M?BB FH;L;DJJ7CF;H?D= 7D: KD7KJ>EH?P;: 799;II 7BB E<<?9?7B 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI H;9;?L;: <HEC 78I;DJ;; ;B;9JEHI *,#), .) ." &)-#(!) ."*)&&-)(."2) ."FH?C7HOEH&.#)( X;CF>7I?I7::;:   *KHIK7DJJEJ>;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;ZI9B;7H:?H;9J?L;I W .,.")*(#(!)  ."*)&&-)(."2) ."FH?C7HO ;B;9J?ED EH,/() J>;,!#-.,,-),-(. &&).&,%--"&&/."),#3.))*(.")/.,(0&)*XED7C7?B ?D78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ   7J 7 ;CF>7I?I 7::;:  ::?J?ED7BBO  W )/(.2 &.#)( -/*,#(.((. '2  ?D >?I EH >;H :?I9H;J?ED  7<J;H    '  )( ." 2 )  ." FH?C7HO  ;B;9J?ED  EH ,/() )*( ." #((, (0&)*- ?D 799EH:7D9; M?J> J>; FHE9;:KH;I FH;I9H?8;: ?D J>?I IK8I;9J?ED 7D: 8;=?DD?D= J78KB7J?D= J>; 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI37<J;H<EBBEM?D=9;HJ7?DDEJ?9;FHE9;:KH;I4 X7J7 #DI>EHJ C7?B ?D Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 11 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 12 of 35  FHE>?8?JI J>; EF;D?D= E< 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI 8;<EH; ;B;9J?ED :7O  #D 9EDJH7IJ  J>; ;<;D:7DJIZ +KB; ;NFH;IIBO 7BBEMI J>; EF;D?D= E< 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI J>H;; M;;AI 8;<EH;;B;9J?ED:7O ->;E:;7D:J>;+KB;7H;?D9EDI?IJ;DJ7D:CKJK7BBO;N9BKI?L;  ->;+KB;CKIJ8;:;9B7H;:?DL7B?:7D:IJH?9A;D7D: EHJ>;;<;D:7DJI>EKB:8;?D ;D@E?D;:<HEC;CFBEO?D=J>;+KB;   B;9JEHIM?BB8;7:L;HI;BO7<<;9J;:?<C7?B;:?D87BBEJI7H;EF;D;:?D7:L7D9; E<;B;9J?ED:7O #DJ>;(EL;C8;H   ;B;9J?ED C7DOLEJ;HIM;DJJEJ>;FEBBI?D ;7HBOLEJ?D=7D:ED;B;9J?ED:7O7D:M;H;JEB:J>;O>7:7BH;7:OLEJ;:U7<H7K:KB;DJ C7?B ?D87BBEJ>7:8;;D97IJ?DJ>;?HD7C; ,;;";7H?D=IE<J>;B;9J?ED&7M,JK:O ,K89ECC?JJ;; E< J>; ,J7D:?D=,;D7J;$K:?9?7HO ECC?JJ;;  ;9;C8;H      7L7?B78B; 7J >JJFI B?L;IJH;7C 9EC 799EKDJI   ;L;DJI   L?:;EI  J J>7JFE?DJ J>;<H7K:KB;DJLEJ;I97IJ?DJ>;?HD7C;M;H;7BH;7:O?D9BK:;:?DJ>;FEEB E<EF;D;:87BBEJI KD78B;JE8;I;=H;=7J;:7D:J>;L7B?:;B;9JEHM7I:;FH?L;:E<>?I EH>;H H?=>JJELEJ; ->?IM7I?D9EDI?IJ;DJM?J>J>;FHE9;:KH;IC7D:7J;:8OJ>; !;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;?DJ>;B;9J?EDE:;  %" "#"*!*/.60*(2#0(&*./((/&+*+#0*0/%+-&5"!((+/!-+, +3".-"*+/,"-)&//"!0*!"-/%" "+-$&"$&.(/0-"6."(" /&+*(2 #-)"2+-' Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 13 of 35   ->;J>?H: KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B FHE9;:KH;?DJ>?I 97I;?DLEBL;IJ>;;<;D:7DJIZ ;IJ78B?I>C;DJ E< 7D KDB7M<KB C;J>E: E< :;B?L;H?D= 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI JE ;B;9J?ED E<<?9?7BI   ->;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;;IJ78B?I>;:79B;7HFHE9;:KH;<EHLEJ;HIJE:;B?L;H 78I;DJ;;87BBEJIJE;B;9J?EDE<<?9?7BI )  !  R  IF;9?<?;I>EM7D:M>;H; 78I;DJ;;87BBEJIC7O8;:;B?L;H;:JE9EKDJO;B;9J?EDE<<?9?7BI  KHJ>;H )  !  R   7 H;GK?H;I ;B;9JEHI EH 9;HJ7?D 7KJ>EH?P;: H;FH;I;DJ7J?L;I E< ;B;9JEHI JE F;HIED7BBO C7?B EH F;HIED7BBO :;B?L;H 3J>;?H 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI4 JE J>; 8E7H: E< H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HA   ->;I;IJ7JKJ;I M>?9>9E:?<O7IF;9?<?97D::;J7?B;:FHE9;:KH;<EHH;GK;IJ?D=  :;B?L;H?D= FHE9;II?D= L;H?<O?D=7D:CED?JEH?D=J>;J78KB7J?EDE<78I;DJ;;87BBEJI  7H;:;I?=D;:JEFHEJ;9J!;EH=?7DI <HECJ>;KD?L;HI7BBO79ADEMB;:=;::7D=;HIE< 87BBEJ >7HL;IJ?D= J>HEK=> M?:;IFH;7: C7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; LEJ?D=  M>?9> 97HH?;I 7 I?=D?<?97DJH?IAE<;B;9J?ED?HH;=KB7H?J?;I7D:LEJ;<H7K:   ,F;9?<?97BBO C7?B ?D78I;DJ;;LEJ?D=9H;7J;IEFFEHJKD?J?;IJEE8I9KH;J>;JHK; ?:;DJ?J?;IE<F;HIEDI<H7K:KB;DJBO9B7?C?D=JE8;B;=?J?C7J;;B;9JEHI7D:<79?B?J7J;I J>; 9EBB;9J?ED E< B7H=; GK7DJ?J?;I E< FKHFEHJ;:BO L7B?: 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI 8O J>?H: F7HJ?;IU 9ECCEDBO 97BB;: 87BBEJ >7HL;IJ?D= U J>7J H;IKBJI ?D 7D ;NJH7EH:?D7HO   -/+$/ /$0(#$,1 (++3  /1$/ ,# $"/$1 /3 -% 1 1$  +$0   )$/  -"' (/0        1 .       '11.0222*$&(0* 1(-,*(,$-/&#-2,*- #(# %(*$ !   !# "!$% "  .#% Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 14 of 35  ?D9H;7I;?DJ>; DKC8;H E< 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI H;9;?L;: 8O 9EKDJO ;B;9J?ED E<<?9?7BI  ?D9BK:?D=C7DOJ>7J7H;DEJH;9;?L;:7D:L;H?<?;:?D799EH:7D9;M?J>J>;FHE9;:KH; H;GK?H;:8O7FFB?978B;!;EH=?7IJ7JKJ;I #D<79J J>;!;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;I;J<EHJ> J>;L;HOIF;9?<?99?H9KCIJ7D9;I<EHH;JKHD?D=7D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ 7D:EDBO7KJ>EH?P;I J>EI; JE 8; H;JKHD;: 8O 97H;=?L;HI EH 9BEI; <7C?BO C;C8;HI   )  !   R  7   #D9EDJH7L;DJ?EDE<J>;B;9J?EDE:; ;<;D:7DJI,),7D:J>;,7:EFJ;: +KB;    7KJ>EH?P?D=J>;KI;E<:HEF8EN;I?DEH:;HJEFHEL?:; 7IJ>; HKB; IJ7J;I  7C;7DI <EH 78I;DJ;; 8OC7?B ;B;9JEHIJE :;B?L;HJ>;?H 87BBEJIJEJ>; 9EKDJOH;=?IJH7HI   OJ>?IHKB; ;<;D:7DJ,F;HC?JJ;:7D:;D9EKH7=;:J>;?DIJ7BB7J?ED7D: KI;E<KD7JJ;D:;::HEF8EN;IM?J>?D!;EH=?7I9EKDJ?;I7I7C;7DI<EH:;B?L;HOE< 78I;DJ;;87BBEJI ->;H;?IDEC;9>7D?ICJE;DIKH;J>7J7F;HIEDM>EKI;I7:HEF 8ENC;;JIJ>;H;GK?H;C;DJIE<J>;B;9J?EDE:;   ,+KB;    9B7?CIJ>7J7:HEF8ENI>7BB8;:;;C;::;B?L;HO FKHIK7DJJE)  !  R     ->?I HKB;I :;<?D?J?ED E< :;B?L;HO?I?D :?H;9J 9ED<B?9J M?J>J>;B7D=K7=; E< )  !   R     M>?9> J>; !;EH=?7 !;D;H7B II;C8BO 7C;D:;: ?D   IF;9?<?97BBOJEFHE>?8?J87BBEJ>7HL;IJ?D=  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 15 of 35   )  !  R  DEMIF;9?<?;IEDBOJMEEFJ?EDI<EHJ>;IK8C?II?EDE< 7D78I;DJ;;87BBEJJ>;;B;9JEHI>7BBJ>;DF;HIED7BBOC7?BEHF;HIED7BBO:;B?L;HJ>; I7C;JEJ>;8E7H:E<H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HA      )  !  R  7;IJ78B?I>;IJ>;FH;9?I;BE97J?EDIM>;H;7D;B;9J?ED E<<?9?7BC7OH;9;?L;7D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ<HECJ>;?D:?L?:K7BLEJ;HEHJ>;?H97H;=?L;HI EH<7C?BOC;C8;H ->;I;I?J;I7H;:;<?D;:7I7::?J?ED7BH;=?IJH7HIE<<?9;IEHFB79;I E<H;=?IJH7J?ED  DOEJ>;HFHEL?I?EDIE<J>?I9>7FJ;HJEJ>;9EDJH7HODEJM?J>IJ7D:?D=  J>; 8E7H: E< H;=?IJH7HI C7O ;IJ78B?I> 7::?J?ED7B I?J;I 7I 7::?J?ED7B H;=?IJH7HIE<<?9;IEHFB79;IE<H;=?IJH7J?ED<EHJ>;FKHFEI;E<H;9;?L?D= 78I;DJ;;87BBEJIKD:;HE:;,;9J?ED  7D:<EHJ>;FKHFEI;E< LEJ?D=78I;DJ;;87BBEJIKD:;HE:;,;9J?ED   FHEL?:;:J>7J7DO IK9>I?J;?I78H7D9>E<J>;9EKDJO9EKHJ>EKI; 79EKHJ>EKI;7DD;N 7 =EL;HDC;DJ I;HL?9; 9;DJ;H FHEL?:?D= =;D;H7B =EL;HDC;DJ I;HL?9;I  7DEJ>;H =EL;HDC;DJ 8K?B:?D= =;D;H7BBO 799;II?8B;JEJ>; FK8B?9  EH 7 BE97J?EDJ>7J?IKI;:7I7D;B;9J?ED:7OFEBB?D=FB79; DEJM?J>IJ7D:?D= J>7JIK9>BE97J?ED?IDEJ7=EL;HDC;DJ8K?B:?D=   )  !  R  :;<?D;I7FEBB?D=FB79;JEC;7DJ>;HEECFHEL?:;: ?D;79>FH;9?D9J<EHLEJ?D=7J7FH?C7HOEH;B;9J?ED   )  !   R   8 FHEL?:;I J>7J ?D B7H=;H FEFKB7J?ED 7H;7I  IK9> 7I KBJED  ;%7B8  !M?DD;JJ  7D: E88 9EKDJ?;I  J>; <EBBEM?D= I?J;I MEKB: 7KJEC7J?97BBOI;HL;7I7::?J?ED7BH;9;?L?D=BE97J?EDI<EH78I;DJ;;87BBEJI 7DO8H7D9>E<J>;9EKDJO9EKHJ>EKI;EH9EKHJ>EKI;7DD;N;IJ78B?I>;: M?J>?D 7DO IK9> 9EKDJO I>7BB 8; 7D 7::?J?ED7B H;=?IJH7HI EH 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ9B;HAIE<<?9;EHFB79;E<H;=?IJH7J?ED<EHJ>;FKHFEI;E<H;9;?L?D= 78I;DJ;;87BBEJI   KD:;HE:;,;9J?ED    Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 16 of 35   :HEF8EN >EM;L;H ?IDEJ?D9BK:;:?DJ>;B?IJE<7::?J?ED7BH;9;FJ?EDI?J;I :;I9H?8;:?DJ>;;N;H9?I;?D)  !  R  77D:87D:?IDEJM?J>?DJ>; C;7D?D=E<7H;=?IJH7HIE<<?9;EHFB79;IE<H;=?IJH7J?ED?D)  !  R     H;=?IJH7HIE<<?9;EHFB79;IE<H;=?IJH7J?ED9EDJ;CFB7J;I78K?B:?D=M?J> IJ7<<97F78B;E<H;9;?L?D=78I;DJ;;87BBEJI7D:L;H?<O?D=J>;I?=D7JKH;7IH;GK?H;: 8OJ>;FHE9;:KH;IFH;I9H?8;:?DR     :HEF8EN97DDEJ8;:;;C;:7BE97J?EDJE7FFBO<EH7D78I;DJ;;87BBEJ?D F;HIED?DJ>;H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HAIE<<?9;7IFH;I9H?8;:8OR   DEH 97D ?J 8; 7 BE97J?ED <EH 7D ;B;9JEH JE 7FF;7H ?D F;HIED JE FH;I;DJ J>; 78I;DJ;;87BBEJJEJ>;8E7H:E<H;=?IJH7HIEH78I;DJ;;87BBEJ9B;HA 7IFH;I9H?8;:8O R     *KHIK7DJ JE )  !   R      EDBO J>; 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ 9B;HA 97D F;H<EHCJ>;<KD9J?EDIEH:KJ?;IFH;I9H?8;:?DJ>;B;9J?EDE:; ->;78I;DJ;;87BBEJ 9B;HAC7O8;J>;9EKDJOH;=?IJH7HEH7DOEJ>;H:;I?=D7J;:E<<?9?7BM>EI>7BBF;H<EHC J>;:KJ?;II;J<EHJ>?DJ>?I7HJ?9B;   ->HEK=>EKJJ>;!;EH=?7B;9J?EDE:; J>;&;=?IB7JKH;9B;7HBO9EDJ;CFB7J;: 7 IJ7<<;: E<<?9; EH 8K?B:?D= <EH LEJ;H H;=?IJH7J?ED  H;9;?FJ E< 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ 7FFB?97J?EDI 7D:H;9;?FJE<78I;DJ;;87BBEJIIEJ>7JJ>;LEJ;H97D:;B?L;HJ>;87BBEJ ?DF;HIEDEHJ>HEK=>J>;?H:;I?=D7J;:IJ7JKJEHO7=;DJ  !)  !  R    Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 17 of 35    HEF8EN;IC7A;?J;7I?;H<EHFEB?J?97B79J?L?IJIJE9ED:K9J87BBEJ>7HL;IJ?D= JE=7J>;HLEJ;I 0>;DJ>;O7H;KI;:J>;H;?I78H;7A?DJ>;9>7?DE<9KIJE:OE<J>EI; 7KJ>EH?P;: 8O IJ7JKJ; JE 9EBB;9J 7D: :;B?L;H 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI  M>?9> FHE:K9;I EFFEHJKD?J?;I <EH FEB?J?97B79J?L?IJIJE IK8C?J <H7K:KB;DJ78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI 7D:J>; EFFEHJKD?JO<EH?BB?9?JLEJ;IJE8;9EKDJ;:?II?=D?<?97DJBO?D9H;7I;:   ->;8H;7A?DJ>;9>7?DE<9KIJE:O97KI;:8OJ>;KI;E<:HEF8EN;I?D9H;7I;I J>; 9>7D9;I J>7J 7D 78I;DJ;; LEJ;H M?BB 97IJ >?I EH >;H LEJ; KD:;H J>; ?CFHEF;H ?D<BK;D9; E< 7DEJ>;H ?D:?L?:K7B 7D: ;D>7D9;I EFFEHJKD?J?;I <EH 87BBEJ J>;<J EH IK8C?II?EDE<?BB?9?JBO=;D;H7J;:78I;DJ;;87BBEJI   ->; FHE9;:KH;I EKJB?D;: 78EL; :?BKJ; J>; *B7?DJ?<<ZI <KD:7C;DJ7B H?=>J JE LEJ; JH;7JJ>;?HLEJ;?D7:?IF7H7J;C7DD;H7D:L?EB7J;J>;?H9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BH?=>JIJE GK7B *HEJ;9J?ED  K; *HE9;II 7D: J>; !K7H7DJ;; E< 7 +;FK8B?97D <EHC E< !EL;HDC;DJKD:;HJ>;. , EDIJ?JKJ?ED   ;97KI;J>;EDIJ?JKJ?EDH;I;HL;I<EH,J7J;&;=?IB7JKH;IJ>;FEM;HJEI;JJ>; J?C;I  FB79;I  7D: C7DD;H E< >EB:?D= <;:;H7B ;B;9J?EDI  IJ7J; ;N;9KJ?L; E<<?9;HI 79J?D= KD:;H 9EBEH E< B7M  B?A; ;<;D:7DJI ?D J>?I 97I;  >7L; DE 7KJ>EH?JO JE KD?B7J;H7BBO;N;H9?I;J>7JFEM;H CK9>B;II<BEKJEH?=DEH;J>;B;9J?EDE:; 7IM7I :ED;?DJ>?I97I;   !;EH=?7ZI&;=?IB7JKH;>7IDEJH7J?<?;:J>;78EL;C7J;H?7B9>7D=;IJEIJ7JKJEHO B7MC7D:7J;:8OJ>;;<;D:7DJI  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 18 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 19 of 35   II;J<EHJ>?D7EC?D?ED0>?IJB;8BEM;H+;FEHJ J>;,C7HJC7J?9IE<JM7H; M7I9EDJH?L;:J>HEK=>79H?C?D7B9EDIF?H79OJEC7D?FKB7J;/;D;PK;B7D;B;9J?EDI?D <7LEHE<:?9J7JEH"K=E>7L;P #CFEHJ7DJBO #M7I7:?H;9JM?JD;IIJEJ>;9H;7J?ED7D:EF;H7J?EDE<7D ;B;9JHED?9LEJ?D=IOIJ;C?D79EDIF?H79O8;JM;;D79ECF7DOADEMD7I ,C7HJC7J?9 7D: J>; B;7:;HI E< 9EDIF?H79O M?J> J>; /;D;PK;B7D =EL;HDC;DJ  ->?I 9EDIF?H79O IF;9?<?97BBO ?DLEBL;: *H;I?:;DJ "K=E >7L;P H?7I J>;F;HIED?D9>7H=;E<J>;(7J?ED7BB;9JEH7BEKD9?B D7C;:$EH=;+E:H?=K;P 7D:FH?D9?F7BI H;FH;I;DJ7J?L;I 7D:F;HIEDD;B <HEC ,C7HJC7J?9  ->; FKHFEI; E< J>?I 9EDIF?H79O M7I JE 9H;7J; 7D: EF;H7J;7LEJ?D=IOIJ;CJ>7J9EKB:9>7D=;J>;LEJ;I?D;B;9J?EDI<HEC LEJ;I7=7?DIJF;HIEDIHKDD?D=J>;/;D;PK;B7D=EL;HDC;DJJELEJ;I?D J>;?H <7LEH ?D EH:;H JE C7?DJ7?D 9EDJHEB E< J>; =EL;HDC;DJ  #D C?: ;8HK7HO E<    J>;H; M7I 7 D7J?ED7B H;<;H;D:KC JE 9>7D=; J>; EDIJ?JKJ?ED E< /;D;PK;B7 JE ;D: J;HC B?C?JI <EH ;B;9J;: E<<?9?7BI  ?D9BK:?D= J>; *H;I?:;DJ E< /;D;PK;B7  ->; H;<;H;D:KC F7II;:  ->?I F;HC?JJ;:"K=E>7L;PJE8;H; ;B;9J;:7DKDB?C?J;:DKC8;HE<J?C;I     ,C7HJC7J?9ZI ;B;9JEH7B J;9>DEBE=O M7I 97BB;: W,?IJ;C7 :; !;IJ?QD B;9JEH7BX J>; WB;9JEH7B '7D7=;C;DJ ,OIJ;CX  ,C7HJC7J?9 M7I 7 F?ED;;H?DJ>?I7H;7E<9ECFKJ?D=IOIJ;CI ->;?HIOIJ;CFHEL?:;:<EH JH7DIC?II?EDE<LEJ?D=:7J7EL;HJ>;?DJ;HD;JJE79ECFKJ;H?P;:9;DJH7B J78KB7J?D= 9;DJ;H  ->; LEJ?D= C79>?D;I J>;CI;BL;I >7: 7 :?=?J7B :?IFB7O <?D=;HFH?DJH;9E=D?J?ED<;7JKH;JE?:;DJ?<OJ>;LEJ;H 7D:FH?DJ;: EKJ J>; LEJ;HZI 87BBEJ  ->; LEJ;HZI J>KC8FH?DJ M7I B?DA;: JE 7 9ECFKJ;H?P;: H;9EH: E<J>7J LEJ;HZI?:;DJ?JO  ,C7HJC7J?9 9H;7J;: 7D: EF;H7J;:J>;;DJ?H;IOIJ;C 0>?IJB;8BEM;HH;FEHJSS    9EH;H;GK?H;C;DJE<J>;,C7HJC7J?9IE<JM7H;:;I?=DKBJ?C7J;BO7:EFJ;:8O EC?D?ED<EH!;EH=?7ZI;B;9J?EDIM7IJ>;IE<JM7H;ZI78?B?JOJE>?:;?JIC7D?FKB7J?ED E<LEJ;I<HEC7DO7K:?J IJ>;M>?IJB;8BEM;H;NFB7?DI  &%')("') %$($%' + )(''')%' $("" ", ))" $) (.*&%# $#'$- %) %$%'$!*$) +"  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 20 of 35  >7L;PM7ICEIJ?DI?IJ;DJJ>7J,C7HJC7J?9:;I?=DJ>;IOIJ;C?D7M7O J>7J J>; IOIJ;C 9EKB: 9>7D=; J>; LEJ; E< ;79> LEJ;H M?J>EKJ 8;?D= :;J;9J;: ";M7DJ;:J>; IE<JM7H;?JI;B<JE <KD9J?ED?D IK9>7C7DD;H J>7J ?< J>; LEJ;H M;H; JE FB79; J>;?H J>KC8 FH?DJ EH <?D=;HFH?DJ ED 7 I97DD;H J>;DJ>;J>KC8FH?DJMEKB:8;J?;:JE7 H;9EH:E<J>;LEJ;HZI D7C;7D:?:;DJ?JO7I>7L?D=LEJ;: 8KJJ>7JLEJ;HMEKB:DEJ8;JH79A;: JEJ>;9>7D=;:LEJ; ";C7:;?J9B;7HJ>7JJ>;IOIJ;CMEKB:>7L;JE8; I;JKFJEDEJB;7L;7DO;L?:;D9;E<J>;9>7D=;:LEJ;<EH7IF;9?<?9LEJ;H 7D:J>7JJ>;H;MEKB:8;DE;L?:;D9;JEI>EM7D:DEJ>?D=JE9EDJH7:?9J J>7J J>; D7C; EH J>; <?D=;HFH?DJ EH J>KC8 FH?DJ M7I =E?D= M?J> 7 9>7D=;:LEJ; ,C7HJC7J?97=H;;:JE9H;7J;IK9>7IOIJ;C7D:FHE:K9;: J>;IE<JM7H;7D:>7H:M7H;J>7J799ECFB?I>;:J>7JH;IKBJ<EH*H;I?:;DJ >7L;P S   ->; :;I?=D7D: <;7JKH;I E<J>;EC?D?ED IE<JM7H; :E DEJ F;HC?J7 I?CFB; 7K:?J JE H;L;7B ?JI C?I7BBE97J?ED  H;:?IJH?8KJ?ED  EH :;B;J?ED E< LEJ;I  ?HIJ  J>; IOIJ;CI9;DJH7B799KCKB7JEH:E;IDEJ?D9BK:;7FHEJ;9J;:H;7B J?C;7K:?JBE=J>7J C7?DJ7?DI J>; :7J; 7D: J?C; IJ7CFI E< 7BB I?=D?<?97DJ ;B;9J?ED ;L;DJI  %;O 9ECFED;DJI E< J>; IOIJ;C KJ?B?P; KDFHEJ;9J;: BE=I  II;DJ?7BBO J>?I 7BBEMI 7D KD7KJ>EH?P;:KI;HJ>;EFFEHJKD?JOJE7H8?JH7H?BO7:: CE:?<O EHH;CEL;BE=;DJH?;I  97KI?D= J>; C79>?D; JE BE= ;B;9J?ED ;L;DJI J>7J :E DEJ H;<B;9J 79JK7B LEJ?D= J78KB7J?EDIVEHCEH;IF;9?<?97BBO :EDEJH;<B;9JJ>;79JK7BLEJ;IE<EHJ>;M?BBE< J>;F;EFB;  #D:;;: KD:;HJ>;FHE<;II?ED7BIJ7D:7H:IM?J>?DJ>;?D:KIJHO?D7K:?J?D=7D: <EH;DI?97D7BOI?I M>;D7BE=?IKDFHEJ;9J;: 7D:97D8;7BJ;H;: ?J97DDEBED=;H I;HL;J>;FKHFEI;E<7D7K:?JBE= ->;H;?I?D9EDJHEL;HJ?8B;F>OI?97B;L?:;D9;J>7J J>; IJ7D:7H:I E< F>OI?97B I;9KH?JO E<J>; LEJ?D=C79>?D;I 7D:J>; IE<JM7H;M;H; Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 21 of 35  8H;79>;: 7D:C79>?D;IM;H;9EDD;9J;:JEJ>;?DJ;HD;J?DL?EB7J?EDE<FHE<;II?ED7B IJ7D:7H:I M>?9>L?EB7J;I<;:;H7B;B;9J?EDB7MEDJ>;FH;I;HL7J?EDE<;L?:;D9;   #D :;9?:?D=JE 7M7H:EC?D?ED 7CKBJ? C?BB?ED :EBB7H BED=J;HC9EDJH79J  7D: J>;D 9;HJ?<O?D= EC?D?ED IE<JM7H;  !;EH=?7 E<<?9?7BI :?IH;=7H:;: 7BB J>; 9ED9;HDI J>7J 97KI;: EC?D?ED IE<JM7H; JE 8; H;@;9J;: 8O J>; -;N7I E7H: E< ;B;9J?EDI?D  8;97KI;?JM7I:;;C;:LKBD;H78B;JEKD:;J;9J;:7D:DED 7K:?J78B; C7D?FKB7J?ED  D ?D:KIJHO ;NF;HJ  H  D:H;M FF;B  *H?D9;JED *HE<;IIEH E< ECFKJ;H ,9?;D9; 7D: B;9J?ED ,;9KH?JO NF;HJ >7I H;9;DJBO E8I;HL;:  M?J> H;<;H;D9; JE EC?D?ED /EJ?D= C79>?D;I # <?=KH;: EKJ >EM JE C7A; 7 IB?=>JBO :?<<;H;DJ9ECFKJ;HFHE=H7CJ>7J@KIJ8;<EH;J>;FEBBIM;H;9BEI;: ?JIM?J9>;IIEC; LEJ;I7HEKD:<HECED;97D:?:7J;JE7DEJ>;H #MHEJ;J>7J9ECFKJ;HFHE=H7C?DJE7 C;CEHO9>?F7D:DEMJE>79A7LEJ?D=C79>?D;OEK@KIJD;;:C?DKJ;I7BED;M?J> ?J7I9H;M:H?L;H   DEJ>;H;NF;HJ +KII;BB$7C;I+7CIB7D: $H >7I9ED9BK:;:J>7JEC?D?ED 7BED;M7IH;IFEDI?8B;<EHJ>;?D@;9J?ED EH<78H?97J?ED E< ?BB;=7BLEJ;I?D '?9>?=7D   #D:;;:  7 <EH;DI?9 H;FEHJ :7J;: ;9;C8;H      8O BB?;: ,;9KH?JO )F;H7J?EDI!HEKF7K:?J;:7D:J;IJ;:J>;?DJ;=H?JOE<J>;EC?D?ED/EJ?D=,OIJ;C F;H<EHC7D9;?DDJH?CEKDJO '?9>?=7D7D:9ED9BK:;:J>7J WJ>;EC?D?ED/EJ?D=,OIJ;C?I?DJ;DJ?ED7BBO7D:FKHFEI;<KBBO:;I?=D;: M?J> ?D>;H;DJ ;HHEHI JE 9H;7J;: IOIJ;C?9 <H7K: 7D: ?D<BK;D9; ;B;9J?ED Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 22 of 35  H;IKBJI ->;IOIJ;C?DJ;DJ?ED7BBO=;D;H7J;I7D;DEHCEKIBO>?=>DKC8;HE< 87BBEJ;HHEHI ->;;B;9JHED?987BBEJI7H;J>;DJH7DI<;HH;:<EH7:@K:?97J?ED  ->; ?DJ;DJ?ED7B ;HHEHI B;7: JE 8KBA 7:@K:?97J?ED E< 87BBEJI M?J> DE EL;HI?=>J DEJH7DIF7H;D9O 7D:DE7K:?JJH?7B ->?IB;7:IJELEJ;HEH;B;9J?ED <H7K: 7I;:EDEKHIJK:O M;9ED9BK:;J>7JJ>;EC?D?ED/EJ?D=,OIJ;C I>EKB:DEJ8;KI;:34 X ->;H;FEHJ<KHJ>;HIJ7J;:WM;9ED9BK:;J>7JJ>;;HHEHI7H;IEI?=D?<?97DJJ>7JJ>;O 97BB?DJEGK;IJ?EDJ>;?DJ;=H?JO7D:B;=?J?C79OE<J>;H;IKBJI?DJ>;DJH?CEKDJO    ;B;9J?ED JE J>; FE?DJ J>7J J>; H;IKBJI 7H; DEJ 9;HJ?<?78B;  ;97KI; J>; I7C; C79>?D;I7D:IE<JM7H;7H;KI;:?DEJ>;H9EKDJ?;I?D'?9>?=7D /%&. ./.!+0/ +*/%"&*/"$-&/4+#/%""*/&-""(" /&+*?DJ>;IJ7J;E<'?9>?=7D XCF>7I?I7::;:   ::?J?ED7BBO !7HB7D: 7LEH?JE 7D?D<EHC7J?EDJ;9>DEBE=OFHE<;II?ED7BM?J> EL;H O;7HIZ;NF;H?;D9;>7IFH;I;DJ;:7IMEHD7<<?:7L?J:E9KC;DJ?D=J>EKI7D:I E<LEJ;I8;?D= <B?FF;: <HEC*H;I?:;DJ-HKCFJEJ>;;CE9H7J?97D:?:7J;?DJ>; (EL;C8;H   ;B;9J?ED ";>7I9ED9BK:;:W?J?ICEH;B?A;BOJ>7JLEJ; IM7FF?D= C7BM7H;;N?IJ;:ED8EJ> J>;'?9>?=7D7D:!;EH=?7EKDJO;B;9J?EDC7D7=;C;DJ I;HL;HI X D: ;NFB7?D;: J>; D;9;II?JO E< <EH;DI?9 ;N7C?D7J?ED E< J>; EC?D?ED IOIJ;C ?D !;EH=?7   FH;II H;B;7I; :7J;: ,;FJ;C8;H      <HEC /EJ;H!7 H;FEHJ;:J>7JW,;9H;J7HOE<,J7J;,),-!##"*.,"-$"-&.(+ '&*$&/. ((. #+- #+-"*.&  -",+-/. +# #0(/4 +)&*&+* 1+/&*$ .4./"). ?D E<<;; 7D: 07H; 9EKDJ?;I XCF>7I?I?DEH?=?D7B   ->;I;I7C;LEJ?D=C79>?D;I7D:IE<JM7H;7H;7D:M?BB8;?CFB;C;DJ;:<EH KI;?DJ>;!;EH=?7. , ,;D7J;HKDE<<;B;9J?ED 78I;DJJ>?IEKHJZI?DJ;HL;DJ?ED  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 23 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 24 of 35  #D:;;: J>;>7?HC7DZIH;FEHJE<J>;;B;9J?EDB7MIJK:OIK89ECC?JJ;;E<J>; ,J7D:?D=,;D7J;$K:?9?7HOECC?JJ;;?IIK;:7H;FEHJ87I;:EDJ;IJ?CEDO<HEC7 >;7H?D=>;B:;9;C8;H   M>;H;?D?JM7I9ED9BK:;:J>7JJ>;W(EL;C8;H    =;D;H7B;B;9J?EDJ>;W;B;9J?EDXM7I9>7EJ?97D:7DOH;FEHJ;:H;IKBJICKIJ8; L?;M;:7IKDJHKIJMEHJ>O X #CFEHJ7DJBO  J>; FH;I?:;DJ?7B 97D:?:7J;I M;H; I;F7H7J;: 8O EDBO 7FFHEN?C7J;BO   LEJ;I  ->; DKC8;H E< LEJ;I 7<<;9J;: 8O J>; 78EL; 9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B L?EB7J?EDI ;N9;;:I J>; C7H=?D E< LEJ;I :?L?:?D= J>; FH;I?:;DJ?7B 97D:?:7J;I ->;H;?I7D?CC?D;DJ >7HCJEJ>;*B7?DJ?<<?DJ>7JI7?:9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B L?EB7J?EDIM?BBE99KH?DJ>;HKDE<<;B;9J?ED   *B7?DJ?<<I;;AI?D@KD9J?L;H;B?;<?D9BK:?D=;D@E?D?D=J>;HKDE<<;B;9J?ED<EHJ>; JME .D?J;: ,J7J;I ,;D7J; I;7JI <HEC !;EH=?7 <HEC FHE9;;:?D= M>?B; J>; KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BFHE9;:KH;I:;I9H?8;:>;H;?D7H;?DFB79;      ->;*B7?DJ?<<>;H;8O?D9EHFEH7J;I8OH;<;H;D9;J>;7BB;=7J?EDI?DF7H7=H7F>I J>HEK=>   9?J?P;DZI H?=>JJELEJ;?D7,J7J;;B;9J?ED?DLEBL?D= <;:;H7B97D:?:7J;I?I H;9E=D?P;: 7I 7 <KD:7C;DJ7B H?=>J KD:;H J>; EKHJ;;DJ> C;D:C;DJ JE J>; EDIJ?JKJ?ED  M>?9> FHE>?8?JI 7 ,J7J; <HEC :;DO?D= JE 7DO F;HIED M?J>?D ?JI @KH?I:?9J?EDJ>;GK7B*HEJ;9J?EDE<J>;B7MI  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 25 of 35   ->; GK7B *HEJ;9J?ED 9B7KI; FHE>?8?JI ,J7J;I <HEC 7H8?JH7HO 7D: :?IF7H7J; JH;7JC;DJE<LEJ;HI ->KI ;79>9?J?P;D>7IJ>;9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BH?=>JJEF7HJ?9?F7J;?D ;B;9J?EDI ?D9BK:?D=J>;HKDE<<FEHJ?EDE<7DO;B;9J?ED ED7D;GK7B87I?IM?J>EJ>;H 9?J?P;DI?D!;EH=?7 ->;,J7J;C7ODEJL7BK;ED;F;HIEDZILEJ;EL;HJ>7JE<7DEJ>;H  -H;7J?D=LEJ;HI:?<<;H;DJBOL?EB7J;IJ>;H?=>JJEGK7B*HEJ;9J?ED   ;<;D:7DJIZ FHE9;:KH;I :;I9H?8;: 78EL; H;=7H:?D= C7?B ?D 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJ LEJ;H?:;DJ?JOL;H?<?97J?ED ;7HBOEF;D?D=E<78I;DJ;;87BBEJI:;B?L;HOE<78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI ?BB;=7B:HEF8EN;I 7D:J>;KI;E<EC?D?EDLEJ?D=C79>?D;I>7L;J>;;<<;9J E< :?BKJ?D= J>; *B7?DJ?<<ZI LEJ;  ->?I >7FF;D;: ?D 9EDD;9J?ED M?J> J>;    *H;I?:;DJ?7B B;9J?ED  7D: KDB;IIJ>;EKHJ?DJ;HL;D;I?J?I 7D: M?BB E99KH?DJ>; HKDE<<  I7H;IKBJE<J>;;<;D:7DJIZKD7KJ>EH?P;:79J?EDI7D::?IF7H7J;JH;7JC;DJ E< *B7?DJ?<<ZI LEJ; J>?IEKHJ I>EKB: ;DJ;H 7D EH:;H :;9B7H7J?ED KD:;H  . ,   RR 77D: 7D: EH?D@KD9J?EDJ>7JFHE>?8?JI;<;D:7DJI<HECKJ?B?P?D=?D J>; HKDE<< ;B;9J?ED J>; KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B FHE9;:KH;I I;J <EHJ> 78EL;  ;<;D:7DJI 79J?EDIM?BB:?C?D?I>7D::?BKJ;J>;M;?=>JE<J>;B7M<KBLEJ;I97IJ;:?DJ>;HKDE<< ;B;9J?ED ?D9BK:?D=*B7?DJ?<<  *B7?DJ?<<>7IDE7:;GK7J;H;C;:O7JB7M7D:M?BBIK<<;HI;H?EKI7D:?HH;F7H78B; >7HCKDB;IIJ>;H;B?;<H;GK;IJ;:>;H;?D?I=H7DJ;:  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 26 of 35  ->;*B7?DJ?<<>7I>7:JE;D=7=;J>;KD:;HI?=D;:B7M<?HCJEH;FH;I;DJ>?C?D J>?I79J?ED7D:?IE8B?=7J;:JEF7OI7C;7H;7IED78B;<;;  0"+ )+  <EH J>; <EH;=E?D= H;7IEDI  J>; *B7?DJ?<< :;C7D:I 7D EH:;H  FH;B?C?D7HO7D:F;HC7D;DJ?D@KD9J?ED 7D::;9B7H7JEHO@K:=C;DJ?DJ>;?H<7LEH7D: 7=7?DIJ;<;D:7DJI:;9B7H?D=J>7JJ>7J  ,;D7JEH?7BHKDE<<;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;I E< J>; ;<;D:7DJI L?EB7J; *B7?DJ?<<ZI 9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B H?=>J JE ;GK7B FHEJ;9J?ED ;D@E?D?D=J>;KI;E< I7?:KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BFHE9;:KH;I?DJ>; HKDE<<:;9B7H?D=J>; HKDE<<;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;I:;I9H?8;:>;H;?D:;<;9J?L;7D:H;GK?H?D=;<;D:7DJIJE 9KH;J>;?HL?EB7J?ED7M7H:?D=DEC?D7B:7C7=;I?<7FFB?978B;=H7DJ?D=IK9>EJ>;H H;B?;<7IJ>;EKHJ:;;CI@KIJ7D:FHEF;H7D:7M7H:?D=*B7?DJ?<<ZI7JJEHD;OZI<;;I 7D:9EIJI      ->;*B7?DJ?<<>;H;8O?D9EHFEH7J;I8OH;<;H;D9;J>;7BB;=7J?EDI?DF7H7=H7F>I J>HEK=>  ->;FHE9;:KH;IKJ?B?P;:?DJ>;HKDE<<;B;9J?EDL?EB7J;J>;*B7?DJ?<<ZIH?=>JJE :K;FHE9;II ->;78HE=7J?EDE<J>;78I;DJ;;87BBEJI?=D7JKH;L;H?<?97J?EDIJ7JKJ; E< J>; H;GK?H;C;DJ J>7J 78I;DJ;; 87BBEJI DEJ 8; EF;D;: 8;<EH; ;B;9J?ED :7O  J>; ?DIJ7BB7J?ED E< KD7KJ>EH?P;: 87BBEJ :HEF 8EN;I  7D: J>; KI; E< J>; 9ECFHEC?I;: EC?D?ED LEJ?D= C79>?D;I  M>;D 9EDI?:;H;: I?D=KB7HBO 7D: 9;HJ7?DBO M>;D 9EDI?:;H;:9EBB;9J?L;BO  H;D:;HJ>;;B;9J?ED FHE9;:KH; <EHJ>;HKDE<< IE :;<;9J?L; Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 27 of 35   7D: KDB7M<KB 7I JE 9EDIJ?JKJ; 7 L?EB7J?ED E< FHE9;:KH7B :K; FHE9;II KD:;H J>; EKHJ;;DJ>C;D:C;DJJEJ>;EDIJ?JKJ?ED   ->;.D?J;:,J7J;I,KFH;C;EKHJ7D:EJ>;H<;:;H7B9EKHJI>7L;H;F;7J;:BO H;9E=D?P;:J>7JM>;D;B;9J?EDFH79J?9;IH;79>J>;FE?DJE<F7J;DJ7D:<KD:7C;DJ7B KD<7?HD;II  J>; ?DJ;=H?JO E< J>; ;B;9J?ED ?JI;B< L?EB7J;I *B7?DJ?<<ZI IK8IJ7DJ?L; :K; FHE9;IIH?=>JI   ->;;<;D:7DJIKD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BHKB;C7A?D=:?I9KII;:78EL;H;FH;I;DJI7D ?DJ;DJ?ED7B <7?BKH;JE <EBBEM ;B;9J?EDB7M 7I ;D79J;: 8OJ>; !;EH=?7&;=?IB7JKH;  ->;I;KD7KJ>EH?P;:79JIL?EB7J;*B7?DJ?<<ZIFHE9;:KH7B:K;FHE9;IIH?=>JI   *B7?DJ?<<>7IDE7:;GK7J;H;C;:O7JB7M7D:M?BBIK<<;HI;H?EKI7D:?HH;F7H78B; >7HCKDB;IIJ>;H;B?;<H;GK;IJ;:>;H;?D?I=H7DJ;:   ->;*B7?DJ?<<>7I>7:JE;D=7=;J>;KD:;HI?=D;:B7M<?HCJEH;FH;I;DJJ>;C ?DJ>?I79J?ED7D:7H;E8B?=7J;:JEF7OI7C;7H;7IED78B;<;;  0"+ )+  <EH J>; <EH;=E?D= H;7IEDI  J>; *B7?DJ?<< :;C7D:I 7D EH:;H  FH;B?C?D7HO7D:F;HC7D;DJ?D@KD9J?ED 7D::;9B7H7JEHO@K:=C;DJ?DJ>;?H<7LEH7D: 7=7?DIJ;<;D:7DJI:;9B7H?D=J>7JJ>7J  ,;D7JEH?7BHKDE<<;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;I E<J>;;<;D:7DJIL?EB7J;*B7?DJ?<<ZI9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BH?=>JJE:K;FHE9;II;D@E?D?D= J>; KI; E< I7?: KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B FHE9;:KH;I ?D J>; HKDE<< :;9B7H?D= J>; HKDE<< ;B;9J?ED FHE9;:KH;I :;I9H?8;: >;H;?D :;<;9J?L; 7D: H;GK?H?D= ;<;D:7DJIJE 9KH; J>;?HL?EB7J?ED7M7H:?D=DEC?D7B:7C7=;I?<7FFB?978B;=H7DJ?D=IK9>EJ>;HH;B?;< Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 28 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 29 of 35  .I?D=KDH;B?78B;7D:9ECFH?I;:EC?D?EDLEJ?D=C79>?D;I?I9EDJH7HOJEJ>; HEEJ F>?BEIEF>O E< FHEL?:?D= <EH 7D 799EKDJ78B; =EL;HDC;DJ U J>; <KD:7C;DJ7B <;7JKH;E<7H;FK8B?97D<EHCE<=EL;HDC;DJ ->?IJ>?IEKHJI>EKB:DEJ9EKDJ;D7D9; 7DO KD<7?HD;II ?D J>; ;B;9J?ED HKB;I  F7HJ?9KB7HBO ?< J>7J KD<7?HD;II ?I DEJ ?D 799EH:7D9;M?J>J>;M?BBE<J>;,J7J;&;=?IB7JKH; ->?IEKHJI>EKB:;D<EH9;J>; !K7H7DJ;;B7KI;7D:;D@E?DJ>;KI;E<J>;?HH7J?ED7B7D:KDFH;:?9J78B;EC?D?ED C79>?D;I?DJ>;HKDE<< ->;'?9>?=7DK:?J8O7BB?;:,;9KH?JO)F;H7J?EDI!HEKF :7J;: ;9;C8;H      ;IJ78B?I>;I J>; KDH;B?78B; D7JKH; E< J>; EC?D?ED C79>?D;I  ->; ;<;D:7DJIZ ?DJ;H<;H;D9; M?J> J>; H?=>J JE LEJ; 97BBI <EH DE B;II J>7D 79J?L;@K:?9?7BFHEJ;9J?ED 0>;D 7I>;H; 7I7H;IKBJE<<H7K:7D:KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B 79J?EDI IJ7J;;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;IH;IKBJ?DJ>;;B;9J?EDE<?BB;=?J?C7J;E<<?9;>EB:;HI  DEJ EDBO 7H; LEJ;H ?DJ;H;IJI :?BKJ;:  8KJ J>; H;FK8B?97D <EHC E< =EL;HDC;DJ ?I KD:;HC?D;:   ->?IEKHJ?I9ECF;BB;:KD:;HJ>;9?H9KCIJ7D9;IE<J>?I97I;JE?DLEA;J>; =K7H7DJ;;9B7KI;7D:79J?L;BOFHEJ;9JJ>;*B7?DJ?<<ZI<KD:7C;DJ7BH?=>JJELEJ;   *B7?DJ?<<I >7L; DE 7:;GK7J; H;C;:O 7J B7M 7D: M?BB IK<<;H I;H?EKI 7D: ?HH;F7H78B;>7HCKDB;IIJ>;H;B?;<H;GK;IJ;:>;H;?D?I=H7DJ;:   ->;*B7?DJ?<<>7I>7:JE;D=7=;J>;KD:;HI?=D;:B7M<?HCJEH;FH;I;DJJ>;C ?DJ>?I79J?ED7D:7H;E8B?=7J;:JEF7OI7C;7H;7IED78B;<;;  Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 30 of 35  0"+ )+  <EH J>; <EH;=E?D= H;7IEDI  J>; *B7?DJ?<< :;C7D:I 7D EH:;H  FH;B?C?D7HO7D:F;HC7D;DJ?D@KD9J?ED 7D::;9B7H7JEHO@K:=C;DJ?DJ>;?H<7LEH7D: 7=7?DIJ;<;D:7DJI:;9B7H?D=J>7JJ>7J  ,;D7JEH?7BHKDE<<;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;I E< J>; ;<;D:7DJI L?EB7J; J>; =K7H7DJ;; 9B7KI; ;D@E?D?D= J>; KI; E< I7?: KD9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7BFHE9;:KH;I?DJ>;HKDE<<:;9B7H?D=J>;HKDE<<;B;9J?EDFHE9;:KH;I :;I9H?8;: >;H;?D :;<;9J?L; 7D: H;GK?H?D= ;<;D:7DJI JE 9KH; J>;?H L?EB7J?ED 7M7H:?D= DEC?D7B :7C7=;I?< 7FFB?978B; =H7DJ?D= IK9> EJ>;H H;B?;< 7IJ>;EKHJ :;;CI@KIJ7D:FHEF;H7D:7M7H:?D=*B7?DJ?<<ZI7JJEHD;OZI<;;I7D:9EIJI      *KHIK7DJJE. ,  R #:;9B7H;7D:L;H?<OKD:;HFB;DJOE<F;H@KHOJ>7J J>; <79JI 9EDJ7?D;: ?D J>; <EH;=E?D= /;H?<?;: ECFB7?DJ <EH ;9B7H7JEHO 7D: #D@KD9J?L;+;B?;<7H;JHK;7D:9EHH;9J  7J;:;9;C8;H     6666666666666666666666666    & &?D0EE: $H IG  !7H(E  & &#(0)) *   * ) )1 JB7DJ7 !       BMEE:B?DMEE:B7M 9EC 666666666 Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 31 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 32 of 35  9C9=EM7DB7M =7 =EL    J;B ..),(2- ),..  ((.- :7C' ,F7HAI "7BI;O! %D7FF $H  $EO9;!?IJ&;M?I ,KI7D* EFF;:=; :7C' ,F7HAI %+/)&#((")+,- && )D;JB7DJ?9;DJ;H  0 *;79>JH;;,JH;;J (0 ,J;   JB7DJ7 !   -;B;F>ED;    79I?C?B;   >AD7FFA>B7M<?HC 9EC @B;M?IA>B7M<?HC 9EC 9EFF;:=;A>B7M<?HC 9EC IF7HAIA>B7M<?HC 9EC '7H9 B?7I C7D:7+ 7BB7?I B;N?' /;B;P C?BO+ H7?B;O *+%#(,)#&&*  ->?HJ;;DJ>,JH;;J(0 ,K?J;  07I>?D=JED   -;B;F>ED;    C;B?7IF;HA?DI9E?; 9EC 797BB7?IF;HA?DI9E?; 9EC 7L;B;PF;HA?DI9E?; 9EC ;8H7?B;OF;HA?DI9E?; 9EC %;L?D$ "7C?BJED C7D:7$ ;7D; *+%#(,)#&&*  ->?H:L;DK; ,K?J;  ,;7JJB; 07I>?D=JED  -;B;F>ED;    A>7C?BJEDF;HA?DI9E?; 9EC Case 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 33 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 34 of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ase 1:20-cv-05155-TCB Document 1 Filed 12/18/20 Page 35 of 35

Related Documents (6)

DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown

EFTA Document EFTA01429752

0p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown

EFTA Document EFTA01483680

0p
DOJ Data Set 11OtherUnknown

EFTA02311972

1p
DOJ Data Set 10OtherUnknown

EFTA02126504

2p
DOJ Data Set 10CorrespondenceUnknown

EFTA Document EFTA01654956

0p
DOJ Data Set 11OtherUnknown

EFTA02462465

1p

Forum Discussions

This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.

DonateMore ways to support →
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.