P007796-031024-001-463

P007796-031024-000001 P007796-031024-000002 P007796-031024-000003 P007796-031024-000004 P007796-031024-000005 Serial Number Date Obs Time Citation Operator Last Name Operator Agency Code BrAC 1 IR BrAC 1 EC ES IR ES EC BrAC 2 IR BrAC2 EC Sts ARKC-0062 9/24/2018 20:07:00 1826701771 FETTER, ARTHUR R 0270400 0.268 0.274 0.085 0.089 0.273 0.273 0 ARKC-0062 10/16/2018 00:46:00 1828900025 FETTER, ARTHUR R 0270400 0.117 0.12 0.086 0.089 0.118 0.119 0 ARKC-0060 10/18/2018 17:38:00 1829101593 NESTOR, SHAUN 0270100 0.279 0.293 0.083 0.089 0 0 46 ARKC-0060 10/21/2018 08:23:00 1829400340 RICE, D D 0270100 0.138 0.145 0.084 0.089 0.144 0.151 0 ARKC-0060 10/25/2018 20:43:00 8Z0966655 JOHNSTON, TOBIE J 0271400 0.279 0.294 0.084 0.089 0.288 0.301 0 ARKC-0062 10/27/2018 02:00:00 123 FRAZIER, JACK P WA027040 0.001 0 0.087 0.089 0.001 0 0 ARKC-0060 11/2/2018 23:16:00 1830602289 DONOVAN, PATRICK A 0270900 0.12 0.127 0.084 0.089 0.109 0.116 0 ARKC-0062 11/3/2018 19:58:00 18-029318 SEABURG, RAYMOND E WSP0217 0.126 0.131 0.086 0.089 0.125 0.128 0 ARKC-0060 11/4/2018 01:15:00 1830800013 WICKS, JORDAN P 0270100 0.113 0.12 0.084 0.089 0.109 0.115 0 ARKC-0060 11/4/2018 21:49:00 1830801664 SHELTON-JOHNSON, KALEB 0270100 0.251 0.265 0.083 0.089 0.249 0.261 0 ARKC-0060 11/11/2018 03:12:00 1831500184 VANCE, NATE J 0271400 0.199 0.209 0.084 0.089 0.197 0.206 0 ARKC-0062 11/16/2018 08:58:00 18-030551 DERR, ANDREW J WSP0104 0.267 0.27 0.084 0.089 0.256 0.259 0 ARKC-0060 11/18/2018 21:26:00 1832201529 BOND, ANDREW D 0270100 0.103 0.11 0.084 0.089 0.11 0.115 0 ARKC-0067 5/4/2019 12:25:00 1912400004 DEFFIT, LUIS L 0271300 0.148 0.156 0.084 0.089 0.149 0.155 0 ARKC-0069 6/12/2020 03:03:00 2016400140 BAILEY, ALEXANDER ELLIOTT E 0270000 0.187 0.2 0.082 0.089 0.183 0.196 0 ARKC-0067 6/18/2020 23:00:00 2017001983 DEFFIT, LUIS L 0271300 0.213 0.227 0.082 0.089 0.224 0.237 0 ARKC-0069 6/23/2020 01:08:00 2017402204 PARHAM, PATRICK A 0270000 0.051 0.055 0.082 0.089 0.053 0.057 0 ARKC-0069 6/28/2020 01:06:00 20-010287 SIX, BRANDON K WSP0113 0.078 0.084 0.083 0.089 0.082 0.087 0 ARKC-0069 6/30/2020 19:32:00 20-010447 SANBORN, JOSHUA A WSP0103 0.048 0.052 0.083 0.089 0.048 0.052 0 ARKC-0069 7/4/2020 02:46:00 20-010657 DATTILO, JOHN D WSP0103 0.098 0.107 0.082 0.089 0.106 0.114 0 ARKC-0067 7/16/2020 21:14:00 2019802074 DEFFIT, LUIS L 0271300 0.055 0.06 0.083 0.089 0.055 0.059 0 ARLC-0009 6/18/2021 13:57:00 21-001086 JENKINS, DAVID W WSP0104 0.137 0.144 0.083 0.089 0.135 0.144 0 ARKD-0018 7/16/2021 00:36:00 21-012801 MAGERSTAEDT, JOSHUA H WSP0808 0.217 0.23 0.083 0.089 0.216 0.224 0 ARKD-0018 8/1/2021 15:48:00 9060067 RICE, STEVEN D 0000004 0.028 0.03 0.085 0.089 0.026 0.027 0 ARKC-0072 11/7/2021 01:08:00 2131100037 URCKFITZ, SEAN A 0271100 0.169 0.175 0.083 0.089 0.162 0.168 0 ARKC-0066 11/16/2021 20:31:00 21-019558 BIDOT, P WSP0113 0.24 0.249 0.083 0.089 0.241 0.25 0 ARKC-0072 11/25/2021 00:16:00 2132802245 PALMA, PJ S 0271100 0.187 0.194 0.083 0.089 0.192 0.199 0 ARKC-0072 12/12/2021 04:38:00 2134600275 URCKFITZ, SEAN A 0271100 0.143 0.148 0.083 0.089 0.154 0.16 0 ARKC-0072 1/17/2022 01:45:00 2201700077 FELEPPA, GREGORY 0271100 0.162 0.168 0.083 0.089 0.155 0.161 0 P007796-031024-000006 The below is in reference to the March 10, 2022, WSP Breath Test Program letter re: Potential Impeachment Disclosure Concerning Breath Test Documents. Each test lists identified, and listed on page two of the original document, provides an operator agency code. The effected agencies are identified below based on ORI. All cases appear to be within the county of Pierce with two exceptions (Mason County and one unknown). WA0270400 BUCKLEY PD WA0270100 PUYALLUP PD WA0271400 BONNEY LAKE PD WA0270900 MILTON PD WA0271300 ORTING PD WA0270000 PIERCE CO SO TACOMA WA0271100 STEILACOOM PD WSP0217 11/3/2018 18-029318* Pierce County *incorrect case # in database (18-029384) WSP0104 11/16/2018 18-030551 Pierce County WSP0113 06/28/2020 20-010287 Pierce County WSP0103 06/30/2020 20-010477 Pierce County WSP0103 07/04/2020 20-010657 Pierce County WSP0104 06/18/2021 21-011086 Pierce County WSP0808 07/16/2021 21-012801 Mason County WSP0113 11/16/2021 21-019558 Pierce County 0000004 Unknown Agency – Operator listed under National Park Service – Breath Test Instrument located at Shelton PD **Cases with a WSP ORI were reviewed in the agency records management system P007796-031024-000007 July 11, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning the Washington State Patrol (WSP) State Toxicologist Office, and State Toxicologist, Dr. Fiona J. Couper Dear Mr. Brown: On June 13, 2022, the Kitsap County District Court issued an order to suppress Drager generated breath test results. The order stated the State Toxicologist Office provided inaccurate, incomplete, and/or false or misleading information to WAPA concerning the failure of the self-certifying Drager to comply with WAC 448- 16-060. The order also stated State Toxicologist, Dr. Fiona Couper, testified by declaration in a false or misleading manner regarding the compliance of the self-certifying Drager machine with WAC 448-16-060. The WSP is forwarding the order as possible potential impeachment disclosure information pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1983) for your review and distribution as you deem appropriate. Additional information will be provided as it becomes available. If you need additional information, please contact Acting Captain Pete Stock at 360-239-4904. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh Attachments (2) P007796-031024-000008 Page 1 of 1 COMPANY STATEMENT July 29, 2021 BD Statement on False Recall Notice for BD Vacutainer® Fluoride Tubes for Blood Alcohol Determinations Ensuring the safety and quality of our products is our top priority at BD. As part of that commitment, BD has a robust quality system in place, including a comprehensive post-market surveillance process. BD was recently notified by a customer that a recall announcement, purporting to be from BD, has been circulated. The falsified notice is dated June 4, 2021 and appears to be recalling one lot of BD Vacutainer® Fluoride Tubes, but was not issued by BD. To be clear, there are no current recall notices for BD Vacutainer® Fluoride Tubes from BD. BD did have a recall in 2019 for BD Vacutainer® Fluoride Tubes, but this recall was for a different, now expired, lot number and the recall has since been terminated by the FDA. The falsified recall notice includes many of the same elements from the 2019 recall notice but lists a different lot number and expiration date. We are investigating the situation and will take appropriate actions, including notifying regulatory bodies and law enforcement as needed. For any further questions, please contact BD’s customer response team at productcomplaints@bd.com or 1-844-8-BD-LIFE (844-823-5433). P007796-031024-000009 j 1 j ' State of-Washington DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE Malling Address: 600 Capitol Way N • Olympia, WA 98501-1091 • (360) 902-2200, TDD (360) 902-220! Main Office Location: Natural Resources Building• 1111 Washington Street SE• Olympia, WA , Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary April 25, 2016 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia, WA 98501 . Subject: Potential Disclosur~(s) concerning Government Witness - Officer Gaston, Badge Number: 141 . . Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife's (WDFW) Law Enforcement Program is providing notification that an administrative investigation has been completed and found the above named employee: Provided false and/or misleading testimony as a witness during an administrative investigation. If you need additional information, please contact me, at 360-701-6261 Sincerely, Captain Dan Brinson Office Professional Standards Deputy Chief Mike Cenci Captain Alan Myers, Region 4 Sergeant Russ Mullins, Detachment 13 Officer Zach Gaston, Detachment 13 Personnel File P007796-031024-000010 "f I ~tate of Washington DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE Malling Address: 600 Capitol Way N • Olympia, WA 98501-1091 • (360) 902-2200-, TDD (360) 902-2207 Main Office ~ocatlon: Natural Resources Building • 1111 Washington Street SE • Olympia, WA Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary _ April 25, 2016 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 ·10th Ave SE . Olympia, WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosure(s) concerning Government Witness ..,, Officer Jones, Badge Number: 151 Dear Mr. McBride: - The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife's (WDFW) Law Enforcement Program is providing notification that an administrative investigation has been completed and found the above named employee: Intentionally removed a gun safe containing firearms (property of another) from a State-owned facility to his personal residence. If you need additional information, please contact me, at 360-701 -:-6261 . Captain Dan on Office of Pro essional Standards WDFWPolice Cc: Deputy Chief Mike Cenci Captain Alan Myers, Region 4 Sergeant Jennifer Maurstad, Detachment 11 Officer David Jones, Detachment 11 Personnel File P007796-031024-000011 • Washington State Liquor and Cannabis Board ?-------,---------------------------------- October 18, 2019 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential disclosures concerning government witness - Sergeant Mark Baker Dear Mr. Brown: On August 13, 2019, the Washington Liquor and Cannabis Board (LCB) received Information and commenced an investigation on the above named employee in which the following misconduct was alleged: • Sgt. Mark Baker fraudulently entered field contacts into the Enforcement Electronic Notebook (EN) that he did not perform on the date and time he claimed. • When questioned by his supervisor about the fraudulent field contacts, Sgt. Baker continued his deception by answering questions and offering additional 'information regarding them. • Sgt. Baker engaged in time theft on July 31, 2019 when he claimed three hours of work time for time spent at home not performing work duties, including fraudulently entering field caatacts into the EN .. I am writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been completed and due to the findings in the investigation, Sergeant Baker's employment was terminated on September 13, 2019. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 664-1617. sëLoQ¾ Ronald Rupke, Deputy Chief WSLCB Enforcement cc: ChiefJustin Nordhorn, WSLCB Deputy Chief Steve Johnson, WSLCB Sam Young, WSLCB PO Box 43075, 3000 Pacific Ave. SE, Olympia WA 98504-3075, (360) 664-1600 lcb.wa.gov P007796-031024-000012 P007796-031024-000013 P007796-031024-000014 Randall K. Gaylord SAN WAN COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY 350 Court Street• P.O. Box 760 • Friday Harbor, WA 98250 (360) 378-4101 (tel)• (360) 378-3180 (fax) Victim Services Christine Miller Danielle Kindelberger To Whom It May Concern: October 24, 2016 Deputies Jonathan W. Cain Amy S. Vira Teresa Zueger Gwendolyn L. Halliday Carolyn M. Jewett RE: Potential Impeachment Disclosure Regarding Stephen Parker, San Juan County Sheriff Detective This office has received credible information regarding matter(s) of potential impeachment involving Detective Stephen Parker of the San Juan County Sheriff's Office. The alleged conduct pertains to events which occurred after November. 1, 2015 regarding allegations of gross neglect of duty, lack of candor and truthfulness, and perhaps other matters. A review of the conduct is underway by the Skagit County Sheriff's Office. Sheriff Ron Krebs has placed Detective Parker on paid administrative leave during the pendency of this investigation. No findings or conclusions regarding these matters have been made and additional details are not available at this time. This disclosure is effective as of this date and any recipient of this letter should contact the undersigned to determine if additional information is available. i:.i://l//parkerpid201242016.docx Sincerely, . 1 1 / ~lcuv {V AJ M.../ Randall K. Gaylord ,-6 Prosecuting Attorney P007796-031024-000015 P007796-031024-000016 February 16, 2021 Mr. Randall Gaylord San Juan County Sheriff's Office Ron Krebs, Slicriff Zac Reimer, llndcrslicriff Kim Ott, Chief Civil Deputy Post Office Box 669 • Friday Harbor, Washington 98250 • (360) 378-4151 • Fax (360) 378-7125 RECEIVED FEB 1 7 2021 SAN JUAN COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY Re: Potential Disclosures regarding States witness - Deputy Mark Wong (Former Seattle Police Officer #5885) Dear Mr. Gaylord, On December 191 h, 2020 the San Juan County Sheriffs Office began conducting an administrative, as well as criminal investigation, for the following allegation(s): "Deputy Mark Wong was involved in a motor vehicle accident where alcohol may have been a contributing factor. " Upon conclusion of the investigation(s), an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please feel free to contact Sheriff Ron Krebs at 360-370-7620 or UndersheriffReimer at 360-370-7623. Respectfully, <::¥- Ron Krebs Sheriff cc: Teresa Barnett P007796-031024-000017 Pi†F?” ii’! 1 3 .. . . em“ Wl-lATCOM COUNTY PROSECUTING A1 ’1 0mm.’ SAN JUAN COUNTY’; ____ D’AVID s. McEACHRAN Whatcom County Courthouse CHIEF CIVIL DEPUTY Eric-J. Rithey 311 Grand Avenue, Suite 201 Bellingham, Washington 982235-4079 ASST. CHIEF CRIMINAL DEPUIW’ (360) 676-6784 lMain Cilia-â€FA X’ (360)738-2532 Warren J. Page Appellate FAX 738-2517 CRIMINAL DEPU-TlES Dnv’ld A. G’rnhn’m Jnrnu"f._ll1_zl_bg:rt Jeffrey 1).;52wycr Shannon-Connor Daniel LIGibson ASST. CHIEF CIVIL DEPUTY Angela A. Curves ICIVIL DEPUTIES Karen F’rnk’ea Row-55.1 Buckingham. Elimblgllr L Gallery norm B’r’n’ck’c CIVIL SUPPORT Nathan E.Decn ENFORCEMENT DEPUTY Jonathan Richardson Dionne M. C’lascn Christopher â€D. Quinn Brandon Wisldron APPELLATE DEPUTIES Melissa-Slope â€Kimberly Thulin Kellen â€Knnisltra Hilary A. Thomas Evan P.Joucs _ ,H . . ., Caitlin R. McG ram: Kn thy Walker July 22, 201-4 To: Sheriff Bill Elfo Frorn: David S. McEael-iranyProsecuting Attorney RE: Potential Impeachment Disclosure.Determination re Whntcom County Sheriff’s Deputy Zach Reimer I have ccompletedm-y review of-the Potential impeachment Disclosure (PID) matter†relatinglto Deputy Zach Reimer. This memo sets forth the .infonnaiion ihai’l haverevi’ewed, the standard applied, and my conclusions. information Reviewed: I reviewed the following reports that were-submitted by your department: l. Entire Investigative File OPS 2009-014 including memorande from Chief Criminal Deputy Doug Chadwick, Chief inspector Cooley and Undersheriff JeffParks and statements taken by Chief inspector Geoley. ~ Standardh “’ men A â€constitutional Due Process ~requirement for disclosure is set out in Bred_´¢_e,_´¥l´§fiex; "lend? 373 U..S. 83 (1983). â€This requirement has been explained and modied by several subsequent ceSesj’lhe Due Process requirement applies to all informal-i011 in†the hands of government agencies. Prosecutors have “a dut-y to l _j 419~(J,:19´§-´§)._â€unpeiiehmem evidence; is _ selassure-requirements. viiBlggyg; 41 6 F.3tli3i810=~(9!h Cir. D _ ’ ’llp"-´§Ii1f..:2l;3´§z=lailureâ€to comply withithese requirements can-lead to i reversal of a conviction. ’ ’ l. _ 1 > " - I ’ P007796-031024-000018 Independent of the constitutional due process requirement, there are court and practice rules that apply. Prosecutors are required by Criminal Rule 4.7(a)(3) t0 “disclose any material or information within the prosecuting attorney’s know-ledge which tends to negate dcfendant’s guilt as to the offense charged.” This obligation is “limited to material and information within the knowledge, possession or control of members ofthe prosecuting attorney’s staff.” Criminal Rule 4.7(a)(4). Once .informatiOn i’s prOvided to the Prosecutor’s Office by law enforcement agencies, that material becomes subject to disclosure under a, Criminal Rule 4.7(a)(3). . A closely concurrent duty to disclose such information is also placed upon prosecutors by Rule of , i Professional Conduct 3.8(d). The requirements ofDue Process and those of Criminal Rule 4.7 and Rule ofProfessional Conduct 3.8 apply to evidence that could be used to impeach witnesses. The scope ofthe requirements addressing potential impeachment evidence is different. Due Process will focus upon evidence that raises issues of credibility or competency, â€and imposes an ailirmjative duty on prosecuting attorneys to learn of impeachment evidence for recurring witnesses for the prosecution/investigation team i.c. investigators and I forensic scientists. The co’tnt and practice rules requirements are limited to information possessed by the prosecuting attorney, but categorically include any prior convictions of a recurring witness for the prosecution/investigation team. A law enforcement ofcer’s or forensic expert’s privacy interest does not prevent disclosure of disciplinary records, as such records are considered to be of legitimate concernto the public. See, e.g. Dawson v. Daly, 120 Wn.2d 782, 795-96, 845 P.2d 995 (199.3);jccfwlcs Panacea,ataienamig 44 Wn. App. 882, 7’24 P.2d 379 (1986),.15 satanievaamitn- 109 anjd 71-2; 748 P.2d 5-97 (â€1988). Thus, Prosecuting Attorney’s disclosure requirements cumulatively include both an affirmative duty to seek out certain impeachment information. and a duty to disclose information that may impact the witnesses credibility. Decision Ibclieve that a reasonable person could conclude that Deputy Reimer, in responding to the request foran information report and civilian waiver to the Whatcom County Sheriffs Office, directed by his supervisor, submitted a waiver form from a civilian ride-along participant, that he knew bore a signature that wasnot. authentic. -†This decision was based on reviewing the reports identied above, including statements that were taken in this inquiry. My staff and I have spent a great deal of’time reviewing this matter and in reaching this decision. Notwithstanding that, we are very willing to work with Deputy Reimer in present and future eases. iWe do not view him as a deceptive. officer but have decided that the notice hasto be given under these facts and under the case law and authorities dealing with discovery matters. Summary The forgoing, ifheard by a reasonable person (such’as a judge orjuror), could lead that person to conclude that Deputy Reimer submitted areport that he knew bore a signature that was not authentic on a waiver form for a civilian ride-along. A notice that summarizes this memorandum should be generated whenever Deputy Reimer’s name appears on a witness list. Sincerely yours, -. , ,. , Prosecuting Attorney P007796-031024-000019 ., Christine Gray Senior Disciplinary Counsel September 14, 2011 Aaron Doyle 601 S Pioneer Way Ste F384 Moses Lake, WA 98837 WSBA OFFICE OF DISCIPLIN,-\RY COUNSEL RECEIVED SEP 1-9 2011 direct line: 206-733-5908 fax: 206-727-8325 Re: Grievance of Aaron Doyle against lawyer D. Angus Lee WSBA File No. 10-01105 Dear Mr. Doyle: This letter is to advise you that we have completed our investigation of your grievance against lawyer D. Angus Lee and to advise you of our decision. The purpose of our review has been to determine whether sufficient evidence exists on which to base a disciplinary proceeding. Under the Rules for Enforcement of Lawyer Conduct (ELC), a lawyer may be disciplined only on a showing by a clear preponderance of the evidence that the lawyer violated the Rules of Professional Conduct (RPC). This standard of proof is more stringent than the standard applied in civil cases. Based on the information we have received, insufficient evidence exists to prove unethical conduct by Mr. Lee by a clear preponderance of the evidence in this matter. Therefore, we are dismissing the grievance. Our decision to dismiss the grievance is based on a review of your original grievance received on June 22, 2010; Mr. Lee's response dated July 27, 2010, submitted tlu·ough his lawyer, Leland G. Ripley; Mr. Ripley's August 2, 2010 submission; your August 2, 2010 submission; Mr. Ripley's August 12, 2010 submission; Mr. Ripley's September 3, 2010 submission; Mr. Ripley's September 29, 2010 submission; our November 29, 20 10 request for additional information and docwnents; Mr. Ripley's December 14, 2010 letter; our December 16, 2010 letter; Mr. Ripley's February 3, 2011 Jetter; four boxes of documents produced in February 2010 in response to ODC's November 29, 2010 request; Mr. Ripley's February 28, 2011 letter; and your March 11 , 2011 letter. We interviewed la'-"ryer Garth Dano and his assistant, Amy Brittingham. Jn addition, in August 2011, we deposed Mr. Lee, Dalton L. Pence and Douglas Mitchell. Your grievance relates to documents and a thumb drive that you have alleged were stolen from you in late 2008 or early 2009 by your fonner girlfriend, Hayley Taylor. The documents and information contained on the tlnunb drive related to your departure from a law enforcement job in Sie1Ta County, California. For ease of reference, tl1ese documents and the information contained on the thumb drive will be referred to herein as the "California material." You have Washington State Bar Association • 1325 4•h Avenue, Suite 600 / Sca1tlc, WA 98101-2539 • 206-727-8200 / fax: 206-727-8325 P007796-031024-000020 .• ·, Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Pa e2 alleged that the California material is subject to a sealing order issued by a California court, and has been since before the time it was stolen from you. 1 In 2009, you were in litigation against Ms. Taylor and her parents. During the course of that litigation, Ms. Taylor's lawyer, Brian Chase, filed a letter that was a part of the California material, attempting to discredit you. Mr. Chase had obtained that document, and a thumb drive containing additional California material, from Ms. Taylor. In early May 2009, at a deposition of you being taken by Mr. Chase, he showed you additional documents that were part of the_ California material obtained from the thumb drive. You reported the stolen California material to the police, and alleged that the thumb drive had been stolen from you. The police took possession, from Mr. Chase, of the original thumb drive. Mr. Lee is the elected prosecutor in Grant County. In 2009, Mr. Lee's office received police reports regarding possible criminal violations related to the thumb drive and the California materials. While Mr. Lee's office had received copies of the California materials in 2009 in connection with its consideration of possible charges against Ms. Taylor and Mr. Chase, Mr. Lee asserts that he did not review the California materials prior to late March or early April 2010 (discussed below). On June 26, 2009, Mr. Lee's office filed criminal charges against Ms. Taylor related to theft of the California materials from you. However, on September 21, 2009, Mr. Lee referred the matter involving Ms. Taylor's alleged theft of the California materials to the Adams County Prosecuting Attorney's office for resolution, citing a "potential conflict" in his referral letter. Mr. Lee has indicated that he made the referral for the sake of appearances, since he had earlier referred out a separate criminal matter2 also involving you and Ms. Taylor, and not because of an actual conflict of interest. The Adams County Prosecuting Attorney's Office determined not to proceed with criminal charges against Ms. Taylor, and in November 2009 the case against her was dismissed. On March 2, 2010, Mr. Lee referred the matter involving Brian Chase's possession of the California materials to the Adams County Prosecuting Attorney's office for resolution, citing a "potential conflict" in his referral letter. Mr. Lee has indicated that he made the referral for the sake of appearances, since he had earlier referred out related cases also involving you and Ms. Taylor, and not because of an actual conflict of interest. The Adams County Prosecuting Attorney's Office determined not to proceed with criminal charges against Mr. Chase. On March 23, 2010, when Mr. Lee was meeting with Moses Lake Police Chief Dean Mitchell about other matters, Mr. Mitchell indicated to Mr. Lee that he should review the materials related to the alleged theft of the California materials, suggesting that those materials might constitute 1 Neither Mr. Lee nor the Grant County Prosecuting Attorney's Office was a party to the California action. Thus it appears that they are not subject to the California court's order. See Richards v. Jefferson County, 517 U.S. 793,794,798, 116 S.Ct. 1761, 16 L.Ed.2d 76 (1996); La Fray v. City of Seattle, 12 Wn.2d 583, 588, 123 P.2d 345 (1942). 2 In early 2009, Mr. Lee's office received a criminal complaint brought against you by Ms. Taylor and her parents. He referred it to the Adams County Prosecuting Attorney's Office for resolution. P007796-031024-000021 Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Pae 3 impeachment materials. As you know, prosecutors are obligated, by the United States Constitution, to provide defendants with impeachment material regarding its witnesses. See generally Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194, 10 L.Ed.2d 215 (1963) (due process requires disclosure of exculpatory evidence); United States v. Bagley, 473 U.S. 667, 105 S.Ct. 3375, 87 L.Ed.2d 481 (1985) (impeachment evidence falls within the Brady rule). Since you were a witness in a number of pending criminal cases handled by Mr. Lee's office, Mr. Lee's office had an potential obligation to disclose information contained in the California materials. Within the week or so following his conversation with Chief Mitchell, Mr. Lee reviewed the California materials. Mr. Lee has testified that this is the first time he reviewed the California materials. On April 2, 2010, Mr. Lee wrote to your lawyer, Garth Dano, inquiring about the California materials, and asking for your response by April 9, 2010. The apparent purpose of that letter was to provide you an opportunity to provide information and context to the California materials, to enable Mr. Lee's office to make a fully informed decision regarding how they should handle their possible disclosure obligations regarding the California materials. On April 8, 2010, Mr. Dano went to Superior Court in adjoining Kittitas County, and obtained a temporary restraining order (TRO) prohibiting Mr. Lee and his office from divulging or using the contents and subject matter of the California materials. On Friday, April 9, 2010, Mr. Dano hand delivered a packet of materials to Mr. Lee related to the Kittitas proceedings, along with a cover letter. That cover letter did not state that a TRO had been entered. Mr. Dano and his assistant have declared that a signed copy of the TRO was in the packet of materials delivered to Mr. Lee on April 9, 2010. Mr. Lee, who apparently opened the packet, and Dalton L. Pence, the chief civil deputy in Mr. Lee's office, who apparently reviewed the packet shortly after it was opened, have testified that a signed copy of the TRO was not included in the packet. Douglas Mitchell, another deputy in Mr. Lee's office, also reviewed the packet on April 9, 2010. Mr. Mitchell has also testified that there was no signed TRO in the packet. In connection with the criminal case of State v. Carillo, on April 12, 2010 at approximately 2:30 p.m., Mr. Mitchell approached the Grant County Superior Court Judge Antosz, in the presence of defense counsel, and asked that a matter concerning a Brady issue regarding an unnamed law enforcement officer be placed on the Judge's calendar hearing calendar on a shortened time frame. Judge Antosz denied the motion to shorten time. As discussed above, Mr. Lee, Mr. Pence and Mr. Mitchell all assert that they had not been notified that a TRO had been issued as of the early afternoon of April 12, 2010. There is no evidence that on April 12, 2010 Mr. Mitchell revealed the identity of the law enforcement officer or revealed any of the California materials. At approximately 4:15 p.m. on April 12, 2010, Mr. Dano spoke to Mr. Pence. Mr. Pence asserted that he had not received a signed TRO. Mr. Dana's office faxed a copy of the signed TRO to Mr. Pence. Mr. Lee's office took no further action on the Brady issue in the Carillo case until after the TRO was modified. On April 23, 2010, the Kittitas Superior Court issued a preliminary injunction that superseded the TRO. Under the terms of the preliminary injunction, Mr. Lee and his office could only P007796-031024-000022 , Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Pa e4 disseminate the information related to the California materials by submitting the issue to the criminal courts of Grant County, under seal and upon notice to your lawyer. Subsequently, a number of judges in Grant County reviewed the California materials submitted by Mr. Lee's office for an in camera inspection in relation to cases for which you were a prosecution witness, including Judge Antosz in the Carillo case. Those judges who reviewed the California materials all ordered that certain redacted materials be provided to the defense. On July 16, 2010, the Kittitas Superior Court dismissed your lawsuit against Mr. Lee and his office. It determined that the California materials were subject to disclosure under Brady. The issue of whether those rulings were correct is currently on appeal. However, even if the Court of Appeals determines that the California material should not have been provided to defense counsel, the fact that several district and superior court judges have determined otherwise provides powerful evidence that Mr. Lee's office acted reasonably and appropriately in submitting the information to the court for a determination of its disclosure obligations under the Brady doctrine. Prosecutors have a constitutional and ethical obligation to fully comply with their Brady obligations. Violation of Kittitas County TRO/Preliminary Iniunction: You have alleged that Mr. Lee violated the TRO issued by the Kittitas County Superior Court on April 8, 2010, and the preliminary injunction that superseded the TRO issued by the Kittitas Court on April 23, 2010. Based on the facts set forth above, we cannot meet our burden of proving, by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that Mr. Lee was provided a copy of the TRO, or notified that a TRO had been issued, on April 9, 2010. Accordingly, we cannot meet our burden of proving that Mr. Lee violated the TRO. With regard to actions taken after Mr. Lee learned that the TRO had been issued (which admittedly occurred by the late afternoon of April 12, 2010), there is no • evidence that any of the California material was provided to any court or any defense counsel other than pursuant to the procedures set forth in the Kittitas preliminary injunction issued on April 23, 2010. Conflict of Interest: You have alleged that Mr. Lee had a conflict of interest as of April 2010 in determining his office's obligations regarding disclosure of the California material to various defense counsel in pending criminal matters. You have suggested two separate bases for your allegation: (1) that Mr. Lee had a conflict because he knew, at the time, that you were a witness in an ongoing grievance investigation, filed by Dan Couture, pending with the Office of Disciplinary Counsel and (2) that Mr. Lee had a conflict regarding all matters involving you as demonstrated by his decision to refer out the criminal matters in which you were a victim, involving Ms. Taylor and Mr. Chase. With regard to the first basis for your allegation of a conflict of interest, there is !!.Q. evidence that Mr. Lee knew that you were a witness in an ongoing investigation of a grievance filed by Dan Couture. Accordingly, we cannot meet our burden of proving, by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that any desire to discredit you as a witness against him created a conflict of interest for Mr. Lee. With regard to the second basis for your allegation of a conflict of interest, the fact that Mr. Lee decided that it would appear fairer to all concerned (particularly Ms. Taylor and Mr. Chase) if their matters were not handled by an office that worked with you on a regular and ongoing basis does not provide proof that he had a conflict P007796-031024-000023 .• ' ' . Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Pa e5 of interest in handling Brady issues concerning you. Prosecuting offices routinely make determinations regarding impeachment issues about law enforcement officers with whom they work regularly. Accordingly, we cannot meet our burden of proving, by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that Mr. Lee had a conflict of interest regarding the California materials issues. Possession of alleged Brady documents for over a year: Although it is your position that the California materials do not fall within Brady, you have alleged, in the alternative, that Mr. Lee had possession of the California materials for nearly a year before making any Brady disclosures. While those materials were apparently in the possession of his office in connection with the misdemeanor case pending against Ms. Taylor, there is insufficient evidence that Mr. Lee reviewed the materials in 2009. You indicate that you and your lawyer, Robert Schiffner, both spoke to Mr. Lee about the materials in or about May 2009, when the thumb drive was removed from Mr. Chase's office. However, it is clear that neither you nor Mr. Schiffner would have described the content of the thumb drive materials in a manner that would make Mr. Lee conclude that they were subject to Brady disclosure. You have also indicated that Mr. Lee referred to these materials when he spoke to you about the coroner's race in November 2009. Mr. Lee denies that he made this statement to you. Accordingly, there is insufficient evidence to prove, by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that Mr. Lee knew about the existence of Brady materials, but failed to disclose them to defense counsel. Grant County Victim/Witness Advocate: On the issue of whether Mr. Lee acted inappropriately in failing to assist you in obtaining the return of the California materials in the possession of the Moses Lake Police Department, we note that you filed legal action seeking to compel Mr. Lee and his office to do so. The court denied you relief. We do not see any ethical violation here. For the reasons stated above, we are dismissing this matter under ELC 5.6(a). If you do not mail or deliver a written request for review of this dismissal to us within forty-five ( 45) days of the date of this letter, the decision to dismiss your grievance will be final. Sincerely, ~--I c:::;:= Christine Gray Senior Disciplinary Counsel cc: Leland G. Ripley, counsel for D. Angus Lee Attorney at Law PO Box 1716 Duvall, WA 98019-1716 P007796-031024-000024 Christine Gray Senior Di~ciplinary Counsel September 14, 2011 Aaron Doyle 60 I S Pioneer Way Ste F384 Moses Lake, WA 98837 WSBA OFFICE OF DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL RECEIVED SEP 1-9 2011 direct line: (206) 733-5908 fax: (206) 727-8325 Re: Grievance of Aaron Doyle against lawyer Douglas R. Mitchell WSBA File Nos. 10-01292 Dear Mr. Doyle: This Jetter is to advise you that we have completed our investigation of your grievance against lawyer Douglas R. Mitchell and to advise you of our decision. The purpose of our review has been to determine whether sufficient evidence exists on which to base a disciplinary proceeding. Under the Rules for Enforcement of Lav.ryer Conduct (ELC), a lawyer may be disciplined only on a showing by a clear preponderance of the evidence that the lawyer violated the Rules of Professional Conduct (RPC). This standard of proof is more stringent than the standard applied in civil cases. Based on the information we have received, insufficient evidence exists to prove unethical conduct by Mr. Mitchell by a clear preponderance of the evidence in this matter. Therefore, we are dismissing the grievance. Our decision to dismiss the grievance is based on a review of your original grievance received on July 26, 201 O; Mr. Mitchell's preliminary response dated August 2, 2010, submitted through his lav,ryer, Leland G. Ripley; Mr. Ripley's second August 2, 2010 submission; our November 22, 2010 additional request for response; Mr. Ripley's February l , 2011 letter; four boxes of documents produced in February 2010 in response to ODC's November 22, 2010 request; and Mr. Ripley's February 28, 2011 letter. We interviewed lawyer Garth Dano and his assistant, Amy Brittingham. In addition, in August 2011 , we deposed Mr. Mitchell, Dalton L. Pence and D. Angus Lee. Your grievance relates to documents and a thumb drive that you have aJ1eged were stolen from you in late 2008 or early 2009 by your former girlfriend, Hayley Taylor. The documents and information contained on the thumb drive related to your deparh1re from a law enforcement job in Sierra County, California. For ease of reference, these documents and the information contained on the thumb drive will be refen-ed to herein as the "California material." You have alleged that the California material is subject to a sealing order issued by a California court, and Washington State Bar Associ:11ion • 1325 4th Avenue, Suit e 600 / Seattle, WA 98101 -2539 • '.!06-727-8200 / fax: 206-727-8325 P007796-031024-000025 ✓ Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Page 2 of 4 has been since before the time it was stolen from you. 1 In 2009, you were in litigation against Ms. Taylor and her parents. During the course of that litigation, Ms. Taylor's lawyer, Brian Chase, filed a letter that was a part of the California material, attempting to discredit you. Mr. Chase had obtained that document, and a thumb drive containing additional California material, from Ms. Taylor. In early May 2009, at a deposition of you being taken by Mr. Chase, he showed you additional documents that were part of the California material obtained from the thumb drive. You reported the stolen California material to the police, and alleged that the thumb drive had been stolen from you. The police took possession, from Mr. Chase, of the original thumb drive. D. Angus Lee is the elected prosecutor in Grant County. Douglas R. Mitchell is one of the deputy prosecuting attorneys who work for Mr. Lee. In 2009, Mr. Lee's office received police reports regarding possible criminal violations related to the thumb drive and the California materials. In late March or early April 2010, Mr. Lee personally reviewed the materials related to the alleged theft of the California materials. As you know, prosecutors are obligated, by the United States Constitution, to provide defendants with impeachment material regarding its witnesses. See generally Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194, 10 L.Ed.2d 215 (1963) (due process requires disclosure of exculpatory evidence); United States v. Bagley. 473 U.S. 667, 105 S.Ct. 3375, 87 L.Ed.2d 481 (1985) (impeachment evidence falls within the Brady rule). Since you were a witness in a number of pending criminal cases handled by Mr. Lee's office, Mr. Lee's office had an potential obligation to disclose information contained in the California materials. On April 2, 2010, Mr. Lee wrote to your lawyer, Garth Dano, inquiring about the Califorrµa materials, and asking for your response by April 9, 2010. The apparent purpose of that letter was to provide you an opportunity to provide information and context to the California materials, to enable Mr. Lee's office to make a fully informed decision regarding how they should handle their possible disclosure obligations regarding the California materials. On April 8, 2010, Mr. Dano went to Superior Court in adjoining Kittitas County, and obtained a temporary restraining order (TRO) prohibiting Mr. Lee and his office from divulging or using the contents and subject matter of the California materials. On Friday, April 9, 2010, Mr. Dano hand delivered a packet of materials to Mr. Lee related to the Kittitas proceedings, along with a cover letter. That cover letter did not state that a TRO had been entered. Mr. Dano and his assistant have declared that a signed copy of the TRO was in the packet of materials delivered to Mr. Lee on April 9, 2010. Mr. Lee, who apparently opened the packet, and Dalton L. Pence, the chief civil deputy in Mr. Lee's office, who apparently reviewed the packet shortly after it was opened, have testified that a signed copy of the TRO was not included in the packet. Mr. 1 Neither Mr. Mitchell nor the Grant County Prosecuting Attorney's Office was a party to the California action. Thus it appears that they are not subject to the California court's order. See Richards v. Jefferson County. 517 U.S. 793, 794, 798, 116 S.Ct. 1761, 16 L.Ed.2d 76 (1996); La Fray v. City of Seattle, 12 Wn.2d 583 ,588, 123 P.2d 345 (1942). P007796-031024-000026 Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Page 3 of 4 Mitchell also reviewed the packet on April 9, 2010. Mr. Mitchell has also testified that there was no signed TRO in the packet. In connection with the criminal case of State v. Carillo, on April 12, 2010 at approximately 2:30 p.m., Mr. Mitchell approached the Grant County Superior Court Judge Antosz, in the presence of defense counsel, and asked that a matter concerning a Brady issue regarding an unnamed law enforcement officer be placed on the Judge's calendar hearing calendar on a shortened time frame. Judge Antosz denied the motion to shorten time. During the colloquy between the court, Mr. Mitchell and defense counsel, Mr. Mitchell indicated his belief that no TRO had been entered. Based on the evidence set forth above, there is insufficient evidence to prove, by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that Mr. Mitchell knew or had reason to know a TRO had been entered at the time he spoke to Judge Antosz on April 12, 2010. As discussed above, Mr. Lee, Mr. Pence and Mr. Mitchell all assert that they had not been notified that a TRO had been issued as of the early afternoon of April 12, 2010. We are aware of no evidence that on April 12, 2010 Mr. Mitchell revealed the identity of the law enforcement officer or revealed any of the California materials to either Judge Antosz or to defense counsel. At approximately 4:15 p.m. on April 12, 2010, Mr. Dano spoke to Mr. Pence. Mr. Pence asserted that he had not received a signed TRO. Mr. Dano's office faxed a copy of the signed TRO to Mr. Pence. Mr. Lee's office took no further action on the Brady issue in the Carillo case until after the TRO was modified. On April 23 , 2010, the Kittitas Superior Court issued a preliminary injunction that superseded the TRO. Under the terms of the preliminary injunction, Mr. Lee's office could only disseminate the information related to the California materials by submitting the issue to the criminal courts of Grant County, under seal and upon notice to your lawyer. Subsequently, a number of judges in Grant County reviewed the California materials submitted by Mr. Lee's office for an in camera inspection in relation to cases for which you were a prosecution witness, including Judge Antosz in the Carillo case. Those judges who reviewed the California materials all ordered that certain redacted materials be provided to the defense. On July 16, 2010, the Kittitas Superior Court dismissed your lawsuit against Mr. Lee and his office. It determined that the California materials were subject to disclosure under Brady. The issue of whether those rulings were correct is currently on appeal. However, even if the Court of Appeals determines that the California material should not have been provided to defense counsel, the fact that several district and superior court judges have determined otherwise provides powerful evidence that Mr. Lee's office acted reasonably and appropriately in submitting the information to the court for a determination of its disclosure obligations under the Brady doctrine. Prosecutors have a constitutional and ethical obligation to fully comply with their Brady obligations. P007796-031024-000027 Aaron Doyle September 14, 2011 Page 4 of 4 For the reasons stated above, we are dismissing this matter under ELC 5.6(a). If you do not mail or deliver a written request for review of this dismissal to us within forty-five ( 45) days of the date of this letter, the decision to dismiss your grievance will be final. Sincerely, ~-/- S?c;;;;;__ __ _ Senior Disciplinary Counsel cc: Leland G. Ripley, counsel for Douglas R. Mitchell Attorney at Law PO Box 1716 Duvall, WA 98019-1716 P007796-031024-000028 Issued: August 25, 2020 WSP Toxicology Laboratory toxlab@wsp.wa.gov Methamphetamine Contamination – Q&A How/when was the methamphetamine contamination initially identified? Between October 2018 and early June 2019, 3 separate cases were identified where confirmation (quantitative) results for methamphetamine were not comparable to the initial positive screening results. A second round of confirmation testing verified the negative methamphetamine results in these 3 cases. Initial investigation of the first isolated occurrence found no root cause for the screening and confirmation discrepancy. After the second case discrepancy occurred, it was hypothesized that contamination could be the cause. In mid-June 2019, while procuring services to test the facility for environmental methamphetamine, 5 additional cases were found to have the same discrepancy, where the initial positive screening result was not replicated in subsequent confirmation testing. Further investigation determined that in all 8 cases, the sample preparation for one or more of the analyses was performed by a scientist occupying lab and office areas previously utilized for chemical/materials analysis work by the Crime Laboratory Division (CLD). These ‘annex’ lab and office areas had been acquired for use by the Toxicology Laboratory Division (TLD), beginning in March 2018. What drugs were identified as possible contaminants in casework? Methamphetamine was the only drug identified as a contaminant. It was the only drug where initial screening results and subsequent confirmation testing were not in agreement. The TLD practice of comparing screening results to confirmation results as the case moves through the examination process is what led to the identification of the potential contamination issue. Documentation of the discrepant results was included in the case files for affected cases. How many cases were known to be affected? Eight cases were found to have discrepant results, including 7 death investigation cases and 1 law enforcement (DUI) case. Although only 8 cases had discrepant results, between March 2018 and June 2019, a total of 3,832 cases had at least one test performed by scientists occupying the annex office and/or lab areas previously used by the CLD. This included 872 death investigation cases, 2,857 DUI/DRE law enforcement cases, and 103 other miscellaneous cases. What actions were taken by the TLD in response to the identified contamination? In June 2019, when it was confirmed that a potential methamphetamine contamination existed, TLD personnel immediately discontinued work in the sample preparation lab area, as well as in the office space previously utilized by the CLD. A review of testing work was performed to determine if other cases were affected. Results from initial testing and confirmation testing were compared to ensure agreement between all results. For methamphetamine positive cases, the presence of the metabolite amphetamine in blood was also used to support agreement in results, as amphetamine is commonly found with methamphetamine, at an expected ratio. The TLD’s accrediting body, ANAB, was notified of the environmental methamphetamine contamination. A certified external service, BioClean, was contracted to perform environmental (wipe method) testing to aid in determination of the overall extent and impact of the contamination in the CLD and TLD. Any P007796-031024-000029 Issued: August 25, 2020 WSP Toxicology Laboratory toxlab@wsp.wa.gov lab or office area that tested positive for methamphetamine was cleaned and decontaminated by BioClean. Subsequent wipe sample analysis found all sampled areas were below the Washington State Decontamination Standard for methamphetamine. TLD personnel have not returned to, and testing has not been performed in, the affected CLD lab and office areas since June 2019. What tests were performed in the annex lab area, by scientists stationed in the annex office area? The scope of tests performed in this area included the majority of testing performed by the TLD (alcohol/volatiles, drug screening, and drug confirmation tests). Were the actual evidence items (submitted blood tubes) contaminated? No. The TLD has determined that the blood tubes themselves were not contaminated. During sample preparation, one blood tube at a time is opened, only for the amount of time needed to remove a sample for testing. Retesting of the blood from the same evidence tubes where methamphetamine was initially identified yielded results that were negative for methamphetamine. Other blood specimens, initially negative for methamphetamine, but analyzed in the same testing batch as affected cases, were retested. Retest results for those cases were again negative for methamphetamine. Were any incorrect results reported/released to the customer? No. The TLD’s internal quality assurance policies and procedures identified the issue during the course of testing, prior to results being reported to the customer. Was there any impact on ethanol/volatile test results for casework? No. Ethanol and other volatile compounds (acetone, isopropanol and methanol) are tested by headspace gas chromatography. This test method only detects volatile compounds. The presence of any non-volatile compounds (e.g., methamphetamine) does not affect ethanol test results. Were any instruments used in testing affected by this issue? No. Sample preparation/extraction (where the contamination is suspected to have occurred) is not performed in the areas of the laboratory designated for instrumentation. After sample preparation, extracts are transferred to auto-sampler vials and capped, prior to transfer to the instrument for analysis. For EMIT immunoassay testing, the extracts are transferred to sample cups and immediately loaded on the analyzer. Does the TLD implement practices to ensure quality and accuracy of reported results? Yes. Policies and procedures are in place to ensure the quality of work performed within the laboratory and the accuracy of results reported to the customer. This is demonstrated throughout the process of examination, from ethanol testing and drug screens through confirmation and/or quantitation of drugs present.  Forensic Scientists are required to follow evidence handling procedures to protect the integrity of the specimens. P007796-031024-000030 Issued: August 25, 2020 WSP Toxicology Laboratory toxlab@wsp.wa.gov  Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for alcohol and drug analysis include use of a negative quality control sample and/or a blank sample and positive quality control samples.  Prior to running a testing batch on an instrument, maintenance is performed by the scientist to confirm instrumentation is functioning properly.  Laboratory policy requires 100% technical review of all testing batch data.  As cases move through the examination process, screening results are compared to confirmation test results, as well as information provided in the Request for Analysis.  For a qualitative or quantitative result to be reported, two independent tests (independent sampling from submitted blood tube and acquisition on the instrument) are required.  Laboratory policy requires 100% technical review of the Toxicology Test Report and associated case files prior to release. P007796-031024-000031 December 28, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Connor M. Ahlstedt, Badge Number 508 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while off duty, Trooper operated a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs and was arrested for DUI.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason L. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000032 November 24, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Hyungjun Ahn, Badge Number 424 Dear Mr. Brown: On October 8, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged that Trooper conducted an unsafe U-turn and was struck, causing a collision. It is further alleged that Trooper provided untruthful information regarding the collision to the on-scene Sergeant.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the finding for the truthfulness allegation was Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000033 December 23, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Retired Assistant Chief Johnny Alexander, Badge Number 6 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 17, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while testifying in a deposition and/or civil trial, Assistant Chief provided false, untruthful, or misleading information.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000034 August 16, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CO4 Anthony J. Amorati, Badge Number X118 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged CO4 acted in an inappropriate, discriminatory and/or retaliatory manner toward coworkers.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Michael Gonzales, Coalition Commander Vanessa C. Barnes, Communications Division Assistant Chief Shannon I. Bendiksen Technical Services Bureau P007796-031024-000035 September 15, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CO 4 Anthony J. Amorati, Badge Number X118 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 16, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged CO4 acted in an inappropriate, discriminatory and/or retaliatory manner toward coworkers.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Proven. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Adam Murphy, Coalition Commander Vanessa C. Barnes, Communications Division Assistant Chief Shannon I. Bendiksen Technical Services Bureau P007796-031024-000036 September 19, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Derek O. Anderson, Badge Number 145 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards initiated an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant stopped the complainant due to his race. It is further alleged Sergeant treated the complainant differently due to his race.” A preliminary investigation was completed and the allegation was found to be not sustained. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000037 March 15, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant James R. Arnold, Badge Number 237 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 8, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, Sergeant made inappropriate, hostile and/or discriminatory comments to subordinates. IT IS FURTHER ALLEGED SERGEANT MADE UNWELCOME AND ONGOING PHYSICAL CONTACT WITH SUBORDINATES, INCLUDING AFTER BEING ASKED TO STOP. IT IS ALSO ALLEGED SERGEANT FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE DIRECTIVES PROVIDED IN THE ADVANCE NOTICE FORM WHEN HE COMMUNICATED WITH POTENTIAL WITNESSES AND/OR PERSONS WHO MAY BE MATERIALLY INVOLVED IN AN ADMINISTRATIVE INVESTIGATION.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The finding regarding unacceptable conduct was Proven. The findings regarding insubordination and interference with discipline were Undetermined, while the finding regarding discrimination and harassment was Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000038 August 8, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant James R. Arnold, Badge Number 237 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, Sergeant made inappropriate, hostile and/or discriminatory comments to subordinates.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000039 JAY IN LEE Governor STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL JOHN R. BATISTE Chief PO Bo 42611 • Olympia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.wsp.wa .gov October 25, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 1ot11 Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness-Trooper Brent Ashton, Badge Number 1236 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the trooper was untruthful when providing information to his supervisor regarding the traffic stop of a motorcycle conducted on September 1, 2018. " If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeff Merrill, WSPTA Captain Scott A. McCoy, Marysville Sincerely, ~~ Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000040 P007796-031024-000041 IA\ l"-'>IH Cou•rnor IOHN R. BATISTE Chief Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary q,\Tf OF WASHIM,TON VVASHINCTON STATF PATROL October 22, 2013 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Aircraft Mechanjc Supervisor James E. Beins Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regard ing the above named former WSP employee: A 2012 allegation that Be ins falsified official FAA records in order to maintain Inspection Authorization (IA). It is further alleged he falsified 3 separate maintenance log books, claiming to have conducted a Phase 3 aircraft inspection without actually doing one. It is also alleged he requested a subordinate allow him to take credit for the inspection in order to maintain an FAA qualification. If you need additional information, please contact me, at (360) 704-2333. TWM:dp Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards cc: Assistant Chief Christopher T. Gundermann, Investigative Services Bureau Deputy Chief G. Curt Hattell 0 P007796-031024-000042 August 13, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Elizabeth P. Bigger, Badge Number 190 Dear Mr. Brown: On March 4, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Sergeant acted in an inappropriate, retaliatory and/or discriminatory manner toward the complainant. It is further alleged Sergeant was untruthful in her response to the complainant regarding a counseling document.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been closed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000043 August 13, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Office Manager Brenda A. Biscay Dear Mr. Brown: On February 4, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while testifying in a deposition and/or civil trial, Office Manager provided untruthful information regarding a sexual harassment allegation.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been closed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Ms. Christy Reed, WFSE Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain John E. Matagi, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000044 )A'l' I 'l,lH Co1t·rnor JOH!'. R. BATISTE (hid Sll\lf Of WASHI/\.GlO'- vV;\SH INCf()N STATE PATROL PO Bo" ~!hl 1 • Ohmpi,1 \'lc.1,hington 98304-..!bl l • lh0-704-4110 • WW\\.w~p.wa.go1 October 22, 2013 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Forensic Scientist 3 Franklin E. Boshears Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named former WSP employee: 2012 Unsatisfactory Performance allegation that he submitted reports for peer review in which he failed to properly document the item 's labeling which if not caught by the peer reviewer would have affected the schedule under the Controlled Substance Act which could have impacted the prosecution of the case. An allegation he submitted a case for peer review reporting no controlled substance which was in conflict with data and documentation in the case which indicated a controlled substance was likely to be present. A 2012 Unsatisfactory Performance allegation that during technical peer review of the case, there were repeated concerns with data quality, lack of investigation into conflicting results, and lack of communication by the Forensic Scientist 3 to resolve the case with the reviewer. This case had to go the peer reviewer six times before it was finalized. lf you need additional information, please contact me, at (360) 704-2333. TWM:dp cc: Deputy ChiefG. Curt Hattell Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards 0 P007796-031024-000045 P007796-031024-000046 August 19, 2020 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Richard P. Bulley, Badge Number 992 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper was untruthful in his verbal communication with the complainant and/or when authoring affidavits pertaining to the arrest. It is further alleged the trooper used excessive force by slamming his patrol vehicle door into the complainant's head and shoulder. It is also alleged the complainant was arrested without legal authority. It is further alleged the trooper acted in this manner because the complainant was black.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Trooper Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain James R. Mjor II, Bremerton Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000047 January 13, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Thomas L. Burress, Badge Number 187 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant threatened his former domestic partner with a firearm.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000048 July 26, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Thomas L. Burress, Badge Number 187 Dear Mr. Brown: On January 13, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Sergeant threatened his former domestic partner with a firearm.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000049 P007796-031024-000050 P007796-031024-000051 Pierce County Office of Prosecuting Attorney MARY E. ROBNETT Prosecuting Attorney REPLY TO: CRIMINAL FELONY DIVISION Main Office: (253) 798-7400 930 Tacoma Avenue South, Room 946 Tacoma, Washington 98402-2171 Victim-Witness Assistance: (253) 798-7400 (FAX) (253) 798-6636 September 12, 2023 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Lab Attn: Forensic Scientist Brian Capron 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, Washington Re: Forensic Scientist Brian Capron, Brady or Impeachment Evidence Dear Mr. Capron: As you are no doubt aware both your department and prosecutors have a constitutional duty to disclose evidence or information concerning possible Brady1 or potential impeachment evidence or information to criminal defendants. The matter referenced was brought to our attention and led the opening of a file which will be maintained in our office. This letter is intended to provide you with notice of this matter. We wish to extend you the opportunity to review the written material provided to us. Please contact the undersigned if you would like to come to our office for such a review. We also extend to you the opportunity to provide us with any additional evidence or information concerning this matter to be added to and included with the evidence and information we keep in our file. Please be advised that any such evidence or information you provide us is not privileged or confidential and is subject to public disclosure. It could also be disclosed to criminal defense attorneys and public records requestors along with the content of our file. Please feel free to contact the undersigned if you or your representatives or attorneys have any questions. Sincerely, BROOKE BURBANK Pierce County Prosecutor’s Office cc: Brady/Impeachment File 1 Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83(1963) P007796-031024-000052 INTEROFFICE COMMUNICATION INASHINGTON STATE PATROL TO: Ms. Amanda Black, Toxicology Laboratory Division FROM: Dr. Brianna Peterson, Toxicology Laboratory Division SUBJECT: Corrective Action Report - incorrect evidence items disposed DA TE: July 24, 2020 FILE: On July 15, 2020, Forensic Scientist 5 Katie Harris notified me via email that evidence items for ST-19-12786 (A and B tubes) had been disposed prior to completion of all testing and release of a final Toxicology Test Report. The series of events leading up to this notification are as follows: • July 14, 2020 - Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested ST-19-12786-A from the evidence vault through OneNote. • July 15, 2020 - Property and Evidence Custodian Melanie Diggs was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 in the evidence vault. Upon examining LIMS, Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. • July 15, 2020 - Shelby notified her supervisor, Katie Harris, that the evidence for an active case had been disposed. • July 15, 2020 - Tyler pulled the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report related to the Evidence Disposition Records for 5/19/20 and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19-12786-B were not listed on the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report. In addition, the Evidence Disposition Records for 5/19/20 indicated ST-19-12786 had been disposed. Tyler provided these records to Katie. Investigation: This event was determined to be significant and a corrective action process initiated. The chain of custody records in LIMS for ST-19-12876 verify that this case was not disposed on 5/19/20; both evidence items were disposed on 6/29/20. The Evidence Handling Inquiry Report for 5/19/20 have the initials of "TP" and "BC" at the top of the first page. The initials indicate that Property and Evidence Custodian Tanica Perry pulled the samples on this report from the evidence vault and FS5 Brian Capron facilitated the disposal process. Root Cause: The root cause of this nonconformity was inattention. Tani ca originally pulled the incorrect evidence items trom storage in the evidence vault. Forensic Scientist 5 Brian Capron and Forensic Scientist 3 Asa Louis worked together to dispose of the evidence. Asa examined the evidence items and recited the case number to Brian; Brian verified the case number against the 3000-323-00] (5/96) An internationally accredited agency providing prof essional law e,iforcement services P007796-031024-000053 Ms. Amanda Black Page2 7/24/2020 Evidence Handling Inquiry Report. Inattention to the case number occurred in both stages of this disposal process. Impact: The impact of this nonconformity was significant. Drug screening by EMIT was the only test that had been performed, therefore a final Toxicology Test report for this case could not be issued. Evaluation: Section 4.3.1.1 of the Quality Assurance Manual (Notification of Appropriate Authority) was properly followed. Cessation of all evidence disposals was put into place on 7/16/2020. Correction/ Action: For future evidence disposals, an additional 'read back' will be implemented. One person will recite the case number from the evidence item to a secondary person. The secondary person will recite the case number from the disposal log. Both individuals will now be reciting and verifying the case number, whereas the previous process only instituted one recitation and verification step. In addition, the Subject Name from the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report will be recited for verification against the tubes. If the subject name is not present on the tubes, then the Agency Case number can be used for comparison. If the sample is unlabeled, this is noted in the "Evid/Handle Note" column of the report. Follow-up/Monitoring: The submitting agency and assigned prosecutor were notified that a final report would not be issued on 7 /16/20. Evidence audits routinely occur following Section 7 .18 of the Operations Manual. Based on results of audits for the past decade, this nonconformity is an isolated incident. BP:bp 6f cc: Mr. Brian Capron, Toxicology Laboratory Division Dr. Fiona Couper, Toxicology Laboratory Division Ms. Kimberly Miller, Toxicology Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000054 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report Case ID: ST-19-12786 ITEM 1 ST-19-12786-A: One vacutainer with gray top Date Qf Tr2 ~fer From PIN To PIN 10/30/2019 Velliquette, John [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [] hand delivery 10/30/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 03/18/2020 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 05/19/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] capron, Brian TOX [X] 05/19/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] ITEM2 ST-19-12786-B: One vacutainer with gray top Date of Transfer ftQm PIN To PIN 10/30/2019 Velliquette, John [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [] hand delivery 10/30/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 03/18/2020 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 05/19/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] capron, Brian TOX [X] 05/19/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tox Lab) [ ] NOTE: [X] indicates a secured transaction ( a PIN was entered ) [R0.0-20110323] caseCOC.rpt Page 1 of 1 Print: 7/24/2020, 12:05:29PM P007796-031024-000055 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report Case ID: ST-19-12876 ITEM 1 ST-19-12876-A: One vacutainer with gray top Ds:ite Qf Transfer From PIN To .em 11/05/2019 Demyen, Jessica [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [] Fed Ex 11/05/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 11/14/2019 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X) Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 11/22/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 12/09/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/09/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] 12/27/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/27/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Okolie, Onyi TOX [X] 12/30/2019 Okolie, Onyi TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/30/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 01/08/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X) 01/08/2020 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Krantz, Mindy TOX [X] 01/16/2020 Krantz, Mindy TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 01/16/2020 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 06/29/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Capron, Brian TOX [X] 06/29/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] ITEM 2 ST-19-12876-B: One vacutainer with gray top bls:ite of I[ansfer From PIN To 1:1.N 11/05/2019 Demyen, Jessica [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [] Fed Ex 11/05/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 11/14/2019 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [XJ Vault - Fridge TOX [] 11/22/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 12/09/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/09/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [XJ 12/13/2019 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [XJ 12/13/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] 06/29/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Capron, Brian TOX [X] 06/29/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] [R0.0-20110323] caseCOC.rpt Page 1 of 2 Print: 7/24/2020, 11 :38:38AM P007796-031024-000056 Case ID: ST-19-12876 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report NOTE: [X] indicates a secured transaction { a PIN was entered ) [R0.0-20110323) caseCOC.rpt Page 2 of 2 Print: 7/24/2020, 11 :38:38AM P007796-031024-000057 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Orrell, Tyler (WSP) Monday, July 20, 2020 6:34 AM Keeley, Shelby (WSP); Peterson, Brianna (WSP) Miller, Kimberly (WSP); Harris, Katie (WSP) RE: missing evidence On 07-15-2020 while pulling tubes for Shelby, Laney was unable to locate ST-19-12786 A or B. Spots were vacant where those tubes would have been so our standard next step is to check LIMS for its location. That is when we discovered it had been disposed. I looked further into the matter and discovered it was pulled accidentally instead of a tube of similar ST number for May 19th disposals. I presented the transfer logs and disposal list to Katie on 07-15-2020 at ~1000 Tyler Orrell From: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM To: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7 /14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day (7 /15) and gave her the fi le which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa .gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence t hat had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Prope1iy and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 1 P007796-031024-000058 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie ofthi3 discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboralury Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 2 P007796-031024-000059 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM Peterson, Brianna (WSP); Orrell, Tyler (WSP); Harris, Katie (WSP) Miller, Kimberly (WSP) RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7/14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day {7 /15) and gave her the file which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM To: Keeley, Shelby {WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler {WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie {WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly {WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence that had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Onell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed . ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie of this discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboratory Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 P007796-031024-000060 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Harris, Katie (WSP) Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 7:38 AM To: Subject: Peterson, Brianna (WSP); Miller, Kimberly (WSP) FW: missing evidence I was initially alerted to the disposed evidence by Shelby Keeley soon after the vault discovered the tubes had been disposed on 7/15/2020. Tyler had pulled the disposal log shortly after and showed it to me. This all took place just prior to 8:30am on 7/15/2020 as I emailed Brianna just prior to the management meeting and then it was briefly discussed during the meeting. Katie Harris Forensic Scientist Supervisor Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South, Suite 360 Seattle, WA 98134 Telephone: (206) 262-6100 Fax: (206) 262-6145 From: Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 6:34 AM To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence On 07-15-2020 while pulling tubes for Shelby, Laney was unable to locate ST-19-12786 A or B. Spots were vacant where those tubes would have been so our sta ndard next step is to check LIMS for its location. That is when we discovered it had been disposed. I looked further into the matter and discovered it was pulled accidentally instead of a tube of similar ST number for May 19th disposals. I presented the transfer logs and disposal list to Katie on 07-15-2020 at ~1000 Tyler Orrell From: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM To: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <l<atie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7/14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day (7 /15) and gave her the file which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM 1 P007796-031024-000061 To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa .gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence that had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie of this discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboratory Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 2 P007796-031024-000062 No. Agency Name To Be Disposed HoquiamWSP 2 Tacoma WSP 3 Tumwater WSP 4 TacomaWSP 5 Port Orchard Police Dept 6 Port Orchard Police Dept 7 Jefferson Co Sheriff - Port Hadlock 8 Asotin County Sheriff 9 Port Angeles Police Dept 10 Woodland Police Dept Evidence Handling Inquiry (by Case#} Report for Releasable Cases Between 1/1/2000 and 2/18/2020 Age Case# Subject Name 16-037668 Gurvinder Mander 18-014152 Oscar Cruz 18-015454 Dagim Fassil 18-019645 Troy Egbert D 19-000041 Lorianne Wood riff 019-00421 Rusty Mullikin 19-1483 Ruthann Glassman 19A00839 Omar Sanchez 2019-2975 Natalee Amsdill ST-17-00299 /A / VGray ST-17-00299 I B / ST-18-06357 /A ./ ST-18-06357 / B / ST-18-07042 / A ,,,,- ST-18-07042 / B / - ST-18-09161 / B / ST-1S-01672 /A ,,,- ST-19-01672 / B / ST-1S-01672 / C ,-- ST-1S-01672 /D / ST-19-02255 / A / ST-1S-02255 / B / ST-19-02347 / A / ST-1S-02347 / B / VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray . . . - . - - VGray VGray VGray VRed VRed VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-1S-02355 /A,,,,- VGray __ 5.~-'.~~~5_5 ,( ~ /' ___ VGray ST-1 S-02923 / A-; VGray ST-1S-02923 /B / VGray _____ ______________ . ____ ____ ~-1S-02923 C ;;, PC9'P. 0 To Be Disposed Print Date: 5118/2020 Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age Name on req. form: 'Davinder S. Gandhamy' LK 1/26/1 7 Name on req. form: 'Davinder S. Gandhamy' LK 1/26/17 W19°188 lsaacSeavey ST-19-03331 /A ," VGray _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _________________ 5.~·!9-~~~3_1 / B _":. __ _ ~~~a! ______ _ . ___ ____ ______ _______ _____ __ ____ _ [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 1 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000063 I No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name 11 Wenatchee Police Dept 19W03463 Jennifer Dechenne 12 Jefferson Co Sheriff- Port Hadlock 19-2332 Dennis Gray 13 Wenatchee Police Dept 19W03540 James Schuyleman 14 Marysville Police Dept 2019-000014451Jolene Love 15 Port Angeles Police Dept 2019-6371 Matthew Gamer 16 Jefferson Co Sheriff - Port Hadlock 19-3811 Damon Clarke 17 Puyallup Police Dept 1911601162 Amy Weis beck 18 Puyallup Police Dept 1911801852 James Coffee 19 Marysville Police Dept 2019-00022913 Chad Torve 20 Othello Police Dept 19-001409 Isaias Sanchez-Gonsalez 21 Othello Police Dept 19-001346 Juan Valencia Ochoa 22 Asotin County Sheriff 19A02097 Peter Cavenaugh Case ID Evid. ST-19.03452 / A ,; ST-19-03452 / B / ST-19-03574 /A / ST-19-03574 / B / ST-19-03693 /A.., ST-1 9.03693 / B / ST-19-03881 /A - . / ST-19-03881 / B ST-19-04916 / A ,; ST-19-04916 / B r ST-19-04916 / C r ST-19-04916 / D ,,- - · - . ------ ST-19-04930 / A ., .. ~~·!9-~930 / B / ST-19-05089 /A _. . S~·!9·0~89/ B / ST-19-05090 /A.,,.. ST-19-05090 / B' ST-19.05163 / A - ST-19-05163 / B / ST-19.051 64 /A.,- ST-19-05164 / B ,,,-- . - - - - - - - - . - ... . -.. . ST-19-05165 /A - sr-19-0s1ss Is "' . ·sr-19-osis:i /A;_ - ST-1 9-05183 / B / Desc. VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray 23 Jefferson Co Sheriff- Port Hadlock 19-4262 Alanna Upp ST-19-05195 /A ,; VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ST-19-05195 /B ' VGray · - .24 · · Ell~~;b~rg-P~li~~ D~pt-· · · · · --· · · --E19--0295_3_. ·N;~;n Sa-dang - - . - · ST-19-05471 . /A-·; -··· VG;a;- • - - - • ·. - - - . - - - .. - - - - . - .... - - • - ....... - . ST-19-05471 / B ✓ VGray . - .. . - -----.. . .. -- . -. - . ---- -. - .. -- - -. .. -.. -. -. -. -- . -.... . . -.. - . -.. - ... --. -...... ·/ . - . . ----. -- -.. - - . --... . . - .. - - .. .. - . --- . - . - .... -- 25 Ellensburg Police Dept E19-07983 Ram Rai Kirati ST-19-07516/ A VGray IR1 0-201610271 Evid Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 2 of 13 Print 5/1 8/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000064 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name Desc. 42 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-411 Michael Aeon ST·19-12621 / A / VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age . 43 .. Kl!~~~ ·c; c~~~~~r· . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . KCA~ 1·9~ 106. · An~;l~~; Th~~;~~ . . . ST· 19-1263.17.;, / . . VG;ay. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . • . . . . ... .• • .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... . . .... ·7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . .. ....... . . .. . 44 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191025·365 Keith Standal ST·19-12747 / A VGray ------------------ ---- -- --- ··-· ---- - ---- - -------- --------- - ----- ---- -- - - ·--- -- ---- ---- -- --- --- --- --- - -- --- -· ---------- ----- · 45 Clark Co Medical Examiner 2019·2674 Bryan Bocanegra ST·19-12876 /A .,,. VGray ST·19-12876 / B / VGray 46 Thurston Co Coroner 47 King Co Medical Examiner 48 King Co Medical Examiner 49 King Co Medical Examiner 50 King Co Medical Examiner 51 King Co Medical Examiner 52 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 53 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 54 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 55 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 56 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 57 King Co Medical Examiner 58 King Co Medical Examiner 19·2181·11 19·02301 Morton James Martin lndalecio 19·02294 Michael Knapp 19·02293 Joseph Antoncich 19·02259 Daniel Gleason 19·02296 Judy Wayne 192144 192151 Larry Lane Noel Cabardo 192149 Evan Suckow 192177 Percy David 19·2077 Amberly Masonholder 19·02376 Cesar Erazo 19·2372 Alison Powell 191117 ·94 Matthew Dick ST·19-13161 / A ,,.,- ST•19·13189 /A r VGray VGray ST·1 9-13190 / A ,,- VLavender ST•1 9-13190 / B r SST ST·19-13190 /C / SST ST•19·13194 / A _,, VGray · · ST·19·131 98 J A / VLavender ST·19·13199 / A ,.. VGray ST•19-13332 / A / VGray · ST·19-13333 / A / · VLavender ST·19-13334 / A / VLavender . . . . .. . . . / . . . . . . ST•19-13335 /A VGray ST·19-13461 I A ,,.- VLavender ST·19·13461 / 8 .,,.. SST ST•19-13461 / C / SST ~T·~~~3~6 / ~ .. .. ~~~a! .... . ST·19-13669 / A r VGray ST·1 9-13669 / 8 VGray ST·19-13669 /C / VGray 59 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner ST·19-13761 / A _,, VGray 60 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191113·305 Nicholas Soulias ·sr.is-i3i64 / ;: -;· ... vG;ay . .. . .. . .. . .... . . . . ... ....•.. ..•......... 61 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-451 Michael Studley ST•19•13766 /A./ VGray ST.19-13766.,) 8 / VGray ·········•· · ······ ······· · ···· · ······ • • ··· · ·· · ······· ···•······ · ······· · ··· · ······· ,; · · ·········· • ·· ··· ······· · ·· · ······ · ········ · · 62 ClallamCoCoroner 2019.co.205 RodneyEdwards ST·19-13770_/A / VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 4 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000065 No. Agency Name 62 Clallam Co Coroner 63 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 64 Benton Co Coroner 65 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 66 Clark Co Medical Examiner 67 Clark Co Medical Examiner 68 Clark Co Medical Examiner 69 Benton Co Coroner 70 Cowlitz Co Coroner 71 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 72 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 73 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 74 King Co Medical Examiner 75 King Co Med_ical Examiner 76 King Co Medical Examiner 77 King Co Medical Examiner 78 King Co Medical Examiner Age Case # Subject Name 2019-C0-205 Rodney Edwards Kari Foss Case ID Evid. ST·19-13770 /B / ST·19·13773 I A .,,, Desc. VGray VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age 191118-414 C19-441 192230 Melanie Novotney David Kesner . ·sr.ig.13774. 1 s· / -. -. vG;a;·. -.. 2019-2858 Jonathan Pfingsten 2019-2848 Frederick Stephens - --- ·--- -· 2019-2818 Kathleen Lane -- -· ---- - C19-444 Theodore Knuth 19-637 PennyTumer 19-2105 Terry Coleman 19-2099 nmothy Daily 19-2102 Maya Aubert 19-02402 Wayne Newkirk - - - . . - -- -- - . - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - -. - - - -- - - - - - - - - - -- . - - ST·19-13m /A/ VGray ST·19-13778 /A./ ST•19-13778 / B ./ - - - -· -- - --- S'.·19-1~77~! ✓ ~T·:~:~76!1. fB / ST•iS-13782 / A .,,, ST·19-13782 / B / ·si-is-i:ii84 / A ,,,,,- VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray ST·1 9-13789 / A ,... VGray ST-19-13789 / B / VGray ST•19-13790 /A / ST-19-13790 / B ST-19-13792 / A _. ST-19-13792 / B / ST-19-13792 / C / ST-19-13795 / A / VGray VGray VGray VGreen VGray 19-02370 Valeree Neuman ST-19-13797 /B ,,... ST·19-13797 ) C ' VGray VBlue SST . - - . - - - - - -- - - - - - -. -- - 19-02385 Stephen Wilson ST-19-13880 / B / ST-19-13880 / C / 19-02396 Tae Shin ST-19-13882 / A ,,, ST-19-13882 / B / VGray VRed VGray Vlavender 19·02397 Christopher Thar])-Drake ST· 19-13883 / A ./ VLavender - - -- - - - ------ - - -.. ---- - - -- - - - - - ---- -- - - - - -- - - . . - - - - - - . - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - . - - - - --- - -- - - . - - - - - - -- - - ----- -- - . -- - -- - - - - - - . - - - 79 King Co Medical Examiner 81 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 19-02400 192254 Kevin Sieele ST· 19-13886 / A / VGray ·····---·•·--··--·-·--····· ---•-···--·--·-·- ·· -- -·--··· ··· ·- ··--·· · ····•···· ·-·· 1 -- ··-·-- · ·· ····-·· -·· ··-· ··· ·· -·----·--· -- ··- ·· 80 Cowlitz Co Coroner 19·663 Ronnie Cox ST·19-13892 /A VGray ·Th~~~Watki;s·- -- --- . ··sr.is-13904)" A. / -·v~~~n-d~; --.. ---·:. -... -· -·- ····-· -- -.. ·----- [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 5 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000066 No. Agency Name 82 King Co Medical Examiner 83 King Co Medical Examiner 84 King Co Medical Examiner 85 Clark Co Medical Examiner 86 Clark Co Medical Examiner 87 Chelan Co Coroner 88 Kitsap Co Coroner 89 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 90 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 91 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 92 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 93 Clark Co Medical Examiner 94 Clark Co Medical Examiner 95 Clark Co Medical Examiner 96 Clark Co Medical Examiner 97 Clark Co Medical Examiner 98 Island Co Coroner 99 Pierce Co Medical Examiner Age Case# Subject Name 19-02394 Donovan Stuhr 19-02427 Branden Cope 19-02412 Roger Sherman 2019-2895 Viola Thuring-Bregenzer 2019-2880 Larry Tonder CH2019-464 Andrew Dickinson . . ---- · - KCl-19-057 Riley Gibson - - - - - - - - - -- - -.. - - . 192284 Wendey Foster 192278 Jacob Dawson 192272 Craig Hunter 192263 John Smith 2019-2932 Steven Hayes 2019-2933 Kimberly Rojas-Flores 2019-2937 Marry Casey . - - - - - - - - . -- -- - - . - - - 2019-2901 Susan Wallace - -- - - -- -- . . --- 2019-2921 nffanyHill 19-378 Phillip Bakke 192313 Kellie Ford .. Note: Returned items are not included Case ID Evid. Desc. Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ST-19-13911 /A/ VL.avender . sr-1s.13!i12 ; s · / · --vt.~~;nd~; - sr-1!i-i.i040 ; i,., -/ ----vG;a~-------- . - -. - - . - . - . - -- . - - -- - - - -- - - - . ST-19-14043 / A - VGray ST-19-14043 / B / VGray ST-19-14044 / A ,,- ST-19-14044 / B / ---- --- . - . ST-19-14045 /A - ~~-!9-1404_5 ,/~ _ ~ ST-19-14052 / A ,,- - - - -·- - - . . -- ST-19-14056 / A / ST-19-14057 /A .,..- ST-19-14059 / A .,,- ST-19-14060 / A / ST-19-14065 J A ,, ST-19-14065 /B /' VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VBlue VPink VGray VGray VGray ST-19-14066 /A ,,,.. VGray Sagittal ST-19-14066 .l B /" VGray . - . -- ·· · . . · - ST-19-14067 / A .,.,,- VGray ~T-!~~~06?/ ~ ./ . __ ~~~a! ___ _ _ ST-19-14069 / A .,.. ST-19-1 4069 / B / VGray VGray ST-19-14070 / A - VGray ST-19-14070 / B ✓ VGray ----- ---- ---- --- - --------- -- ·-- --· -- --- -- ----- ------ -------- ---- ST-19-14071 / A ~ VGray ST-19-14071 / B / VGray ---- ---- -- - ---------- -- ---- -------- ------ -- ----- -- -------- --· ST-19-14072 /A .,, VGray 100 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192318 Matthew Klaniecki ST-19-14074 / A ., VGray --;o,--Pi~r;~ -c~ M~di~,-E;;~ln~~ - - - - - .. - - - . 192304 - -·M;l~-Osb~~-----------ST-19-14075/ A -:/ ----VG;a~ ---------.. -. -------------------.. ---. -. - {R1.0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 6 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000067 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name Case ID Evid. ST-19-14160 / A ... Desc. VGray ST-19-14162 /A' VGray Note: Returned items are not included EvidfHandle Note Return to Other Age 102 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 103 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 104 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 105 King Co Medical Examiner 106 King Co Medical Examiner 107 King Co Medical Examiner 108 King Co Medical Examiner 109 King Co Medical Examiner 192266 192299 192292 John Stockman Ailill Breiner Peter Heryford ·- -- - - -- ·· · - -- - ·-·····--- ·-- - - 110 King Co Medical Examiner 111 King Co Medical Examiner 112 King Co Medical Examiner 113 King Co Medical Examiner 114 King Co Medical Examiner 115 King Co Medical Examiner 19-02453 Joe Ramos 19-02449 Joon Parl< 19-02452 19-02447 Douglas Sykes Michelle Yarnell 19-02440 Michael Chevalier 19-02437 Joseph Webb 19-02420 April Cook 19-02 4 7 4 Robert Mitchell 19-02472 Alice Johnson 19-02470 Craig Taylor 19-02466 Rebecca Richman ST-19-14164 /A/ VGray ST-19-14166 / A / VGray ST-19-14167 / A ,,,- VGray ~~-! ~-~41_6~/ ~ r _ -~~?-~4171 _,/A / ST-19-14173 / B ..- ST-19-14173 / C / VGray VGray SST SST ST-19-14174 i A ,,- VBlue ST-19-14174 / B " Vlavender ST-19-14174 / C / SST ST-19-14175 / B - ST-19-14175 / C " ST-19-14175 / D ., ST-19-14175 / E ,- ST-19-14175 / F.,.. ST-19-14175 / G.,.. ST-19-14175 / H / __ __ __ _ ____ ___ _ __ / _ _ ____ . ST-19-14177 / A / . - . - - . - . - - . - . . ST-19-14179 / A ' ST-19-14179 / B / ST-19-14180. - A-/ ------ ----- -- - / _ ..... ST-19-14182 / A , PTube SST SST PTube PTube PTube SST VGray VGray Vlavender VGray Vlavender 11 6 King Co Medical Examiner 19-2463 Rodney Mulvaney ST-19-14183 / B / Vlavender -· 1,i-i<i~g c~-M~ct1c~1 E~~~i~;; · ---------·1·9~024s1 · - -J·u~tin· s~iih - - - - - sr-1 9.141-ss j A-> .. · vG~a;· ------. --- ------------- ------------------. ---------------. - -------. ----. --------------. --7 · -. --. ------. --.. - . ----------------. ---. -. __ ! ~8-_ ~~:r~~ ?~ ~:~i~l-~~n,~n_e_r ________ ___ 1 ~2~~~ ___ -~~ch~l~e-~~n~ ____ __ ___ _ ~~-~~!~~9~/ ~ _____ __ ~~ra! _______ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ __ _______ _ _ 119 Island Co Coroner 19-379 John Prutton ST-19-14194 /A .,.. VGray ST-19-14194) B / VGray ------ - - - --- --- - - ------ --- - -- ----- -- --- - ----- - - -- ---- -- -- - ------ - - - - -- --- --- ·-- - -/ ·- · · ·· -·- - ·-- - -- --- ---- --- --- - --- - -- --- ---- - - -- 120 Yakima Co Coroner 19-516MVF15 EnriqueArreola ST-19-14196/ A VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 7 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000068 No. Agency Name Age Case # Subject Name 120 Yakima Co Coroner 19-516 MVF15 Enrique Arreola Case ID Evid. Desc. ST-19-14196 / B .,, VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age · ·--------- ----- --- --- · ----·------ ------- · --· - ---- 121 Skagit Co Coroner 19SK0375 Richard Johnson sr-is.1.i19a)s-_;; · -· vcir~n--·-··· -- ----- --- -- . - - - - - - - .. .. - - - - - - - -- - - - - .. - - - - - . - - - - -.. - -- - - . --- - - - - - - .. - . -- 122 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 123 Clark Co Medical Examiner 124 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 125 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 126 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 127 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 128 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 129 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 130 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 131 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 132 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 133 Clallam Co Coroner 134 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191124-169 Joseph Love ---- - ----------- - ------- ------ - 2019-2971 Anthony Hanington 192322 Roy Evans 19-2165 Emily Hamptoo 19-2129 Kenneth Buelo 19-2126 1121 Monroe UDM 19-2139 John Alfino 19-2162 Dean York 19-2172 Brenna Strine 19-2186 Harvey Willey . .. - - - -- . - . . -- - ·- 19-2168 Benjamin Wheeler - - - - - . -- .. . - . - - -- - . 19-C0-218 William Carr 191202-177 Aubrey Forslof ST-19-14284 / A / ST-19-14291 / A .,,.. ST-19-14291 / B / -- - - - -. . - - - - ST-19-14300 /A / ST-19-14300 /B VGray VGray VGray VGray VGreen ST-19-14302 /A - VLavender / ~~-: ~-:43_02/ _ B ___ __ __ SST ST-19-14305 / A ,, VBlue ,,. ST-19-14305 / B PTube ~~-'.9-14305 / C / SST S~-1~1~306_/B / __ . VGray .. ~~-~~14309 / B VGray ST-19-14313 /A ✓ VGray ST-19-14313 / B _,, VGreen ST-19-14313 /C / VGray ST-19-14315 /B / . VGray sr-1s-i4:i1ii/ s· -- --. ve,;a~ -·- - ·-· . - / --· -- - · · ST-19-14317 / B VGray - - - . - - - . . - ST-19-14319 /A,,,- VGray ST-19-14319 / B / VGray ST-19-14446 / A / VGray -.135. s~~h;~i~h c~ M~dl~I Ex~~i~~~ - ... 1°91203~261 . Cy~~ia-Ulridl . -ST-19-14447 / A / . ---VG;a~-. - - - ·--- ----- ---------··- · ·· ·- -·-· ·-- ---- ---1 --· - . -------· •·-· 136 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191204-96 Thomas Boullioun ST-19-14448 A / VGray .. -------------------. -... --------.. -------.. -... -------. . .. -. -. . -. -. --.. -... ---1-. . -. ---. . . . . . . . ... - -----. ... -------. -------- 137 Kitsap Co Coroner KCl-19-060 Robert Morales ST-19-14451 /A VGray 140 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192348 : : !~~ : ~'.~r~:~~~~~i~l:~~0~n~~:::::: _: :: 3~~~~::: -~;_0~1~~ ~~l~~d:o~ :::: :-: ~~-~~-~~5~; ~-; :::: ~~~aj:::::: : ::: :.- -: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : . : : : :: : : : : : : 139 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192358 Eyan Ricker ST-19-14454 .l A VGray donation ------- - -------·· · --1------ -- --------- - ----- -- --- --- ---- -- --- --- ----- Clinton Rave ST-19-14455 ,l A VGray [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 8 of 13 Print 5/1 8/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000069 No. Agency Name 141 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 142 King Co Medical Examiner 143 King Co Medical Examiner 144 King Co Medical Examiner 145 King Co Medical Examiner 146 Clark Co Medical Examiner 147 Clark Co Medical Examiner 148 Clark Co Medical Examiner 149 Clark Co Medical Examiner 150 Okanogan Co Coroner 151 Island Co Coroner 152 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 153 Yakima Co Coroner 154 Pacific Co Coroner - Raymond 155 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 156 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 157 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 158 Clallam Co Coroner 159 Clallam Co Coroner 160 Benton Co Coroner 161 Benton Co Coroner 162 Benton Co Coroner 163 Clark Co Medical Examiner Age Case# Subject Name 192366 Dennis Williams 19-02500 Sammy Dehart 19-02499 Dawn Miller 19-002 41 Vuong Do 19-2508 Lawrence Morgan 2019-3039 Sally Hoptowit 2019-2984 Charles Mason -- . -. - - . - . - - - - - - ... - 2019-3047 Derick Rasband 2019-3008 David Gehring · - -- -·. - . X19-137 Joseph Gutierrez . - -·· · 19-398 Corey Simmons 2019644 Dwayne Alley ... . - · . - -- - 19-547 T46 Leroy Dollicker 1028 Marta Porter . . -- - -- ·-·· 19-2235 Robert Lucas . - . - . - .. - . 19-2220 Ronald Wittkop/ 19-2229 Robert Taitch 2019-C0-225 Kathern Allen 2019-C0-224 Kimberly Bender . .. - - . . - - - -- - - - - . - -- - - . - - . C19-474 Sheila Smith C19-479 Case ID Evid. ST-19-14456 /A .,,. ·sr-is-1«s3 JA-·:,_ Desc. VGray VGray ST-19-14560 / B / VLavender Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ----- -- ----· ---- -------- --- - ----- -- -·-· ····----- ST-19-14561 / B .,,, Vlavender ST-19-14561 / C / SST ST-19-14561 / D / SST ··- -· · - -- ST-19-14562 / B / VGray sr-is-1.iss:i / s .,,. . . sr-i!i-i,iss.1I s. > - sr-1s-1455s 1 13 ;, . . ST-19-14567 j B / . - · sr-1s-1,i514 / s 7 ST-19-14588 / B / ST-19-14589 / B ,,.. sr-1s-14s90 /a·; s-i-is-1.iis1 / 13 / VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-19-14592 / B _.,. VGray . ... - . .... ·,r - ST-19-14593 / B VGray ST-19-14594 /B / VGray ST-19-14595"1 s· / · · · VG;a~--· -· - . . - .. . ·-. / " ... - .. - .. ST-19-14599 ~ VGray Donald Scully . sr-is-i.iiso/ A.;.., .. ·· vG;a~--- . ______ ~~-~~~~~60 (~< -- __ ~?~! _ C19-473 David Dana 201 9-3082 Mortimer Hernandez ST-19-14762 / B ,,,, VGray ST-19-14762 / C / VGreen ------ --------· -··- ···-··-------------- -- --------- ----- ----· ST-19-14764 /A _, ST-19-14764 / B / VGray VGray [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).,pt Page 9 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000070 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name 164 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 165 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 19-2387 166 King Co Medical Examiner 19-02583 Christopher Dennis Edward Webb Gerald lncrocci Case ID Evid. ST-19-14772 / A ,- ST-19-14774 / A ,,, Desc. VGray VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age -sr-iS-iiim-/ ;..-; ----vo;a~----------------------------------- ------ -167 . Ki~g c~-M~di~i Bc~~i~;; -----------1-9--02536 - - -,:e~;a~~-C;n~~d------- ST-19--1-4-783 / B --; -----SST -- ------------------------------------ _ S'.-:~-:~~8! { ? / SST ___________ _________ ___ _ ____ ____ __ _ ST-19-14 789 / B .,, Vlavender ST-19-14789 / C / SST 168 King Co Medical Examiner 19-2256 Torrance Cummings 169 King Co Medical Examiner 170 King Co Medical Examiner 171 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 172 Clallam Co Coroner 19-02573 Ahmed Noor ST-19-14792 / A .,, VGray . - .. - -- - - - - /' ... - - - - 19-02558 Gabriel Puentes-Hernandez ST-19-14799 / A VGray 173 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 174 Clark Co Medical Examiner 175 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 176 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 177 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 191213-115 Joseph Bullen 2019-CO-231 James Washburn 191215-112 Soundarya Narayan 2019-3103 Glenda Buck 191211-38 Te Nguyen 19-2264 Brady Bums 19-2262 Robert Froman 178 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2248 Michaei Koentopp 179 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2260 James Palmer Dennis MichelBook Gary Ebel ST-19-14891 / B / ST-19-14892 / B / - ST-19-14900 / B _,, ST-19-14900 / C / - - __ ~T-! 9-1~90_1 /~ ~ _ VGray VGray Vlavender SST VGray ST-19-14902 / B r VLavender - ST-19-14914> B /" · - VG;ay ---· - -ST-19-14915/s / VGray ST-1 9-14916 /B / -ST-19-14917 ls -/ VGray VGray ST-19-14918 /B _,, VGray sr-19-14s1s-/ s- - - -vo;a~ -------------- 180 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 181 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 182 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 183 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2250 19-2254 19-2270 19-2261 Donald Owens David Oden sr-is-isooo/s>- ·-vG;ay ____ ____ __ ---------- ----- --- ----- ------ ·sr-iS-isooi-/s / -- - VGray - ----- -- - -- ----- ---- · -- 184 Benton Co Coroner C19-491 Cliff Johnson ST-19-15003/ B / VGray -- - - - - ---- - - --- --- - - - - -- - - - -- - - - - - - --- -- -- - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - -- -- - -- - - - -/ - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- - -- - - - -- - - - - - - - __ !~5-_ h~~~~~~ ~~~~n e: _______ ________ ~~ ~9~~~ _ :~~~~:~ _____ _____ -~'.-:~:~~-8./ ~-_/ ___ ~G~ay_ _______ _ __________ ______ __ ___ ______ __ _ _ _ !~6-_ ~i~~~ ~~ ?_o:~~~r- ___________ _ : _ ~~--IJ:'?_0_9? __ ~a.~~~~~~~~ ______ _ ~T•'.~:~~O?/. ~ _ _ -~~~ ________ ___ ___ _______ ______________ ____ _ 187 Pacific Co Coroner - Raymond S-1029 Terry Barber ST-19-15013 / B .,, VGray - - - - - - -- ---- -- - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---- - - - - - - - - - -- - --- - - - - -- - - - - -- --- - - - ------ -/ -- - - - - - - - -- - - ---- - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - --- - - - - - -- - --- -- 188 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2278 1216upriver UDF ST-19-15014 / B VGray [R1 .0-20161 027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 10 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000071 No. Agency Name 189 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 190 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 191 Yakima Co Coroner 192 Yakima Co Coroner 193 Yakima Co Coroner 194 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 195 Yakima Co Coroner 196 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 187 Skagit Co Coroner 198 King Co Medical Examiner 199 King Co Medical Examiner 200 Clark Co Medical Examiner 201 Clark Co Medical Examiner 202 Clark Co Medical Examiner 203 Clark Co Medical Examiner 204 Benton Co Coroner 205 Benton Co Coroner 206 Benton Co Coroner 207 Kitsap Co Coroner 208 King Co Medical Examiner 209 King Co Medical Examiner 210 King Co Medical Examiner Age Case # Subject Name 19-2279 John Lawson 19-2275 Sharon Lawley 19-565 H27 Richard Plumlee 19-557 MVP6 Lakhwainder Singh . - -- .. - - - . - - . - - - - -.. - - . - - . - - - 19-549 H25 Luis Acosta 191218-109 Therese Williams 19-555 H26 Manuel Pantaleon 192452 Cooper Dyson 19SK0396 Arthur Oneal 19-02640 Douglas Walker 19-02627 Devon Cooper 2019-3123 Amber Clinton 2019-3195 Andrew Lutes 2019-3177 Scott Rielly 2019-3183 Ronald Coelho C19-496 Levi Small C19-503 Wanda Cowell-Saylors C19-506 Kerry McSwan KCl-19-062 Ronald Pease 19-02651 Rudi Hirschel 19-02657 Ryan Friend 19-02656 Kolbi Stewart Note: Returned items are not included Case ID Evid. Desc. Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age :T-!~!5~15/~_< -~G~a! ___ ____ __ ___ __ . ____ -- - ----- - -- · ST-19-15016 /. B .,,. Vlavender _ ~~-~~~5~1~/~ _ ,, ___ :!~~~s_n~~ . ST-~~•!501!_ /'. ~ _ -'_ _ _~~~a! ___ _ ST-19-15018 /B / VGray ST-19-15020 / B ,.,- VGray -ST-19-15038-/ B ,,,- VGray . . - - - - . . . - . . - - - . - . - - - . ST-19-15039 / B / VGray -- sr-iii-i si24"f s ·;;-·vGr~~n----. ST-19-15130 /B ,,.,,. PTubeSnap -ST-19-15134 / B / - VLavender ST-19-1 5135/ C / SST ST-19-15154 i B ·/ VGray ST-19-15155 /'s / VGray ·· - -· · - · ,,,- ----· ··- -· ST-1 9-15156 / B VGray - - - - - . - - - . - - - - . ST-19-15157 / B ,,,.- VGray - -- -- -- / - ST-19-15158 / B VGray :T-19-_1525_6_ /B_ >-_ VGray __ :T-19-~5~5? (_ ~ _ _ _ _ VG~a!_ _ _ _ ST-19-15280 / A - ST-19-15282 / B / ST-19-15282 / C / ST-19-15294 ( B / -ST-i9-15295 ;-;._ ✓ VGreen VLavender VGray 211 Clallam Co Coroner 2019-C0-235 Monty Robuck ST-19-15304 /B ./ Vlavender VGray VGray 212 Clallam Co Coroner 213 Clallam Co Coroner 214 Benton Co Coroner 2019-C0-233 Ricky McGowan 2019-C0-238 Joel Blazek C 19-519 Francisco Martinez ST-19-15305 / B / VGray .. - - - -- - . - - . --.. - . . - - . - -- - - - - - -- ---- - -- - - - - - - -- - -. - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - ST-19-15306 / B / VGray · sr-2(}-0003s-; s--; -.. -· vG;;y---------------------- ---------------. - -- ------------------- --- ------- ----- --- ------ --- ---- ------------- ------ ------- -- --- --- ----- ----- - ---------- --- ----------------- ---- [R1 _0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#J.rpt Page 11 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000072 No. Agency Name Age Case # Subject Name Case ID Evid. Desc. 215 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-502 Vicky Albrecht ST-20-00038 / B / VGray -216 -Ch~i;n c~- c;;;~n·e·r- - . .. ... - - - . - c:"riio19.501 .Eri·c-Hoff;rb;; - - • . ST-20-00039. is. ✓ - -VG;a~ - -211 . sk~9 it c; c~~~~~~ -. -.... ---.. -. -. 19s1<.04oa- - -c~n-H~ide. - - - - - - - .• - - - . sr-26.oo041 / s.; ---·vGr;;n X20-001 Cole Garcia VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age 218 Okanogan Co Coroner 219 Whitman Co Coroner 220 Yakima Co Coroner ST-20-00051 / B / ST-20-00053 I B / ------ ------------ - --------- ------- -- - 221 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 222 Clark Co Medical Examiner 19-WC093 Vess Brelsford 19-581 T38 Roberto Davila 192530 Remains Unidentified 2019-3188 Laurel Marquiss 2020-0014 Juan Carrillo 2019-3213 Lena Barnes 2020-0004 Samuel Souken 2020-0003 Kim Croft Kory Mitchell VRed -sr-20-oiios=r;,· s 1 - VGray ST-20-00214/ B / VGreen ST-20-00228 / B ;r VL.avender ST-20-00228 / C " VLavender ST-20-00228 / D / VLavender ST-20-00228 / E / SST ST-20-00228 / F / VGray -sr-26.oom / a j ST-20-00232 / B / -- . -- .. - - -- ST-20-00234 / B / - · ----. · -- -- ST-20-00235 / B /' VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-20-00236 / B .,- VGray 223 Clark Co Medical Examiner 224 Clark Co Medical Examiner 225 Clark Co Medical Examiner 226 Clark Co Medical Examiner 227 Clark Co Medical Examiner 228 Clark Co Medical Examiner 229 King Co Medical Examiner 2019-3210 2020-0006 20-00004 Aaron Washington ST-2().00238/ s r VGray · - · · · · · ·· · - - - - - · · • · · · · • · · · · - · · · · · · Delbert Kinghorn ··· - ··· ·· / ··-·-•· · ·-· ·· · - -·-·-·----····· · ST-20-00361 / B Vlavender . •· ·--·- ---- ·-·--• •·- ----- --- ---- ---------- ---· 230 Whatcom Co Medical Examiner A-007-2020 ST-20-00382 / B .,,- VGray ST-20-00382/ C / VRed Richard Bernard 231 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 200106-397 ~~u~:~ ~arre'.n~~~ _ . : : : : . ~~-~().~~~8_9 /'a./ _ . _ -~~r~:[l >;.::::::: _:::: ~:::::::::.:::::. . .. . 232 Yakima Co Coroner 20-010 Manuel Mendez 233 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 20-0013 Timothy Mead 234 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2286 Zackary Beach 235 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2315 Latoya Holland ST-20-00457 /B sr-26.oii4s2 -. fi 1 ST-20-00463 / B ST-2~63 / C / ST-20-00468 / B _, 236 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 20-0016 John Schuessler ST-20-00469 /B ./ VGray VGray VGray VGreen VGray VGray .. 237 -Sp~k~~~ ·c~ M~d·i~I-E;~~i~~~ - - - - .. - - 19:2·3-19- . - -Willi~~ -Felt;r- - - - - - - - . - - -ST-20-00472/s j . .. -VG;a~ - ......... - - .. - . . - - - - ..... - - - - . . . - . . . . . . [R1. 0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 12 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000073 No. Agency Name 238 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 239 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 240 Benton Co Coroner 241 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 242 Walla Walla Co Coroner 243 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 244 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 245 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 246 Clark Co Medical Examiner · 247 Clark Co Medical Examiner 248 Benton Co Coroner "To Be Disposed" Case Count : 248 "To Be Disposed" Evid Count: 356 Age Case# Subject Name 19-2339 19-2347 C20-013 Mykola Tretyak Ronald Mickelson Robert Simmons 2020026 Jeri Stiles 200109-447 200112 20-0067 Gilberto Saenz Joshua Smith Clando Anitok UDM 20-0069 Kevin Brown 2020-0139 Dan Winston 2020-0068 Jarrett Alexander C20-033 Tessa West Total Case Count: 248 Total Evidence Count: 356 ----c Case ID Evid. sr-20-00475 is·~ VGray ST-20-00476 / B / VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ------- - · -------- ------------ ---------- --- -----------· -- --- - ST-20-00640 /8 ....- VGray ST-20-00643 / B .,,.. Vlavender ST-20-00643 ./ C / SST . - . - - - - - - - - - . - ST-20-00650 /8 ,,,. sr.-~~~7~-/~ ( _ ST-20-00773 / B .-- ST-20-00m j"B / ST-20-00940-; B / .. - -- . . ST-20-00954 /B ST-20-00954 I c r ST-20-00954 / D / ST-20-01299 /B / VGray VGreen VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VRed VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_:.(by Case#).rpt Page 13 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000074 ·-·~··' :·T. . Toxicology Laboratory Evidence Disposition Records . . Evidence Relinquished By: Capron, Brian Evidence Released To: - Setting Final Disposition - Disposed, (by Tox Lab) Transfer Info: [VIA] [Date] 5/19/2020 [Note] Total Case Count: 247 Total Evidence Count: 355 ~ Lab Ci:!~e #. Ag~nc~ Ca§~ #. Subject Ni;;!me 1 ST-17-00299 16-037668 Gurvinder Mander ( 1) ST-17-00299-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-17 -00299-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 2 ST-18-06357 18-014152 Oscar G. Cruz ( 1) ST-18-06357-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-18-06357-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 3 ST-18-07042 18-015454 Daqim Fassil (1) ST-18-07042-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-18-07042-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 4 ST-18-09161 18-019645 Troy D. Egbert ( 1) ST-18-09161-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 5 ST-19-01672 019-000041 Lorianne R. Woodriff ( 1) ST-19-01672-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-01672-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-01672-C One vacutainer with red top Urine (4) ST-19-01672-D One vacutainer with red top Urine 6 ST-19-02255 019-00421 Rusty L. Mullikin (1) ST-19-02255-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02255-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 7 ST-19-02347 19-1483 Ruthann L. Glassman ( 1) ST-19-0234 7 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-0234 7 -B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 8 ST-19-02355 19A00839 Omar Sanchez ( 1) ST-19-02355-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02355-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 9 ST-19-02923 2019-2975 Natalee R. Amsdill (1) ST-19-02923-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02923-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-02923-C One plastic cup Urine 10 ST-19-03331 W19-188 Isaac L. Seavey (1) ST-19-03331 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03331-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 11 ST-19-03452 19W03463 Jennifer S. Dechenne [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 1 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000075 ( 1) ST-19-03452-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03452-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 12 ST-19-03574 19-2332 Dennis L. Gray (1) ST-19-0357 4-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03574-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 13 ST-19-03693 19W03540 James J. Schuyleman (1) ST-19-03693-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03693-B One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral 14 ST-19-03881 2019-000014451 Jolene S. Love (1) ST-19-03881-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03881-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 15 ST-19-04916 2019-6371 Matthew E. Garner (1) ST-19-04916-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-04916-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-04916-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (4) ST-19-04916-D One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 16 ST-19-04930 19-3811 Damon W. Clarke (1) ST-19-04930-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-04930-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 17 ST-19-05089 1911601162 Amy D. Weisbeck ( 1) ST-19-05089-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05089-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 18 ST-19-05090 1911801852 James P. Coffee (1) ST-19-05090-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-05090-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 19 ST-19-05163 2019-00022913 Chad D. Torve (1) ST-19-05163-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05163-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 20 ST-19-05164 19-001409 Isaias Sanchez-Gonsalez (1) ST-19-05164-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05164-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 21 ST-19-05165 19-001346 Juan C. Valencia Ochoa (1) ST-19-05165-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05165-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 22 ST-19-05183 19A02097 Peter M. Cavenaugh (1) ST-19-05183-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05183-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 23 ST-19-05195 19-4262 Alanna L. Upp (1) ST-19-05195-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05195-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 24 ST-19-05471 E19-02953 Nathan I. Sadang (1) ST-19-054 71-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05471-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 25 ST-19-07516 E19-07983 Ram B. Rai Kirati (1) ST-19-07516-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-07516-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 26 ST-19-08628 19W09842 Justin J. HIii (1) ST-19-08628-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-08628-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R 1.0-20190424) ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 2 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000076 27 ST-19-08908 19-01589 Joseghlne V. Vongsengchan (1) ST-19-08908-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-08908-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-08908-C One serum separator tube Serum - Hospital 28 ST-19-09291 1921500225 Kenneth W , Cormier ( 1) ST-19-09291 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-09291 -B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 29 ST-19-10223 19-01809 Edwin A. Wolff (1) ST-19-10223-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-10223-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Peripheral 30 ST-19-10232 19-01754 Lashaun M. Hartfield (1) ST-19-10232-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-10232-B One serum separator tube Serum - Hospital 31 ST-19-11235 19-01977 Jermaine K. Norman (1) ST-19-11235-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-11235-B One serum separator tube Serum 32 ST-19-11236 19-01984 Enrigue Rodriguez ( 1) ST-19-11236-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-11236-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 33 ST-19-11886 19-01933 Tyrone N. Bolds ( 1) ST-19-11886-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 34 ST-19-11908 2019-2442 Deborah L. Nelsen (1) ST-19-11908-A One vacutainer with gray top Other (2) ST-19-11908-B One vacutainer with gray top Other 35 ST-19-12167 19-2116 Emily Parker (1) ST-19-12167-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-12167-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-12167-C One plastic tube Serum 36 ST-19-12269 19-1892 1012 Fancher Rd UDM ( 1) ST-19-12269-A One plastic cup Brain (2) ST-19-12269-A-1 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 37 ST-19-12294 191012-385 Shawna L. Brune (1) ST-19-12294-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 38 ST-19-12307 191016-345 John O'Leary (1) ST-19-12307-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 39 ST-19-12316 19-02166 Kim G. Holding ( 1) ST-19-1 2316-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 40 ST-19-12524 1928402231 Daniel J. Restau (1) ST-19-12524-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-12524-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 41 ST-19-12621 CH2019-411 Michael P. Aeon ( 1) ST-19-12621-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 42 ST-19-12631 KCA-19-106 Annalese Thomgson ( 1) ST-19-12631-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 43 ST-19-12747 191025-365 Keith E. Standal (1) ST-19-12747-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 44 ST-19-12786 19-375003 Dylan M. Shafman (1) ST-19-12786-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-12786-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 3 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000077 45 ST-19-13161 19-2181-11 Morton S. James ( 1) ST-19-13161-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 46 ST-19-13189 19-02301 Martin D. lndalecio (1) ST-19-13189-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 47 ST-19-13190 19-02294 Michael F. Knapp (1) ST-19-13190-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13190-B One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-13190-C One serum separator tube Serum 48 ST-19-13194 19-02293 Joseph K. Antoncich (1) ST-19-13194-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 49 ST-19-13198 19-02259 Daniel E. Gleason ( 1) ST-19-13198-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 50 ST-19-13199 19-02296 Judy L. Wayne ( 1) ST-19-13199-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 51 ST-19-13332 192144 Larry Lane ( 1) ST-19-13332-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 52 ST-19-13333 192151 Noel Cabardo ( 1) ST-19-13333-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 53 ST-19-13334 192149 Evan Suckow ( 1) ST-19-13334-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 54 ST-19-13335 192177 Percy David ( 1) ST-19-13335-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 55 ST-19-13461 19-2077 Amberly T. Masonholder (1) ST-19-13461-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13461-B One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-13461-C One serum separator tube Serum 56 ST-19-13666 19-02376 Cesar 0 . Erazo (1) ST-19-13666-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Cavity 57 ST-19-13669 19-2372 Alison A. Powell (1) ST-19-13669-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13669-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-13669-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital 58 ST-19-13761 191117-94 Matthew A. Dick ( 1) ST-19-13761-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 59 ST-19-13764 191113-305 Nicholas A. Soulias (1) ST-19-13764-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 60 ST-19-13766 CH2019-451 Michael J. Studley (1) ST-19-13766-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13766-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 61 ST-19-13770 2019-CO-205 Rodney Edwards (1) ST-19-13770-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood (2) ST-19-13770-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood 62 ST-19-13773 191118-414 Kari L. Foss (1) ST-19-13773-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 63 ST-19-13774 C19-441 Melanie A. Novotney (1) ST-19-13774-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 64 ST-19-13777 192230 David Kesner (1) ST-19-13777-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 65 ST-19-13778 2019-2858 Jonathan Pfingston [R1 . 0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound. rpt Page 4 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000078 ( 1) ST-19-13778-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13778-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 66 ST-19-13779 2019-2848 Frederick C. SteQhens ( 1) ST-19-13779-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 67 ST-19-13780 2019-2818 Kathleen E. Lane (1) ST-19-13780-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 68 ST-19-13782 C19-444 Theodore Knuth (1) ST-19-13782-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-13782-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 69 ST-19-13784 19-637 Penny L. Turner ( 1) ST-19-13784-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 70 ST-19-13789 19-2105 Terry L. Coleman ( 1) ST-19-13789-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13789-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 71 ST-19-13790 19-2099 Timothy J. Daily (1) ST-19-13790-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13790-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 72 ST-19-13792 19-2102 Maya E. Aubert ( 1) ST-19-13792-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13792-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-13792-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 73 ST-19-13795 19-02402 Wayne L. Newkirk (1) ST-19-13795-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 74 ST-19-13797 19-02370 Valeree A. Neuman (1) ST-19-13797-B One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13797-C One serum separator tube Serum 75 ST-19-13880 19-02385 SteQhen P. Wilson (1) ST-19-13880-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13880-C One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 76 ST-19-13882 19-02396 Tae H. Shin (1) ST-19-13882-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13882-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 77 ST-19-13883 19-02397 Christo12her P. Tharg-Drake ( 1) ST-19-13883-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 78 ST-19-13886 19-02400 Kevin M. Steele ( 1) ST-19-13886-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 79 ST-19-13892 19-663 Ronnie Cox ( 1) ST-19-13892-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 80 ST-19-13904 192254 Thomas Watkins (1) ST-19-13904-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 81 ST-19-13911 19-02394 Donovan Stuhr (1) ST-19-13911-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 82 ST-19-13912 19-02427 Branden B. Coge (1) ST-19-13912-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 83 ST-19-14040 19-02412 Roger G. Sherman (1) ST-19-14040-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 84 ST-19-14043 2019-2895 Viola Thuring-Bregenzer (1) ST-19-14043-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14043-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous [R1. 0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 5 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000079 85 ST-19-14044 2019-2880 Larry 0. Tonder ( 1) ST-19-14044-A One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14044-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 86 ST-19-14045 CH2019-464 Andrew Dickinson ( 1) ST-19-14045-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14045-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 87 ST-19-14052 KCl-19-057 Riley Gibson (1) ST-19-14052-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 88 ST-19-14056 192284 Wendey Foster (1) ST-19-14056-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 89 ST-19-14057 192278 Jacob Dawson (1) ST-19-14057-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital 90 ST-19-14059 192272 Craig Hunter (1) ST-19-14059-A One vacutainer with pink top Blood - Hospital 91 ST-19-14060 192263 John Smith (1) ST-19-14060-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 92 ST-19-14065 2019-2932 Steven Hayes (1) ST-19-14065-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14065-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 93 ST-19-14066 2019-2933 Kimberly Rojas-Flores ( 1) ST-19-14066-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood (2) ST-19-14066-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 94 ST-19-14067 2019-2937 Marry A. Casey (1) ST-19-14067-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14067-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 95 ST-19-14069 2019-2901 Susan M. Wallace (1) ST-19-14069-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14069-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 96 ST-19-14070 2019-2921 Tiffany Hill ( 1) ST-19-14070-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14070-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 97 ST-19-14071 19-378 Phillip I. Bakke ( 1) ST-19-14071-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14071-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 98 ST-19-14072 192313 Kellie Ford (1) ST-19-14072-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 99 ST-19-14074 192318 Matthew Klaniecki (1) ST-19-14074-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 100 ST-19-14075 192304 Melvyn Osburn ( 1) ST-19-14075-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 101 ST-19-14160 192266 John Stockman (1) ST-19-14160-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 102 ST-19-14162 192299 Ailill Breiner (1) ST-19-14162-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 103 ST-19-14164 192292 Peter Heryford (1) ST-19-14164-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 104 ST-19-14166 19-02453 Joe D. Ramos (1) ST-19-14166-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 105 ST-19-14167 19-02449 Joon Y. Park {R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 6 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000080 ( 1) ST-19-14167-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 106 ST-19-14169 19-02452 Douglas J. Sykes ( 1) ST-19-14169-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 107 ST-19-14171 19-02447 Michelle D. Yarnell ( 1) ST-19-14171-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 108 ST-19-14173 19-02440 Michael P. Chevalier ( 1) ST-19-14173-B One serum separator tube Serum (2) ST-19-14173-C One serum separator tube Serum 109 ST-19-14174 19-02437 Joseph M. Webb ( 1) ST-19-14174-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14174-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-14174-C One serum separator tube Serum 110 ST-19-14175 19-02420 April Cook ( 1) ST-19-14175-B One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14175-C One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-14175-D One serum separator tube Serum (4) ST-19-14175-E One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (5) ST-19-14175-F One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (6) ST-19-14175-G One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (7) ST-19-14175-H One serum separator tube Serum 111 ST-19-14177 19-02474 Robert L. Mitchell (1) ST-19-14177-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 112 ST-19-14179 19-02472 Alice N. Johnson (1) ST-19-14179-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14179-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 113 ST-19-14180 19-02470 Craig M. Taylor ( 1) ST-19-14180-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 114 ST-19-14182 19-02466 Rebecca A. Richman (1) ST-19-14182-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 115 ST-19-14183 19-2463 Rodney R. Mulvaney (1) ST-19-14183-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 116 ST-19-14185 19-02461 Justin T. Smith (1) ST-19-14185-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 117 ST-19-14192 192329 Machelle Winn (1) ST-19-14192-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 118 ST-19-14194 19-379 John L. Prutton (1) ST-19-14194-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14194-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 119 ST-19-14196 19-516 MVF15 Enrique Arreola (1) ST-19-14196-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14196-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 120 ST-19-14198 19SK0375 Richard L. Johnson (1) ST-19-14198-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 121 ST-19-14284 191124-169 Joseph J. Love (1) ST-19-14284-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 122 ST-19-14291 2019-2971 Anthony R. Harrington (1) ST-19-14291-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14291-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 123 ST-19-14300 192322 Roy Evans [R 1.0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 7 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000081 ( 1) ST-19-14300-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14300-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 124 ST-19-14302 19-2165 Emily Hampton (1) ST-19-14302-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14302-B One serum separator tube Serum 125 ST-19-14305 19-2129 Kenneth W. Buelo (1) ST-19-14305-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14305-B One plastic tube Serum (3) ST-19-14305-C One serum separator tube Serum 126 ST-19-14306 19-2126 1121 Momoe UDM (1) ST-19-14306-B One vacutainer with gray top Spleen Squeeze 127 ST-19-14309 19-2139 John R. Alfino (1) ST-19-14309-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 128 ST-19-14313 19-2162 Dean M. York (1) ST-19-14313-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14313-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-14313-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 129 ST-19-14315 19-2172 Brenna L. Strine (1) ST-19-14315-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 130 ST-19-14316 19-2186 Harvey A. Willey (1) ST-19-14316-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 131 ST-19-14317 19-2168 Benjamin J. Wheeler ( 1) ST-19-14317-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 132 ST· 19-14319 19-CO-218 William Carr (1) ST-19-14319-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14319-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 133 ST-19-14446 191202-177 Aubrey L. Forslof ( 1) ST-19-14446-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 134 ST-19-14447 191203-261 Cynthia J. Ulrich ( 1) ST-19-14447-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 135 ST-19-14448 191204-96 Thomas A. Boullioun (1) ST -1 9-14448-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 136 ST-19-14451 KCl-19-060 Robert Morales (1) ST-19-14451-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 137 ST-19-14453 192345 Reynaldo Salvador ( 1) ST-19-14453-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 138 ST-19-14454 192358 Eyan Ricker (1) ST -19-14454-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood 139 ST-19-14455 192348 Clinton Rave (1) ST-19-14455-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 140 ST-19-14456 192366 Dennis Williams ( 1) ST-19-14456-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 141 ST-19-14463 19-02500 Sammy D. Dehart (1) ST -19-14463-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 142 ST-19-14464 19-02499 Dawn R. Miller ( 1) ST-19-14464-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood • Peripheral 143 ST-19-14560 19-00241 Vuong H. Do (1) ST -19-14560-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 144 ST-19-14561 19-2508 Lawrence A. Morgan [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 8 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000082 (1) ST-19-14561-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14561-C One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-14561-D One serum separator tube Serum 145 ST-19-14562 2019-3039 Sally Hoptowit (1) ST-19-14562-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 146 ST-19-14563 2019-2984 Charles C. Mason ( 1) ST-19-14563-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 147 ST-19-14564 2019-3047 Derick Rasband ( 1) ST -19-14564-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 148 ST-19-14565 2019-3008 David A. Gehring (1) ST-19-14565-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 149 ST-19-14567 X19-137 Joseph R. Gutierrez (1) ST-19-14567-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 150 ST-19-14574 19-398 Corey M. Simmons (1) ST-19-14574-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 151 ST-19-14588 2019644 Dwayne A. Alley (1) ST-19-14588-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 152 ST-19-14589 19-547 T46 Leroy J. Dollicker ( 1) ST-19-14589-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 153 ST-19-14590 1028 Marla J. Porter ( 1) ST-19-14590-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 154 ST-19-14591 19-2235 Robert J. Lucas ( 1) ST-19-14591-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 155 ST-19-14592 19-2220 Ronald J. Wittkopf (1) ST-19-14592-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 156 ST-19-14593 19-2229 Robert A. Taitch (1) ST-19-14593-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 157 ST-19-14594 2019-CO-225 Kathern Allen (1) ST-19-14594-B One vacutainer with gray top Spleen Squeeze 158 ST-19-14595 2019-CO-224 Kimberly Bender ( 1) ST-19-14595-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 159 ST-19-14599 C19-474 Sheila Smith ( 1) ST-19-14599-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 160 ST-19-14760 C19-479 Donald E. Scully (1) ST-19-14760-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14760-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 161 ST-19-14762 C19-473 David A. Dana (1) ST-19-14762-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14762-C One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 162 ST-19-14764 2019-3082 Mortimer M. Hernandez ( 1) ST-19-14 764-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14764-8 One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 163 ST-19-14772 192418 Christopher Dennis (1) ST-19-14772-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 164 ST-19-14774 19-2387 Edward Webb (1) ST-19-14774-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 165 ST-19-14777 19-02583 Gerald N. lncrocci (1) ST-19-14777-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 9 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000083 166 ST-19-14783 19-02536 Terrance L. Conrad ( 1) ST-19-14783-8 One serum separator tube Serum (2) ST-19-14783-C One serum separator tube Serum 167 ST-19-14789 19-2256 Torrance J. Cummings ( 1) ST-19-14789-8 One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14789-C One serum separator tube Serum 168 ST-19-14792 19-02573 Ahmed A Noor ( 1) ST-19-14792-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 169 ST-19-14799 19-02558 Gabriel Puentes-Hernandez (1) ST-19-14799-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 170 ST-19-14891 191213-115 Joseph N. Bullen (1) ST-19-14891-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 171 ST-19-14892 2019-CO-231 James E. Washburn (1) ST-19-14892-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 172 ST-19-14900 191215-112 Sounda[Ya Narayan ( 1) ST-19-14900-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14900-C One serum separator tube Serum 173 ST-19-14901 2019-3103 Glenda J. Buck (1) ST-19-14901-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 174 ST-19-14902 191211-38 Te T. Nguyen (1) ST-19-14902-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 175 ST-19-14914 19-2264 Brady Burns (1) ST-19-14914-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 176 ST-19-14915 19-2262 Robert L. Froman (1) ST-19-14915-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 177 ST-19-14916 19-2248 Michael Koentopp ( 1) ST-19-14916-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 178 ST-19-14917 19-2260 James L. Palmer (1) ST-19-14917-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 179 ST-19-14918 19-2250 Dennis B. MichelBook (1) ST-19-14918-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 180 ST-19-14919 19-2254 Ga[Y H. Ebel (1) ST-19-14919-B One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral 181 ST-19-15000 19-2270 Donald J. Owens (1) ST-19-15000-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 182 ST-19-15001 19-2261 David M. Oden (1) ST-19-15001-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 183 ST-19-15003 C19-491 Cliff D. Johnson (1) ST-19-15003-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 184 ST-19-15008 CH2019-492 Grego[Y I. Ness (1) ST-19-15008-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 185 ST-19-15009 19-WC092 Ma[Y Ann Bowman (1) ST-19-15009-B One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 186 ST-19-15013 S-1029 Ter[Y R. Barber (1) ST-19-15013-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 187 ST-19-15014 19-2278 1216upriver UDF (1) ST-19-1 5014-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 188 ST-19-15015 19-2279 John M. Lawson {R1 .0-20190424) ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 10 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000084 (1) ST-19-15015-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 189 ST-19-15016 19-2275 Sharon M. Lawley (1) ST-19-15016-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-15016-C One plastic tube with snap top Serum - Hospital 190 ST-19-15017 19-565 H27 Richard Plumlee (1) ST-19-15017-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 191 ST-19-15018 19-Q57 MVP6 Lakhwainder M. Singh (1) ST-19-15018-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 192 ST-19-15020 19-549 H25 Luis Acosta ( 1) ST-19-15020-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 193 ST-19-15038 191218-109 Therese Williams (1) ST-19-15038-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 194 ST-19-15039 19-555 H26 Manuel M. Pantaleon (1) ST-19-15039-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 195 ST-19-15124 192452 Cooper Dyson (1) ST-19-15124-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 196 ST-19-15130 19SK0396 Arthur F. Oneal (1) ST-19-15130-B One plastic tube with snap top Vitreous 197 ST-19-15134 19-02640 Douglas Walker ( 1) ST-19-15134-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 198 ST-19-15135 19-02627 Devon M. Cooper (1) ST-19-15135-C One serum separator tube Serum 199 ST-19-15154 2019-3123 Amber Clinton (1) ST-19-15154-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 200 ST-19-15155 2019-3195 Andrew W. Lutes (1) ST-19-15155-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 201 ST-19-15156 2019-3177 Scott A. Rielly ( 1) ST-19-15156-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 202 ST-19-15157 2019-3183 Ronald P. Coelho (1) ST-19-15157-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 203 ST-19-15158 C19-496 Levi Small ( 1) ST-19-15158-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 204 ST-19-15256 C19-503 Wanda Cowell-Saylors ( 1) ST-19-15256-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 205 ST-19-15257 C19-506 Kerry McSwan ( 1) ST-19-15257-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 206 ST-19-15280 KCl-19-062 Ronald A. Pease ( 1) ST-19-15280-A One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 207 ST-19-15282 19-02651 Rudi Hirsche! ( 1) ST-19-15282-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-15282-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 208 ST-19-15294 19-02657 Ryan M. Friend (1) ST-19-15294-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 209 ST-19-15295 19-02656 Kolbi J. Stewart (1) ST-19-15295-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 210 ST-19-15304 2019-CO-235 Monty Robuck (1) ST-19-15304-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 211 ST-19-15305 2019-C0-233 Ricky McGowan [R 1. 0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound. rpt Page 11 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000085 (1) ST-19-15305-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 212 ST-19-15306 2019-CO-238 Joel Blazek ( 1) ST-19-15306-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 213 ST-20-00036 C19-519 Francisco Martinez (1) ST-20-00036-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 214 ST-20-00038 CH2019-502 Vicky L. Albrecht ( 1) ST-20-00038-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 215 ST-20-00039 CH2019-501 Eric M. Hofferber (1) ST-20-00039-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 216 ST-20-00041 19SK0408 Carl P. Heide (1) ST-20-00041-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 217 ST-20-00051 X20-001 Cole W. Garcia ( 1) ST-20-00051-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 218 ST-20-00053 19-WC093 Vess L. Brelsford (1) ST-20-00053-B One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 219 ST-20-00057 19-581 T38 Roberto A. Davila ( 1) ST-20-00057-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 220 ST-20-00214 192530 Remains Unidentified ( 1) ST-20-00214-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 221 ST-20-00228 2019-3188 Laurel Marquiss ( 1) ST-20-00228-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-20-00228-C One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-20-00228-D One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (4) ST-20-00228-E One serum separator tube Serum (5) ST-20-00228-F One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 222 ST-20-00229 2020-0014 Juan J. Carrillo ( 1) ST-20-00229-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 223 ST-20-00232 2019-3213 Lena D. Barnes (1) ST-20-00232-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 224 ST-20-00234 2020-0004 Samuel Souken (1) ST-20-00234-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 225 ST-20-00235 2020-0003 Kim Croft (1) ST-20-00235-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 226 ST-20-00236 2019-3210 Kory E. Mitchell (1) ST-20-00236-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 227 ST-20-00238 2020-0006 Aaron L. Washington (1) ST-20-00238-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 228 ST-20-00361 20-00004 Delbert N. Kinghorn (1) ST-20-00361-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 229 ST-20-00382 A-007-2020 Richard T. Bernard (1) ST-20-00382-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-20-00382-C One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 230 ST-20-00389 200106-397 Courtney A. Larreinaga ( 1) ST-20-00389-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 231 ST-20-00457 20-010 Manuel T. Mendez (1) ST-20-00457-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 232 ST-20-00462 20-0013 Timothy 0. Mead (1) ST-20-00462-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1. 0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 12 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000086 233 ST-20-00463 19-2286 Zackary Beach (1) ST-20-00463-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-20-00463-C One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 234 ST-20-00468 19-2315 Latoya L. Holland (1) ST-20-00468-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 235 ST-20-00469 20-0016 John L. Schuessler (1) ST-20-00469-B - One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 236 ST-20-00472 19-2319 William N. Felter (1) ST-20-004 72-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 237 ST-20-00475 19-2339 Mykola Tretyak ( 1) ST-20-004 75-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 238 ST-20-00476 19-2347 Ronald P. Mickelson ( 1) ST-20-004 76-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 239 ST-20-00640 C20-013 Robert W. Simmons (1) ST-20-00640-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 240 ST-20-00643 2020026 Jeri R. Stiles (1 ) ST-20-00643-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-20-00643-C One serum separator tube Serum 241 ST-20-00650 200109-417 Gilberto M. Saenz ( 1) ST-20-00650-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 242 ST-20-00754 200112 Joshua Smith ( 1) ST-20-00754-8 One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 243 ST-20-00773 20-0067 Ciancio Anitok UDM (1) ST-20-00773-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 244 ST-20-00777 20-0069 Kevin W. Brown ( 1) ST-20-00777-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 245 ST-20-00940 2020-0139 Dan W. Winston (1) ST-20-00940-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 246 ST-20-00954 2020-0068 Jarrett R. Alexander (1) ST-20-00954-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous (2) ST-20-00954-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (3) ST-20-00954-D One vacutainer with red top Urine 247 ST-20-01299 C20-033 Tessa P. West (1) ST-20-01299-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central SIGNATURES Evidence Disposed By: Signature of the Supervisor: Date: ) / (°l I 2.-v [R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 13 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000087 March 18, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Former Sergeant Sean M. Carr Dear Mr. Brown: On February 25, 2021, the Office of the Kitsap County Prosecuting Attorney provided a Potential Impeachment Disclosure (PID) notification regarding the above named employee. The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is advising of the Kitsap County PID notification pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1983) for your review and distribution as you deem appropriate. The WSP Office of Professional Standards completed an administrative investigation into the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while on duty, sergeant blocked a female employee's vehicle with his patrol vehicle, assaulted her by grabbing her arm, and then verbally and physically compelled her to perform a sexual act. It is further alleged sergeant, while on duty, used his patrol vehicle to influence the employee to pull over and then compelled her to engage in sexual activity. It is also alleged, while on duty, sergeant used state resources to solicit and participate in sexual acts with the female on multiple occasions. It is further alleged sergeant sent the female sexually explicit images and/or videos of himself in uniform. It is also alleged sergeant sent the female an excessive number of electronic messages while on duty.” Prior to the case being closed, the employee resigned his position with the WSP effective July 19, 2020. Therefore, the department neither has now, nor anticipates having in the future, a finding or determination regarding these allegations. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Assistant Chief Robert E. Huss, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000088 August 23, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Retired Trooper Nicholas Casto, Badge Number 451 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 10, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) received a complaint regarding the above named employee for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged that Trooper kicked and harassed an individual laying in the park. It is further alleged the Trooper was discourteous to the reporting party when they attempted to intervene.” Following a review by the appointing authority on August 15, 2023, it was determined there was no factual information to support the allegation and the complaint was not accepted. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain John E. Matagi, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000089 July 14, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan T. Certain, Badge Number 426 Dear Mr. Brown: On October 8, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper acted in a threatening and/or harassing manner which caused the victim to fear for her life. It is further alleged Trooper stalked the victim and sent her harassing and/or unwanted messages. It is also alleged Trooper violated the provisions of a temporary protection order issued by Snohomish County Superior Court.” “EXPANDED: IT IS ALSO ALLEGED TROOPER CERTAIN VIOLATED THE PROVISIONS OF A TEMPORARY PROTECTION ORDER ISSUED BY SNOHOMISH COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT.” Prior the case being closed, the employee resigned his position with the WSP in lieu of termination effective July 22, 2022. If you need additional information, please contact Acting Captain Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000090 October 8, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan T. Certain, Badge Number 426 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards has conducted an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper acted in a threatening and/or harassing manner which caused the victim to fear for her life. It is further alleged Trooper stalked the victim and sent her harassing and/or unwanted messages. It is also alleged Trooper violated the provisions of a temporary protection order issued by Snohomish County Superior Court.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Proven. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Bellevue P007796-031024-000091 December 10, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tenzin Choeying, Badge Number 1253 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while off-duty, Trooper threatened and assaulted the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000092 December 15, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tenzin Choeying, Badge Number 1253 Dear Mr. Brown: On December 10, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while off-duty, Trooper threatened and assaulted the complainant.” We are writing to notify you a preliminary investigation was completed and no factual information of a policy violation was identified. As a result, the complaint was rejected. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000093 February 22, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper J. Michael Cortez, Badge Number 568 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while off duty, Trooper Cortez operated a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs and was arrested for DUI.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Shane M. Nelson, Yakima P007796-031024-000094 January 2, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Lieutenant Peter A. Cozzitorto, Badge Number 44 Dear Mr. Brown: On June 5, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Lieutenant Cozzitorto engaged in acts of domestic violence towards his spouse.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Jason M. Linn, WSPLCA Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue Assistant Chief James R. Mjor II, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000095 June 5, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Lieutenant Peter A. Cozzitorto, Badge Number 44 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Lieutenant Cozzitorto engaged in acts of domestic violence towards his spouse.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Jason M. Linn, WSPLCA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000096 P007796-031024-000097 P007796-031024-000098 June 16, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Bjorn C. Dahl, Badge Number 1103 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper stopped the complainant due to her race. It is further alleged Trooper acted in an inappropriate and/or discriminatory manner towards the complainant during the traffic stop.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000099 October 23, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Bjorn C. Dahl, Badge Number 1103 Dear Mr. Brown: On June 16, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper stopped the complainant due to her race. It is further alleged Trooper acted in an inappropriate and/or discriminatory manner towards the complainant during the traffic stop.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has concluded, and the findings for courtesy and employee conduct were Proven, the findings for unbiased policing and code of ethics were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue Assistant Chief James R. Mjor II, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000100 November 17, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Former Trooper Christopher J. Daigle, Badge Number 569 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards has conducted an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged the trooper engaged in illicit sexual misconduct with a minor. It is further alleged the trooper provided alcoholic beverages to minors. Expanded Summary: It is alleged the trooper was insubordinate when he failed to call the Bremerton District Office between 3:00 and 3:30 p.m. as directed in the administrative reassignment to residence IOC from the Assistant Chief.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Proven. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain James R. Mjor II, Bremerton P007796-031024-000101 February 22, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Sydney A. DelaCruz, Badge Number 967 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper acted in an inappropriate manner during a contact with the complainant. It is further alleged the reason for the contact and/or Trooper's actions during the contact were due to the complainant's race.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000102 May 23, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Sydney A. DelaCruz, Badge Number 967 Dear Mr. Brown: On February 22, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper acted in an inappropriate manner during a contact with the complainant. It is further alleged the reason for the contact and/or Trooper's actions during the contact were due to the complainant's race.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings for the Employee Conduct, Courtesy, Code of Ethics, and Unbiased Policing were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000103 jf.\ I\JSU[ Cowrnor JOHN R. BATISH Chief STI\TE OF WASHIM,101', 'vVAStllNCTON ST,ATE PA-I ROI. f'O llo\ llhl 1 • Ol\ntpi,1, W,i,.hington 'Hl504-2b11 • lh0-i04-4220 • \\\H\.w~p.w,l go, October 22, 2013 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Trooper David S. Dixon Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named WSP employee: A 1992 allegation that Dixon was untruthful in alleging misconduct regarding his sergeant and another trooper. If you need additional information, please contact me, at (360) 704-2333. TWM:dp Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards cc: Captain Jay Cabezuela, Homeland Security Division Assistant Chief Christopher T. Gundermann, Investigative Services Bureau Deputy Chief G. Curt Hattell 0 P007796-031024-000104 JAY INSLEE Governor JOHN R. BATISTE Chief STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL Washington State Patrol Headquarters • PO Box 42600 • Olympia WA 98504-2600 • www.wsp.wa.gov December 12, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Avenue SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Drager Compliance Dear Mr. Brown, This correspondence is follow-up to the Washington State Patrol’s (WSP) letter dated July 11, 2022, regarding potential impeachment disclosure information related to Dr. Fiona Couper, the State Toxicologist. Our initial notification was made following a June 13, 2022, Kitsap County District Court order to suppress breath test results obtained by the Dräger Alcotest 9510. This order concluded that the instrument’s internal calculations failed to follow the protocols promulgated in WAC 448-16-060. Within the order, the court found: 1. Dr. Couper’s office provided inaccurate, incomplete, and/or false or misleading information to WAPA regarding the Dräger’s compliance with WAC 448-16-060. 2. Dr. Couper provided testimony, by declaration, in a false or misleading manner regarding the Dräger’s compliance with WAC 448-16-060. Background In November 2008, the WSP started the procurement of a new evidential breath test instrument and identified the desired specifications as part of the solicitation. Those desired specifications, approved by Dr. Couper, required any viable instrument to ensure a subject’s breath results be within +/- 10% of the mean of the samples provided. At that time, the approved method for that calculation, as recorded in WAC 448-16-060, included rounding the mean of those samples to four decimal places. In December 2010, Dr. Couper approved the Dräger Alcotest 9510 as a suitable instrument for the quantitative measurement of alcohol in a person’s breath. However, as it related to the +/- 10% calculation, the Dräger was programmed to truncate the mean at four decimal places, which differed from the method of rounding as prescribed in the WAC. Effective December 31, 2010, Dr. Couper amended WAC 448-16-060, but failed to modify the rounding provisions from previous WACs to require truncating. On June 3, 2021, the WSP was advised of a legal brief filed in Snohomish County District Court that argued the Dräger’s calculations contradicted protocols established in WAC 448-16-060. P007796-031024-000105 Mr. Russell Brown Page 2 December 12, 2022 On June 16, 2021, after researching the matter further, the WSP’s Impaired Driving Section (IDS) notified WAPA (and cc’d Dr. Couper) that breath samples were “potentially not calculated” in accordance with the WAC and confirmed that the instrument’s calculations truncated the mean. On July 8, 2021, IDS sent a follow-up notification to WAPA indicating that a continued analysis of breath test data had occurred. IDS identified eight tests that appeared to meet the acceptance criteria, but were not accepted by the instrument. Furthermore, IDS indicated that no accepted tests had been discovered that failed to meet the +/- 10% criteria. On March 8, 2022, the Kitsap County District Court bench convened en banc to hear defendants’ arguments that Drager breath test results were invalid on grounds that the results were not achieved by a calculation that complied with WAC 448-16-060 requirement of rounding the mean. On June 13, 2022, the Kitsap County District Court entered an order suppressing all Dräger breath tests in its jurisdiction. This order is currently on appeal to the Washington State Supreme Court. In its findings, the district court referenced both IDS notifications to WAPA and concluded that both notifications contained statements that were false or misleading. Each of these conclusions is addressed in turn. 1. Court’s finding that Dr. Couper’s office provided inaccurate, incomplete, and/or false or misleading information to WAPA regarding the Dräger’s compliance with WAC 448-16-060. Regarding the first notification to WAPA on June 16, 2021, the court drew attention to the IDS claim that breath samples were “potentially not calculated” in accordance with the WAC and also that IDS had confirmed the instrument’s calculations truncated the mean, as opposed to rounding. However, the court found that since Dr. Couper approved the bid specifications in 2008, and ultimately approved the Dräger in December 2010, her office was on notice and they knew, or should have known, that the instrument had always truncated the mean as opposed to rounding the mean. Regarding the second notification to WAPA on July 8, 2021, the court pointed to the IDS assertion that no accepted test results had failed to meet the acceptance criteria. The court found this statement to be patently false and indicated that no Dräger test had ever met the acceptance criteria, as the calculation to truncate the mean failed to follow the protocols promulgated in WAC 448-16-060. WSP does not comment on these two judicial findings, but following an internal review of this matter, concludes that the failure to change the word “rounded” to “truncated” when WAC 448-16-060 was amended in December 2010 was an administrative oversight. 2. Court’s finding that Dr. Couper provided testimony, by declaration, in a false or misleading manner regarding the Dräger’s compliance with WAC 448-16-060. In her role as the State Toxicologist, Dr. Couper has provided testimony through declarations that are used in conjunction with implied consent hearings conducted by the Department of Licensing. These declarations establish the foundational requirements for admissibility of the breath test document. Dr. Couper’s declaration dated May 8, 2015, stated in relevant part, “All approved breath test instruments calculate whether the breath test results are within plus or minus 10% of their mean in accordance with WAC 448-16-060. If a breath sample is outside this parameter, no breath test result is generated.” P007796-031024-000106 Mr. Russell Brown Page 3 December 12, 2022 In its June 13, 2022 order suppressing Dräger breath test results, the Kitsap County District Court ruled that Dr. Couper’s testimony, by way of the aforementioned declaration, was false and misleading. Again, the court concluded that Dr. Couper completed the bid specification for a new breath test instrument in 2008, approved the Dräger in 2010, and since that time has known the instrument’s internal calculations were not completed in accordance with WAC 448-16-060. Furthermore, the court concluded that since the calculations did not follow the protocols established in the WAC, a breath test document should never be printed. WSP does not comment on this judicial finding, but following an internal review of this matter, attributes the statements in Dr. Couper’s 2015 declaration to the same administrative oversight that occurred in 2010. Conclusion In June 2021, once the WSP was made aware of the aforementioned Snohomish County brief, the agency confirmed that the Dräger truncated the mean and took initial steps to resolve the matter. This included a June 18, 2021, declaration by Dr. Couper that documented how hand calculations could be utilized to validate a breath sample at any time in the process. In July 2021, after a favorable ruling for admission of breath test results in the Snohomish County case, the WSP concluded that a long-term solution could be identified through the normal course of business. After Kitsap County District Court issued its order in June 2022, WSP explored two potential paths: 1) To amend the WAC to require truncation of the calculations of Dräger breath test results in conformity with what the Drager machine does, or 2) change the software of the Drager instrument to round the mean of the breath test results in alignment with the former wording of WAC 448-16-060. As truncating the mean is accepted in the scientific community, utilized in other portions of the current WAC, and has been approved by the state toxicologist, the WSP started the process of amending WAC 448-16-060. As of November 6, 2022, the amendment to the WAC is adopted and requires truncation of the mean of the breath test results, which the Drager machines in operation already do. Sincerely, Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau SAM:sam P007796-031024-000107 JAY IN LEE Gov rnor TATE OF WA HI GTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL JOHN R. BATISTE hief PO Bo 42611 • Olympia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.wsp.wa.gov October 25, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Trooper Saul Duran, Badge Number 924 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the trooper demonstrated an unwillingness or inability to perform the duties and responsibilities of his position and failed to meet supervisory and departmental expectations. EXPANDED SUMMARY· It is further alleged the trooper caused damage to the Special Operations' Utility Terrain Vehicle while driving up a flight of stairs and failed to immediately report the resulting damage. " If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, ~~ Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeff Merrill, WSPTA Captain Johnny R. Alexander, Special Operations Division Assistant Chief Randall F. Drake, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000108 April 4, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Blake E. Elliott, Badge Number 994 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while serving as a Field Training Officer, Trooper treated a Trooper Cadet unfairly based on her gender.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000109 November 18, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Blake E. Elliott, Badge Number 994 Dear Mr. Brown: On April 4, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while serving as a Field Training Officer, Trooper treated a Trooper Cadet unfairly based on her gender.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded – sufficient evidence existed to conclude Trooper Elliott did not commit the above allegation. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000110 P007796-031024-000111 P007796-031024-000112 JAY l'iSLH t.o\ (·rnor STATE Of WASHIM,lO/'. \VA~r-HNGTON STA.lF PATROl l'O lltn ..\2h 11 • Ohmpi,1 W,i,,hington 'Hl'i04-lb 11 • ih0-70..\-4210 • W\H\.\~•p.w.i.~o, October 22, 20 13 Mr. Torn McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 I 0th Ave SE Olympia WA 9850 I JOHN R. BA.TISfE Chief Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Crime Laboratory Manager Kevin Fortney Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named former WSP employee: 2003 through 2012 Unsatisfactory Performance and Truthfulness allegations that he placed evidence into a temporary storage area of the laboratory and falsely recorded in the Laboratory Information Management System (LJMS) that these cases were completed and reports released. It is further alleged numerous charcoal strip evidence vials used in absorption-elution in 20 separate laboratory cases associated with fire debris case work was found in the bottom drawer of Fortney 's filing cabinet. If you need additional information, please contact me, at (360) 704-2333 . TWM:dp cc: Deputy Chief G. Curt Rattell Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards Mr. Larry Hebert, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau P007796-031024-000113 August 8, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Jason W. Gainer, Badge Number 112 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant assaulted the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason M. Linn, Vancouver P007796-031024-000114 December 5, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Jason W. Gainer, Badge Number 112 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 8, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Sergeant assaulted the complainant.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded – sufficient evidence existed to conclude Sergeant Gainer did not commit the above allegation. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Jason M. Linn, Vancouver P007796-031024-000115 May 17, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Detective John Garden, Badge Number 534 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation: “It is alleged Detective provided inaccurate information regarding a search warrant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Roger D. Wilbur, Investigative Assistance Division P007796-031024-000116 May 28, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper John A. Garden, Badge Number 534 Dear Mr. Brown: On May 17, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Detective provided inaccurate information regarding a search warrant.” We are writing to notify you it was determined the employee did not violate policy and the above referenced investigation has been closed. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Robert E. Huss, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Roger D. Wilbur, Investigative Assistance Division P007796-031024-000117 January 21, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Troy J. Giddings, Badge Number 1163 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while off-duty, Trooper engaged in an act of domestic violence towards a household member.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Dennis L. Bosman, Commercial Vehicle Division Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000118 February 9, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Troy J. Giddings, Badge Number 1163 Dear Mr. Brown: On January 21, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while off-duty, Trooper engaged in an act of domestic violence towards a household member.” We are writing to notify you no factual information of a policy violation was identified and the complaint was not accepted. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704- 2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Dennis L. Bosman, Commercial Vehicle Division Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000119 November 14, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan W. Hagreen, Badge Number 653 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper sexually assaulted the complainant during a DUI investigation, search incident to arrest, and/or while being transported.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000120 November 18, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan W. Hagreen, Badge Number 653 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 14, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper sexually assaulted the complainant during a DUI investigation, search incident to arrest, and/or while being transported.” We are writing to notify you a preliminary investigation was completed and no factual information of a policy was identified. As a result, the complaint was not accepted. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000121 P007796-031024-000122 P007796-031024-000123 Pierce County Office of Prosecuting Attorney MARY E. ROBNETT Prosecuting Attorney REPLY TO: CRIMINAL FELONY DIVISION Main Office: (253) 798-7400 930 Tacoma Avenue South, Room 946 Tacoma, Washington 98402-2171 Victim-Witness Assistance: (253) 798-7400 (FAX) (253) 798-6636 September 12, 2023 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Lab Attn: Forensic Scientist Katie Harris 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, Washington Re: Forensic Scientist Katie Harris, Brady or Impeachment Evidence Dear Ms. Harris: As you are no doubt aware both your department and prosecutors have a constitutional duty to disclose evidence or information concerning possible Brady1 or potential impeachment evidence or information to criminal defendants. The matter referenced was brought to our attention and led the opening of a file which will be maintained in our office. This letter is intended to provide you with notice of this matter. We wish to extend you the opportunity to review the written material provided to us. Please contact the undersigned if you would like to come to our office for such a review. We also extend to you the opportunity to provide us with any additional evidence or information concerning this matter to be added to and included with the evidence and information we keep in our file. Please be advised that any such evidence or information you provide us is not privileged or confidential and is subject to public disclosure. It could also be disclosed to criminal defense attorneys and public records requestors along with the content of our file. Please feel free to contact the undersigned if you or your representatives or attorneys have any questions. Sincerely, BROOKE BURBANK Pierce County Prosecutor’s Office cc: Brady/Impeachment File 1 Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83(1963) P007796-031024-000124 INTEROFFICE COMMUNICATION . . .. •.. . . INASHl·I\IGTON .·· STATE PATROL TO: Ms. Amanda B1ack, Toxicology Laboratory Division FROM: Mr. Brian Capron, Toxicology Laboratory Division SUBJECT: Corrective Action Report - Sample switching DATE: February 28, 2018 On January 23, 2018, Dr. Brianna Peterson alerted me to an instance of non-conforming work by Forensic Scientist Katie Hanis while conducting confirmation testing, The series of events leading up to this notification are as follows: • January 1 i\ 2018: Katie performed an opiate confirmation (batch 180117KB) on a set of 27 cases. Four of the cases in this batch were STI 7-14089, ST17-14090, STl 7-14097, and STl 7-14140. • January 18th , 2018: Katie performed data analysis on batch 180117KH, reviewed the data, and submitted it for supervisory review. • January 22nd, 2018: The batch was reviewed by Dr. Peterson and returned to Katie for distribution of the results. • January 22nd, 2018: While Katie was placing the data in her files she noticed that two cases, STl 7-14090 and STl 7-14140, did not have data that matched her basic drug screen results or drugs suspected by the submitting agencies. Katie checked all of the other cases that belonged to her and did not find anything else that seemed incorrect. • January 22nd, 2018: After completing her review Katie notified Dr. Peterson that there was an issue with batch 180117KH. Katie was instructed to discuss the matter with me the following day and did not return data to two other analysts that had samples contained within batch 180117KB. • January 23rd , 2018: Katie and I spoke about the error and I directed her to re-extract the entire batch to make sure that there were no other cases that may have been affected. • January 24°1, 2018: Katie re-extracted all 27 cases that were originally in batch 180117KB, in addition she also tested four other samples for a batch of 31 total cases (180124 KH). • January 25th, 2018: Katie analyzed batch 180124KB and identified an additional two samples that seemed to have inaccurate results when compared to screening data and confirmation data from the original batch 180117KH. ST17-14089 and STl 7-14097 appeared to have been switched as well bringing the total number of cases to four. • January 251 '\ 2018: Katie notified me of the errors and I instructed her to create a . spreadsheet with results on all 31 cases to include results from: EMIT testing, basic drug screen testing, and the results from 180117KH and 180124KB. I also asked her to summarize what she felt caused the error and send me an email stating as such. Investigation: The non-conforming work was determined to be significant and a corrective action process was initiated. On January 291 \ 2018, I received a spreadsheet from Katie with the results of her 3000-323-00 I (5/96) An i11/ema//011a/ly accredited agency providing professio11a/ /aw e1!force111e11/ services P007796-031024-000125 Ms: Amanda Black Page 2 February 28, 2018 investigation, I also pulled the 31 cases involved and the two batches 180117KB and 180124KH to compare all the data for each case. The results of that comparison are in the table below: STII Emit NPD BDS 011lntes 1801171<1-l H!Ol24KH 17-13615 Pos Neg Mor 46 ng/111L Mor 48 ne/mL 17-13616 Pos Neg Mor 17 ng/mL Mor 17 ng/mL 17-14061 Nc.e. HC 9 ng/mL HC 12ng/mL. HC 12ng/mL 17-14065 Pos Neg ND (MOR<I0nl!.lmL) ND (MOR<IOng/mL} 17-14068 Pps Cod 3 ng/mL Mor 51 ng/mL Mor 50 ng/mL 17-14075 Pos Cod 4 ng/mL Mor 19 ng/111L Mor 19 ng/mL 17-14080 Neg Neg ND ND 17-14084 Pas Cod < I .0nwrnL Mor 20nl!.lmL Mor 19nwmL 17-14D87 Pas NeR Mor 14 ng/mL Mor 14 ng/mL 17-14088 Pos Cod 4 ng/mL Mor 21 ng/mL Mor 20ng/mL Ii;J{6.il Y; ~~r:J:.;f--f;iisJ 1 ~i)~W.~-i'.;; -,:~J\fi-~~-;1-tlrb¥4iiii1;i'ir:'i/ :?vt-t.tJ t :°:;;· r:it?!t\Ma} ;;-~~)l\h~ir_ \:~\\r: i:"17,i',ict;r,:;: ::~;J~it~:; \f-{8ci\J6~;./n';i; ·r·: I /. ·;-; {.' ,,/: ·; iic J1i,:~;;;c . 'i< : : :, .··. :•-; '\ ' . :_· .··•·•···•·· .. / 66 ~5 ,111!/rii:L'.. :: :: :-: :\ /:\ : .. ~}tr~~~;~; }t~r%\0.:t~:~ fJJ;51:~itN~-~~~~;~~:-}~ ~l1~~ ~:t~J~~;:~~ 6~~~iteJ~fJ:~~~::;;y; .~~~~;~~~\- f!~~~-:f~~;~~~~:fi-:~to~f~~~.nt~:tfi~~~:-/:~~::~;.!~ \ :,ih -1\140>< ::,:r,i>;;~ . '. .'i-1C\i;,g1n~J<> ·' · · .. · .. ';' 'a~ i/,;·0~iL ' . .: ./'-' · ·. i :;, · ·.• .. , :.1-ic soi,Wiiu/ . / ·.•· =·:, 17-141 43 Pos Cod I011g/111L Mor 25 ng/111L Mor 25 ng/mL 17-14148 Pos Cod 48 n?/rnL Cod 53 nwmL Cod 51 ng/mL 17-14154 Pos Neg ( A Tube) ND (A tube) Mor 114 ng/mL (B lube) 17-14165 Pos Nol run, limited Mor 187 nl'.lmL, Cod 19 nwmL Mor 176 nl'.lmL (0.SmL, cannot report Cod) 17-14168 Pas Neg Mor 83 ng/mL (C tube, Hos11) Mor 214 ng/mL Cod l 5 ng/mL (A Tube) 17-14 169 Neg OC 35 n.l'JmL OC 32 n.e,/mL OC 28 nv/rnL 17-14179 Pos Cod 2 ng/mL Mor 28 ng/mL Mor 27 ng/mL 17-14 18D Neg OC 23 nl!.lmL Not Run in this batch OC 23 nl!/111L 17-1 4182 Neg OC 43 ng/111L Not Ru n in this batch OC 42 nglmL 17-14186 Neg oc· 1611w111L Not Run in this batch OC 12 nwmL 17-1 4187 Pas Not run, limited Mor 186 ng/mL, Cod 15 ng/mL Mor - 182 ng/mL (0.SmL, cunnot report Cod} 17-14188 Pos Cod 18 ng/mL Mor 415 nl!/rnL Co<l I 9 nl!/mL 6AM 54 nl!.lrnL Mor 417 ng/mL Cod 18 ng/mL 6AM 41 ng/mL 17-14189 Pos Neg MOR 57 ng/mL Mor 55 ng/mL l 7-14193 Neg OCl5ng/mL Not Run in this batch OC 15 nwmL 17-14209 Pas Neg Mor 28 ng/mL Mor 28 ng/mL 17-14210 Pos HC 29 ng/mL HC 30 ng/mL HC 30 ng/mL l 7-1445D Pos Neg ND ND Pos= positive, neg= negative, ND= not detected, Cod= codeine, HC= hydrocodone, Mm= Morphine, OC= oxycodone, 6am= 6acetylmorphine L P007796-031024-000126 Ms. Amanda Black Page 3 Febrnary 28, 2018 Ro9t cause: The root cause of the error appears to have been misplacement of tubes during the elution step. Katie discovered that she had misplaced her tubes into the elution rack backwards and she then moved them into what she thought was the correct order. It appears that she did not have the tubes in the correct order and this directly led to the error being made. Impact: There was no direct negative impact to any cases as no reports went out with inc01Tect drugs identified or incorrect quantitative drug concentrations. All cases from batch 1801 17KH (27 cases in total) were reanalyzed in batch 180124KH (27 cases from previous batch, plus four additional cases) and the problem was isolated to STI 7-14089, STl 7-14090, STl 7-14097, and ST17-14140. From the investigation Katie was able to determine that STl 7-14089 was switched with STl 7-14097 and STl 7-14090 was switched with STl 7-14140 within batch 180117K.H. Evaluation: Katie did report this incident to management and therefore she properly followed Section 4.3.1 .1 of the Quality Assurance Manual (Notification of the Appropriate Authority). She discovered the e1rnr on her own when filing her results into the corresponding case folders. When she discovered the discrepancy she notified proper authorities. Correction/ Action: I met with Katie on January 25, 2016, to discuss the impact of this non-conforming work. I reiterated the absolute need to be focused and to pay close attention to details when performing lab work of any kind. I offered suggestions that may help to limit distractions in the lab such as not conversing with other analysts while working on an extraction, letting phone calls go to voice mail, and having another person verify sequences, vial placement, and extraction tube order if necessary. Follow-up/Monitoring: With her impending maternity leave approaching she has finished up her assigned cases and. has been working on the TOF project within the laboratory. I will follow up with her after she gets back from maternity leave and returns to perfonning case work, PL BC:bc cc: Dr. Fiona Couper, Toxicology Laboratory Division Dr. Brianna Peterson, Toxicology Laboratory Division Ms. Katie Harris, Toxicology Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000127 Capron, Brian (WSP) From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Harris, Katie (WSP) Monday, January 29, 2018 3:58 PM Capron, Brian (WSP) FW: Opiates, l80117KH opiates investigation.xlsx Also - NN has reported her two cases 17-13615 and 17-13616, AC has reported hers 17-14450, and I have placed about 5-6 up for review a.well Just in case you wanted to put a hold on those reports until you have written this up. l<atie Harris Forensic Scientist 3 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division 2203 Airport Way S. Suite 360 Seattle, WA 98134 206.262.6100 phone 206.262 .6145 fax From: Harris, Katie (WSP) Sent: Monday, January 29, 2018 3:57 PM To: Capron, Brian (WSP) Subject: FW: Opiates, 180117KH BC￾Please find attached the spreadsheet with the opia tes information I gathered for the Emit, BDS, and my two batches of opiates. I believe that sample 17-14089 was switched with 17-14097, and sample 17-14090 was switched with 17-14140 during the extraction process. All other results agree well as you will see ln the chart. I am putting a copy of the spreadsheet and my original papers with the info in your mailbox if you need them. Let me know if you need additional information. Katie Harris Forensic Scientist 3 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division 2203 Airport Way S. Suite 360 Seattle, WA 98134 206.262.6100 phone 206.262.6145 fax From: Harris, Katie (WSP) Sent: Tuesday, January 23, 2018 7:50 AM To: Capron, Brian (WSP) Subject: Opiates, 180117KH Bria n, P007796-031024-000128 Per our conversation, I am writing this email to let you know that I have determined that there Is an issue with my most recent opiate confirmation batch, batch 180117KH. The sequence of events is as follows: • On 1/17 /18 I performed the opiates confirmation extraction and placed the samples on the instrument for analysis. • On 1/18/18 I reviewed my data and placed the batch up for technical review. • On 1/22/18 the batch was reviewed and returned to me by Brianna Peterson, • On 1/22/181 began placing the data Into the correct case files. As I was doing this, I checked what I had found In the confirmation versus what was listed/found so far In the case. I noticed quickly that two samples did not match up with the data that I had/what was suspected by the submitting agency. For instance, one case has Hydrocodone suspected, I found Hydrocodone In my basic, but the opiate confirmation returned a positive for oxycodone. I then went through every case from the batch except 3 cases, 2 belong to NN and 1 to AC. All data appears consistent with previous results except 2 cases - 14090 and 14140. I also checked other confirmation results against my basic drug screen results to verify that it wasn't the BDS data that had been confused. I do not bel ieve this to be the case as other confirmation tests confirm the results of the BOS, and the basic drug screens for each of these two cases were performed on different dates and in different batches, • On 1/22/18 after completing the review of all cases in the batch and comparing the results, I notified Brianna Peterson that I felt there was an issue with the batch. BP directed me to discuss the Issue with you the following day. I did not create any reports nor return any data to AC and NN, so none of these cases have been reviewed or signed out by a supervisor/manager. • I cannot explain what occurred during the extraction/analysis of this batch that caused this discrepancy. I plan to re-extract and reanalyze the entire set of samples that were run In this batch on Wednesday, 1/24/18. The only thing I can think of is during the extraction process at the elution step, I discovered I had placed my tubes Into the plastic elution rack backwards and moved them around to be what I thought was the correct order. It is possible that at this stage I did not get the exact order of the tubes correct. I do not know that this is what happened, but is the only thing that I can think of. Ka tie Harris Forensic Scientist 3 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division 2203 Airport Way S. Suite 360 Seattle, WA 98134 206.262.6100 phone 206.262.6145 fax 2 P007796-031024-000129 February 15, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 3, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper made inappropriate comments to another Trooper during a traffic stop. It is further alleged Trooper improperly encouraged, coached and/or pressured another Trooper to make a DUI arrest without probable cause.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed. The finding regarding unacceptable conduct was Proven, while the finding regarding code of ethics was Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000130 June 28, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 25, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to demonstrate sufficient competency while investigating impaired drivers. It is further alleged Trooper was untruthful when providing information regarding DUI arrests.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000131 July 25, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 18, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while conducting a search, Trooper inappropriately touched the complainant. It is further alleged Trooper provided untruthful information in the DUI arrest report involving the complainant.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been completed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000132 August 3, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper made inappropriate comments to another Trooper during a traffic stop. It is further alleged Trooper improperly encouraged, coached and/or pressured another Trooper to make a DUI arrest without probable cause.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000133 August 13, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: On February 4, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, during a DUI arrest, Trooper used excessive force, was discourteous, and/or treated the complainant differently because of her race. It is further alleged Trooper failed to notify his supervisor after having been involved in a reportable use of force.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been closed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000134 August 18, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cale J. Hayes, Badge Number 809 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, while conducting a search, Trooper inappropriately touched the complainant. It is further alleged Trooper provided untruthful information in the DUI arrest report involving the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000135 February 22, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Jeffrey J. Heath, Badge Number 251 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant wrote retaliatory comments within the complainant’s Job Performance Appraisal due to her filing a complaint against him.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000136 July 26, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Jeffrey J. Heath, Badge Number 251 Dear Mr. Brown: On February 22, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Sergeant wrote retaliatory comments within the complainant’s Job Performance Appraisal due to her filing a complaint against him.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Christina R. Martin, Homeland Security Division P007796-031024-000137 March 29, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Forensic Scientist 3 Sharon M. Herbelin Dear Mr. McBride: On May 18, 2017, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged FS3 failed to demonstrate the knowledge, skills, and abilities required for her position based on her duty performance, her failed drug proficiency test and her failed subsequent Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP).” We are writing to notify you, the above referenced investigation has been completed with a proven finding and subsequent employee termination. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704- 2330. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Mr. Ton Johnson, Washington State Federation Employees Director Larry D. Hebert, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau Captain Michael S. Saunders, Office of Professional Standards Mr. James A. Tarver, Crime Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000138 May 18, 2017 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Forensic Scientist 3 Sharon M. Herbelin Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged FS3 failed to demonstrate the knowledge, skills, and abilities required for her position based on her duty performance, her failed drug proficiency test and her failed subsequent Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP).” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Tyler Drake, at (360) 704-2346. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Mr. Ton Johnson, Washington State Federation Employees Director Larry D. Hebert, Forensic Lab Services Bureau Director Mr. James A. Tarver, Crime Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000139 JAY INSLEE l'^P^^'\ JOHN R. BATISTE Governor ^iJli^SIJ^ chief <'^ 'f^^ s^ t^ ^ STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL WSP Headquarters • PO Box 42600 • Olympia, WA 98504-2600 • www.wsp.wa.gov August 21,2023 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Avenue SE OlympiaWA 98501 Subject: NIOSH Health Hazard Evaluation Report No. 2021-Oil 5-33 88 In April 2021, the Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division requested the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) provide a Health Hazard Evaluation (HHE) for the Seattle Forensic Laboratories. The HHE included the Seattle Toxicology Laboratory and Seattle Crime Laboratory Chemical Analysis Section. The focus of the HHE was to evaluate the potential for occupational exposure to illicit drugs among employees working in these laboratory areas. NIOSH completed two virtual site visits in March 2022 and April 2022 and an on-site visit in June 2022. The site visits included confidential medical interviews; observation of work processes, practices, and conditions; ventilation evaluations; and employee hand wipes and surface sampling. The final HHE report, received August 17,2023,is attached herein and will be available on our public websites. In the final HHE Report, NIOSH provided recommendations to further minimize exposure risk to employees and improve safety training among laboratory personnel. The safety and wellness of our employees is paramount and the Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau is committed to: • Strengthening training on personal protective equipment (PPE) and consistent use of PPE • Updating Manuals/Policies to provide clearer guidance on task-based PPE requirements • Augmenting cleaning methodologies and the use of local exhaust ventilation (fume hoods) to further minimize background levels of drugs detected on surfaces For questions regarding the evaluation, report and recommendations please contact: Mr. Gene Lawrence Ms. Lizz Gough Crime Laboratory Division Commander Toxicology Laboratory Division Commander gene.la\vrence/a).wsp.wa.gov elizabeth.gough/a)wsp.wa.gov (206) 262-6^)5 0 (206) 262-61 00 Dr. yiona J. Couper Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau FC:GL:LG:ch Enclosure P007796-031024-000140 P007796-031024-000141 P007796-031024-000142 P007796-031024-000143 P007796-031024-000144 P007796-031024-000145 P007796-031024-000146 P007796-031024-000147 P007796-031024-000148 P007796-031024-000149 P007796-031024-000150 P007796-031024-000151 P007796-031024-000152 P007796-031024-000153 P007796-031024-000154 P007796-031024-000155 P007796-031024-000156 P007796-031024-000157 P007796-031024-000158 P007796-031024-000159 P007796-031024-000160 P007796-031024-000161 P007796-031024-000162 P007796-031024-000163 P007796-031024-000164 P007796-031024-000165 P007796-031024-000166 P007796-031024-000167 P007796-031024-000168 P007796-031024-000169 P007796-031024-000170 P007796-031024-000171 P007796-031024-000172 P007796-031024-000173 P007796-031024-000174 P007796-031024-000175 P007796-031024-000176 P007796-031024-000177 P007796-031024-000178 P007796-031024-000179 P007796-031024-000180 P007796-031024-000181 P007796-031024-000182 P007796-031024-000183 P007796-031024-000184 P007796-031024-000185 P007796-031024-000186 P007796-031024-000187 P007796-031024-000188 May 3, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper David M. Hinchliff, Badge Number 815 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper failed to take appropriate actions during a traffic stop after observing and/or being made aware of potential criminal activity.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jeffrey D. Closner, Wenatchee P007796-031024-000189 July 25, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper David M. Hinchliff, Badge Number 815 Dear Mr. Brown: On May 3, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to take appropriate actions during a traffic stop after observing and/or being made aware of potential criminal activity.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Proven. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jeffrey D. Closner, Wenatchee P007796-031024-000190 March 27, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Brandon S. Hyatt, Badge Number #496 Dear Mr. Brown: On December 16, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper Hyatt acted in an inappropriate and/or discriminatory manner when he made a comment towards the complainant.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings for employee conduct and courtesy were Proven, and the code of ethics allegation was Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000191 December 16, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Brandon Hyatt, Badge Number #496 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper Hyatt acted in an inappropriate and/or discriminatory manner when he made a comment towards the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000192 October 8, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Hyungjun, Badge Number 424 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged that Trooper conducted an unsafe U-turn and was struck, causing a collision. It is further alleged that Trooper provided untruthful information regarding the collision to the on-scene sergeant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000193 Potential Impeachment Disclosure Concerning Evidential Breath Test Results June 16, 2021 Terminology “Truncation means a cutoff of the measurement at two decimal places without regard to the value of any number in the third decimal place. It differs from the colloquial meaning of ‘rounding off’ the second decimal place downward or upward by consideration of the third decimal place number.” Com. v. Hourican, 85 Mass. App. Ct. 408, 412, 10 N.E.3d 646, 650 (2014) “The effect of truncating, as opposed to rounding, is to under-report the concentration, to the benefit of the arrestee.” State v. Chun, 194 N.J. 54, 83, 943 A.2d 114, cert. denied, --- U.S. ----, 129 S.Ct. 158, 172 L.Ed.2d 41 (2008). Washington Law Statutory foundational requirements for admission of breath tests. (1) Upon the trial of any civil or criminal action or proceeding arising out of acts alleged to have been committed by anyperson while driving or in actual physical control of a vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor or any drug, if On June 3, 2021, the Washington State Patrol Impaired Driving Section (IDS) was notified that the process used by the Draeger Alcotest 9510 to determine agreement of duplicate breath samples is potentially not calculated in accordance with the Washington Administrative Code (WAC 448-16-060). The WAC states, for determining whether two breath samples agree to within ± 10 % of their mean, the mean of the four breath test results is calculated and rounded to four decimal places. Initial investigation indicates the Draeger Alcotest performs this mean calculation and truncates to four decimal places. A comprehensive review of approximately 81,000 evidential breath test results has been initiated. To date, preliminary evaluation of these results has found no instance of a subject test which was accepted at the time of the breath test (samples within ± 10% of the truncated mean) but would not be acceptable where the mean is rounded. Only four (4) tests appear to have met the acceptance criteria outlined in WAC 448-16-060 and were not accepted. Page 1 of 4 P007796-031024-000194 the person's alcohol concentration is less than 0.08 or the person's THC concentration is less than 5.00, it is evidence that may be considered with other competent evidence in determining whether the person was under the influence of intoxicating liquor or any drug. (2)(a) The breath analysis of the person's alcohol concentration shall be based upon grams of alcohol per two hundred ten liters of breath. (b) The blood analysis of the person's THC concentration shall be based upon nanograms per milliliter of whole blood. (c) The foregoing provisions of this section shall not be construed as limiting the introduction of any other competent evidence bearing upon the question whether the person was under the influence of intoxicating liquor or any drug. (3) Analysis of the person's blood or breath to be considered valid under the provisions of this section or RCW 46.61.502 or 46.61.504 shall have been performed according to methods approved by the state toxicologist and by an individual possessing a valid permit issued by the state toxicologist for this purpose. The state toxicologist is directed to approve satisfactory techniques or methods, to supervise the examination of individuals to ascertain their qualifications and competence to conduct such analyses, and to issue permits which shall be subject to termination or revocation at the discretion of the state toxicologist. (4)(a) A breath test performed by any instrument approved by the state toxicologist shall be admissible at trial or in an administrative proceeding if the prosecution or department produces prima facie evidence of the following: (i) The person who performed the test was authorized to perform such test by the state toxicologist; (ii) The person being tested did not vomit or have anything to eat, drink, or smoke for at least fifteen minutes prior to administration of the test; (iii) The person being tested did not have any foreign substances, not to include dental work or piercings, fixed or removable, in his or her mouth at the beginning of the fifteen-minute observation period; (iv) Prior to the start of the test, the temperature of any liquid simulator solution utilized as an external standard, as measured by a thermometer approved of by the state toxicologist was thirty-four degrees centigrade plus or minus 0.3 degrees centigrade; Page 2 of 4 P007796-031024-000195 (v) The internal standard test resulted in the message "verified"; (vi) The two breath samples agree to within plus or minus ten percent of their mean to be determined by the method approved by the state toxicologist; (vii) The result of the test of the liquid simulator solution external standard or dry gas external standard result did lie between .072 to .088 inclusive; and (viii) All blank tests gave results of .000. (b) For purposes of this section, "prima facie evidence" is evidence of sufficient circumstances that would support a logical and reasonable inference of the facts sought to be proved. In assessing whether there is sufficient evidence of the foundational facts, the court or administrative tribunal is to assume the truth of the prosecution's or department's evidence and all reasonable inferences from it in a light most favorable to the prosecution or department. (c) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to prevent the subject of the test from challenging the reliability or accuracy of the test, the reliability or functioning of the instrument, or any maintenance procedures. Such challenges, however, shall not preclude the admissibility of the test once the prosecution or department has made a prima facie showing of the requirements contained in (a) of this subsection. Instead, such challenges may be considered by the trier of fact in determining what weight to give to the test result. . . . RCW 46.61.506. Calculation method approved by the state toxicologist: Determining agreement of duplicate breath samples. Pursuant to RCW 46.61.506 the following method is approved for determining whether two breath samples agree to within plus or minus ten percent of their mean. (1) The breath test results will be reported, truncated to three decimal places. (2) For the DataMaster instruments, the mean of the two breath test results will be calculated and rounded to four decimal places. For the Drager instrument, the mean of all four results will be calculated and rounded to four decimal places. (3) The lower acceptable limit will be determined by multiplying the above mean by 0.9, and truncating to three decimal places. (4) The upper acceptable limit will be determined by multiplying the mean Page 3 of 4 P007796-031024-000196 by 1.1 and truncating to three decimal places. (5) If the individual results fall within and inclusive of the upper and lower acceptable limits, the two breath samples are valid. WAC 448-16-060 Legal Analysis The information regarding how the Draeger device performs the ± 10 % calculation is clearly potentially exculpatory and must (has been) disclosed to the defense bar. But, post-conviction disclosure of potential impeachment information alone does not provide a basis for vacating a conviction. See Strickler v. Greene, 527 U.S. 263, 281-82 (1999) (“the term ‘Brady violation’ is sometimes used to refer to any breach of the broad obligation to disclose exculpatoryevidence -- that is, to anysuppression of so-called ‘Bradymaterial’ -- although, strictly speaking, there is never a real ‘Brady violation’ unless the nondisclosure was so serious that there is a reasonable probability that the suppressed evidence would have produced a different verdict.”). A due process violation (“Brady”) that merits post-conviction relief only“where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment.” Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87 (1963). Evidence is material if there is “a reasonable probability” that disclosing it would have changed the outcome of the proceeding. “A ‘reasonable probability’ [is] ‘a probability sufficient to undermine confidence in the outcome.” United States v. Bagley, 473 U.S. 667, 682 (1985) (quoting Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 694 (1984)). There are two separate ways in which the non-WAC complaint calculation might be material: admissibility and accuracy. The admissibility of the breath test in light of this information is still possible pursuant to RCW 46.61.506(2)(4)(a) because the WAC merely sets out the proper calculation and does not state that the Draeger instrument is the only way the calculation can be performed. Thus, the question becomes whether the Draeger produces and stores readings sufficient to enable a qualified witness to perform the calculation specified in the WAC. If the answer to this question is yes, then the prosecution can satisfy its prima facie showing and the results “shall be admissible at trial or in an administrative proceeding.” RCW 46.61.506(4)(a). How the ± 10 % calculation is performed does not impact the accuracy of the test itself. What impacts the accuracy of the breath test is whether the individual readings are within ± 10 %. Except for those cases in which a calculation performed in accordance with WAC 448-16-060 is outside of the ± 10% calculation, the Draeger’s non-WAC complaint calculation is not material. Page 4 of 4 P007796-031024-000197 May 19, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Thomas J. Johnson, Badge Number 229 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant Johnson failed to remain impartial and/or acted in an inappropriate manner following a collision involving a trooper he supervised. It is further alleged Sergeant Johnson made inappropriate and/or willfully disrespectful statements regarding WSP personnel.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000198 August 19, 2020 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Seth C. Jones, Badge Number 501 Dear Mr. Brown: On January 10, 2019, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged the trooper communicated with a minor for immoral purposes, possessed depictions of a minor engaged in sexually explicit conduct, and sexually exploited a minor. It is further alleged the trooper misrepresented himself while procuring employment with the Washington State Patrol. EXPANDED SUMMARY: IT IS ALSO ALLEGED THE TROOPER WAS UNTRUTHFUL IN HIS RESPONSES TO DETECTIVES DURING A CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION ON OCTOBER 23, 2018.” Trooper Jones resigned from his employment with the WSP effective August 1, 2020. The administrative investigation regarding the above allegations has been closed. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344 or Captain Tyler Drake at (360) 704-2333. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Trooper Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000199 December 28, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper KC J. Jones, Badge Number 767 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged the detective displayed unacceptable conduct when he impeded the trooper from completing his job and was hostile toward the trooper during a traffic stop. It is further alleged the detective was untruthful during the traffic stop.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Trisena M. Sharff, Criminal Investigation Division P007796-031024-000200 March 8, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Brandon W. Kendall, Badge Number 657 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to act in a manner consistent with his duty requirements and failed to respond to calls for service. It is further alleged Trooper entered inaccurate information on his time and activity reports.” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPTA Captain Jeff M. Otis, Spokane Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000201 April 8, 2019 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Brandon W. Kendall, Badge Number 657 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to act in a manner consistent with his duty requirements and also entered inaccurate information on his Time and Activity Reports.” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPTA Captain Jeff M. Otis, Spokane Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000202 June 15, 2020 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Forensic Scientist 2 Raymond S. Kusumi Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above the named WSP employee: On March 4, 2020, Forensic Scientist 2 Raymond Kusumi was placed on a Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP) to address unacceptable performance. The WSP Office of Professional Standards is now conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged FS2 failed to meet the work standards and demonstrate the knowledge, skills, and abilities required of his position. It is further alleged FS2 failed to successfully complete his Job Performance Improvement Plan.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Mr. Ton Johnson, WFSE Director Larry D. Hebert, Forensic Scientist Laboratory Bureau Commander Gene P. Lawrence, Crime Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000203 July 19, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Forensic Scientist 2 Raymond S. Kusumi Dear Mr. Brown: On June 15, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged FS2 failed to meet the work standards and demonstrate the knowledge, skills, and abilities required of his position. It is further alleged FS2 failed to successfully complete his Job Performance Improvement Plan.” We are writing to notify you it was determined the employee allegation was proven and the above referenced investigation has been closed. Further, Mr. Kusumi resigned from the WSP, effective May 26, 2021. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Ms. Christy Reed, WFSE Bureau Director Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Lab Services Bureau P007796-031024-000204 P007796-031024-000205 P007796-031024-000206 P007796-031024-000207 P007796-031024-000208 June 21, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper McKenzy Hawke Leach, Badge Number 1060 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper used deadly force with a firearm without proper justification. It is further alleged Trooper failed to notify a supervisor of the use of deadly force.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Acting Captain Aaron M. Westbrooke Office of Professional Standards AMW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000209 JAY INSLE( Governor JOHN R. BATIST[ Chief STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Box -l2611 • Olympia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-70-l-4220 • \'\IWW.wsp.wa.gov /./Ci. Q.,;;._ __ 0• o January 26, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Corporal Mark H. Lewis, Badge Number 1014 Dear Mr. Brown: On October 30, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Corporal made inappropriate comments towards the complainant and motioned as if he were going to draw his weapon. It is further alleged Corporal's comments and actions were unacceptable because of the complainant's race.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The finding for the Code of Ethics - Officers (C) Performance of the Duties of an Officer allegation was Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Technical Services Bureau Captain Mark R. Tegard, Training Division P007796-031024-000210 November 4, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Corporal Mark H. Lewis, Badge Number 1014 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Corporal made inappropriate and/or discriminatory comments to female recruits during CJTC traffic week. It is further alleged Corporal made unwelcome physical contact with female recruits during CJTC traffic week, some of which resulted in pain and/or visible injury to recruits.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Robert W. Sharpe, Training Division P007796-031024-000211 P007796-031024-000212 January 20, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cameron A. MacKinnon, Badge Number #1257 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper assaulted the daughter of the complainant when he threw a ticket at her, striking her in the eye. It is further alleged Trooper treated the complainant and his daughter differently due to their race.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000213 P007796-031024-000214 March 21, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Juan Martinez Jr., Badge Number #1127 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper stole $600 from the complainant's purse during her arrest.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000215 September 18, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Juan Martinez Jr., Badge Number #1127 Dear Mr. Brown: On March 21, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper stole $600 from the complainant's purse during her arrest.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief James R. Mjor II, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000216 August 13, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Retired Captain Travis W. Matheson, Badge Number 20 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 17, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while testifying in a deposition and/or civil trial, omitted and/or provided untruthful information about his involvement and responsibilities as a Whistleblower designee.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Jason M. Linn, WSPLCA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000217 September 7, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Joseph B. McClain, Badge Number 880 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper was untruthful while reporting an on-duty injury to a supervisor. It is further alleged Trooper knowingly entered fictitious information on an injury exposure report.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain John E. Matagi, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000218 December 29, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Joseph B. McClain, Badge Number 880 Dear Mr. Brown: On September 7, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above-named employee: “It is alleged Trooper was untruthful while reporting an on-duty injury to a supervisor. It is further alleged Trooper knowingly entered fictitious information on an injury exposure report.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain John E. Matagi, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000219 May 25, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Correctional Records Supervisor Kimberly A. McParland Dear Mr. Brown: On June 2, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged CRT Supervisor failed to take appropriate supervisory action when notified coworkers had been using improper pronouns. It is further alleged supervisor imposed different work standards for the complainant due to him being transgender. It is also alleged supervisor was untruthful when providing information for the department’s response to the EEOC.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Ms. Debra Montez, WPEA Commander James W. Anderson, Criminal Records Division Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000220 April 8, 2019 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Thomas J. A. Megargle, Badge Number 660 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged the trooper failed to perform duties consistent with his training and expectations during two separate criminal investigations. It is further alleged the trooper failed to conduct searches in accordance with departmental training.” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffery Merrill, WSPTA Captain Robert E. Huss, Wenatchee Assistant Chief Jeff R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000221 P007796-031024-000222 P007796-031024-000223 P007796-031024-000224 JAY INSLEE Governor JOHN R. BATISTE Chief STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL WASHINGTON STATE TOXICOLOGY LABORATORY 2203 Airport Way South, Suite 360 • Seattle, Washington 98134-2027 • (206) 262-6100 • FAX (206) 262-6145 October 27, 2021 Dear Ms. Loginsky: The Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division has updated the Active Case List￾Meth Result Discrepancies Identified During Testing Document on the Laboratory's website (https://wsp.wa.gov/forensics/toxicology.htm). An inconsistent result for methamphetamine was identified in the testing of ST-20-11433. The inconsistent result identified was from a test performed in March 20211 , prior to the Laboratory implementing additional laboratory cleaning procedures. A root cause analysis was performed and was inconclusive in determining the source of the inconsistent result in this case. The submitting agency and local prosecutor have been notified. Final documentation is pending and will be available upon completion. Sincerely, Acting Toxicology Laboratory Division Commander EG:eg 1 Observation of a potentially inconsistent result in this case occurred in August 2021. Follow-up testing, review and evaluation occurred in September and October 2021. Limited personnel resources contributed to the above timeline. corrected website address link 10-27-21 P007796-031024-000225 January 23, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Lieutenant Jody M. Metz, Badge Number 73 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Lieutenant Metz acted in an inappropriate manner and/or made on-going unwanted physical contact with the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Jason M. Linn, WSPLCA Captain Shane M. Nelson, Yakima P007796-031024-000226 May 23, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Austin J. Miller, Badge Number 1248 Dear Mr. Brown: On December 23, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper was untruthful when providing information to his supervisor.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the finding for the Truthfulness was Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000227 August 21, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Former Trooper Austin J. Miller, Badge Number 1248 Dear Mr. Brown: On September 30, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to properly perform the duties required of his position. It is further alleged Trooper failed a Job Performance Improvement Plan.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the finding for the Unsatisfactory Performance was Proven. Further, former Trooper Miller resigned from the agency on November 28, 2022. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau Assistant Chief James R. Mjor II, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000228 September 30, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Austin J. Miller, Badge Number 1248 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper failed to properly perform the duties required of his position. It is further alleged Trooper failed a Job Performance Improvement Plan.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000229 December 23, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Austin J. Miller, Badge Number 1248 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper was untruthful when providing information to his supervisor.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000230 December 5, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CVEO 2 Marc A. Modler, Badge Number X734 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged CVEO 2 acted in an inappropriate manner and/or made a discriminatory comment towards the complainant.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Ms. Alexis Young, PTE Captain Jason R. Cuthbert, Motor Carrier Safety Division Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000231 JAY IN LEE Governor OF WASHINCTO WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Bo 42611 • Ol mpia, Wa hington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.~ p.wa .go Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary October 8, 2018 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 JOH R. BATISTE Chief Subject: UPDATE - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Forms and Records Analyst 3 Joanne Molstad Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: • On July 26, 2018 Forms and Records Analyst 3 Joanne Molstad was placed on a Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPJP) to address unacceptable performance. We are writing to notify you, the above referenced JPIP has been completed successfully as of September 26, 2018. If you need additional information, please contact me our Human Resources Division at (360) 704- 2320. MSS:mg Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards cc: Mr. Ton Johnson, Washington Federation of State Employees Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Technical Services Bureau Captain Travis W. Matheson, Human Resources Division Captain Michael S. Saunders, Office of Professional Standards Dr. Donald A. Sorenson, Risk Management Division P007796-031024-000232 January 2, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CVEO 1 Vladislav Nehaev, Badge Number X793 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 20, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged CVEO 1 failed to perform his duties impartially and/or acted in an inappropriate manner during a vehicle inspection.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Unfounded. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Ms. Alexis Young, PTE Local 17 Captain Dennis L. Bosman, Commercial Vehicle Division Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000233 November 20, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CVEO 1 Vladislav Nehaev, Badge Number X793 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged CVEO 1 failed to perform his duties impartially and/or acted in an inappropriate manner during a vehicle inspection.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Ms. Alexis Young, PTE Local 17 Captain Dennis L. Bosman, Commercial Vehicle Division Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000234 JAY IN LEE Go crnor JOH R. BATISTI: TATE OF WASHINCT WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Box 42611 • 01 mpia, Washington 98504-2611 • 60-704-4220 • www.wsp.wa .gov Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary October 8, 2018 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 9850 I Chief Subject: UPDATE - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Forensic Scientist 3 David Vu X Nguyen Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: Forensic Scientist 3 David Nguyen has multiple confirmed performance errors and will be placed on a Job Performance Improvement Plan in June, 2018. We are writing to notify you, the above referenced JPIP has been completed successfully as of August 30, 2018. If you need additional information, please contact me our Human Resources Division at (360) 704- 2320. MSS:rng Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards cc: Mr. Ton Johnson, Washington Federation of State Employees Director Larry D. Hebert, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau Captain Travis W. Matheson, Human Resources Division Captain Michael S. Saunders, Office of Professional Standards P007796-031024-000235 P007796-031024-000236 January 6, 2023 Participation in NIST Study (Quarterly Environmental Sampling) – Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Report The Toxicology Laboratory continues its collaboration with NIST in a current study, the goal of which is to establish drug background levels present in a forensic science facility. NIST provides the Laboratory with test kits, which the Laboratory uses to collect environmental samples, and the samples are sent to NIST for testing. Follow-up sample collection from the area with a detectable result from the November 2022 round of environmental sampling was performed 12/21/22. The sample was sent to NIST for analysis and inclusion in the study. A summary of testing performed by NIST is attached (report dated 1/4/23), with test results listed on page 4 of the report. The sample (identified as Bay 9 Under Window) had no compounds detected when screened by DART-MS and no quantifiable levels of any compound in the LC￾MSMS panel. The regularly scheduled full round of environmental sampling, to include additional samples collected from the Bay 9 area, will take place in first quarter 2023. P007796-031024-000237 1 January 4th, 2023 Eric Lo Laboratory Manager Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, WA 98134 Brian, Thank you for participating in our study. The goal of this project was to establish the narcotics background present in a forensic science laboratory. The following report contains the results from the analysis of 1 sample collected from the Washington State Toxicology Laboratory on December 21, 2022. The analysis scheme involved a broad screening of over 1100 drugs and common excipients and a targeted quantification of 29 drugs. We would be happy to discuss these results in further detail with you at any time and hope to continue collaborative efforts in the future. If we can be of any assistance to you, please don’t hesitate to ask. Sincerely, Edward Sisco Research Chemist Materials Measurement Science Division National Institute of Standards & Technology 100 Bureau Dr. Gaithersburg, MD 20899 Phone: (301)975-2093 E-mail: edward.sisco@nist.gov P007796-031024-000238 2 Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Introduction The recent spike in forensic cases containing highly toxic fentanyl analogues highlights the critical need to safeguard analysts from inadvertently encountering these, or other, compounds through skin adsorption and/or inhalation.1 Establishing background levels of compounds of interest in a forensic laboratory can provide drug analysts and laboratory quality managers with valuable information to make informed decisions on a range of topics such as: workflow processes, adequate PPE, cleaning protocols, and occupational safety hazards. Given that trace amounts of narcotics have been reported in a variety of environments including public spaces,2 and that instruments continue to improve in sensitivity, it is important to monitor the environmental background levels of these compounds. For field and/or screening applications, establishing the background is key to setting instrument detection thresholds and preventing false positives.3 This is especially critical in environments where there is an expected higher background level such as prisons or border crossings. In a laboratory setting, high environmental background levels can suggest a need to monitor background for quality and health purposes. Finally, since forensic laboratories continue to struggle with a high number of emerging drug cases and rising backlogs, opportunities for rapid screening / presumptive testing are desired. The ability to screen evidence in a high throughput manner with little to no sample preparation is currently being investigated. To ensure the results from such analysis are from the evidence and not from possible background within the laboratory, a baseline of the environment must be known. Experimental Samples were collected with manual Nomex wipes (Part No. DSW1210P) (DSA Detection, North Andover, MA) which are commonly used for particle collection in trace contraband detection. The particle collection efficiency of this material has been previously measured by our laboratory and results demonstrate that it is an adequate substrate for the collection of trace residues off a variety of surfaces. 4 A total of 1 sample was provided to us for analysis. Upon receipt samples were stored, at -10 °C, until they were processed. Prior to analysis, the Nomex wipes were trimmed in size to remove the unused area of the wipe. The trimmed wipe was placed in a 10 mL amber glass vial and extracted with 4.0 mL of methanol (Chromasolv Grade, Sigma-Aldrich). The 4.0 mL extract was subsequently split into two 2.0 mL aliquots – one for the screening analysis and one for the quantitation analysis. Both aliquots were then evaporated to dryness under a stream of nitrogen. The aliquot for the screening analysis was reconstituted in 200 µL of acetonitrile, to concentrate the sample, while the aliquot for quantitation was reconstituted in 500 µL of methanol containing 5 internal standards. The quantitation aliquot was directly loaded onto the LC-MS/MS system. Chemicals & Materials Analytes for the screening and quantitation studies were obtained from either Cayman Chemical (Ann Arbor, MI), Cerilliant (Round Rock, TX), or Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO) as 1 mg/mL standards (when possible) or as pure crystalline material. Solvents for extraction and the LC P007796-031024-000239 3 mobile phase were Chromasolv-grade solvents purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. For quantitation, the 5 deuterated internal standards were: methamphetamine-d5, heroin-d9, cocaine-d3, fentanyl￾d5, and THC-d9. They were added to 1 L of methanol, providing an internal standard concentration of approximately 1 µg/mL, to be used for the reconstitution of the quantitation aliquot. Wipe materials were purchased from Smiths Detection and used as-is. Quantitation of Drugs by LC-MS/MS In order to have the highest level of sensitivity and specificity for the quantitation runs, a LC triple quadrupole MS operating in multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode was used. The system consisted of a Thermo Ulti-Mate 3000 LC system coupled to a ABSciex Q-Trap 4000 mass spectrometer. Separation was achieved using a Restek Raptor Biphenyl column (150 mm x 4.6 mm x 2.7 µm). The analysis time was 15 minutes with a flow rate of 0.75 mL/min and an injection volume of 15 µL. During the run, a 12-minute solvent gradient was used (95 % water / 5 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid to 100 % methanol with 0.1 % formic) followed by a 3-minute isocratic period (100 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid). The MS utilized zero-air nitrogen as both the desolvating and nebulizing gases. An electrospray ionization (ESI) source was used with a temperature of 550 °C and a spray voltage of +5500 V. A timed MRM was used to monitor two transitions for all drugs (one for quantitation and one for confirmatory identification) and one transition for each of the 5 internal standards. The MRM detection window was set to 120 s and the target scan time was set to 0.1 s. Quantitation was calculated by taking the ratio of the peak areas of a drug to the appropriate internal standard and comparing that ratio to a 13-point calibration curve. Absolute concentrations reported in the summary account for the various dilution and sample splitting steps in the extraction process. They do not, however, account for the extraction efficiency of the Nomex wipe, which is typically in the range of 30 % - 40 %. Screening of Drugs by DART-MS The aliquot prepared for the screening analysis was sampled using glass microcapillary rods. The DART-MS system used a JEOL AccuTOF JMS T100-LP time-of-flight mass spectrometer (JEOL USA) coupled with a DART ion source (IonSense). A 400 °C DART gas temperature, a +50 V DART exit grid voltage, and helium as the ionization gas was used. Mass spectrometer settings included operation in positive ionization mode, a +800 V peaks voltage, a +5 V orifice 2 and ring lens voltage, and a mass scan range of 80 m/z – 800 m/z. To obtain characteristic molecular and fragmentation spectra, the orifice 1 voltage was cycled between +30 V and +60 V. PEG-600 was used as a mass calibrant and AB-FUBINACA was used as a mass drift compensation compound. The resulting mass spectra were searched against an in-house created library of over 1,100 compounds using the NIST DART-MS Data Interpretation Tool. The screening results reported met the following identification criteria: the protonated molecular ion peak of the compound was present at greater than 5 % relative abundance and within ±5 amu of the calculated accurate mass. P007796-031024-000240 4 Results There were no quantifiable levels of any compound in the LC-MS/MS panel found in the sample provided (labelled “Bay 9 Under Window”). From the presumptive screening analysis, no compounds of interest were detected in the sample provided, when analyzed by DART-MS utilizing a 5 % relative intensity identification threshold. As stated in the opening letter, we would be more than happy to discuss these results with you and other interested members of your lab. If you would like us to analyze samples from additional areas, re-sample after any operational changes, or re-sample to monitor trends, we would be happy to do so. If there is any other way which we could be of assistance or form a stronger collaboration, please let us know. Disclaimer Certain commercial equipment, instruments, or materials are identified in this document. Such identification does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, nor does it imply that the products identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose. References 1. Daughton, C. G. Illicit Drugs and the Environment. in Illicit Drugs in the Environment (eds. Castiglioni, S., Zuccato, E. & Fanelli, R.) 1–27 (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2011). 2. Forbes, T. P. & Najarro, M. Ion mobility spectrometry nuisance alarm threshold analysis for illicit narcotics based on environmental background and a ROC-curve approach. Analyst 141, 4438–4446 (2016). 3. Sisco, E. et al. Rapid detection of fentanyl, fentanyl analogues, and opioids for on-site or laboratory based drug seizure screening using thermal desorption DART-MS and ion mobility spectrometry. Forensic Chem. 4, 108–115 (2017). 4. Verkouteren, J. R. et al. A method to determine collection efficiency of particles by swipe sampling. Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 115101 (2008). P007796-031024-000241 P007796-031024-000242 November 23, 2022 Participation in NIST Study (Quarterly Environmental Sampling) – Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Report The Toxicology Laboratory continues its collaboration with NIST in a current study, the goal of which is to establish drug background levels present in a forensic science facility. NIST provides the Laboratory with test kits, which the Laboratory uses to collect environmental samples, and the samples are sent to NIST for testing. In accordance with the Laboratory’s quarterly environmental sampling plan, Toxicology Laboratory personnel collected samples on 11/8/22, which the Laboratory sent to NIST for analysis. A summary of testing performed by NIST is attached (report dated 11/17/22), with test results listed on page 4 of the report. Of the 25 samples submitted for analysis, one sample (identified as Sample #8) was negative when screened by DART-MS but had a detectable level of oxycodone when analyzed by LC-MSMS. The area with a detectable level of analyte, and adjacent areas, were cleaned by laboratory personnel on November 17th. Follow-up sample collection from those areas using NIST test kits is planned, with samples to be sent to NIST for analysis and inclusion in the study. The next regularly scheduled full round of environmental sampling is planned for first quarter 2023. P007796-031024-000243 1 November 17th, 2022 Brian Capron Acting Laboratory Manager Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, WA 98134 Brian, Thank you for participating in our study. The goal of this project was to establish the narcotics background present in a forensic science laboratory. The following report contains the results from the analysis of 25 samples collected from the Washington State Toxicology Laboratory on November 8, 2022. The analysis scheme involved a broad screening of over 1100 drugs and common excipients and a targeted quantification of 29 drugs. We would be happy to discuss these results in further detail with you at any time and hope to continue collaborative efforts in the future. If we can be of any assistance to you, please don’t hesitate to ask. Sincerely, Edward Sisco Research Chemist Materials Measurement Science Division National Institute of Standards & Technology 100 Bureau Dr. Gaithersburg, MD 20899 Phone: (301)975-2093 E-mail: edward.sisco@nist.gov P007796-031024-000244 2 Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Introduction The recent spike in forensic cases containing highly toxic fentanyl analogues highlights the critical need to safeguard analysts from inadvertently encountering these, or other, compounds through skin adsorption and/or inhalation.1 Establishing background levels of compounds of interest in a forensic laboratory can provide drug analysts and laboratory quality managers with valuable information to make informed decisions on a range of topics such as: workflow processes, adequate PPE, cleaning protocols, and occupational safety hazards. Given that trace amounts of narcotics have been reported in a variety of environments including public spaces,2 and that instruments continue to improve in sensitivity, it is important to monitor the environmental background levels of these compounds. For field and/or screening applications, establishing the background is key to setting instrument detection thresholds and preventing false positives.3 This is especially critical in environments where there is an expected higher background level such as prisons or border crossings. In a laboratory setting, high environmental background levels can suggest a need to monitor background for quality and health purposes. Finally, since forensic laboratories continue to struggle with a high number of emerging drug cases and rising backlogs, opportunities for rapid screening / presumptive testing are desired. The ability to screen evidence in a high throughput manner with little to no sample preparation is currently being investigated. To ensure the results from such analysis are from the evidence and not from possible background within the laboratory, a baseline of the environment must be known. Experimental Samples were collected with manual Nomex wipes (Part No. DSW1210P) (DSA Detection, North Andover, MA) which are commonly used for particle collection in trace contraband detection. The particle collection efficiency of this material has been previously measured by our laboratory and results demonstrate that it is an adequate substrate for the collection of trace residues off a variety of surfaces. 4 A total of 25 samples were provided to us for analysis. Upon receipt samples were stored, at -10 °C, until they were processed. Prior to analysis, the Nomex wipes were trimmed in size to remove the unused area of the wipe. The trimmed wipe was placed in a 10 mL amber glass vial and extracted with 4.0 mL of methanol (Chromasolv Grade, Sigma-Aldrich). The 4.0 mL extract was subsequently split into two 2.0 mL aliquots – one for the screening analysis and one for the quantitation analysis. Both aliquots were then evaporated to dryness under a stream of nitrogen. The aliquot for the screening analysis was reconstituted in 200 µL of acetonitrile, to concentrate the sample, while the aliquot for quantitation was reconstituted in 500 µL of methanol containing 5 internal standards. The quantitation aliquot was directly loaded onto the LC-MS/MS system. Chemicals & Materials Analytes for the screening and quantitation studies were obtained from either Cayman Chemical (Ann Arbor, MI), Cerilliant (Round Rock, TX), or Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO) as 1 mg/mL standards (when possible) or as pure crystalline material. Solvents for extraction and the LC P007796-031024-000245 3 mobile phase were Chromasolv-grade solvents purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. For quantitation, the 5 deuterated internal standards were: methamphetamine-d5, heroin-d9, cocaine-d3, fentanyl￾d5, and THC-d9. They were added to 1 L of methanol, providing an internal standard concentration of approximately 1 µg/mL, to be used for the reconstitution of the quantitation aliquot. Wipe materials were purchased from Smiths Detection and used as-is. Quantitation of Drugs by LC-MS/MS In order to have the highest level of sensitivity and specificity for the quantitation runs, a LC triple quadrupole MS operating in multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode was used. The system consisted of a Thermo Ulti-Mate 3000 LC system coupled to a ABSciex Q-Trap 4000 mass spectrometer. Separation was achieved using a Restek Raptor Biphenyl column (150 mm x 4.6 mm x 2.7 µm). The analysis time was 15 minutes with a flow rate of 0.75 mL/min and an injection volume of 15 µL. During the run, a 12-minute solvent gradient was used (95 % water / 5 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid to 100 % methanol with 0.1 % formic) followed by a 3-minute isocratic period (100 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid). The MS utilized zero-air nitrogen as both the desolvating and nebulizing gases. An electrospray ionization (ESI) source was used with a temperature of 550 °C and a spray voltage of +5500 V. A timed MRM was used to monitor two transitions for all drugs (one for quantitation and one for confirmatory identification) and one transition for each of the 5 internal standards. The MRM detection window was set to 120 s and the target scan time was set to 0.1 s. Quantitation was calculated by taking the ratio of the peak areas of a drug to the appropriate internal standard and comparing that ratio to a 13-point calibration curve. Absolute concentrations reported in the summary account for the various dilution and sample splitting steps in the extraction process. They do not, however, account for the extraction efficiency of the Nomex wipe, which is typically in the range of 30 % - 40 %. Screening of Drugs by DART-MS The aliquot prepared for the screening analysis was sampled using glass microcapillary rods. The DART-MS system used a JEOL AccuTOF JMS T100-LP time-of-flight mass spectrometer (JEOL USA) coupled with a DART ion source (IonSense). A 400 °C DART gas temperature, a +50 V DART exit grid voltage, and helium as the ionization gas was used. Mass spectrometer settings included operation in positive ionization mode, a +800 V peaks voltage, a +5 V orifice 2 and ring lens voltage, and a mass scan range of 80 m/z – 800 m/z. To obtain characteristic molecular and fragmentation spectra, the orifice 1 voltage was cycled between +30 V and +60 V. PEG-600 was used as a mass calibrant and AB-FUBINACA was used as a mass drift compensation compound. The resulting mass spectra were searched against an in-house created library of over 1,100 compounds using the NIST DART-MS Data Interpretation Tool. The screening results reported met the following identification criteria: the protonated molecular ion peak of the compound was present at greater than 5 % relative abundance and within ±5 amu of the calculated accurate mass. P007796-031024-000246 4 Results From the 25 samples provided, listed in Table 1, one was found to have quantifiable levels of a surface. Sample #8 (Bay 9 Bench) had a detectable level of oxycodone (0.11 µg). No other sample had detectable levels of any of the 29 drugs included in the LC-MS/MS panel. From the presumptive screening analysis, no compounds of interest were detected in any of the samples provided, when analyzed by DART-MS utilizing a 5 % relative intensity identification threshold. As stated in the opening letter, we would be more than happy to discuss these results with you and other interested members of your lab. If you would like us to analyze samples from additional areas, re-sample after any operational changes, or re-sample to monitor trends, we would be happy to do so. If there is any other way which we could be of assistance or form a stronger collaboration, please let us know. Table 1. Locations of samples collected. All samples were noted to have been collected on November 8, 2022. Sample # Location Sample # Location 1 Hood #4 Benchtop 14 Volatile Fridge Door 2 Hood #4 Sash 15 LC/MS #2 Bench 3 Hood #10 Benchtop 16 GC/MS #5 Bench 4 Hood #10 Sash 17 QQQ #4 Bench 5 Bay ½ Bench 18 GC/MS #14 Bench 6 Bay 5/6 Bench 19 HSGC #7 Bench 7 Bay 7/8 Bench 20 Refrigerator #15 (door) 8 Bay 9 Bench 21 DI Water System 9 Standards Freezer Door 22 Extinguisher B (Door) 10 Flammable Cabinet (Hexanes) 23 Vacant Desk (AM) 11 BA#1 Benchtop 24 Bench (Cubiles up front) 12 BA#2 Benchtop 25 JS Cabinet 13 Peak H (alcohol) Disclaimer Certain commercial equipment, instruments, or materials are identified in this document. Such identification does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, nor does it imply that the products identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose. P007796-031024-000247 5 References 1. Daughton, C. G. Illicit Drugs and the Environment. in Illicit Drugs in the Environment (eds. Castiglioni, S., Zuccato, E. & Fanelli, R.) 1–27 (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2011). 2. Forbes, T. P. & Najarro, M. Ion mobility spectrometry nuisance alarm threshold analysis for illicit narcotics based on environmental background and a ROC-curve approach. Analyst 141, 4438–4446 (2016). 3. Sisco, E. et al. Rapid detection of fentanyl, fentanyl analogues, and opioids for on-site or laboratory based drug seizure screening using thermal desorption DART-MS and ion mobility spectrometry. Forensic Chem. 4, 108–115 (2017). 4. Verkouteren, J. R. et al. A method to determine collection efficiency of particles by swipe sampling. Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 115101 (2008). P007796-031024-000248 P007796-031024-000249 November 23, 2022 Participation in NIST Study (Quarterly Environmental Sampling) – Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Report The Toxicology Laboratory continues its collaboration with NIST in a current study, the goal of which is to establish drug background levels present in a forensic science facility. NIST provides the Laboratory with test kits, which the Laboratory uses to collect environmental samples, and the samples are sent to NIST for testing. In accordance with the Laboratory’s quarterly environmental sampling plan, Toxicology Laboratory personnel collected samples on 11/8/22, which the Laboratory sent to NIST for analysis. A summary of testing performed by NIST is attached (report dated 11/17/22), with test results listed on page 4 of the report. Of the 25 samples submitted for analysis, one sample (identified as Sample #8) was negative when screened by DART-MS but had a detectable level of oxycodone when analyzed by LC-MSMS. The area with a detectable level of analyte, and adjacent areas, were cleaned by laboratory personnel on November 17th. Follow-up sample collection from those areas using NIST test kits is planned, with samples to be sent to NIST for analysis and inclusion in the study. The next regularly scheduled full round of environmental sampling is planned for first quarter 2023. P007796-031024-000250 1 November 17th, 2022 Brian Capron Acting Laboratory Manager Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, WA 98134 Brian, Thank you for participating in our study. The goal of this project was to establish the narcotics background present in a forensic science laboratory. The following report contains the results from the analysis of 25 samples collected from the Washington State Toxicology Laboratory on November 8, 2022. The analysis scheme involved a broad screening of over 1100 drugs and common excipients and a targeted quantification of 29 drugs. We would be happy to discuss these results in further detail with you at any time and hope to continue collaborative efforts in the future. If we can be of any assistance to you, please don’t hesitate to ask. Sincerely, Edward Sisco Research Chemist Materials Measurement Science Division National Institute of Standards & Technology 100 Bureau Dr. Gaithersburg, MD 20899 Phone: (301)975-2093 E-mail: edward.sisco@nist.gov P007796-031024-000251 2 Narcotics Background Quantitation & Screening Summary Introduction The recent spike in forensic cases containing highly toxic fentanyl analogues highlights the critical need to safeguard analysts from inadvertently encountering these, or other, compounds through skin adsorption and/or inhalation.1 Establishing background levels of compounds of interest in a forensic laboratory can provide drug analysts and laboratory quality managers with valuable information to make informed decisions on a range of topics such as: workflow processes, adequate PPE, cleaning protocols, and occupational safety hazards. Given that trace amounts of narcotics have been reported in a variety of environments including public spaces,2 and that instruments continue to improve in sensitivity, it is important to monitor the environmental background levels of these compounds. For field and/or screening applications, establishing the background is key to setting instrument detection thresholds and preventing false positives.3 This is especially critical in environments where there is an expected higher background level such as prisons or border crossings. In a laboratory setting, high environmental background levels can suggest a need to monitor background for quality and health purposes. Finally, since forensic laboratories continue to struggle with a high number of emerging drug cases and rising backlogs, opportunities for rapid screening / presumptive testing are desired. The ability to screen evidence in a high throughput manner with little to no sample preparation is currently being investigated. To ensure the results from such analysis are from the evidence and not from possible background within the laboratory, a baseline of the environment must be known. Experimental Samples were collected with manual Nomex wipes (Part No. DSW1210P) (DSA Detection, North Andover, MA) which are commonly used for particle collection in trace contraband detection. The particle collection efficiency of this material has been previously measured by our laboratory and results demonstrate that it is an adequate substrate for the collection of trace residues off a variety of surfaces. 4 A total of 25 samples were provided to us for analysis. Upon receipt samples were stored, at -10 °C, until they were processed. Prior to analysis, the Nomex wipes were trimmed in size to remove the unused area of the wipe. The trimmed wipe was placed in a 10 mL amber glass vial and extracted with 4.0 mL of methanol (Chromasolv Grade, Sigma-Aldrich). The 4.0 mL extract was subsequently split into two 2.0 mL aliquots – one for the screening analysis and one for the quantitation analysis. Both aliquots were then evaporated to dryness under a stream of nitrogen. The aliquot for the screening analysis was reconstituted in 200 µL of acetonitrile, to concentrate the sample, while the aliquot for quantitation was reconstituted in 500 µL of methanol containing 5 internal standards. The quantitation aliquot was directly loaded onto the LC-MS/MS system. Chemicals & Materials Analytes for the screening and quantitation studies were obtained from either Cayman Chemical (Ann Arbor, MI), Cerilliant (Round Rock, TX), or Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO) as 1 mg/mL standards (when possible) or as pure crystalline material. Solvents for extraction and the LC P007796-031024-000252 3 mobile phase were Chromasolv-grade solvents purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. For quantitation, the 5 deuterated internal standards were: methamphetamine-d5, heroin-d9, cocaine-d3, fentanyl￾d5, and THC-d9. They were added to 1 L of methanol, providing an internal standard concentration of approximately 1 µg/mL, to be used for the reconstitution of the quantitation aliquot. Wipe materials were purchased from Smiths Detection and used as-is. Quantitation of Drugs by LC-MS/MS In order to have the highest level of sensitivity and specificity for the quantitation runs, a LC triple quadrupole MS operating in multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode was used. The system consisted of a Thermo Ulti-Mate 3000 LC system coupled to a ABSciex Q-Trap 4000 mass spectrometer. Separation was achieved using a Restek Raptor Biphenyl column (150 mm x 4.6 mm x 2.7 µm). The analysis time was 15 minutes with a flow rate of 0.75 mL/min and an injection volume of 15 µL. During the run, a 12-minute solvent gradient was used (95 % water / 5 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid to 100 % methanol with 0.1 % formic) followed by a 3-minute isocratic period (100 % methanol + 0.1 % formic acid). The MS utilized zero-air nitrogen as both the desolvating and nebulizing gases. An electrospray ionization (ESI) source was used with a temperature of 550 °C and a spray voltage of +5500 V. A timed MRM was used to monitor two transitions for all drugs (one for quantitation and one for confirmatory identification) and one transition for each of the 5 internal standards. The MRM detection window was set to 120 s and the target scan time was set to 0.1 s. Quantitation was calculated by taking the ratio of the peak areas of a drug to the appropriate internal standard and comparing that ratio to a 13-point calibration curve. Absolute concentrations reported in the summary account for the various dilution and sample splitting steps in the extraction process. They do not, however, account for the extraction efficiency of the Nomex wipe, which is typically in the range of 30 % - 40 %. Screening of Drugs by DART-MS The aliquot prepared for the screening analysis was sampled using glass microcapillary rods. The DART-MS system used a JEOL AccuTOF JMS T100-LP time-of-flight mass spectrometer (JEOL USA) coupled with a DART ion source (IonSense). A 400 °C DART gas temperature, a +50 V DART exit grid voltage, and helium as the ionization gas was used. Mass spectrometer settings included operation in positive ionization mode, a +800 V peaks voltage, a +5 V orifice 2 and ring lens voltage, and a mass scan range of 80 m/z – 800 m/z. To obtain characteristic molecular and fragmentation spectra, the orifice 1 voltage was cycled between +30 V and +60 V. PEG-600 was used as a mass calibrant and AB-FUBINACA was used as a mass drift compensation compound. The resulting mass spectra were searched against an in-house created library of over 1,100 compounds using the NIST DART-MS Data Interpretation Tool. The screening results reported met the following identification criteria: the protonated molecular ion peak of the compound was present at greater than 5 % relative abundance and within ±5 amu of the calculated accurate mass. P007796-031024-000253 4 Results From the 25 samples provided, listed in Table 1, one was found to have quantifiable levels of a surface. Sample #8 (Bay 9 Bench) had a detectable level of oxycodone (0.11 µg). No other sample had detectable levels of any of the 29 drugs included in the LC-MS/MS panel. From the presumptive screening analysis, no compounds of interest were detected in any of the samples provided, when analyzed by DART-MS utilizing a 5 % relative intensity identification threshold. As stated in the opening letter, we would be more than happy to discuss these results with you and other interested members of your lab. If you would like us to analyze samples from additional areas, re-sample after any operational changes, or re-sample to monitor trends, we would be happy to do so. If there is any other way which we could be of assistance or form a stronger collaboration, please let us know. Table 1. Locations of samples collected. All samples were noted to have been collected on November 8, 2022. Sample # Location Sample # Location 1 Hood #4 Benchtop 14 Volatile Fridge Door 2 Hood #4 Sash 15 LC/MS #2 Bench 3 Hood #10 Benchtop 16 GC/MS #5 Bench 4 Hood #10 Sash 17 QQQ #4 Bench 5 Bay ½ Bench 18 GC/MS #14 Bench 6 Bay 5/6 Bench 19 HSGC #7 Bench 7 Bay 7/8 Bench 20 Refrigerator #15 (door) 8 Bay 9 Bench 21 DI Water System 9 Standards Freezer Door 22 Extinguisher B (Door) 10 Flammable Cabinet (Hexanes) 23 Vacant Desk (AM) 11 BA#1 Benchtop 24 Bench (Cubiles up front) 12 BA#2 Benchtop 25 JS Cabinet 13 Peak H (alcohol) Disclaimer Certain commercial equipment, instruments, or materials are identified in this document. Such identification does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, nor does it imply that the products identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose. P007796-031024-000254 5 References 1. Daughton, C. G. Illicit Drugs and the Environment. in Illicit Drugs in the Environment (eds. Castiglioni, S., Zuccato, E. & Fanelli, R.) 1–27 (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2011). 2. Forbes, T. P. & Najarro, M. Ion mobility spectrometry nuisance alarm threshold analysis for illicit narcotics based on environmental background and a ROC-curve approach. Analyst 141, 4438–4446 (2016). 3. Sisco, E. et al. Rapid detection of fentanyl, fentanyl analogues, and opioids for on-site or laboratory based drug seizure screening using thermal desorption DART-MS and ion mobility spectrometry. Forensic Chem. 4, 108–115 (2017). 4. Verkouteren, J. R. et al. A method to determine collection efficiency of particles by swipe sampling. Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 115101 (2008). P007796-031024-000255 July 21, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Retired Lieutenant D. Jim Nobach, Badge Number 50 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 20, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while testifying in a deposition and/or civil trial, Lieutenant provided untruthful information regarding a sexual harassment allegation.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The alleged violation of Unsatisfactory Performance were unfounded. The alleged violations of Unacceptable Conduct and Truthfulness were undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh cc: Mr. Jason M. Linn, WSPLCA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000256 J/\Y INSLEE GcHwnor JOH I R. BATISH Chief STAH Of WA,Hl"-l(,TON WASHINCTON STATF PATRC)L October 22, 2013 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 I 0th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Forensic Scientist 3 Denise M. Olson Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named former WSP employee: A 2010 Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP) to address low performance and a 2010 allegation of Unsatisfactory Performance when Olson failed to meet the standards that were outlined in her JPIP. If you need additional information, please contact me, at (360) 704-2333. TWM:dp cc: Deputy Chief G. Curt Hattell Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards Mr. Larry Hebert, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau 0 P007796-031024-000257 November 14, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cameron M. Osmer, Badge Number 1151 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper failed to act in a manner consistent with his overtime duty requirements. It is further alleged Trooper entered inaccurate information on his time and activity report.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000258 December 5, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cameron M. Osmer, Badge Number 1151 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 14, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to act in a manner consistent with his overtime duty requirements. It is further alleged Trooper entered inaccurate information on his time and activity report.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Proven. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000259 January 20, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Collin Overend-Pearson, Badge Number #632 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper falsely reported hours worked and/or fraudulently received pay for off-duty employment he had not performed.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000260 July 18, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Collin Overend￾Pearson, Badge Number 632 Dear Mr. Brown: On January 20, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper falsely reported hours worked and/or fraudulently received pay for off￾duty employment he had not performed.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the finding for employee conduct was Proven, the code of ethics and rules of conduct allegations were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief James R. Mjor II, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000261 P007796-031024-000262 P007796-031024-000263 P007796-031024-000264 Pierce County Office of Prosecuting Attorney MARY E. ROBNETT Prosecuting Attorney REPLY TO: CRIMINAL FELONY DIVISION Main Office: (253) 798-7400 930 Tacoma Avenue South, Room 946 Tacoma, Washington 98402-2171 Victim-Witness Assistance: (253) 798-7400 (FAX) (253) 798-6636 September 12, 2023 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Lab Attn: Forensic Scientist Tianca Penny 2203 Airport Way South Seattle, Washington Re: Forensic Scientist Tianca Penny, Brady or Impeachment Evidence Dear Tianca Penny: As you are no doubt aware both your department and prosecutors have a constitutional duty to disclose evidence or information concerning possible Brady1 or potential impeachment evidence or information to criminal defendants. The matter referenced was brought to our attention and led the opening of a file which will be maintained in our office. This letter is intended to provide you with notice of this matter. We wish to extend you the opportunity to review the written material provided to us. Please contact the undersigned if you would like to come to our office for such a review. We also extend to you the opportunity to provide us with any additional evidence or information concerning this matter to be added to and included with the evidence and information we keep in our file. Please be advised that any such evidence or information you provide us is not privileged or confidential and is subject to public disclosure. It could also be disclosed to criminal defense attorneys and public records requestors along with the content of our file. Please feel free to contact the undersigned if you or your representatives or attorneys have any questions. Sincerely, BROOKE BURBANK Pierce County Prosecutor’s Office cc: Brady/Impeachment File 1 Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83(1963) P007796-031024-000265 INTEROFFICE COMMUNICATION INASHINGTON STATE PATROL TO: Ms. Amanda Black, Toxicology Laboratory Division FROM: Dr. Brianna Peterson, Toxicology Laboratory Division SUBJECT: Corrective Action Report - incorrect evidence items disposed DA TE: July 24, 2020 FILE: On July 15, 2020, Forensic Scientist 5 Katie Harris notified me via email that evidence items for ST-19-12786 (A and B tubes) had been disposed prior to completion of all testing and release of a final Toxicology Test Report. The series of events leading up to this notification are as follows: • July 14, 2020 - Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested ST-19-12786-A from the evidence vault through OneNote. • July 15, 2020 - Property and Evidence Custodian Melanie Diggs was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 in the evidence vault. Upon examining LIMS, Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. • July 15, 2020 - Shelby notified her supervisor, Katie Harris, that the evidence for an active case had been disposed. • July 15, 2020 - Tyler pulled the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report related to the Evidence Disposition Records for 5/19/20 and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19-12786-B were not listed on the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report. In addition, the Evidence Disposition Records for 5/19/20 indicated ST-19-12786 had been disposed. Tyler provided these records to Katie. Investigation: This event was determined to be significant and a corrective action process initiated. The chain of custody records in LIMS for ST-19-12876 verify that this case was not disposed on 5/19/20; both evidence items were disposed on 6/29/20. The Evidence Handling Inquiry Report for 5/19/20 have the initials of "TP" and "BC" at the top of the first page. The initials indicate that Property and Evidence Custodian Tanica Perry pulled the samples on this report from the evidence vault and FS5 Brian Capron facilitated the disposal process. Root Cause: The root cause of this nonconformity was inattention. Tani ca originally pulled the incorrect evidence items trom storage in the evidence vault. Forensic Scientist 5 Brian Capron and Forensic Scientist 3 Asa Louis worked together to dispose of the evidence. Asa examined the evidence items and recited the case number to Brian; Brian verified the case number against the 3000-323-00] (5/96) An internationally accredited agency providing prof essional law e,iforcement services P007796-031024-000266 Ms. Amanda Black Page2 7/24/2020 Evidence Handling Inquiry Report. Inattention to the case number occurred in both stages of this disposal process. Impact: The impact of this nonconformity was significant. Drug screening by EMIT was the only test that had been performed, therefore a final Toxicology Test report for this case could not be issued. Evaluation: Section 4.3.1.1 of the Quality Assurance Manual (Notification of Appropriate Authority) was properly followed. Cessation of all evidence disposals was put into place on 7/16/2020. Correction/ Action: For future evidence disposals, an additional 'read back' will be implemented. One person will recite the case number from the evidence item to a secondary person. The secondary person will recite the case number from the disposal log. Both individuals will now be reciting and verifying the case number, whereas the previous process only instituted one recitation and verification step. In addition, the Subject Name from the Evidence Handling Inquiry Report will be recited for verification against the tubes. If the subject name is not present on the tubes, then the Agency Case number can be used for comparison. If the sample is unlabeled, this is noted in the "Evid/Handle Note" column of the report. Follow-up/Monitoring: The submitting agency and assigned prosecutor were notified that a final report would not be issued on 7 /16/20. Evidence audits routinely occur following Section 7 .18 of the Operations Manual. Based on results of audits for the past decade, this nonconformity is an isolated incident. BP:bp 6f cc: Mr. Brian Capron, Toxicology Laboratory Division Dr. Fiona Couper, Toxicology Laboratory Division Ms. Kimberly Miller, Toxicology Laboratory Division P007796-031024-000267 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report Case ID: ST-19-12786 ITEM 1 ST-19-12786-A: One vacutainer with gray top Date Qf Tr2 ~fer From PIN To PIN 10/30/2019 Velliquette, John [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [] hand delivery 10/30/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 03/18/2020 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 05/19/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] capron, Brian TOX [X] 05/19/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] ITEM2 ST-19-12786-B: One vacutainer with gray top Date of Transfer ftQm PIN To PIN 10/30/2019 Velliquette, John [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [] hand delivery 10/30/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 03/18/2020 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 03/18/2020 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 05/19/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] capron, Brian TOX [X] 05/19/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tox Lab) [ ] NOTE: [X] indicates a secured transaction ( a PIN was entered ) [R0.0-20110323] caseCOC.rpt Page 1 of 1 Print: 7/24/2020, 12:05:29PM P007796-031024-000268 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report Case ID: ST-19-12876 ITEM 1 ST-19-12876-A: One vacutainer with gray top Ds:ite Qf Transfer From PIN To .em 11/05/2019 Demyen, Jessica [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [] Fed Ex 11/05/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 11/14/2019 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X) Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 11/22/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 12/09/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/09/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] 12/27/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/27/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Okolie, Onyi TOX [X] 12/30/2019 Okolie, Onyi TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/30/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 01/08/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X) 01/08/2020 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Krantz, Mindy TOX [X] 01/16/2020 Krantz, Mindy TOX [X] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 01/16/2020 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 06/29/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Capron, Brian TOX [X] 06/29/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] ITEM 2 ST-19-12876-B: One vacutainer with gray top bls:ite of I[ansfer From PIN To 1:1.N 11/05/2019 Demyen, Jessica [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [] Fed Ex 11/05/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [ ] Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [] 11/14/2019 Vault - Fridge Bulk TOX [ ] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Orrell, Tyler P TOX [X] 11/14/2019 Orrell, Tyler P TOX [XJ Vault - Fridge TOX [] 11/22/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Cruz, Brittany C TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [X] 11/22/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [] 12/09/2019 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Perry, Tanica TOX [X] 12/09/2019 Perry, Tanica TOX [X] Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] 12/11/2019 Artz, Brandie K TOX [X] Flay, Corie S TOX [XJ 12/13/2019 Flay, Corie S TOX [X] Barnett, Hj TOX [XJ 12/13/2019 Barnett, Hj TOX [X] Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] 06/29/2020 Vault - Fridge TOX [ ] Capron, Brian TOX [X] 06/29/2020 Capron, Brian TOX [X] Disposed, (by Tax Lab) [ ] [R0.0-20110323] caseCOC.rpt Page 1 of 2 Print: 7/24/2020, 11 :38:38AM P007796-031024-000269 Case ID: ST-19-12876 Toxicology Laboratory Chain of Custody Report NOTE: [X] indicates a secured transaction { a PIN was entered ) [R0.0-20110323) caseCOC.rpt Page 2 of 2 Print: 7/24/2020, 11 :38:38AM P007796-031024-000270 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Orrell, Tyler (WSP) Monday, July 20, 2020 6:34 AM Keeley, Shelby (WSP); Peterson, Brianna (WSP) Miller, Kimberly (WSP); Harris, Katie (WSP) RE: missing evidence On 07-15-2020 while pulling tubes for Shelby, Laney was unable to locate ST-19-12786 A or B. Spots were vacant where those tubes would have been so our standard next step is to check LIMS for its location. That is when we discovered it had been disposed. I looked further into the matter and discovered it was pulled accidentally instead of a tube of similar ST number for May 19th disposals. I presented the transfer logs and disposal list to Katie on 07-15-2020 at ~1000 Tyler Orrell From: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM To: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7 /14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day (7 /15) and gave her the fi le which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa .gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence t hat had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Prope1iy and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 1 P007796-031024-000271 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie ofthi3 discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboralury Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 2 P007796-031024-000272 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM Peterson, Brianna (WSP); Orrell, Tyler (WSP); Harris, Katie (WSP) Miller, Kimberly (WSP) RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7/14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day {7 /15) and gave her the file which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa.gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM To: Keeley, Shelby {WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler {WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie {WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly {WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence that had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Onell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed . ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie of this discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboratory Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 P007796-031024-000273 Peterson, Brianna (WSP) From: Harris, Katie (WSP) Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 7:38 AM To: Subject: Peterson, Brianna (WSP); Miller, Kimberly (WSP) FW: missing evidence I was initially alerted to the disposed evidence by Shelby Keeley soon after the vault discovered the tubes had been disposed on 7/15/2020. Tyler had pulled the disposal log shortly after and showed it to me. This all took place just prior to 8:30am on 7/15/2020 as I emailed Brianna just prior to the management meeting and then it was briefly discussed during the meeting. Katie Harris Forensic Scientist Supervisor Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South, Suite 360 Seattle, WA 98134 Telephone: (206) 262-6100 Fax: (206) 262-6145 From: Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 6:34 AM To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa .gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence On 07-15-2020 while pulling tubes for Shelby, Laney was unable to locate ST-19-12786 A or B. Spots were vacant where those tubes would have been so our sta ndard next step is to check LIMS for its location. That is when we discovered it had been disposed. I looked further into the matter and discovered it was pulled accidentally instead of a tube of similar ST number for May 19th disposals. I presented the transfer logs and disposal list to Katie on 07-15-2020 at ~1000 Tyler Orrell From: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 9:06 AM To: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <l<atie.Harris@wsp.wa.gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: RE: missing evidence Yes, I requested ST-19-12786-A only with my other requests on 7/14. Once we looked in LIMS I notified Katie Harris about it that day (7 /15) and gave her the file which I had pulled from the THC and alcohol shelf. Shelby Keeley From: Peterson, Brianna (WSP) <Brianna.Peterson@wsp.wa .gov> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:55 AM 1 P007796-031024-000274 To: Keeley, Shelby (WSP) <Shelby.Keeley@wsp.wa.gov>; Orrell, Tyler (WSP) <Tyler.Orrell@wsp.wa.gov>; Harris, Katie (WSP) <Katie.Harris@wsp.wa .gov> Cc: Miller, Kimberly (WSP) <Kimberly.Miller@wsp.wa.gov> Subject: missing evidence Hello! I'm writing up our official record for the evidence that had been disposed - and want to make sure I have the series of events accurate. Please let me know any more details, dates, etc that you may have. • Forensic Scientist Shelby Keeley requested the evidence for ST-19-12786 from the evidence vault. (Did you just ask for A tube? Do you happen to recall when request list was put on One Note - 7/14??) • Property and Evidence Custodian Tyler Orrell (was it Tyler? Or Laney?) was unable to locate the tubes for ST-19-12786 (Do you recall what day you attempted to pull the evidence?). Upon examining LIMS, Tyler observed that the evidence had been disposed on 5/19/20. Tyler pulled the disposal record logs for that date and determined that ST-19-12876-A and ST-19-12876-B were the evidence items listed that should have been disposed. ST-19-12786-A and ST-19- 12786-B were not listed on the disposal log for 5/19/20. (who notified Katie of this discrepancy? What date did notification occur in relation to discovery of missing evidence?) Thanks everyone! Brianna Peterson Laboratory Manager Toxicology Laboratory Division Washington State Patrol 2203 Airport Way South Seattle WA 98134 206-262-6100 2 P007796-031024-000275 No. Agency Name To Be Disposed HoquiamWSP 2 Tacoma WSP 3 Tumwater WSP 4 TacomaWSP 5 Port Orchard Police Dept 6 Port Orchard Police Dept 7 Jefferson Co Sheriff - Port Hadlock 8 Asotin County Sheriff 9 Port Angeles Police Dept 10 Woodland Police Dept Evidence Handling Inquiry (by Case#} Report for Releasable Cases Between 1/1/2000 and 2/18/2020 Age Case# Subject Name 16-037668 Gurvinder Mander 18-014152 Oscar Cruz 18-015454 Dagim Fassil 18-019645 Troy Egbert D 19-000041 Lorianne Wood riff 019-00421 Rusty Mullikin 19-1483 Ruthann Glassman 19A00839 Omar Sanchez 2019-2975 Natalee Amsdill ST-17-00299 /A / VGray ST-17-00299 I B / ST-18-06357 /A ./ ST-18-06357 / B / ST-18-07042 / A ,,,,- ST-18-07042 / B / - ST-18-09161 / B / ST-1S-01672 /A ,,,- ST-19-01672 / B / ST-1S-01672 / C ,-- ST-1S-01672 /D / ST-19-02255 / A / ST-1S-02255 / B / ST-19-02347 / A / ST-1S-02347 / B / VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray . . . - . - - VGray VGray VGray VRed VRed VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-1S-02355 /A,,,,- VGray __ 5.~-'.~~~5_5 ,( ~ /' ___ VGray ST-1 S-02923 / A-; VGray ST-1S-02923 /B / VGray _____ ______________ . ____ ____ ~-1S-02923 C ;;, PC9'P. 0 To Be Disposed Print Date: 5118/2020 Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age Name on req. form: 'Davinder S. Gandhamy' LK 1/26/1 7 Name on req. form: 'Davinder S. Gandhamy' LK 1/26/17 W19°188 lsaacSeavey ST-19-03331 /A ," VGray _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _________________ 5.~·!9-~~~3_1 / B _":. __ _ ~~~a! ______ _ . ___ ____ ______ _______ _____ __ ____ _ [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 1 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000276 I No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name 11 Wenatchee Police Dept 19W03463 Jennifer Dechenne 12 Jefferson Co Sheriff- Port Hadlock 19-2332 Dennis Gray 13 Wenatchee Police Dept 19W03540 James Schuyleman 14 Marysville Police Dept 2019-000014451Jolene Love 15 Port Angeles Police Dept 2019-6371 Matthew Gamer 16 Jefferson Co Sheriff - Port Hadlock 19-3811 Damon Clarke 17 Puyallup Police Dept 1911601162 Amy Weis beck 18 Puyallup Police Dept 1911801852 James Coffee 19 Marysville Police Dept 2019-00022913 Chad Torve 20 Othello Police Dept 19-001409 Isaias Sanchez-Gonsalez 21 Othello Police Dept 19-001346 Juan Valencia Ochoa 22 Asotin County Sheriff 19A02097 Peter Cavenaugh Case ID Evid. ST-19.03452 / A ,; ST-19-03452 / B / ST-19-03574 /A / ST-19-03574 / B / ST-19-03693 /A.., ST-1 9.03693 / B / ST-19-03881 /A - . / ST-19-03881 / B ST-19-04916 / A ,; ST-19-04916 / B r ST-19-04916 / C r ST-19-04916 / D ,,- - · - . ------ ST-19-04930 / A ., .. ~~·!9-~930 / B / ST-19-05089 /A _. . S~·!9·0~89/ B / ST-19-05090 /A.,,.. ST-19-05090 / B' ST-19.05163 / A - ST-19-05163 / B / ST-19.051 64 /A.,- ST-19-05164 / B ,,,-- . - - - - - - - - . - ... . -.. . ST-19-05165 /A - sr-19-0s1ss Is "' . ·sr-19-osis:i /A;_ - ST-1 9-05183 / B / Desc. VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray 23 Jefferson Co Sheriff- Port Hadlock 19-4262 Alanna Upp ST-19-05195 /A ,; VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ST-19-05195 /B ' VGray · - .24 · · Ell~~;b~rg-P~li~~ D~pt-· · · · · --· · · --E19--0295_3_. ·N;~;n Sa-dang - - . - · ST-19-05471 . /A-·; -··· VG;a;- • - - - • ·. - - - . - - - .. - - - - . - .... - - • - ....... - . ST-19-05471 / B ✓ VGray . - .. . - -----.. . .. -- . -. - . ---- -. - .. -- - -. .. -.. -. -. -. -- . -.... . . -.. - . -.. - ... --. -...... ·/ . - . . ----. -- -.. - - . --... . . - .. - - .. .. - . --- . - . - .... -- 25 Ellensburg Police Dept E19-07983 Ram Rai Kirati ST-19-07516/ A VGray IR1 0-201610271 Evid Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 2 of 13 Print 5/1 8/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000277 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name Desc. 42 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-411 Michael Aeon ST·19-12621 / A / VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age . 43 .. Kl!~~~ ·c; c~~~~~r· . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . KCA~ 1·9~ 106. · An~;l~~; Th~~;~~ . . . ST· 19-1263.17.;, / . . VG;ay. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . • . . . . ... .• • .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... . . .... ·7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . .. ....... . . .. . 44 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191025·365 Keith Standal ST·19-12747 / A VGray ------------------ ---- -- --- ··-· ---- - ---- - -------- --------- - ----- ---- -- - - ·--- -- ---- ---- -- --- --- --- --- - -- --- -· ---------- ----- · 45 Clark Co Medical Examiner 2019·2674 Bryan Bocanegra ST·19-12876 /A .,,. VGray ST·19-12876 / B / VGray 46 Thurston Co Coroner 47 King Co Medical Examiner 48 King Co Medical Examiner 49 King Co Medical Examiner 50 King Co Medical Examiner 51 King Co Medical Examiner 52 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 53 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 54 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 55 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 56 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 57 King Co Medical Examiner 58 King Co Medical Examiner 19·2181·11 19·02301 Morton James Martin lndalecio 19·02294 Michael Knapp 19·02293 Joseph Antoncich 19·02259 Daniel Gleason 19·02296 Judy Wayne 192144 192151 Larry Lane Noel Cabardo 192149 Evan Suckow 192177 Percy David 19·2077 Amberly Masonholder 19·02376 Cesar Erazo 19·2372 Alison Powell 191117 ·94 Matthew Dick ST·19-13161 / A ,,.,- ST•19·13189 /A r VGray VGray ST·1 9-13190 / A ,,- VLavender ST•1 9-13190 / B r SST ST·19-13190 /C / SST ST•19·13194 / A _,, VGray · · ST·19·131 98 J A / VLavender ST·19·13199 / A ,.. VGray ST•19-13332 / A / VGray · ST·19-13333 / A / · VLavender ST·19-13334 / A / VLavender . . . . .. . . . / . . . . . . ST•19-13335 /A VGray ST·19-13461 I A ,,.- VLavender ST·19·13461 / 8 .,,.. SST ST•19-13461 / C / SST ~T·~~~3~6 / ~ .. .. ~~~a! .... . ST·19-13669 / A r VGray ST·1 9-13669 / 8 VGray ST·19-13669 /C / VGray 59 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner ST·19-13761 / A _,, VGray 60 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191113·305 Nicholas Soulias ·sr.is-i3i64 / ;: -;· ... vG;ay . .. . .. . .. . .... . . . . ... ....•.. ..•......... 61 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-451 Michael Studley ST•19•13766 /A./ VGray ST.19-13766.,) 8 / VGray ·········•· · ······ ······· · ···· · ······ • • ··· · ·· · ······· ···•······ · ······· · ··· · ······· ,; · · ·········· • ·· ··· ······· · ·· · ······ · ········ · · 62 ClallamCoCoroner 2019.co.205 RodneyEdwards ST·19-13770_/A / VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 4 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000278 No. Agency Name 62 Clallam Co Coroner 63 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 64 Benton Co Coroner 65 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 66 Clark Co Medical Examiner 67 Clark Co Medical Examiner 68 Clark Co Medical Examiner 69 Benton Co Coroner 70 Cowlitz Co Coroner 71 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 72 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 73 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 74 King Co Medical Examiner 75 King Co Med_ical Examiner 76 King Co Medical Examiner 77 King Co Medical Examiner 78 King Co Medical Examiner Age Case # Subject Name 2019-C0-205 Rodney Edwards Kari Foss Case ID Evid. ST·19-13770 /B / ST·19·13773 I A .,,, Desc. VGray VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age 191118-414 C19-441 192230 Melanie Novotney David Kesner . ·sr.ig.13774. 1 s· / -. -. vG;a;·. -.. 2019-2858 Jonathan Pfingsten 2019-2848 Frederick Stephens - --- ·--- -· 2019-2818 Kathleen Lane -- -· ---- - C19-444 Theodore Knuth 19-637 PennyTumer 19-2105 Terry Coleman 19-2099 nmothy Daily 19-2102 Maya Aubert 19-02402 Wayne Newkirk - - - . . - -- -- - . - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - -. - - - -- - - - - - - - - - -- . - - ST·19-13m /A/ VGray ST·19-13778 /A./ ST•19-13778 / B ./ - - - -· -- - --- S'.·19-1~77~! ✓ ~T·:~:~76!1. fB / ST•iS-13782 / A .,,, ST·19-13782 / B / ·si-is-i:ii84 / A ,,,,,- VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray ST·1 9-13789 / A ,... VGray ST-19-13789 / B / VGray ST•19-13790 /A / ST-19-13790 / B ST-19-13792 / A _. ST-19-13792 / B / ST-19-13792 / C / ST-19-13795 / A / VGray VGray VGray VGreen VGray 19-02370 Valeree Neuman ST-19-13797 /B ,,... ST·19-13797 ) C ' VGray VBlue SST . - - . - - - - - -- - - - - - -. -- - 19-02385 Stephen Wilson ST-19-13880 / B / ST-19-13880 / C / 19-02396 Tae Shin ST-19-13882 / A ,,, ST-19-13882 / B / VGray VRed VGray Vlavender 19·02397 Christopher Thar])-Drake ST· 19-13883 / A ./ VLavender - - -- - - - ------ - - -.. ---- - - -- - - - - - ---- -- - - - - -- - - . . - - - - - - . - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - . - - - - --- - -- - - . - - - - - - -- - - ----- -- - . -- - -- - - - - - - . - - - 79 King Co Medical Examiner 81 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 19-02400 192254 Kevin Sieele ST· 19-13886 / A / VGray ·····---·•·--··--·-·--····· ---•-···--·--·-·- ·· -- -·--··· ··· ·- ··--·· · ····•···· ·-·· 1 -- ··-·-- · ·· ····-·· -·· ··-· ··· ·· -·----·--· -- ··- ·· 80 Cowlitz Co Coroner 19·663 Ronnie Cox ST·19-13892 /A VGray ·Th~~~Watki;s·- -- --- . ··sr.is-13904)" A. / -·v~~~n-d~; --.. ---·:. -... -· -·- ····-· -- -.. ·----- [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 5 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000279 No. Agency Name 82 King Co Medical Examiner 83 King Co Medical Examiner 84 King Co Medical Examiner 85 Clark Co Medical Examiner 86 Clark Co Medical Examiner 87 Chelan Co Coroner 88 Kitsap Co Coroner 89 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 90 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 91 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 92 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 93 Clark Co Medical Examiner 94 Clark Co Medical Examiner 95 Clark Co Medical Examiner 96 Clark Co Medical Examiner 97 Clark Co Medical Examiner 98 Island Co Coroner 99 Pierce Co Medical Examiner Age Case# Subject Name 19-02394 Donovan Stuhr 19-02427 Branden Cope 19-02412 Roger Sherman 2019-2895 Viola Thuring-Bregenzer 2019-2880 Larry Tonder CH2019-464 Andrew Dickinson . . ---- · - KCl-19-057 Riley Gibson - - - - - - - - - -- - -.. - - . 192284 Wendey Foster 192278 Jacob Dawson 192272 Craig Hunter 192263 John Smith 2019-2932 Steven Hayes 2019-2933 Kimberly Rojas-Flores 2019-2937 Marry Casey . - - - - - - - - . -- -- - - . - - - 2019-2901 Susan Wallace - -- - - -- -- . . --- 2019-2921 nffanyHill 19-378 Phillip Bakke 192313 Kellie Ford .. Note: Returned items are not included Case ID Evid. Desc. Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ST-19-13911 /A/ VL.avender . sr-1s.13!i12 ; s · / · --vt.~~;nd~; - sr-1!i-i.i040 ; i,., -/ ----vG;a~-------- . - -. - - . - . - . - -- . - - -- - - - -- - - - . ST-19-14043 / A - VGray ST-19-14043 / B / VGray ST-19-14044 / A ,,- ST-19-14044 / B / ---- --- . - . ST-19-14045 /A - ~~-!9-1404_5 ,/~ _ ~ ST-19-14052 / A ,,- - - - -·- - - . . -- ST-19-14056 / A / ST-19-14057 /A .,..- ST-19-14059 / A .,,- ST-19-14060 / A / ST-19-14065 J A ,, ST-19-14065 /B /' VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VBlue VPink VGray VGray VGray ST-19-14066 /A ,,,.. VGray Sagittal ST-19-14066 .l B /" VGray . - . -- ·· · . . · - ST-19-14067 / A .,.,,- VGray ~T-!~~~06?/ ~ ./ . __ ~~~a! ___ _ _ ST-19-14069 / A .,.. ST-19-1 4069 / B / VGray VGray ST-19-14070 / A - VGray ST-19-14070 / B ✓ VGray ----- ---- ---- --- - --------- -- ·-- --· -- --- -- ----- ------ -------- ---- ST-19-14071 / A ~ VGray ST-19-14071 / B / VGray ---- ---- -- - ---------- -- ---- -------- ------ -- ----- -- -------- --· ST-19-14072 /A .,, VGray 100 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192318 Matthew Klaniecki ST-19-14074 / A ., VGray --;o,--Pi~r;~ -c~ M~di~,-E;;~ln~~ - - - - - .. - - - . 192304 - -·M;l~-Osb~~-----------ST-19-14075/ A -:/ ----VG;a~ ---------.. -. -------------------.. ---. -. - {R1.0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 6 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000280 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name Case ID Evid. ST-19-14160 / A ... Desc. VGray ST-19-14162 /A' VGray Note: Returned items are not included EvidfHandle Note Return to Other Age 102 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 103 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 104 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 105 King Co Medical Examiner 106 King Co Medical Examiner 107 King Co Medical Examiner 108 King Co Medical Examiner 109 King Co Medical Examiner 192266 192299 192292 John Stockman Ailill Breiner Peter Heryford ·- -- - - -- ·· · - -- - ·-·····--- ·-- - - 110 King Co Medical Examiner 111 King Co Medical Examiner 112 King Co Medical Examiner 113 King Co Medical Examiner 114 King Co Medical Examiner 115 King Co Medical Examiner 19-02453 Joe Ramos 19-02449 Joon Parl< 19-02452 19-02447 Douglas Sykes Michelle Yarnell 19-02440 Michael Chevalier 19-02437 Joseph Webb 19-02420 April Cook 19-02 4 7 4 Robert Mitchell 19-02472 Alice Johnson 19-02470 Craig Taylor 19-02466 Rebecca Richman ST-19-14164 /A/ VGray ST-19-14166 / A / VGray ST-19-14167 / A ,,,- VGray ~~-! ~-~41_6~/ ~ r _ -~~?-~4171 _,/A / ST-19-14173 / B ..- ST-19-14173 / C / VGray VGray SST SST ST-19-14174 i A ,,- VBlue ST-19-14174 / B " Vlavender ST-19-14174 / C / SST ST-19-14175 / B - ST-19-14175 / C " ST-19-14175 / D ., ST-19-14175 / E ,- ST-19-14175 / F.,.. ST-19-14175 / G.,.. ST-19-14175 / H / __ __ __ _ ____ ___ _ __ / _ _ ____ . ST-19-14177 / A / . - . - - . - . - - . - . . ST-19-14179 / A ' ST-19-14179 / B / ST-19-14180. - A-/ ------ ----- -- - / _ ..... ST-19-14182 / A , PTube SST SST PTube PTube PTube SST VGray VGray Vlavender VGray Vlavender 11 6 King Co Medical Examiner 19-2463 Rodney Mulvaney ST-19-14183 / B / Vlavender -· 1,i-i<i~g c~-M~ct1c~1 E~~~i~;; · ---------·1·9~024s1 · - -J·u~tin· s~iih - - - - - sr-1 9.141-ss j A-> .. · vG~a;· ------. --- ------------- ------------------. ---------------. - -------. ----. --------------. --7 · -. --. ------. --.. - . ----------------. ---. -. __ ! ~8-_ ~~:r~~ ?~ ~:~i~l-~~n,~n_e_r ________ ___ 1 ~2~~~ ___ -~~ch~l~e-~~n~ ____ __ ___ _ ~~-~~!~~9~/ ~ _____ __ ~~ra! _______ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ __ _______ _ _ 119 Island Co Coroner 19-379 John Prutton ST-19-14194 /A .,.. VGray ST-19-14194) B / VGray ------ - - - --- --- - - ------ --- - -- ----- -- --- - ----- - - -- ---- -- -- - ------ - - - - -- --- --- ·-- - -/ ·- · · ·· -·- - ·-- - -- --- ---- --- --- - --- - -- --- ---- - - -- 120 Yakima Co Coroner 19-516MVF15 EnriqueArreola ST-19-14196/ A VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 7 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000281 No. Agency Name Age Case # Subject Name 120 Yakima Co Coroner 19-516 MVF15 Enrique Arreola Case ID Evid. Desc. ST-19-14196 / B .,, VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age · ·--------- ----- --- --- · ----·------ ------- · --· - ---- 121 Skagit Co Coroner 19SK0375 Richard Johnson sr-is.1.i19a)s-_;; · -· vcir~n--·-··· -- ----- --- -- . - - - - - - - .. .. - - - - - - - -- - - - - .. - - - - - . - - - - -.. - -- - - . --- - - - - - - .. - . -- 122 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 123 Clark Co Medical Examiner 124 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 125 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 126 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 127 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 128 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 129 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 130 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 131 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 132 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 133 Clallam Co Coroner 134 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191124-169 Joseph Love ---- - ----------- - ------- ------ - 2019-2971 Anthony Hanington 192322 Roy Evans 19-2165 Emily Hamptoo 19-2129 Kenneth Buelo 19-2126 1121 Monroe UDM 19-2139 John Alfino 19-2162 Dean York 19-2172 Brenna Strine 19-2186 Harvey Willey . .. - - - -- . - . . -- - ·- 19-2168 Benjamin Wheeler - - - - - . -- .. . - . - - -- - . 19-C0-218 William Carr 191202-177 Aubrey Forslof ST-19-14284 / A / ST-19-14291 / A .,,.. ST-19-14291 / B / -- - - - -. . - - - - ST-19-14300 /A / ST-19-14300 /B VGray VGray VGray VGray VGreen ST-19-14302 /A - VLavender / ~~-: ~-:43_02/ _ B ___ __ __ SST ST-19-14305 / A ,, VBlue ,,. ST-19-14305 / B PTube ~~-'.9-14305 / C / SST S~-1~1~306_/B / __ . VGray .. ~~-~~14309 / B VGray ST-19-14313 /A ✓ VGray ST-19-14313 / B _,, VGreen ST-19-14313 /C / VGray ST-19-14315 /B / . VGray sr-1s-i4:i1ii/ s· -- --. ve,;a~ -·- - ·-· . - / --· -- - · · ST-19-14317 / B VGray - - - . - - - . . - ST-19-14319 /A,,,- VGray ST-19-14319 / B / VGray ST-19-14446 / A / VGray -.135. s~~h;~i~h c~ M~dl~I Ex~~i~~~ - ... 1°91203~261 . Cy~~ia-Ulridl . -ST-19-14447 / A / . ---VG;a~-. - - - ·--- ----- ---------··- · ·· ·- -·-· ·-- ---- ---1 --· - . -------· •·-· 136 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 191204-96 Thomas Boullioun ST-19-14448 A / VGray .. -------------------. -... --------.. -------.. -... -------. . .. -. -. . -. -. --.. -... ---1-. . -. ---. . . . . . . . ... - -----. ... -------. -------- 137 Kitsap Co Coroner KCl-19-060 Robert Morales ST-19-14451 /A VGray 140 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192348 : : !~~ : ~'.~r~:~~~~~i~l:~~0~n~~:::::: _: :: 3~~~~::: -~;_0~1~~ ~~l~~d:o~ :::: :-: ~~-~~-~~5~; ~-; :::: ~~~aj:::::: : ::: :.- -: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : . : : : :: : : : : : : 139 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 192358 Eyan Ricker ST-19-14454 .l A VGray donation ------- - -------·· · --1------ -- --------- - ----- -- --- --- ---- -- --- --- ----- Clinton Rave ST-19-14455 ,l A VGray [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 8 of 13 Print 5/1 8/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000282 No. Agency Name 141 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 142 King Co Medical Examiner 143 King Co Medical Examiner 144 King Co Medical Examiner 145 King Co Medical Examiner 146 Clark Co Medical Examiner 147 Clark Co Medical Examiner 148 Clark Co Medical Examiner 149 Clark Co Medical Examiner 150 Okanogan Co Coroner 151 Island Co Coroner 152 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 153 Yakima Co Coroner 154 Pacific Co Coroner - Raymond 155 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 156 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 157 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 158 Clallam Co Coroner 159 Clallam Co Coroner 160 Benton Co Coroner 161 Benton Co Coroner 162 Benton Co Coroner 163 Clark Co Medical Examiner Age Case# Subject Name 192366 Dennis Williams 19-02500 Sammy Dehart 19-02499 Dawn Miller 19-002 41 Vuong Do 19-2508 Lawrence Morgan 2019-3039 Sally Hoptowit 2019-2984 Charles Mason -- . -. - - . - . - - - - - - ... - 2019-3047 Derick Rasband 2019-3008 David Gehring · - -- -·. - . X19-137 Joseph Gutierrez . - -·· · 19-398 Corey Simmons 2019644 Dwayne Alley ... . - · . - -- - 19-547 T46 Leroy Dollicker 1028 Marta Porter . . -- - -- ·-·· 19-2235 Robert Lucas . - . - . - .. - . 19-2220 Ronald Wittkop/ 19-2229 Robert Taitch 2019-C0-225 Kathern Allen 2019-C0-224 Kimberly Bender . .. - - . . - - - -- - - - - . - -- - - . - - . C19-474 Sheila Smith C19-479 Case ID Evid. ST-19-14456 /A .,,. ·sr-is-1«s3 JA-·:,_ Desc. VGray VGray ST-19-14560 / B / VLavender Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ----- -- ----· ---- -------- --- - ----- -- -·-· ····----- ST-19-14561 / B .,,, Vlavender ST-19-14561 / C / SST ST-19-14561 / D / SST ··- -· · - -- ST-19-14562 / B / VGray sr-is-1.iss:i / s .,,. . . sr-i!i-i,iss.1I s. > - sr-1s-1455s 1 13 ;, . . ST-19-14567 j B / . - · sr-1s-1,i514 / s 7 ST-19-14588 / B / ST-19-14589 / B ,,.. sr-1s-14s90 /a·; s-i-is-1.iis1 / 13 / VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-19-14592 / B _.,. VGray . ... - . .... ·,r - ST-19-14593 / B VGray ST-19-14594 /B / VGray ST-19-14595"1 s· / · · · VG;a~--· -· - . . - .. . ·-. / " ... - .. - .. ST-19-14599 ~ VGray Donald Scully . sr-is-i.iiso/ A.;.., .. ·· vG;a~--- . ______ ~~-~~~~~60 (~< -- __ ~?~! _ C19-473 David Dana 201 9-3082 Mortimer Hernandez ST-19-14762 / B ,,,, VGray ST-19-14762 / C / VGreen ------ --------· -··- ···-··-------------- -- --------- ----- ----· ST-19-14764 /A _, ST-19-14764 / B / VGray VGray [R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).,pt Page 9 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000283 No. Agency Name Age Case# Subject Name 164 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 165 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 19-2387 166 King Co Medical Examiner 19-02583 Christopher Dennis Edward Webb Gerald lncrocci Case ID Evid. ST-19-14772 / A ,- ST-19-14774 / A ,,, Desc. VGray VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age -sr-iS-iiim-/ ;..-; ----vo;a~----------------------------------- ------ -167 . Ki~g c~-M~di~i Bc~~i~;; -----------1-9--02536 - - -,:e~;a~~-C;n~~d------- ST-19--1-4-783 / B --; -----SST -- ------------------------------------ _ S'.-:~-:~~8! { ? / SST ___________ _________ ___ _ ____ ____ __ _ ST-19-14 789 / B .,, Vlavender ST-19-14789 / C / SST 168 King Co Medical Examiner 19-2256 Torrance Cummings 169 King Co Medical Examiner 170 King Co Medical Examiner 171 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 172 Clallam Co Coroner 19-02573 Ahmed Noor ST-19-14792 / A .,, VGray . - .. - -- - - - - /' ... - - - - 19-02558 Gabriel Puentes-Hernandez ST-19-14799 / A VGray 173 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 174 Clark Co Medical Examiner 175 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 176 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 177 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 191213-115 Joseph Bullen 2019-CO-231 James Washburn 191215-112 Soundarya Narayan 2019-3103 Glenda Buck 191211-38 Te Nguyen 19-2264 Brady Bums 19-2262 Robert Froman 178 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2248 Michaei Koentopp 179 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2260 James Palmer Dennis MichelBook Gary Ebel ST-19-14891 / B / ST-19-14892 / B / - ST-19-14900 / B _,, ST-19-14900 / C / - - __ ~T-! 9-1~90_1 /~ ~ _ VGray VGray Vlavender SST VGray ST-19-14902 / B r VLavender - ST-19-14914> B /" · - VG;ay ---· - -ST-19-14915/s / VGray ST-1 9-14916 /B / -ST-19-14917 ls -/ VGray VGray ST-19-14918 /B _,, VGray sr-19-14s1s-/ s- - - -vo;a~ -------------- 180 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 181 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 182 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 183 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2250 19-2254 19-2270 19-2261 Donald Owens David Oden sr-is-isooo/s>- ·-vG;ay ____ ____ __ ---------- ----- --- ----- ------ ·sr-iS-isooi-/s / -- - VGray - ----- -- - -- ----- ---- · -- 184 Benton Co Coroner C19-491 Cliff Johnson ST-19-15003/ B / VGray -- - - - - ---- - - --- --- - - - - -- - - - -- - - - - - - --- -- -- - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - -- -- - -- - - - -/ - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- - -- - - - -- - - - - - - - __ !~5-_ h~~~~~~ ~~~~n e: _______ ________ ~~ ~9~~~ _ :~~~~:~ _____ _____ -~'.-:~:~~-8./ ~-_/ ___ ~G~ay_ _______ _ __________ ______ __ ___ ______ __ _ _ _ !~6-_ ~i~~~ ~~ ?_o:~~~r- ___________ _ : _ ~~--IJ:'?_0_9? __ ~a.~~~~~~~~ ______ _ ~T•'.~:~~O?/. ~ _ _ -~~~ ________ ___ ___ _______ ______________ ____ _ 187 Pacific Co Coroner - Raymond S-1029 Terry Barber ST-19-15013 / B .,, VGray - - - - - - -- ---- -- - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---- - - - - - - - - - -- - --- - - - - -- - - - - -- --- - - - ------ -/ -- - - - - - - - -- - - ---- - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - --- - - - - - -- - --- -- 188 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2278 1216upriver UDF ST-19-15014 / B VGray [R1 .0-20161 027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 10 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000284 No. Agency Name 189 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 190 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 191 Yakima Co Coroner 192 Yakima Co Coroner 193 Yakima Co Coroner 194 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 195 Yakima Co Coroner 196 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 187 Skagit Co Coroner 198 King Co Medical Examiner 199 King Co Medical Examiner 200 Clark Co Medical Examiner 201 Clark Co Medical Examiner 202 Clark Co Medical Examiner 203 Clark Co Medical Examiner 204 Benton Co Coroner 205 Benton Co Coroner 206 Benton Co Coroner 207 Kitsap Co Coroner 208 King Co Medical Examiner 209 King Co Medical Examiner 210 King Co Medical Examiner Age Case # Subject Name 19-2279 John Lawson 19-2275 Sharon Lawley 19-565 H27 Richard Plumlee 19-557 MVP6 Lakhwainder Singh . - -- .. - - - . - - . - - - - -.. - - . - - . - - - 19-549 H25 Luis Acosta 191218-109 Therese Williams 19-555 H26 Manuel Pantaleon 192452 Cooper Dyson 19SK0396 Arthur Oneal 19-02640 Douglas Walker 19-02627 Devon Cooper 2019-3123 Amber Clinton 2019-3195 Andrew Lutes 2019-3177 Scott Rielly 2019-3183 Ronald Coelho C19-496 Levi Small C19-503 Wanda Cowell-Saylors C19-506 Kerry McSwan KCl-19-062 Ronald Pease 19-02651 Rudi Hirschel 19-02657 Ryan Friend 19-02656 Kolbi Stewart Note: Returned items are not included Case ID Evid. Desc. Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age :T-!~!5~15/~_< -~G~a! ___ ____ __ ___ __ . ____ -- - ----- - -- · ST-19-15016 /. B .,,. Vlavender _ ~~-~~~5~1~/~ _ ,, ___ :!~~~s_n~~ . ST-~~•!501!_ /'. ~ _ -'_ _ _~~~a! ___ _ ST-19-15018 /B / VGray ST-19-15020 / B ,.,- VGray -ST-19-15038-/ B ,,,- VGray . . - - - - . . . - . . - - - . - . - - - . ST-19-15039 / B / VGray -- sr-iii-i si24"f s ·;;-·vGr~~n----. ST-19-15130 /B ,,.,,. PTubeSnap -ST-19-15134 / B / - VLavender ST-19-1 5135/ C / SST ST-19-15154 i B ·/ VGray ST-19-15155 /'s / VGray ·· - -· · - · ,,,- ----· ··- -· ST-1 9-15156 / B VGray - - - - - . - - - . - - - - . ST-19-15157 / B ,,,.- VGray - -- -- -- / - ST-19-15158 / B VGray :T-19-_1525_6_ /B_ >-_ VGray __ :T-19-~5~5? (_ ~ _ _ _ _ VG~a!_ _ _ _ ST-19-15280 / A - ST-19-15282 / B / ST-19-15282 / C / ST-19-15294 ( B / -ST-i9-15295 ;-;._ ✓ VGreen VLavender VGray 211 Clallam Co Coroner 2019-C0-235 Monty Robuck ST-19-15304 /B ./ Vlavender VGray VGray 212 Clallam Co Coroner 213 Clallam Co Coroner 214 Benton Co Coroner 2019-C0-233 Ricky McGowan 2019-C0-238 Joel Blazek C 19-519 Francisco Martinez ST-19-15305 / B / VGray .. - - - -- - . - - . --.. - . . - - . - -- - - - - - -- ---- - -- - - - - - - -- - -. - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - ST-19-15306 / B / VGray · sr-2(}-0003s-; s--; -.. -· vG;;y---------------------- ---------------. - -- ------------------- --- ------- ----- --- ------ --- ---- ------------- ------ ------- -- --- --- ----- ----- - ---------- --- ----------------- ---- [R1 _0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_(by Case#J.rpt Page 11 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000285 No. Agency Name Age Case # Subject Name Case ID Evid. Desc. 215 Chelan Co Coroner CH2019-502 Vicky Albrecht ST-20-00038 / B / VGray -216 -Ch~i;n c~- c;;;~n·e·r- - . .. ... - - - . - c:"riio19.501 .Eri·c-Hoff;rb;; - - • . ST-20-00039. is. ✓ - -VG;a~ - -211 . sk~9 it c; c~~~~~~ -. -.... ---.. -. -. 19s1<.04oa- - -c~n-H~ide. - - - - - - - .• - - - . sr-26.oo041 / s.; ---·vGr;;n X20-001 Cole Garcia VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age 218 Okanogan Co Coroner 219 Whitman Co Coroner 220 Yakima Co Coroner ST-20-00051 / B / ST-20-00053 I B / ------ ------------ - --------- ------- -- - 221 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 222 Clark Co Medical Examiner 19-WC093 Vess Brelsford 19-581 T38 Roberto Davila 192530 Remains Unidentified 2019-3188 Laurel Marquiss 2020-0014 Juan Carrillo 2019-3213 Lena Barnes 2020-0004 Samuel Souken 2020-0003 Kim Croft Kory Mitchell VRed -sr-20-oiios=r;,· s 1 - VGray ST-20-00214/ B / VGreen ST-20-00228 / B ;r VL.avender ST-20-00228 / C " VLavender ST-20-00228 / D / VLavender ST-20-00228 / E / SST ST-20-00228 / F / VGray -sr-26.oom / a j ST-20-00232 / B / -- . -- .. - - -- ST-20-00234 / B / - · ----. · -- -- ST-20-00235 / B /' VGray VGray VGray VGray ST-20-00236 / B .,- VGray 223 Clark Co Medical Examiner 224 Clark Co Medical Examiner 225 Clark Co Medical Examiner 226 Clark Co Medical Examiner 227 Clark Co Medical Examiner 228 Clark Co Medical Examiner 229 King Co Medical Examiner 2019-3210 2020-0006 20-00004 Aaron Washington ST-2().00238/ s r VGray · - · · · · · ·· · - - - - - · · • · · · · • · · · · - · · · · · · Delbert Kinghorn ··· - ··· ·· / ··-·-•· · ·-· ·· · - -·-·-·----····· · ST-20-00361 / B Vlavender . •· ·--·- ---- ·-·--• •·- ----- --- ---- ---------- ---· 230 Whatcom Co Medical Examiner A-007-2020 ST-20-00382 / B .,,- VGray ST-20-00382/ C / VRed Richard Bernard 231 Snohomish Co Medical Examiner 200106-397 ~~u~:~ ~arre'.n~~~ _ . : : : : . ~~-~().~~~8_9 /'a./ _ . _ -~~r~:[l >;.::::::: _:::: ~:::::::::.:::::. . .. . 232 Yakima Co Coroner 20-010 Manuel Mendez 233 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 20-0013 Timothy Mead 234 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2286 Zackary Beach 235 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 19-2315 Latoya Holland ST-20-00457 /B sr-26.oii4s2 -. fi 1 ST-20-00463 / B ST-2~63 / C / ST-20-00468 / B _, 236 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 20-0016 John Schuessler ST-20-00469 /B ./ VGray VGray VGray VGreen VGray VGray .. 237 -Sp~k~~~ ·c~ M~d·i~I-E;~~i~~~ - - - - .. - - 19:2·3-19- . - -Willi~~ -Felt;r- - - - - - - - . - - -ST-20-00472/s j . .. -VG;a~ - ......... - - .. - . . - - - - ..... - - - - . . . - . . . . . . [R1. 0-20161027] Evid_Handling_/nquiry_(by Case#).rpt Page 12 of 13 Print 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000286 No. Agency Name 238 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 239 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 240 Benton Co Coroner 241 Grays Harbor Co Coroner 242 Walla Walla Co Coroner 243 Pierce Co Medical Examiner 244 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 245 Spokane Co Medical Examiner 246 Clark Co Medical Examiner · 247 Clark Co Medical Examiner 248 Benton Co Coroner "To Be Disposed" Case Count : 248 "To Be Disposed" Evid Count: 356 Age Case# Subject Name 19-2339 19-2347 C20-013 Mykola Tretyak Ronald Mickelson Robert Simmons 2020026 Jeri Stiles 200109-447 200112 20-0067 Gilberto Saenz Joshua Smith Clando Anitok UDM 20-0069 Kevin Brown 2020-0139 Dan Winston 2020-0068 Jarrett Alexander C20-033 Tessa West Total Case Count: 248 Total Evidence Count: 356 ----c Case ID Evid. sr-20-00475 is·~ VGray ST-20-00476 / B / VGray Note: Returned items are not included Evid/Handle Note Return to Other Age ------- - · -------- ------------ ---------- --- -----------· -- --- - ST-20-00640 /8 ....- VGray ST-20-00643 / B .,,.. Vlavender ST-20-00643 ./ C / SST . - . - - - - - - - - - . - ST-20-00650 /8 ,,,. sr.-~~~7~-/~ ( _ ST-20-00773 / B .-- ST-20-00m j"B / ST-20-00940-; B / .. - -- . . ST-20-00954 /B ST-20-00954 I c r ST-20-00954 / D / ST-20-01299 /B / VGray VGreen VGray VGray VGray VGray VGray VRed VGray {R1 .0-20161027] Evid_Handling_lnquiry_:.(by Case#).rpt Page 13 of 13 Print: 5/18/2020, 12:44:28PM P007796-031024-000287 ·-·~··' :·T. . Toxicology Laboratory Evidence Disposition Records . . Evidence Relinquished By: Capron, Brian Evidence Released To: - Setting Final Disposition - Disposed, (by Tox Lab) Transfer Info: [VIA] [Date] 5/19/2020 [Note] Total Case Count: 247 Total Evidence Count: 355 ~ Lab Ci:!~e #. Ag~nc~ Ca§~ #. Subject Ni;;!me 1 ST-17-00299 16-037668 Gurvinder Mander ( 1) ST-17-00299-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-17 -00299-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 2 ST-18-06357 18-014152 Oscar G. Cruz ( 1) ST-18-06357-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-18-06357-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 3 ST-18-07042 18-015454 Daqim Fassil (1) ST-18-07042-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-18-07042-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 4 ST-18-09161 18-019645 Troy D. Egbert ( 1) ST-18-09161-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 5 ST-19-01672 019-000041 Lorianne R. Woodriff ( 1) ST-19-01672-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-01672-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-01672-C One vacutainer with red top Urine (4) ST-19-01672-D One vacutainer with red top Urine 6 ST-19-02255 019-00421 Rusty L. Mullikin (1) ST-19-02255-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02255-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 7 ST-19-02347 19-1483 Ruthann L. Glassman ( 1) ST-19-0234 7 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-0234 7 -B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 8 ST-19-02355 19A00839 Omar Sanchez ( 1) ST-19-02355-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02355-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 9 ST-19-02923 2019-2975 Natalee R. Amsdill (1) ST-19-02923-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-02923-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-02923-C One plastic cup Urine 10 ST-19-03331 W19-188 Isaac L. Seavey (1) ST-19-03331 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03331-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 11 ST-19-03452 19W03463 Jennifer S. Dechenne [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 1 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000288 ( 1) ST-19-03452-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03452-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 12 ST-19-03574 19-2332 Dennis L. Gray (1) ST-19-0357 4-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03574-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 13 ST-19-03693 19W03540 James J. Schuyleman (1) ST-19-03693-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03693-B One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral 14 ST-19-03881 2019-000014451 Jolene S. Love (1) ST-19-03881-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-03881-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 15 ST-19-04916 2019-6371 Matthew E. Garner (1) ST-19-04916-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-04916-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-04916-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (4) ST-19-04916-D One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 16 ST-19-04930 19-3811 Damon W. Clarke (1) ST-19-04930-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-04930-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 17 ST-19-05089 1911601162 Amy D. Weisbeck ( 1) ST-19-05089-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05089-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 18 ST-19-05090 1911801852 James P. Coffee (1) ST-19-05090-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST -19-05090-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 19 ST-19-05163 2019-00022913 Chad D. Torve (1) ST-19-05163-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05163-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 20 ST-19-05164 19-001409 Isaias Sanchez-Gonsalez (1) ST-19-05164-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05164-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 21 ST-19-05165 19-001346 Juan C. Valencia Ochoa (1) ST-19-05165-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05165-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 22 ST-19-05183 19A02097 Peter M. Cavenaugh (1) ST-19-05183-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05183-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 23 ST-19-05195 19-4262 Alanna L. Upp (1) ST-19-05195-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05195-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 24 ST-19-05471 E19-02953 Nathan I. Sadang (1) ST-19-054 71-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-05471-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 25 ST-19-07516 E19-07983 Ram B. Rai Kirati (1) ST-19-07516-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-07516-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 26 ST-19-08628 19W09842 Justin J. HIii (1) ST-19-08628-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-08628-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R 1.0-20190424) ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 2 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000289 27 ST-19-08908 19-01589 Joseghlne V. Vongsengchan (1) ST-19-08908-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-08908-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-08908-C One serum separator tube Serum - Hospital 28 ST-19-09291 1921500225 Kenneth W , Cormier ( 1) ST-19-09291 -A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-09291 -B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 29 ST-19-10223 19-01809 Edwin A. Wolff (1) ST-19-10223-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-10223-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Peripheral 30 ST-19-10232 19-01754 Lashaun M. Hartfield (1) ST-19-10232-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-10232-B One serum separator tube Serum - Hospital 31 ST-19-11235 19-01977 Jermaine K. Norman (1) ST-19-11235-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-11235-B One serum separator tube Serum 32 ST-19-11236 19-01984 Enrigue Rodriguez ( 1) ST-19-11236-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-11236-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 33 ST-19-11886 19-01933 Tyrone N. Bolds ( 1) ST-19-11886-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 34 ST-19-11908 2019-2442 Deborah L. Nelsen (1) ST-19-11908-A One vacutainer with gray top Other (2) ST-19-11908-B One vacutainer with gray top Other 35 ST-19-12167 19-2116 Emily Parker (1) ST-19-12167-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-12167-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-12167-C One plastic tube Serum 36 ST-19-12269 19-1892 1012 Fancher Rd UDM ( 1) ST-19-12269-A One plastic cup Brain (2) ST-19-12269-A-1 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 37 ST-19-12294 191012-385 Shawna L. Brune (1) ST-19-12294-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 38 ST-19-12307 191016-345 John O'Leary (1) ST-19-12307-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 39 ST-19-12316 19-02166 Kim G. Holding ( 1) ST-19-1 2316-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 40 ST-19-12524 1928402231 Daniel J. Restau (1) ST-19-12524-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-12524-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 41 ST-19-12621 CH2019-411 Michael P. Aeon ( 1) ST-19-12621-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 42 ST-19-12631 KCA-19-106 Annalese Thomgson ( 1) ST-19-12631-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 43 ST-19-12747 191025-365 Keith E. Standal (1) ST-19-12747-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 44 ST-19-12786 19-375003 Dylan M. Shafman (1) ST-19-12786-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-12786-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 3 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000290 45 ST-19-13161 19-2181-11 Morton S. James ( 1) ST-19-13161-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 46 ST-19-13189 19-02301 Martin D. lndalecio (1) ST-19-13189-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 47 ST-19-13190 19-02294 Michael F. Knapp (1) ST-19-13190-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13190-B One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-13190-C One serum separator tube Serum 48 ST-19-13194 19-02293 Joseph K. Antoncich (1) ST-19-13194-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 49 ST-19-13198 19-02259 Daniel E. Gleason ( 1) ST-19-13198-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 50 ST-19-13199 19-02296 Judy L. Wayne ( 1) ST-19-13199-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 51 ST-19-13332 192144 Larry Lane ( 1) ST-19-13332-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 52 ST-19-13333 192151 Noel Cabardo ( 1) ST-19-13333-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 53 ST-19-13334 192149 Evan Suckow ( 1) ST-19-13334-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 54 ST-19-13335 192177 Percy David ( 1) ST-19-13335-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 55 ST-19-13461 19-2077 Amberly T. Masonholder (1) ST-19-13461-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13461-B One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-13461-C One serum separator tube Serum 56 ST-19-13666 19-02376 Cesar 0 . Erazo (1) ST-19-13666-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Cavity 57 ST-19-13669 19-2372 Alison A. Powell (1) ST-19-13669-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13669-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-13669-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Hospital 58 ST-19-13761 191117-94 Matthew A. Dick ( 1) ST-19-13761-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 59 ST-19-13764 191113-305 Nicholas A. Soulias (1) ST-19-13764-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 60 ST-19-13766 CH2019-451 Michael J. Studley (1) ST-19-13766-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13766-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 61 ST-19-13770 2019-CO-205 Rodney Edwards (1) ST-19-13770-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood (2) ST-19-13770-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood 62 ST-19-13773 191118-414 Kari L. Foss (1) ST-19-13773-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 63 ST-19-13774 C19-441 Melanie A. Novotney (1) ST-19-13774-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 64 ST-19-13777 192230 David Kesner (1) ST-19-13777-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 65 ST-19-13778 2019-2858 Jonathan Pfingston [R1 . 0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound. rpt Page 4 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000291 ( 1) ST-19-13778-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13778-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 66 ST-19-13779 2019-2848 Frederick C. SteQhens ( 1) ST-19-13779-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 67 ST-19-13780 2019-2818 Kathleen E. Lane (1) ST-19-13780-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 68 ST-19-13782 C19-444 Theodore Knuth (1) ST-19-13782-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-13782-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 69 ST-19-13784 19-637 Penny L. Turner ( 1) ST-19-13784-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 70 ST-19-13789 19-2105 Terry L. Coleman ( 1) ST-19-13789-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13789-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 71 ST-19-13790 19-2099 Timothy J. Daily (1) ST-19-13790-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13790-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 72 ST-19-13792 19-2102 Maya E. Aubert ( 1) ST-19-13792-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13792-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-13792-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 73 ST-19-13795 19-02402 Wayne L. Newkirk (1) ST-19-13795-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 74 ST-19-13797 19-02370 Valeree A. Neuman (1) ST-19-13797-B One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-13797-C One serum separator tube Serum 75 ST-19-13880 19-02385 SteQhen P. Wilson (1) ST-19-13880-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13880-C One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 76 ST-19-13882 19-02396 Tae H. Shin (1) ST-19-13882-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-13882-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 77 ST-19-13883 19-02397 Christo12her P. Tharg-Drake ( 1) ST-19-13883-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 78 ST-19-13886 19-02400 Kevin M. Steele ( 1) ST-19-13886-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 79 ST-19-13892 19-663 Ronnie Cox ( 1) ST-19-13892-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 80 ST-19-13904 192254 Thomas Watkins (1) ST-19-13904-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 81 ST-19-13911 19-02394 Donovan Stuhr (1) ST-19-13911-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 82 ST-19-13912 19-02427 Branden B. Coge (1) ST-19-13912-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 83 ST-19-14040 19-02412 Roger G. Sherman (1) ST-19-14040-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 84 ST-19-14043 2019-2895 Viola Thuring-Bregenzer (1) ST-19-14043-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14043-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous [R1. 0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 5 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000292 85 ST-19-14044 2019-2880 Larry 0. Tonder ( 1) ST-19-14044-A One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14044-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 86 ST-19-14045 CH2019-464 Andrew Dickinson ( 1) ST-19-14045-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14045-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 87 ST-19-14052 KCl-19-057 Riley Gibson (1) ST-19-14052-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 88 ST-19-14056 192284 Wendey Foster (1) ST-19-14056-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 89 ST-19-14057 192278 Jacob Dawson (1) ST-19-14057-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital 90 ST-19-14059 192272 Craig Hunter (1) ST-19-14059-A One vacutainer with pink top Blood - Hospital 91 ST-19-14060 192263 John Smith (1) ST-19-14060-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 92 ST-19-14065 2019-2932 Steven Hayes (1) ST-19-14065-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14065-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 93 ST-19-14066 2019-2933 Kimberly Rojas-Flores ( 1) ST-19-14066-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood (2) ST-19-14066-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 94 ST-19-14067 2019-2937 Marry A. Casey (1) ST-19-14067-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14067-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 95 ST-19-14069 2019-2901 Susan M. Wallace (1) ST-19-14069-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14069-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 96 ST-19-14070 2019-2921 Tiffany Hill ( 1) ST-19-14070-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14070-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 97 ST-19-14071 19-378 Phillip I. Bakke ( 1) ST-19-14071-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14071-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 98 ST-19-14072 192313 Kellie Ford (1) ST-19-14072-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 99 ST-19-14074 192318 Matthew Klaniecki (1) ST-19-14074-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 100 ST-19-14075 192304 Melvyn Osburn ( 1) ST-19-14075-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 101 ST-19-14160 192266 John Stockman (1) ST-19-14160-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 102 ST-19-14162 192299 Ailill Breiner (1) ST-19-14162-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 103 ST-19-14164 192292 Peter Heryford (1) ST-19-14164-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 104 ST-19-14166 19-02453 Joe D. Ramos (1) ST-19-14166-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 105 ST-19-14167 19-02449 Joon Y. Park {R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 6 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000293 ( 1) ST-19-14167-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 106 ST-19-14169 19-02452 Douglas J. Sykes ( 1) ST-19-14169-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 107 ST-19-14171 19-02447 Michelle D. Yarnell ( 1) ST-19-14171-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 108 ST-19-14173 19-02440 Michael P. Chevalier ( 1) ST-19-14173-B One serum separator tube Serum (2) ST-19-14173-C One serum separator tube Serum 109 ST-19-14174 19-02437 Joseph M. Webb ( 1) ST-19-14174-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14174-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-19-14174-C One serum separator tube Serum 110 ST-19-14175 19-02420 April Cook ( 1) ST-19-14175-B One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14175-C One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-14175-D One serum separator tube Serum (4) ST-19-14175-E One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (5) ST-19-14175-F One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (6) ST-19-14175-G One plastic tube Blood - Hospital (7) ST-19-14175-H One serum separator tube Serum 111 ST-19-14177 19-02474 Robert L. Mitchell (1) ST-19-14177-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 112 ST-19-14179 19-02472 Alice N. Johnson (1) ST-19-14179-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14179-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 113 ST-19-14180 19-02470 Craig M. Taylor ( 1) ST-19-14180-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 114 ST-19-14182 19-02466 Rebecca A. Richman (1) ST-19-14182-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 115 ST-19-14183 19-2463 Rodney R. Mulvaney (1) ST-19-14183-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 116 ST-19-14185 19-02461 Justin T. Smith (1) ST-19-14185-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 117 ST-19-14192 192329 Machelle Winn (1) ST-19-14192-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 118 ST-19-14194 19-379 John L. Prutton (1) ST-19-14194-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14194-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 119 ST-19-14196 19-516 MVF15 Enrique Arreola (1) ST-19-14196-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14196-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 120 ST-19-14198 19SK0375 Richard L. Johnson (1) ST-19-14198-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 121 ST-19-14284 191124-169 Joseph J. Love (1) ST-19-14284-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 122 ST-19-14291 2019-2971 Anthony R. Harrington (1) ST-19-14291-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14291-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 123 ST-19-14300 192322 Roy Evans [R 1.0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 7 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000294 ( 1) ST-19-14300-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14300-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 124 ST-19-14302 19-2165 Emily Hampton (1) ST-19-14302-A One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14302-B One serum separator tube Serum 125 ST-19-14305 19-2129 Kenneth W. Buelo (1) ST-19-14305-A One vacutainer with blue top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14305-B One plastic tube Serum (3) ST-19-14305-C One serum separator tube Serum 126 ST-19-14306 19-2126 1121 Momoe UDM (1) ST-19-14306-B One vacutainer with gray top Spleen Squeeze 127 ST-19-14309 19-2139 John R. Alfino (1) ST-19-14309-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 128 ST-19-14313 19-2162 Dean M. York (1) ST-19-14313-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14313-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral (3) ST-19-14313-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 129 ST-19-14315 19-2172 Brenna L. Strine (1) ST-19-14315-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 130 ST-19-14316 19-2186 Harvey A. Willey (1) ST-19-14316-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 131 ST-19-14317 19-2168 Benjamin J. Wheeler ( 1) ST-19-14317-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 132 ST· 19-14319 19-CO-218 William Carr (1) ST-19-14319-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14319-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 133 ST-19-14446 191202-177 Aubrey L. Forslof ( 1) ST-19-14446-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 134 ST-19-14447 191203-261 Cynthia J. Ulrich ( 1) ST-19-14447-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 135 ST-19-14448 191204-96 Thomas A. Boullioun (1) ST -1 9-14448-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 136 ST-19-14451 KCl-19-060 Robert Morales (1) ST-19-14451-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 137 ST-19-14453 192345 Reynaldo Salvador ( 1) ST-19-14453-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 138 ST-19-14454 192358 Eyan Ricker (1) ST -19-14454-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood 139 ST-19-14455 192348 Clinton Rave (1) ST-19-14455-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 140 ST-19-14456 192366 Dennis Williams ( 1) ST-19-14456-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 141 ST-19-14463 19-02500 Sammy D. Dehart (1) ST -19-14463-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 142 ST-19-14464 19-02499 Dawn R. Miller ( 1) ST-19-14464-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood • Peripheral 143 ST-19-14560 19-00241 Vuong H. Do (1) ST -19-14560-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Central 144 ST-19-14561 19-2508 Lawrence A. Morgan [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 8 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000295 (1) ST-19-14561-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14561-C One serum separator tube Serum (3) ST-19-14561-D One serum separator tube Serum 145 ST-19-14562 2019-3039 Sally Hoptowit (1) ST-19-14562-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 146 ST-19-14563 2019-2984 Charles C. Mason ( 1) ST-19-14563-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 147 ST-19-14564 2019-3047 Derick Rasband ( 1) ST -19-14564-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 148 ST-19-14565 2019-3008 David A. Gehring (1) ST-19-14565-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 149 ST-19-14567 X19-137 Joseph R. Gutierrez (1) ST-19-14567-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 150 ST-19-14574 19-398 Corey M. Simmons (1) ST-19-14574-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 151 ST-19-14588 2019644 Dwayne A. Alley (1) ST-19-14588-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 152 ST-19-14589 19-547 T46 Leroy J. Dollicker ( 1) ST-19-14589-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 153 ST-19-14590 1028 Marla J. Porter ( 1) ST-19-14590-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 154 ST-19-14591 19-2235 Robert J. Lucas ( 1) ST-19-14591-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 155 ST-19-14592 19-2220 Ronald J. Wittkopf (1) ST-19-14592-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 156 ST-19-14593 19-2229 Robert A. Taitch (1) ST-19-14593-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 157 ST-19-14594 2019-CO-225 Kathern Allen (1) ST-19-14594-B One vacutainer with gray top Spleen Squeeze 158 ST-19-14595 2019-CO-224 Kimberly Bender ( 1) ST-19-14595-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 159 ST-19-14599 C19-474 Sheila Smith ( 1) ST-19-14599-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 160 ST-19-14760 C19-479 Donald E. Scully (1) ST-19-14760-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14760-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 161 ST-19-14762 C19-473 David A. Dana (1) ST-19-14762-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-19-14762-C One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 162 ST-19-14764 2019-3082 Mortimer M. Hernandez ( 1) ST-19-14 764-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral (2) ST-19-14764-8 One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 163 ST-19-14772 192418 Christopher Dennis (1) ST-19-14772-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 164 ST-19-14774 19-2387 Edward Webb (1) ST-19-14774-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 165 ST-19-14777 19-02583 Gerald N. lncrocci (1) ST-19-14777-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1.0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 9 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000296 166 ST-19-14783 19-02536 Terrance L. Conrad ( 1) ST-19-14783-8 One serum separator tube Serum (2) ST-19-14783-C One serum separator tube Serum 167 ST-19-14789 19-2256 Torrance J. Cummings ( 1) ST-19-14789-8 One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14789-C One serum separator tube Serum 168 ST-19-14792 19-02573 Ahmed A Noor ( 1) ST-19-14792-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 169 ST-19-14799 19-02558 Gabriel Puentes-Hernandez (1) ST-19-14799-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 170 ST-19-14891 191213-115 Joseph N. Bullen (1) ST-19-14891-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 171 ST-19-14892 2019-CO-231 James E. Washburn (1) ST-19-14892-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 172 ST-19-14900 191215-112 Sounda[Ya Narayan ( 1) ST-19-14900-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-14900-C One serum separator tube Serum 173 ST-19-14901 2019-3103 Glenda J. Buck (1) ST-19-14901-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 174 ST-19-14902 191211-38 Te T. Nguyen (1) ST-19-14902-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 175 ST-19-14914 19-2264 Brady Burns (1) ST-19-14914-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 176 ST-19-14915 19-2262 Robert L. Froman (1) ST-19-14915-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 177 ST-19-14916 19-2248 Michael Koentopp ( 1) ST-19-14916-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 178 ST-19-14917 19-2260 James L. Palmer (1) ST-19-14917-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 179 ST-19-14918 19-2250 Dennis B. MichelBook (1) ST-19-14918-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 180 ST-19-14919 19-2254 Ga[Y H. Ebel (1) ST-19-14919-B One vacutalner with gray top Blood - Peripheral 181 ST-19-15000 19-2270 Donald J. Owens (1) ST-19-15000-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 182 ST-19-15001 19-2261 David M. Oden (1) ST-19-15001-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 183 ST-19-15003 C19-491 Cliff D. Johnson (1) ST-19-15003-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 184 ST-19-15008 CH2019-492 Grego[Y I. Ness (1) ST-19-15008-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 185 ST-19-15009 19-WC092 Ma[Y Ann Bowman (1) ST-19-15009-B One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 186 ST-19-15013 S-1029 Ter[Y R. Barber (1) ST-19-15013-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 187 ST-19-15014 19-2278 1216upriver UDF (1) ST-19-1 5014-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 188 ST-19-15015 19-2279 John M. Lawson {R1 .0-20190424) ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 10 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000297 (1) ST-19-15015-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 189 ST-19-15016 19-2275 Sharon M. Lawley (1) ST-19-15016-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-15016-C One plastic tube with snap top Serum - Hospital 190 ST-19-15017 19-565 H27 Richard Plumlee (1) ST-19-15017-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 191 ST-19-15018 19-Q57 MVP6 Lakhwainder M. Singh (1) ST-19-15018-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 192 ST-19-15020 19-549 H25 Luis Acosta ( 1) ST-19-15020-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 193 ST-19-15038 191218-109 Therese Williams (1) ST-19-15038-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 194 ST-19-15039 19-555 H26 Manuel M. Pantaleon (1) ST-19-15039-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 195 ST-19-15124 192452 Cooper Dyson (1) ST-19-15124-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 196 ST-19-15130 19SK0396 Arthur F. Oneal (1) ST-19-15130-B One plastic tube with snap top Vitreous 197 ST-19-15134 19-02640 Douglas Walker ( 1) ST-19-15134-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 198 ST-19-15135 19-02627 Devon M. Cooper (1) ST-19-15135-C One serum separator tube Serum 199 ST-19-15154 2019-3123 Amber Clinton (1) ST-19-15154-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 200 ST-19-15155 2019-3195 Andrew W. Lutes (1) ST-19-15155-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 201 ST-19-15156 2019-3177 Scott A. Rielly ( 1) ST-19-15156-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 202 ST-19-15157 2019-3183 Ronald P. Coelho (1) ST-19-15157-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 203 ST-19-15158 C19-496 Levi Small ( 1) ST-19-15158-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 204 ST-19-15256 C19-503 Wanda Cowell-Saylors ( 1) ST-19-15256-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 205 ST-19-15257 C19-506 Kerry McSwan ( 1) ST-19-15257-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 206 ST-19-15280 KCl-19-062 Ronald A. Pease ( 1) ST-19-15280-A One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 207 ST-19-15282 19-02651 Rudi Hirsche! ( 1) ST-19-15282-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-19-15282-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 208 ST-19-15294 19-02657 Ryan M. Friend (1) ST-19-15294-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 209 ST-19-15295 19-02656 Kolbi J. Stewart (1) ST-19-15295-A One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 210 ST-19-15304 2019-CO-235 Monty Robuck (1) ST-19-15304-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 211 ST-19-15305 2019-C0-233 Ricky McGowan [R 1. 0-20190424 J ERcpt_ Outbound. rpt Page 11 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000298 (1) ST-19-15305-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 212 ST-19-15306 2019-CO-238 Joel Blazek ( 1) ST-19-15306-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 213 ST-20-00036 C19-519 Francisco Martinez (1) ST-20-00036-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 214 ST-20-00038 CH2019-502 Vicky L. Albrecht ( 1) ST-20-00038-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 215 ST-20-00039 CH2019-501 Eric M. Hofferber (1) ST-20-00039-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 216 ST-20-00041 19SK0408 Carl P. Heide (1) ST-20-00041-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 217 ST-20-00051 X20-001 Cole W. Garcia ( 1) ST-20-00051-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 218 ST-20-00053 19-WC093 Vess L. Brelsford (1) ST-20-00053-B One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 219 ST-20-00057 19-581 T38 Roberto A. Davila ( 1) ST-20-00057-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 220 ST-20-00214 192530 Remains Unidentified ( 1) ST-20-00214-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 221 ST-20-00228 2019-3188 Laurel Marquiss ( 1) ST-20-00228-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-20-00228-C One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (3) ST-20-00228-D One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (4) ST-20-00228-E One serum separator tube Serum (5) ST-20-00228-F One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 222 ST-20-00229 2020-0014 Juan J. Carrillo ( 1) ST-20-00229-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 223 ST-20-00232 2019-3213 Lena D. Barnes (1) ST-20-00232-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 224 ST-20-00234 2020-0004 Samuel Souken (1) ST-20-00234-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 225 ST-20-00235 2020-0003 Kim Croft (1) ST-20-00235-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 226 ST-20-00236 2019-3210 Kory E. Mitchell (1) ST-20-00236-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 227 ST-20-00238 2020-0006 Aaron L. Washington (1) ST-20-00238-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 228 ST-20-00361 20-00004 Delbert N. Kinghorn (1) ST-20-00361-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital 229 ST-20-00382 A-007-2020 Richard T. Bernard (1) ST-20-00382-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-20-00382-C One vacutainer with red top Vitreous 230 ST-20-00389 200106-397 Courtney A. Larreinaga ( 1) ST-20-00389-B One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 231 ST-20-00457 20-010 Manuel T. Mendez (1) ST-20-00457-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 232 ST-20-00462 20-0013 Timothy 0. Mead (1) ST-20-00462-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral [R1. 0-20190424] ERcpt_ Outbound.rpt Page 12 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000299 233 ST-20-00463 19-2286 Zackary Beach (1) ST-20-00463-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (2) ST-20-00463-C One vacutainer with green top Blood - Central 234 ST-20-00468 19-2315 Latoya L. Holland (1) ST-20-00468-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 235 ST-20-00469 20-0016 John L. Schuessler (1) ST-20-00469-B - One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 236 ST-20-00472 19-2319 William N. Felter (1) ST-20-004 72-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 237 ST-20-00475 19-2339 Mykola Tretyak ( 1) ST-20-004 75-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 238 ST-20-00476 19-2347 Ronald P. Mickelson ( 1) ST-20-004 76-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 239 ST-20-00640 C20-013 Robert W. Simmons (1) ST-20-00640-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 240 ST-20-00643 2020026 Jeri R. Stiles (1 ) ST-20-00643-B One vacutainer with lavender top Blood - Hospital (2) ST-20-00643-C One serum separator tube Serum 241 ST-20-00650 200109-417 Gilberto M. Saenz ( 1) ST-20-00650-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 242 ST-20-00754 200112 Joshua Smith ( 1) ST-20-00754-8 One vacutainer with green top Blood - Peripheral 243 ST-20-00773 20-0067 Ciancio Anitok UDM (1) ST-20-00773-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Peripheral 244 ST-20-00777 20-0069 Kevin W. Brown ( 1) ST-20-00777-B One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central 245 ST-20-00940 2020-0139 Dan W. Winston (1) ST-20-00940-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous 246 ST-20-00954 2020-0068 Jarrett R. Alexander (1) ST-20-00954-B One vacutainer with gray top Vitreous (2) ST-20-00954-C One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central (3) ST-20-00954-D One vacutainer with red top Urine 247 ST-20-01299 C20-033 Tessa P. West (1) ST-20-01299-8 One vacutainer with gray top Blood - Central SIGNATURES Evidence Disposed By: Signature of the Supervisor: Date: ) / (°l I 2.-v [R1 .0-20190424] ERcpt_Outbound.rpt Page 13 of 13 Print: 5/19/2020, 12:59:43PM P007796-031024-000300 February 16, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning former Washington State Patrol (WSP) Toxicology Lab Manager, Dr. Brianna Peterson Dear Mr. Brown: On August 3, 2021 the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named former WSP employee. We are notifying you at this time that we have received and are forwarding additional information for review and distribution as you deem appropriate. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh Attachments cc: Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000301 August 3, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning former Washington State Patrol (WSP) Toxicology Lab Manager, Dr. Brianna Peterson Dear Mr. Brown: On July 2, 2021, an Assistant Seattle City Attorney provided a defense motion to dismiss/exclude to Washington State Patrol (WSP) personnel. The defense motion to dismiss/exclude argues that WSP Toxicology Lab Manager Dr. Brianna Peterson presented false testimony. The WSP is forwarding the defense motion to dismiss/exclude as possible potential impeachment disclosure (PID) information pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1983) for your review and distribution as you deem appropriate. Additional information will be provided as it becomes available. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau P007796-031024-000302 October 15, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning former Washington State Patrol (WSP) Toxicology Lab Manager, Dr. Brianna Peterson Dear Mr. Brown: On August 3, 2021 the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named former WSP employee. We are notifying you at this time that we have received and are forwarding additional information for review and distribution as you deem appropriate. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh Attachments cc: Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000303 P007796-031024-000304 P007796-031024-000305 May 20, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Anthony K. Reese, Badge Number 564 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, during a traffic stop, Trooper failed to properly investigate a possible DUI due to his interest in dating a female passenger in the vehicle. It is further alleged Trooper failed to comply with COBAN requirements during the traffic stop. Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000306 September 6, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Anthony K. Reese, Badge Number 564 Dear Mr. Brown: On May 20, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, during a traffic stop, Trooper failed to properly investigate a possible DUI due to his interest in dating a female passenger in the vehicle. It is further alleged Trooper failed to comply with COBAN requirements during the traffic stop.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings regarding unacceptable conduct and COBAN requirements were Proven, while the findings regarding neglect of duty and code of ethics were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000307 March 7, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tyler D. Roberts, Badge Number 753 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper provided untruthful information to agency employees regarding a collision investigation.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jeffrey D. Closner, Wenatchee Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000308 August 29, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tyler D. Roberts, Badge Number 753 Dear Mr. Brown: On March 7, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper provided untruthful information to agency employees regarding a collision investigation.” We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jeffrey D. Closner, Wenatchee Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000309 January 23, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Sergeant Matthew E. Rogers, Badge Number 163 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant Rogers failed to take appropriate action regarding an allegation of unwanted physical contact and/or inappropriate conduct between the complainant and a supervisor.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Kristene D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000310 JAY IN LEE Go crnor JOHN R. BATISTE Chi f STATE OF WASHINCTO WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Bo 42611 • 01 mpia, Wahington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.wp.wa.gov October 25, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Sergeant Joseph Ross, Badge Number277 Dear Mr. McBride: On August 13, 2018, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the sergeant failed to act in a manner consistent with his duty requirements and entered inaccurate information on his time and activity reports. " We are writing to notify you, the above referenced investigation has been completed. The finding on the Unsatisfactory Performance allegation was proven. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeff Merrill, WSPTA Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards Assistant Chief Jason G. Berry, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau Captain Thomas J. Foster, Commercial Vehicle Division Captain Michael S. Saunders, Office of Professional Standards C, P007796-031024-000311 April 6, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper David S. Rudenko, Badge Number 1070 Dear Mr. Brown: On August 3, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper made a DUI arrest without probable cause. It is further alleged Trooper provided untruthful information regarding a DUI arrest.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000312 August 3, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper David S. Rudenko, Badge Number 1070 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper made a DUI arrest without probable cause. It is further alleged Trooper provided untruthful information regarding a DUI arrest.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000313 JAY IN LEf Go crnor TATE OF WA HI GTO WASHINGTON STATE PATROL JOHN R. BATISTE Chi f PO Bo 42611 • Olympia, Wa hington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.\ p.wa.gov May 23 , 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Communications Officer 1 Jensen M. Scott. Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named former employee. On February 5, 2018, the WSP received an allegation that: "It is alleged COi improperly obtained and furnished information from the ACCESS System for personal reasons. EXPANSION: IT JS ALLEGED COi WAS UNTRUTHFUL WHEN QUESTIONED BY A SUPERVISOR DURING AN INVESTIGATION " Before the department could further complete the administrative investigation into the expanded truthfulness allegation, CO 1 Scott resigned from her employment with the WSP effective May 16, 2018. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the Office of Professional Standards at (360) 704-2330. The department does not anticipate receiving any information in the future regarding the above identified former employee. MSS:rng Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards cc: Ms. Heather A. Anderson, Communications Division Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Technical Services Bureau P007796-031024-000314 October 8, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Raymond E. Seaburg, Badge Number 775 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, during a DUI arrest, Trooper made an inappropriate comment to a subject regarding her race.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ronald W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000315 February 15, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Raymond E. Seaburg, Badge Number 775 Dear Mr. Brown: On October 8, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, during a DUI arrest, Trooper made an inappropriate comment to a subject regarding her race.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed. The finding regarding unacceptable conduct was Proven, while the finding regarding code of ethics was Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Ronald W. Mead, Bellevue P007796-031024-000316 August 3, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Washington State Patrol (WSP) Seattle Toxicology Laboratory Dear Mr. Brown: On July 2, 2021, an Assistant Seattle City Attorney provided a defense motion to dismiss/exclude to Washington State Patrol (WSP) personnel. The defense motion to dismiss/ exclude argues government mismanagement of the WSP Seattle Toxicology Laboratory involving methamphetamine contamination. The WSP is forwarding the defense motion to dismiss/exclude as possible potential impeachment disclosure (PID) information pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1983) for your review and distribution as you deem appropriate. Additional information will be provided as it becomes available. If you need any additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau P007796-031024-000317 November 14, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Cadet Muhammad Bilal Shahid, Badge Number 877 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper Cadet sexually assaulted the complainant during a DUI investigations, search incident to arrest, and/or while being transported.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Assistant Chief Shannon I. Bendiksen, Technical Services Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue Captain Robert W. Sharpe, Training Division P007796-031024-000318 November 18, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Former Trooper Cadet Muhammad Bilal Shahid, Badge Number 877 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 14, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper Cadet sexually assaulted the complainant during a DUI investigations, search incident to arrest, and/or while being transported.” We are writing to notify you a preliminary investigation was completed and no factual information of a policy was identified. As a result, the complaint was not accepted. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Assistant Chief Shannon I. Bendiksen, Technical Services Bureau Captain Ron W. Mead, Bellevue Captain Robert W. Sharpe, Training Division P007796-031024-000319 P007796-031024-000320 P007796-031024-000321 P007796-031024-000322 P007796-031024-000323 December 22, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Kristopher D. Sivertsen, Badge Number 717 Dear Mr. Brown: On December 20, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper repeatedly directed the complainant to attach a license plate to the front of her vehicle due to the complainant's national origin, religion, and race.” We are writing to notify you a preliminary investigation was completed and no factual information of a policy violation was identified. As a result, the complaint was rejected. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000324 December 20, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Kristopher D. Sivertsen, Badge Number 717 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper repeatedly directed the complainant to attach a license plate to the front of her vehicle due to the complainant's national origin, religion, and race.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000325 April 4, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Former CVEO 1 Trevor Smith, Badge Number X840 Dear Mr. Brown: On April 29, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, while off and on duty, CVEO 1 engaged in solicitation of illicit sexual acts involving his infant as well as an 11-year-old and 6-year-old child.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed. The findings were proven. Mr. Smith resigned from the agency before discipline could be implemented. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Ms. Alexis Young, PTE 17, Local 17 Assistant Chief Scott A. McCoy, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Bureau P007796-031024-000326 August 13, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Evan L. Smith, Badge Number 1126 Dear Mr. Brown: On November 24, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper made untruthful statements to his supervisor regarding conversations he had with the district command staff regarding his extended probation.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings were Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Kristine D. O’Shannon, Tacoma P007796-031024-000327 February 22, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Liam C. Sullivan, Badge Number 1254 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper Sullivan drove in an unsafe manner resulting in disabling damage to his issued patrol car. It is further alleged Trooper Sullivan was untruthful when providing information associated with the incident.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000328 May 25, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Correctional Records Technician Jesse X. Thayrich Dear Mr. Brown: On December 16, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, Correctional Records Specialist failed to meet the expectations of his position and failed a Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP).” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the finding was Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Ms. Christy Reed, WFSE Commander James W. Anderson, Criminal Records Division Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau P007796-031024-000329 February 6, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan A. Thomas Badge Number #549 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged, during a traffic stop, Trooper conducted an improper search of a vehicle and failed to comply with COBAN requirements.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000330 April 3, 2023 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Ryan A. Thomas Badge Number #549 Dear Mr. Brown: On February 6, 2023, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged, during a traffic stop, Trooper conducted an improper search of a vehicle and failed to comply with COBAN requirements.” We are writing to notify you the investigation referenced above has been completed, and the findings for searches was Proven, and the mobile/in-car video system allegation was Undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Daniel J. Atchison, Field Operations Bureau Captain Jason C. Knott, Marysville P007796-031024-000331 JAY IN LEE Go crnor I TAT OF WA HI GTO WASHINGTON STATE PATR L JOH R. BATI TE Chief PO Bo 42611 • 01 mpia, Wa hington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.\ sp.wa.gov March 8, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Trooper Clint Thompson, Badge Number 473 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the trooper submitted inaccurate and incomplete information on multiple affidavits. " If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPTA Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Sincerely, ~~ Office of Professional Standards Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000332 March 29, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Clint Thompson, Badge Number 473 Dear Mr. McBride: On March 8, 2018, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged the trooper submitted inaccurate and incomplete information on multiple affidavits.” We are writing to notify you, the above referenced investigation has been completed. The finding on the Unsatisfactory Performance allegation was proven. If you need additional information, please contact me at (360) 704-2330. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeff Merrill, WSPTA Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau Captain Michael S. Saunders, Office of Professional Standards P007796-031024-000333 JAY INSLE( Governor JOHN R. BATIST[ Chief STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Box -l2611 • Olympia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-70-l-4220 • \'\IWW.wsp.wa.gov /.foi. Q¿c_ __ 0• o JAY INSLE( Governor JOHN R. BATIST[ Chief STATE OF WASHINGTON WASHINGTON STATE PATROL PO Box -l2611 • Olympia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-70-l-4220 • \'\IWW.wsp.wa.gov /.foi. Q¿c_ __ 0• o November 17, 2020 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Clint Thompson, Badge Number 473 Dear Mr. Brown: On March 3, 2020, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “On February 13, 2020, the Pierce County Prosecuting Attorney issued a Potential Impeachment Disclosure Determination (PID) letter... “ We are writing to notify you the above referenced investigation has been closed. The findings for the allegations were undetermined. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:srw cc: Mr. Spike L. Unruh, WSPTA Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000334 March 8, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Clint Thompson, Badge Number 473 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged the trooper submitted inaccurate and incomplete information on multiple affidavits.” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPTA Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000335 JAY IN LEE Go crnor ' TATE OF WASH! GTO WASHINGTON STATE PATROL JOHN R. BATISTE Chief PO Bo 42611 • Olympia, Wa hington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www.w p.wa.gov March 8, 2018 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Trooper Clint Thompson, Badge Number 473 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the trooper submitted inaccurate and incomplete information on multiple affidavits. " If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Ron Kessler, at (360) 704-2344. MSS:mg cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPT A Captain Daniel A. Hall, Tacoma Captain Sincerely, Michael ~ S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards Assistant Chief Jeffrey R. Sass, Field Operations Bureau P007796-031024-000336 December 13, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning the Washington State Patrol (WSP) State Toxicologist Office, and State Toxicologist, Dr. Fiona J. Couper Dear Mr. Brown: On July 11, 2022, the Washington State Patrol provided notification regarding the State Toxicologist Office and the above named employee. Please find additional information attached for review and distribution as you deem appropriate. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at 360-239-4904. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh Attachments (1) P007796-031024-000337 July 11, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning the Washington State Patrol (WSP) State Toxicologist Office, and State Toxicologist, Dr. Fiona J. Couper Dear Mr. Brown: On June 13, 2022, the Kitsap County District Court issued an order to suppress Drager generated breath test results. The order stated the State Toxicologist Office provided inaccurate, incomplete, and/or false or misleading information to WAPA concerning the failure of the self-certifying Drager to comply with WAC 448- 16-060. The order also stated State Toxicologist, Dr. Fiona Couper, testified by declaration in a false or misleading manner regarding the compliance of the self-certifying Drager machine with WAC 448-16-060. The WSP is forwarding the order as possible potential impeachment disclosure information pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1983) for your review and distribution as you deem appropriate. Additional information will be provided as it becomes available. If you need additional information, please contact Acting Captain Pete Stock at 360-239-4904. Sincerely, Acting Captain Petersen T. Stock Office of Professional Standards PTS:hdh Attachments (2) P007796-031024-000338 P007796-031024-000339 P007796-031024-000340 P007796-031024-000341 P007796-031024-000342 P007796-031024-000343 P007796-031024-000344 P007796-031024-000345 P007796-031024-000346 P007796-031024-000347 P007796-031024-000348 P007796-031024-000349 P007796-031024-000350 P007796-031024-000351 P007796-031024-000352 P007796-031024-000353 P007796-031024-000354 P007796-031024-000355 P007796-031024-000356 P007796-031024-000357 P007796-031024-000358 P007796-031024-000359 P007796-031024-000360 P007796-031024-000361 P007796-031024-000362 P007796-031024-000363 P007796-031024-000364 P007796-031024-000365 P007796-031024-000366 P007796-031024-000367 P007796-031024-000368 P007796-031024-000369 P007796-031024-000370 P007796-031024-000371 P007796-031024-000372 P007796-031024-000373 P007796-031024-000374 P007796-031024-000375 P007796-031024-000376 P007796-031024-000377 P007796-031024-000378 P007796-031024-000379 P007796-031024-000380 P007796-031024-000381 P007796-031024-000382 P007796-031024-000383 P007796-031024-000384 P007796-031024-000385 P007796-031024-000386 P007796-031024-000387 P007796-031024-000388 P007796-031024-000389 P007796-031024-000390 P007796-031024-000391 P007796-031024-000392 P007796-031024-000393 P007796-031024-000394 P007796-031024-000395 P007796-031024-000396 P007796-031024-000397 P007796-031024-000398 P007796-031024-000399 P007796-031024-000400 P007796-031024-000401 P007796-031024-000402 P007796-031024-000403 P007796-031024-000404 P007796-031024-000405 P007796-031024-000406 P007796-031024-000407 P007796-031024-000408 )A'I' I ''!ti H Covnnor JOH R. BATISTE Chid <.;TATE OF WA'!,HIM,101', VVASHINCTON STATE PA-fROI. 1'0 l!tn 421>11 • O!vnipia, \'\'a,hington Yl:1.504-.lbl 1 • !b0-i04-4120 • W\\\\,\\sp \H.gO\ Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary October 22, 2013 Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 9850 I Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Forensic Scientist 5 Lisa M. Turpen Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named WSP employee: A 2013 Job Performance Improvement Plan (JPIP) to address recurring performance deficiencies related to completion of quality casework following current standard operating procedures; organization/cleanliness of work spaces and case files; and time management. If you need additional information, please contact Captain Jeff K. DeVere, Human Resource Division at (360) 704-2324. TWM:dp Sincerely, Captain Travis W. Matheson Office of Professional Standards cc: Captain Jeff K. De Vere, Human Resource Division Deputy Chief G. Curt Rattell Mr. Larry Hebert, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau Mr. James Tarver, Crime Laboratory Division 0 P007796-031024-000409 P007796-031024-000410 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 1 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container ST-22-13768 A Aberdeen Police Dept 22-A30614 N N/A ST-22-13768 B Aberdeen Police Dept 22-A30614 Y Y ST-22-14182 A Adams Co Sheriff - Othello 22-A04294 N N/A ST-22-14182 B Adams Co Sheriff - Othello 22-A04294 Y Y ST-22-14251 A Adams Co Sheriff - Ritzville 22-A01203 N N/A ST-22-14251 B Adams Co Sheriff - Ritzville 22-A01203 N N/A ST-22-13375 A Anacortes Police Dept 22-A08247 N N/A ST-22-13375 B Anacortes Police Dept 22-A08247 N N/A ST-22-13116 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-21191 N N/A ST-22-13116 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-21191 N N/A ST-22-13741 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-22076 Y Y ST-22-13741 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-22076 Y Y ST-22-13742 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-00021790 N N/A ST-22-13742 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-00021790 N N/A ST-22-13743 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-00021943 N N/A ST-22-13743 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-00021943 N N/A ST-22-13986 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-00022148 N N/A ST-22-13986 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-00022148 N N/A ST-22-14095 A Arlington Police Dept 2022-00022580 N N/A ST-22-14095 B Arlington Police Dept 2022-00022580 Y Y ST-22-13135 A Auburn Police Dept 22-11094 AL01 AL02 N N/A ST-22-13135 B Auburn Police Dept 22-11094 AL01 AL02 Y Y ST-22-13311 A Bainbridge Island Police Dept I22-0001098 N N/A 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. P007796-031024-000411 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 2 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13311 B Bainbridge Island Police Dept I22-0001098 Y N ST-22-13756 A Battle Ground Police Dept 22002624 N N/A ST-22-13756 B Battle Ground Police Dept 22002624 N N/A ST-22-13758 A Battle Ground Police Dept 22002826 Y Y ST-22-13758 B Battle Ground Police Dept 22002826 Y Y ST-22-13098 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-59487 Y N ST-22-13098 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-59487 N N/A ST-22-13099 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-59486 N N/A ST-22-13099 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-59486 N N/A ST-22-13285 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-61139 N N/A ST-22-13285 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-61139 Y Y ST-22-13287 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-60713 Y Y ST-22-13287 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-60713 N N/A ST-22-13288 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-59877 N N/A ST-22-13288 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-59877 N N/A ST-22-13572 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-58897 N N/A ST-22-13572 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-58897 N N/A ST-22-13573 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-61704 Y Y ST-22-13573 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-61704 Y Y ST-22-13574 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-61897 Y N ST-22-13574 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-61897 N N/A ST-22-13575 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-61752 Y Y ST-22-13575 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-61752 N N/A P007796-031024-000412 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 3 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13576 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-62090 N N/A ST-22-13576 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-62090 Y Y ST-22-13578 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-00058961 N N/A ST-22-13578 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-00058961 N N/A ST-22-13861 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-63655 N N/A ST-22-13861 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-63655 N N/A ST-22-13862 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-63024/2A0688210 N N/A ST-22-13862 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-63024/2A0688210 Y Y ST-22-13864 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-63020 N N/A ST-22-13864 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-63020 N N/A ST-22-14172 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-63827 N N/A ST-22-14172 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-63827 N N/A ST-22-14173 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-64523 N N/A ST-22-14173 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-64523 Y Y ST-22-14174 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-00063834 Y Y ST-22-14174 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-00063834 Y Y ST-22-14175 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-64462 Y N ST-22-14175 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-64462 N N/A ST-22-14176 A Bellevue Police Dept 2022-64173 N N/A ST-22-14176 B Bellevue Police Dept 2022-64173 N N/A ST-22-14177 A Bellevue Police Dept 22-64222 N N/A ST-22-14177 B Bellevue Police Dept 22-64222 N N/A ST-22-12930 A Bellevue WSP 22-018462 N N/A P007796-031024-000413 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 4 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-12930 B Bellevue WSP 22-018462 N N/A ST-22-12935 A Bellevue WSP 22-018315 N N/A ST-22-12935 B Bellevue WSP 22-018315 N N/A ST-22-13205 A Bellevue WSP 22-018820 Y N ST-22-13205 B Bellevue WSP 22-018820 Y N ST-22-13206 A Bellevue WSP 22-018776 N N/A ST-22-13206 B Bellevue WSP 22-018776 Y N ST-22-13207 A Bellevue WSP 22-018696 Y N ST-22-13207 B Bellevue WSP 22-018696 Y Y ST-22-13208 A Bellevue WSP 22-018704 Y N ST-22-13208 B Bellevue WSP 22-018704 Y N ST-22-13445 A Bellevue WSP 22-019049 Y Y ST-22-13446 A Bellevue WSP 22-019195 N N/A ST-22-13446 B Bellevue WSP 22-019195 N N/A ST-22-13447 A Bellevue WSP 22-019090 Y Y ST-22-13447 B Bellevue WSP 22-019090 N N/A ST-22-13782 A Bellevue WSP 22-019670 Y Y ST-22-13782 B Bellevue WSP 22-019670 Y Y ST-22-13783 A Bellevue WSP 22-019594 Y Y ST-22-13783 B Bellevue WSP 22-019594 Y Y ST-22-13784 A Bellevue WSP 22-019502 N N/A ST-22-13784 B Bellevue WSP 22-019502 Y Y ST-22-13785 A Bellevue WSP 22-019602 N N/A P007796-031024-000414 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 5 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13785 B Bellevue WSP 22-019602 N N/A ST-22-13958 A Bellevue WSP 22-020081 N N/A ST-22-13958 B Bellevue WSP 22-020081 N N/A ST-22-13959 A Bellevue WSP 22-019874 Y Y ST-22-13959 B Bellevue WSP 22-019874 Y Y ST-22-13961 A Bellevue WSP 22-019836 N N/A ST-22-13961 B Bellevue WSP 22-019836 N N/A ST-22-14257 A Bellevue WSP 22-020437 N N/A ST-22-14257 B Bellevue WSP 22-020437 N N/A ST-22-14258 A Bellevue WSP 22-020441 N N/A ST-22-14258 B Bellevue WSP 22-020441 N N/A ST-22-14259 A Bellevue WSP 22-020220 Y N ST-22-14259 B Bellevue WSP 22-020220 Y Y ST-22-13124 A Bellingham Police Dept 22B67865 N N/A ST-22-13124 B Bellingham Police Dept 22B67865 N N/A ST-22-13170 A Bellingham WSP 22-018628 N N/A ST-22-13170 B Bellingham WSP 22-018628 N N/A ST-22-13324 A Bellingham WSP 22-018807 N N/A ST-22-13324 B Bellingham WSP 22-018807 N N/A ST-22-13326 A Bellingham WSP 22-018881 N N/A ST-22-13326 B Bellingham WSP 22-018881 N N/A ST-22-13327 A Bellingham WSP 22-018690 N N/A ST-22-13327 B Bellingham WSP 22-018690 Y Y P007796-031024-000415 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 6 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14206 A Bellingham WSP 22-019867 N N/A ST-22-14206 B Bellingham WSP 22-019867 Y Y ST-22-14207 A Bellingham WSP 22-020105 N N/A ST-22-14207 B Bellingham WSP 22-020105 Y Y ST-22-13018 A Benton Co Sheriff 22-027264 N N/A ST-22-13018 B Benton Co Sheriff 22-027264 Y Y ST-22-13019 A Benton Co Sheriff 22-027362 N N/A ST-22-13019 B Benton Co Sheriff 22-027362 Y Y ST-22-13545 A Benton Co Sheriff 22-028693 N N/A ST-22-13545 B Benton Co Sheriff 22-028693 N N/A ST-22-14267 A Benton Co Sheriff 22-030393 Y N ST-22-14267 B Benton Co Sheriff 22-030393 N N/A ST-22-14268 A Benton Co Sheriff 22-030479 N N/A ST-22-14268 B Benton Co Sheriff 22-030479 Y N ST-22-13655 A Bremerton Police Dept B22-006589 Y Y ST-22-13655 B Bremerton Police Dept B22-006589 Y Y ST-22-13760 A Bremerton Police Dept B22006783 Y N ST-22-13760 B Bremerton Police Dept B22006783 N N/A ST-22-13045 A Bremerton WSP 22-018270 Y Y ST-22-13045 B Bremerton WSP 22-018270 Y Y ST-22-13046 A Bremerton WSP 22-018437 N N/A ST-22-13046 B Bremerton WSP 22-018437 N N/A ST-22-13997 A Buckley Police Dept 2232001466 Y Y P007796-031024-000416 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 7 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13997 B Buckley Police Dept 2232001466 Y Y ST-22-13412 A Burlington Police Dept 22-B09877 N N/A ST-22-13412 B Burlington Police Dept 22-B09877 Y N ST-22-13171 A Burlington WSP 22-018498 N N/A ST-22-13171 B Burlington WSP 22-018498 N N/A ST-22-13172 A Burlington WSP 22-018362 N N/A ST-22-13172 B Burlington WSP 22-018362 N N/A ST-22-13174 A Burlington WSP 22-018534 N N/A ST-22-13174 B Burlington WSP 22-018534 N N/A ST-22-13471 A Burlington WSP 22-019360 Y Y ST-22-13471 B Burlington WSP 22-019360 N N/A ST-22-14209 A Burlington WSP 22-019912 N N/A ST-22-14209 B Burlington WSP 22-019912 N N/A ST-22-14211 A Burlington WSP 22-020084 N N/A ST-22-14211 B Burlington WSP 22-020084 N N/A ST-22-13125 A Camas Police Dept 22002077 Y Y ST-22-13125 B Camas Police Dept 22002077 N N/A ST-22-13117 A Castle Rock Police Dept C22-1154 N N/A ST-22-13117 B Castle Rock Police Dept C22-1154 N N/A ST-22-13657 A Centralia Police Dept 22A13588 Y Y ST-22-13657 B Centralia Police Dept 22A13588 N N/A ST-22-13658 A Centralia Police Dept 22A13276 N N/A ST-22-13658 B Centralia Police Dept 22A13276 N N/A P007796-031024-000417 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 8 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13659 A Centralia Police Dept 22a13259 N N/A ST-22-13659 B Centralia Police Dept 22a13259 N N/A ST-22-14183 A Centralia Police Dept 22A013715 N N/A ST-22-14183 B Centralia Police Dept 22A013715 N N/A ST-22-14185 A Centralia Police Dept 22A13837 N N/A ST-22-14185 B Centralia Police Dept 22A13837 N N/A ST-22-13314 A Chehalis Police Dept 22B6486 N N/A ST-22-13314 B Chehalis Police Dept 22B6486 N N/A ST-22-13924 A Chehalis Police Dept 22B6846 N N/A ST-22-13924 B Chehalis Police Dept 22B6846 N N/A ST-22-13004 A Chehalis WSP 22-017968 Y N ST-22-13004 B Chehalis WSP 22-017968 N N/A ST-22-13470 A Chehalis WSP 22-019118 N N/A ST-22-13470 B Chehalis WSP 22-019118 N N/A ST-22-13306 A Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12349 N N/A ST-22-13306 B Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12349 Y Y ST-22-13452 A Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12516 N N/A ST-22-13452 B Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12516 N N/A ST-22-13453 A Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12521 N N/A ST-22-13453 B Chelan Co Sheriff 22C12521 N N/A ST-22-13132 A Clark Co Sheriff 22009233 N N/A ST-22-13132 B Clark Co Sheriff 22009233 N N/A ST-22-13133 A Clark Co Sheriff 22009932 N N/A P007796-031024-000418 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 9 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13133 B Clark Co Sheriff 22009932 N N/A ST-22-13133 C Clark Co Sheriff 22009932 N N/A ST-22-14113 A Clark Co Sheriff 22010794 N N/A ST-22-14113 B Clark Co Sheriff 22010794 N N/A ST-22-14114 A Clark Co Sheriff 22010627 N N/A ST-22-14114 B Clark Co Sheriff 22010627 N N/A ST-22-14171 A Columbia Co Sheriff 2022-7270 Y Y ST-22-14171 B Columbia Co Sheriff 2022-7270 N N/A ST-22-13137 A Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-11022 N N/A ST-22-13137 B Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-11022 Y N ST-22-13761 A Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-12031 N N/A ST-22-13761 B Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-12031 Y Y ST-22-13762 A Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-13206 Y Y ST-22-13762 B Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-13206 N N/A ST-22-13763 A Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-11089 N N/A ST-22-13763 B Cowlitz Co Sheriff A22-11089 Y Y ST-22-13119 A Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05496 N N/A ST-22-13119 B Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05496 N N/A ST-22-13994 A Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05845 N N/A ST-22-13994 B Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05845 Y Y ST-22-14252 A Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05964 N N/A ST-22-14252 B Douglas Co Sheriff - E Wenatchee 22D05964 N N/A ST-22-13225 A East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06551 N N/A P007796-031024-000419 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 10 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13225 B East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06551 N N/A ST-22-13226 A East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06557 N N/A ST-22-13226 B East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06557 Y N ST-22-13765 A East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06660 N N/A ST-22-13765 B East Wenatchee Police Dept 22E06660 N N/A ST-22-13103 A Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021141 N N/A ST-22-13103 B Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021141 N N/A ST-22-13104 A Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021751 N N/A ST-22-13104 B Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021751 N N/A ST-22-13105 A Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021127 N N/A ST-22-13105 B Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00021127 N N/A ST-22-13815 A Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00023030 N N/A ST-22-13815 B Edmonds Police Dept 2022-00023030 N N/A ST-22-13026 A Ellensburg WSP 22-018106 N N/A ST-22-13026 B Ellensburg WSP 22-018106 N N/A ST-22-13027 A Ellensburg WSP 22-018488 N N/A ST-22-13027 B Ellensburg WSP 22-018488 N N/A ST-22-13669 A Ellensburg WSP 22-018645 Y Y ST-22-13669 B Ellensburg WSP 22-018645 N N/A ST-22-13786 A Ellensburg WSP 22-019500 N N/A ST-22-13786 B Ellensburg WSP 22-019500 N N/A ST-22-13950 A Ellensburg WSP 22-019545 N N/A ST-22-13950 B Ellensburg WSP 22-019545 N N/A P007796-031024-000420 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 11 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13034 A Everett Police Dept 2022-116604 Y Y ST-22-13034 B Everett Police Dept 2022-116604 N N/A ST-22-13301 A Everett Police Dept 2022-118159 N N/A ST-22-13301 B Everett Police Dept 2022-118159 N N/A ST-22-13302 A Everett Police Dept 2022-118542 Y Y ST-22-13302 B Everett Police Dept 2022-118542 N N/A ST-22-13303 A Everett Police Dept 2022-118761 N N/A ST-22-13303 B Everett Police Dept 2022-118761 Y Y ST-22-13304 A Everett Police Dept 2022-118162 Y Y ST-22-13304 B Everett Police Dept 2022-118162 N N/A ST-22-13873 A Everett Police Dept 2022-122424 N N/A ST-22-13873 B Everett Police Dept 2022-122424 N N/A ST-22-13987 A Everett Police Dept 2022-125083 Y N ST-22-13987 B Everett Police Dept 2022-125083 N N/A ST-22-13988 A Everett Police Dept 2022-124860 Y Y ST-22-13988 B Everett Police Dept 2022-124860 Y Y ST-22-13989 A Everett Police Dept 2022-124149 Y Y ST-22-13989 B Everett Police Dept 2022-124149 Y Y ST-22-14256 A Everson Police Dept 22-001278 Y Y ST-22-14256 B Everson Police Dept 22-001278 N N/A ST-22-13929 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013861 Y Y ST-22-13929 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013861 N N/A ST-22-13930 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013938 Y Y P007796-031024-000421 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 12 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13930 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013938 Y Y ST-22-13931 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013493 N N/A ST-22-13931 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013493 N N/A ST-22-13932 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013410 N N/A ST-22-13932 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013410 Y N ST-22-13933 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013159 N N/A ST-22-13933 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013159 N N/A ST-22-13935 A Federal Way Police Dept 220013200 N N/A ST-22-13935 B Federal Way Police Dept 220013200 N N/A ST-22-13804 A Fife Police Dept 2232400368 N N/A ST-22-13804 B Fife Police Dept 2232400368 Y N ST-22-13701 A Franklin Co Sheriff 22-19914 Y Y ST-22-13701 B Franklin Co Sheriff 22-19914 N N/A ST-22-13120 A Garfield Co Sheriff 22-02378 N N/A ST-22-13120 B Garfield Co Sheriff 22-02378 N N/A ST-22-13494 A Gig Harbor Police Dept 2231600110 N N/A ST-22-13494 B Gig Harbor Police Dept 2231600110 N N/A ST-22-13673 A Grandview Police Dept 22V5950 Y Y ST-22-13673 B Grandview Police Dept 22V5950 N N/A ST-22-13139 A Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-024788 Y Y ST-22-13139 B Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-024788 Y N ST-22-13553 A Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-025612 Y Y ST-22-13553 B Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-025612 Y Y P007796-031024-000422 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 13 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13999 A Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-026454 N N/A ST-22-13999 B Grays Harbor Co Sheriff 22-026454 N N/A ST-22-12990 A Hoquiam WSP 22-018216 Y Y ST-22-12990 B Hoquiam WSP 22-018216 N N/A ST-22-12997 A Hoquiam WSP 22-018062 N N/A ST-22-12997 B Hoquiam WSP 22-018062 N N/A ST-22-12998 A Hoquiam WSP 22-018163 N N/A ST-22-12998 B Hoquiam WSP 22-018163 N N/A ST-22-13047 A Hoquiam WSP 22-018431 N N/A ST-22-13047 B Hoquiam WSP 22-018431 N N/A ST-22-13048 A Hoquiam WSP 22-018324 22-018332 N N/A ST-22-13048 B Hoquiam WSP 22-018324 22-018332 N N/A ST-22-13472 A Hoquiam WSP 22-019007 Y Y ST-22-13472 B Hoquiam WSP 22-019007 Y Y ST-22-13879 A Hoquiam WSP 22-019106 N N/A ST-22-13879 B Hoquiam WSP 22-019106 Y Y ST-22-14075 A Hoquiam WSP 22-019626 N N/A ST-22-14075 B Hoquiam WSP 22-019626 N N/A ST-22-14002 A Issaquah Police Dept 22-13826 N N/A ST-22-14002 B Issaquah Police Dept 22-13826 Y Y ST-22-13946 A KCSO - Burien #4 C22038470 N N/A ST-22-13946 B KCSO - Burien #4 C22038470 Y Y ST-22-13869 A KCSO - Maple Valley #3 C22038575 Y Y P007796-031024-000423 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 14 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13869 B KCSO - Maple Valley #3 C22038575 Y N ST-22-13457 A KCSO - Sammamish C22037969 N N/A ST-22-13457 B KCSO - Sammamish C22037969 Y Y ST-22-13458 A KCSO - Sammamish C22037992 Y Y ST-22-13458 B KCSO - Sammamish C22037992 N N/A ST-22-13948 A KCSO - Sammamish C22038487 N N/A ST-22-13948 B KCSO - Sammamish C22038487 N N/A ST-22-13652 A KCSO - Sea-Tac C22037729 N N/A ST-22-13652 B KCSO - Sea-Tac C22037729 N N/A ST-22-13947 A KCSO - Sea-Tac C22038492 N N/A ST-22-13947 B KCSO - Sea-Tac C22038492 N N/A ST-22-12952 A KCSO - Seattle C22036001 Y Y ST-22-12952 B KCSO - Seattle C22036001 N N/A ST-22-13411 A KCSO - Shoreline #5 C22037634 N N/A ST-22-13411 B KCSO - Shoreline #5 C22037634 N N/A ST-22-13984 A KCSO - Shoreline #5 C22039522 N N/A ST-22-13984 B KCSO - Shoreline #5 C22039522 N N/A ST-22-13020 A Kelso Police Dept 22-7841 N N/A ST-22-13020 B Kelso Police Dept 22-7841 N N/A ST-22-13000 A Kelso WSP 22-018077 N N/A ST-22-13000 B Kelso WSP 22-018077 N N/A ST-22-13002 A Kelso WSP 22-017916 Y N ST-22-13002 B Kelso WSP 22-017916 Y Y P007796-031024-000424 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 15 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13003 A Kelso WSP 22-017991 N N/A ST-22-13003 B Kelso WSP 22-017991 N N/A ST-22-13005 A Kelso WSP 22-018269 N N/A ST-22-13005 B Kelso WSP 22-018269 N N/A ST-22-13273 A Kelso WSP 22-018643 N N/A ST-22-13273 B Kelso WSP 22-018643 N N/A ST-22-13227 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-84553 Y N ST-22-13227 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-84553 N N/A ST-22-13661 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-86959 Y Y ST-22-13661 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-86959 Y Y ST-22-13794 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-87795 Y Y ST-22-13794 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-87795 Y Y ST-22-13795 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-087849 N N/A ST-22-13795 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-087849 N N/A ST-22-13796 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-087629 N N/A ST-22-13796 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-087629 N N/A ST-22-14186 A Kennewick Police Dept 22-90191 Y Y ST-22-14186 B Kennewick Police Dept 22-90191 N N/A ST-22-12944 A Kennewick WSP 22-018419 N N/A ST-22-12944 B Kennewick WSP 22-018419 N N/A ST-22-13261 A Kennewick WSP 22-018125 Y N ST-22-13261 B Kennewick WSP 22-018125 N N/A ST-22-13262 A Kennewick WSP 22-018293 Y Y P007796-031024-000425 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 16 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13262 B Kennewick WSP 22-018293 Y Y ST-22-13263 A Kennewick WSP 22-018357 N N/A ST-22-13263 B Kennewick WSP 22-018357 N N/A ST-22-13265 A Kennewick WSP 22-018455 N N/A ST-22-13265 B Kennewick WSP 22-018455 Y Y ST-22-13807 A Kennewick WSP 22-019208 N N/A ST-22-13807 B Kennewick WSP 22-019208 N N/A ST-22-13809 A Kennewick WSP 22-019028 N N/A ST-22-13809 B Kennewick WSP 22-019028 N N/A ST-22-13292 A Kent Police Dept 22-14669 N N/A ST-22-13292 B Kent Police Dept 22-14669 Y Y ST-22-13865 A Kent Police Dept 22-15201 222874-1 Y N ST-22-13865 B Kent Police Dept 22-15201 222874-1 N N/A ST-22-13013 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-39763 N N/A ST-22-13013 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-39763 N N/A ST-22-13014 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-39182 N N/A ST-22-13014 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-39182 N N/A ST-22-13283 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-40309 N N/A ST-22-13283 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-40309 N N/A ST-22-13284 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-40386 Y Y ST-22-13284 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-40386 N N/A ST-22-13498 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-41611 Y Y ST-22-13498 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-41611 Y N P007796-031024-000426 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 17 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13867 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-41925 N N/A ST-22-13867 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-41925 N N/A ST-22-13868 A Kirkland Police Dept. 22-42241 N N/A ST-22-13868 B Kirkland Police Dept. 22-42241 N N/A ST-22-13295 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011488 Y Y ST-22-13295 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011488 N N/A ST-22-13296 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011268 N N/A ST-22-13296 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011268 N N/A ST-22-13744 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011899 N N/A ST-22-13744 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011899 Y Y ST-22-13745 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011637 N N/A ST-22-13745 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011637 N N/A ST-22-13746 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011111 Y Y ST-22-13746 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-011111 N N/A ST-22-14233 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-012032 N N/A ST-22-14233 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-012032 N N/A ST-22-14234 A Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-012162 N N/A ST-22-14234 B Kitsap Co Sheriff - Port Orchard K22-012162 N N/A ST-22-13032 A Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12695 N N/A ST-22-13032 B Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12695 N N/A ST-22-13033 A Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12418 N N/A ST-22-13033 B Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12418 N N/A ST-22-13228 A Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12607 Y N P007796-031024-000427 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 18 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13228 B Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12607 N N/A ST-22-13229 A Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12706 N N/A ST-22-13229 B Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12706 Y N ST-22-13297 A Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12899 N N/A ST-22-13297 B Kittitas Co Sheriff S22-12899 Y Y ST-22-14254 A Klickitat Co Sheriff 22-004771 N N/A ST-22-14254 B Klickitat Co Sheriff 22-004771 N N/A ST-22-14255 A Klickitat Co Sheriff 22-004535 N N/A ST-22-14255 B Klickitat Co Sheriff 22-004535 N N/A ST-22-13537 A Lake Stevens Police Dept 2022-20634 N N/A ST-22-13537 B Lake Stevens Police Dept 2022-20634 N N/A ST-22-13127 A Lakewood Police Dept 22.283.00121 N N/A ST-22-13127 B Lakewood Police Dept 22.283.00121 Y Y ST-22-13366 A Lakewood Police Dept 22-309-01746 N N/A ST-22-13366 B Lakewood Police Dept 22-309-01746 Y Y ST-22-13367 A Lakewood Police Dept 2230600161 N N/A ST-22-13367 B Lakewood Police Dept 2230600161 N N/A ST-22-12953 A Lewis Co Sheriff 22C14167 Y N ST-22-12953 B Lewis Co Sheriff 22C14167 Y Y ST-22-13490 A Lewis Co Sheriff 22C14838 Y Y ST-22-13490 B Lewis Co Sheriff 22C14838 Y Y ST-22-13943 A Lewis Co Sheriff 22C15032 N N/A ST-22-13943 B Lewis Co Sheriff 22C15032 N N/A P007796-031024-000428 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 19 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13975 A Lewis Co Sheriff 22C15220 N N/A ST-22-13975 B Lewis Co Sheriff 22C15220 N N/A ST-22-13581 A Longview Police Dept l22-19250 N N/A ST-22-13581 B Longview Police Dept l22-19250 Y Y ST-22-13582 A Longview Police Dept L22-20148 Y Y ST-22-13582 B Longview Police Dept L22-20148 Y Y ST-22-13583 A Longview Police Dept L22-19027 N N/A ST-22-13583 B Longview Police Dept L22-19027 N N/A ST-22-13584 A Longview Police Dept L22-14723 N N/A ST-22-13584 B Longview Police Dept L22-14723 N N/A ST-22-13585 A Longview Police Dept L22-19916 Y Y ST-22-13585 B Longview Police Dept L22-19916 N N/A ST-22-14179 A Longview Police Dept 20813 N N/A ST-22-14179 B Longview Police Dept 20813 N N/A ST-22-13377 A Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I06540 Y Y ST-22-13377 B Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I06540 N N/A ST-22-13379 A Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I07739 Y Y ST-22-13379 B Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I07739 N N/A ST-22-14180 A Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I08572 N N/A ST-22-14180 B Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I08572 N N/A ST-22-14181 A Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I08902 N N/A ST-22-14181 B Lummi Nation Police Dept 22I08902 Y Y ST-22-14004 A Lynden Police Dept 22L6272 Y Y P007796-031024-000429 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 20 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14004 B Lynden Police Dept 22L6272 Y Y ST-22-13185 A Lynnwood Police Dept 22-35424 N N/A ST-22-13185 B Lynnwood Police Dept 22-35424 N N/A ST-22-13530 A Lynnwood Police Dept 2022-36999 Y Y ST-22-13530 B Lynnwood Police Dept 2022-36999 N N/A ST-22-13351 A Marysville Police Dept 2022-00052954 N N/A ST-22-13351 B Marysville Police Dept 2022-00052954 N N/A ST-22-13008 A Marysville WSP 22-018395 N N/A ST-22-13008 B Marysville WSP 22-018395 N N/A ST-22-13009 A Marysville WSP 22-018166 N N/A ST-22-13009 B Marysville WSP 22-018166 N N/A ST-22-13175 A Marysville WSP 22-018742 N N/A ST-22-13175 B Marysville WSP 22-018742 N N/A ST-22-13330 A Marysville WSP 22-018791 N N/A ST-22-13330 B Marysville WSP 22-018791 N N/A ST-22-13475 A Marysville WSP 22-019236 N N/A ST-22-13475 B Marysville WSP 22-019236 N N/A ST-22-13476 A Marysville WSP 22-019124 N N/A ST-22-13476 B Marysville WSP 22-019124 N N/A ST-22-13478 A Marysville WSP 22-019177 N N/A ST-22-13478 B Marysville WSP 22-019177 N N/A ST-22-13479 A Marysville WSP 22-018970 N N/A ST-22-13479 B Marysville WSP 22-018970 N N/A P007796-031024-000430 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 21 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13482 A Marysville WSP 22-019275 Y N ST-22-13482 B Marysville WSP 22-019275 N N/A ST-22-13700 A Marysville WSP 22-019250 Y Y ST-22-13700 B Marysville WSP 22-019250 Y Y ST-22-13880 A Marysville WSP 22-019552 N N/A ST-22-13880 B Marysville WSP 22-019552 N N/A ST-22-13882 A Marysville WSP 22-019710 Y Y ST-22-13882 B Marysville WSP 22-019710 N N/A ST-22-13883 A Marysville WSP 22-019758 N N/A ST-22-13883 B Marysville WSP 22-019758 N N/A ST-22-13923 A Marysville WSP 22-019664 N N/A ST-22-13923 B Marysville WSP 22-019664 N N/A ST-22-14078 A Marysville WSP 22-020039 N N/A ST-22-14078 B Marysville WSP 22-020039 N N/A ST-22-14079 A Marysville WSP 22-019740 Y Y ST-22-14079 B Marysville WSP 22-019740 Y Y ST-22-14080 A Marysville WSP 22-020170 N N/A ST-22-14080 B Marysville WSP 22-020170 N N/A ST-22-14081 A Marysville WSP 22-020001 N N/A ST-22-14081 B Marysville WSP 22-020001 N N/A ST-22-14082 A Marysville WSP 22-019926 N N/A ST-22-14082 B Marysville WSP 22-019926 N N/A ST-22-14083 A Marysville WSP 22-019938 N N/A P007796-031024-000431 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 22 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14083 B Marysville WSP 22-019938 N N/A ST-22-14084 A Marysville WSP 22-020085 N N/A ST-22-14084 B Marysville WSP 22-020085 N N/A ST-22-14088 A Marysville WSP 22-019978 N N/A ST-22-14088 B Marysville WSP 22-019978 N N/A ST-22-14091 A Marysville WSP 22-019916 N N/A ST-22-14091 B Marysville WSP 22-019916 N N/A ST-22-14214 A Marysville WSP 22-020122 Y Y ST-22-14214 B Marysville WSP 22-020122 N N/A ST-22-13315 A McCleary Police Dept 22-MC2135 Y Y ST-22-13315 B McCleary Police Dept 22-MC2135 Y Y ST-22-13413 A Milton Police Dept 2231300008 Y Y ST-22-13413 B Milton Police Dept 2231300008 Y N ST-22-13106 A Monroe Police Dept 2022-00019489 N N/A ST-22-13106 B Monroe Police Dept 2022-00019489 N N/A ST-22-13010 A Monroe WSP 22-018384 N N/A ST-22-13010 B Monroe WSP 22-018384 N N/A ST-22-13331 A Monroe WSP 22-018593 N N/A ST-22-13331 B Monroe WSP 22-018593 N N/A ST-22-13485 A Monroe WSP 22-019264 Y N ST-22-13485 B Monroe WSP 22-019264 N N/A ST-22-13886 A Monroe WSP 22-019595 N N/A ST-22-13886 B Monroe WSP 22-019595 N N/A P007796-031024-000432 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 23 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13887 A Monroe WSP 22-019672 N N/A ST-22-13887 B Monroe WSP 22-019672 N N/A ST-22-13316 A Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML16461 Y Y ST-22-13316 B Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML16461 N N/A ST-22-13317 A Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML15249 N N/A ST-22-13317 B Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML15249 Y Y ST-22-13318 A Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML17326 N N/A ST-22-13318 B Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML17326 N N/A ST-22-13322 A Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML17282 N N/A ST-22-13322 B Moses Lake Police Dept 22ML17282 Y Y ST-22-13028 A Moses Lake WSP 22-018379 N N/A ST-22-13028 B Moses Lake WSP 22-018379 N N/A ST-22-13670 A Moses Lake WSP 22-018883 N N/A ST-22-13670 B Moses Lake WSP 22-018883 N N/A ST-22-14200 A Mukilteo Police Dept 22-25503 N N/A ST-22-14200 B Mukilteo Police Dept 22-25503 N N/A ST-22-14116 A Napavine Police Dept 22F1004 N N/A ST-22-14116 B Napavine Police Dept 22F1004 Y Y ST-22-13462 A Normandy Park Police Dept 22-3849 N N/A ST-22-13462 B Normandy Park Police Dept 22-3849 Y Y ST-22-13129 A Ocean Shores Police Dept 22-S10563 N N/A ST-22-13129 B Ocean Shores Police Dept 22-S10563 N N/A ST-22-13029 A Okanogan WSP 22-018374 N N/A P007796-031024-000433 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 24 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13029 B Okanogan WSP 22-018374 N N/A ST-22-13030 A Okanogan WSP 22-018562 N N/A ST-22-13030 B Okanogan WSP 22-018562 N N/A ST-22-13952 A Okanogan WSP 22-019739 N N/A ST-22-13952 B Okanogan WSP 22-019739 N N/A ST-22-13953 A Okanogan WSP 22-019553 N N/A ST-22-13953 B Okanogan WSP 22-019553 N N/A ST-22-14270 A Olympia Police Dept 202207620 N N/A ST-22-14270 B Olympia Police Dept 202207620 N N/A ST-22-13100 A Pasco Police Dept 22-057078 N N/A ST-22-13100 B Pasco Police Dept 22-057078 N N/A ST-22-13538 A Pend Oreille Co Sheriff 22-05032 N N/A ST-22-13538 B Pend Oreille Co Sheriff 22-05032 N N/A ST-22-13138 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Edgewood 22-302-00135 N N/A ST-22-13138 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Edgewood 22-302-00135 N N/A ST-22-13771 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Puyallup 2232000122 Y Y ST-22-13771 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Puyallup 2232000122 Y Y ST-22-12958 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2230002070 N N/A ST-22-12958 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2230002070 N N/A ST-22-13416 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2231000976 N N/A ST-22-13416 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2231000976 N N/A ST-22-13464 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2231601461 Y Y ST-22-13464 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2231601461 N N/A P007796-031024-000434 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 25 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14007 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232202191 N N/A ST-22-14007 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232202191 N N/A ST-22-14008 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232401343 Y Y ST-22-14008 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232401343 N N/A ST-22-14009 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232302271 N N/A ST-22-14009 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232302271 N N/A ST-22-14070 A Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232200175 N N/A ST-22-14070 B Pierce Co Sheriff - Tacoma 2232200175 Y Y ST-22-13450 A Port Angeles Police Dept 2022-20159 N N/A ST-22-13450 B Port Angeles Police Dept 2022-20159 Y Y ST-22-13080 A Port Angeles WSP 22-018545 N N/A ST-22-13080 B Port Angeles WSP 22-018545 Y N ST-22-13888 A Port Angeles WSP 22-019072 N N/A ST-22-13888 B Port Angeles WSP 22-019072 N N/A ST-22-14111 A Port Townsend Police Dept 22-6469 Y Y ST-22-14111 B Port Townsend Police Dept 22-6469 Y Y ST-22-14201 A Prosser Police Dept 22-5910 N N/A ST-22-14201 B Prosser Police Dept 22-5910 N N/A ST-22-13675 A Puyallup Police Dept 2229802133 N N/A ST-22-13675 B Puyallup Police Dept 2229802133 N N/A ST-22-13676 A Puyallup Police Dept 2230201916 N N/A ST-22-13676 B Puyallup Police Dept 2230201916 N N/A ST-22-13679 A Puyallup Police Dept 2232000595 N N/A P007796-031024-000435 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 26 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13679 B Puyallup Police Dept 2232000595 N N/A ST-22-13681 A Puyallup Police Dept 2231600176 N N/A ST-22-13681 B Puyallup Police Dept 2231600176 Y Y ST-22-13685 A Puyallup Police Dept 2228100076 N N/A ST-22-13685 B Puyallup Police Dept 2228100076 N N/A ST-22-13686 A Puyallup Police Dept 2228101776 N N/A ST-22-13686 B Puyallup Police Dept 2228101776 N N/A ST-22-13687 A Puyallup Police Dept 2224700028 N N/A ST-22-13687 B Puyallup Police Dept 2224700028 N N/A ST-22-13690 A Puyallup Police Dept 2227902100 N N/A ST-22-13690 B Puyallup Police Dept 2227902100 N N/A ST-22-14102 A Puyallup Police Dept 2232102646 N N/A ST-22-14102 B Puyallup Police Dept 2232102646 N N/A ST-22-14106 A Puyallup Police Dept 2232001451 Y Y ST-22-14106 B Puyallup Police Dept 2232001451 N N/A ST-22-13015 A Redmond Police Dept 22-027874 N N/A ST-22-13015 B Redmond Police Dept 22-027874 N N/A ST-22-13016 A Redmond Police Dept 22-027967 N N/A ST-22-13016 B Redmond Police Dept 22-027967 N N/A ST-22-13289 A Redmond Police Dept 22-028684 N N/A ST-22-13289 B Redmond Police Dept 22-028684 N N/A ST-22-14094 A Redmond Police Dept 22-030701 Y Y ST-22-14094 B Redmond Police Dept 22-030701 N N/A P007796-031024-000436 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 27 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13102 A Renton Police Dept 22-11476 N N/A ST-22-13102 B Renton Police Dept 22-11476 N N/A ST-22-13586 A Renton Police Dept 22-11697 Y Y ST-22-13586 B Renton Police Dept 22-11697 Y Y ST-22-13587 A Renton Police Dept 22-11577 N N/A ST-22-13587 B Renton Police Dept 22-11577 N N/A ST-22-14227 A Renton Police Dept 22-12299 N N/A ST-22-14227 B Renton Police Dept 22-12299 N N/A ST-22-14228 A Renton Police Dept 22-12302 N N/A ST-22-14228 B Renton Police Dept 22-12302 N N/A ST-22-14229 A Renton Police Dept 22-12325 N N/A ST-22-14229 B Renton Police Dept 22-12325 N N/A ST-22-14230 A Renton Police Dept 22-12264 N N/A ST-22-14230 B Renton Police Dept 22-12264 N N/A ST-22-13539 A Richland Police Dept 22-049507 Y Y ST-22-13539 B Richland Police Dept 22-049507 Y Y ST-22-13540 A Richland Police Dept 22-048032 N N/A ST-22-13540 B Richland Police Dept 22-048032 N N/A ST-22-13107 A Ritzville WSP 22-018189 Y Y ST-22-13107 B Ritzville WSP 22-018189 Y N ST-22-13211 A Roanoke WSP 22-018900 N N/A ST-22-13211 B Roanoke WSP 22-018900 Y N ST-22-13212 A Roanoke WSP 22-018912 N N/A P007796-031024-000437 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 28 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13212 B Roanoke WSP 22-018912 N N/A ST-22-13433 A Roanoke WSP 22-019287 Y Y ST-22-13433 B Roanoke WSP 22-019287 Y Y ST-22-13434 A Roanoke WSP 22-019281 N N/A ST-22-13434 B Roanoke WSP 22-019281 N N/A ST-22-13791 A Roanoke WSP 22-019371 Y Y ST-22-13791 B Roanoke WSP 22-019371 Y Y ST-22-13792 A Roanoke WSP 22-019757 Y Y ST-22-13792 B Roanoke WSP 22-019757 Y Y ST-22-13962 A Roanoke WSP 22-019931 Y Y ST-22-13962 B Roanoke WSP 22-019931 Y Y ST-22-13966 A Roanoke WSP 22-019997 Y Y ST-22-13966 B Roanoke WSP 22-019997 Y Y ST-22-13967 A Roanoke WSP 22-020068 N N/A ST-22-13967 B Roanoke WSP 22-020068 N N/A ST-22-14262 A Roanoke WSP 22-020354 Y Y ST-22-14262 B Roanoke WSP 22-020354 Y Y ST-22-13043 A Sedro-Woolley Police Dept 22-W06317 N N/A ST-22-13043 B Sedro-Woolley Police Dept 22-W06317 N N/A ST-22-13081 A Shelton WSP 22-018586 N N/A ST-22-13081 B Shelton WSP 22-018586 N N/A ST-22-13276 A Shelton WSP 22-018700 Y Y ST-22-13276 B Shelton WSP 22-018700 Y N P007796-031024-000438 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 29 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13921 A Shelton WSP 22-019152 N N/A ST-22-13921 B Shelton WSP 22-019152 N N/A ST-22-13922 A Shelton WSP 22-019413 N N/A ST-22-13922 B Shelton WSP 22-019413 N N/A ST-22-13491 A Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16081 N N/A ST-22-13491 B Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16081 N N/A ST-22-13976 A Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16483 N N/A ST-22-13976 B Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16483 N N/A ST-22-14226 A Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16713 N N/A ST-22-14226 B Skagit Co Sheriff 22-16713 N N/A ST-22-13035 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-150495 N N/A ST-22-13035 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-150495 N N/A ST-22-13036 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-152034 N N/A ST-22-13036 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-152034 N N/A ST-22-13038 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00152042 N N/A ST-22-13038 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00152042 N N/A ST-22-13039 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-00147060 N N/A ST-22-13039 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-00147060 N N/A ST-22-13310 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-153360 N N/A ST-22-13310 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-153360 N N/A ST-22-13536 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00159020 N N/A ST-22-13536 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00159020 N N/A ST-22-13541 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00156867 N N/A P007796-031024-000439 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 30 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13541 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00156867 N N/A ST-22-13543 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158347 Y Y ST-22-13543 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158347 N N/A ST-22-13654 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO22-00158779 N N/A ST-22-13654 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO22-00158779 N N/A ST-22-13662 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158728 N N/A ST-22-13662 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158728 N N/A ST-22-13663 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00159536 Y Y ST-22-13663 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00159536 N N/A ST-22-13664 A Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158212 N N/A ST-22-13664 B Snohomish Co Sheriff SO2022-00158212 N N/A ST-22-14189 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-161970 N N/A ST-22-14189 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-161970 N N/A ST-22-14193 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-164400 Y Y ST-22-14193 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-164400 Y Y ST-22-14194 A Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-160554 N N/A ST-22-14194 B Snohomish Co Sheriff 2022-160554 N N/A ST-22-13181 A Snoqualmie Police Dept 22S-5370 N N/A ST-22-13181 B Snoqualmie Police Dept 22S-5370 N N/A ST-22-13767 A Snoqualmie Police Dept 22N-4115 Y N ST-22-13767 B Snoqualmie Police Dept 22N-4115 Y Y ST-22-13083 A SPD - East Precinct 2022-290723 N N/A ST-22-13083 B SPD - East Precinct 2022-290723 N N/A P007796-031024-000440 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 31 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13089 A SPD - East Precinct 2022-291487 N N/A ST-22-13089 B SPD - East Precinct 2022-291487 N N/A ST-22-13569 A SPD - East Precinct 22-304104 N N/A ST-22-13569 B SPD - East Precinct 22-304104 N N/A ST-22-13570 A SPD - East Precinct 2022-306327 N N/A ST-22-13570 B SPD - East Precinct 2022-306327 N N/A ST-22-13818 A SPD - East Precinct 22-310500 N N/A ST-22-13818 B SPD - East Precinct 22-310500 Y Y ST-22-13819 A SPD - East Precinct 22-311386 N N/A ST-22-13819 B SPD - East Precinct 22-311386 Y Y ST-22-14161 A SPD - East Precinct 22-316653 N N/A ST-22-14161 B SPD - East Precinct 22-316653 Y Y ST-22-13093 A SPD - North Precinct 2022-289562 Y N ST-22-13093 B SPD - North Precinct 2022-289562 N N/A ST-22-13338 A SPD - North Precinct 2022-300113 Y Y ST-22-13338 B SPD - North Precinct 2022-300113 Y Y ST-22-13936 A SPD - North Precinct 2022-313539 N N/A ST-22-13936 B SPD - North Precinct 2022-313539 N N/A ST-22-14248 A SPD - North Precinct 2022-319106 N N/A ST-22-14248 B SPD - North Precinct 2022-319106 N N/A ST-22-13754 A SPD - South Precinct 2022-311102 N N/A ST-22-13754 B SPD - South Precinct 2022-311102 N N/A ST-22-13827 A SPD - South Precinct 22-313199 N N/A P007796-031024-000441 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 32 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13827 B SPD - South Precinct 22-313199 N N/A ST-22-13828 A SPD - South Precinct 22-314256 Y Y ST-22-13828 B SPD - South Precinct 22-314256 Y Y ST-22-13938 A SPD - South Precinct 22-315126 N N/A ST-22-13938 B SPD - South Precinct 22-315126 Y Y ST-22-13939 A SPD - South Precinct 22-317711 Y Y ST-22-13939 B SPD - South Precinct 22-317711 Y Y ST-22-14166 A SPD - South Precinct 22-318784 N N/A ST-22-14166 B SPD - South Precinct 22-318784 Y Y ST-22-13086 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-293650 N N/A ST-22-13086 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-293650 N N/A ST-22-13088 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-292620 N N/A ST-22-13088 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-292620 N N/A ST-22-13090 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-294400 N N/A ST-22-13090 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-294400 N N/A ST-22-13094 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-291490 N N/A ST-22-13094 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-291490 Y N ST-22-13180 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 22-295476 N N/A ST-22-13180 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 22-295476 N N/A ST-22-13332 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-289364 N N/A ST-22-13332 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-289364 N N/A ST-22-13822 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-312188 N N/A ST-22-13822 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-312188 N N/A P007796-031024-000442 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 33 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13823 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-310336 N N/A ST-22-13823 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-310336 Y Y ST-22-13940 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-318477 N N/A ST-22-13940 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-318477 N N/A ST-22-14129 A SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-316775 Y Y ST-22-14129 B SPD - Traffic Collision Investigations 2022-316775 N N/A ST-22-13085 A SPD - West Precinct 2022-293542 N N/A ST-22-13085 B SPD - West Precinct 2022-293542 N N/A ST-22-14167 A SPD - West Precinct 22-315558 N N/A ST-22-14167 B SPD - West Precinct 22-315558 N N/A ST-22-14168 A SPD - West Precinct 22-316681 N N/A ST-22-14168 B SPD - West Precinct 22-316681 N N/A ST-22-13200 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10147049 Y Y ST-22-13200 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10147049 N N/A ST-22-13201 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10147078 N N/A ST-22-13201 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10147078 N N/A ST-22-13706 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10152072 Y Y ST-22-13706 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10152072 Y Y ST-22-13797 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155109 N N/A ST-22-13797 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155109 N N/A ST-22-13798 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155508 Y Y ST-22-13798 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155508 Y Y ST-22-13799 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10154308 N N/A P007796-031024-000443 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 34 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13799 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10154308 N N/A ST-22-14118 A Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155273 N N/A ST-22-14118 B Spokane Co Sheriff 2022-10155273 N N/A ST-22-13186 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20191364 N N/A ST-22-13186 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20191364 N N/A ST-22-13189 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20193428 N N/A ST-22-13189 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20193428 N N/A ST-22-13191 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20193609 N N/A ST-22-13191 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20193609 N N/A ST-22-13192 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20194668 N N/A ST-22-13192 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20194668 N N/A ST-22-13339 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20194764 N N/A ST-22-13339 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20194764 Y Y ST-22-13341 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20126773 N N/A ST-22-13341 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20126773 N N/A ST-22-13342 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20198319 Y Y ST-22-13342 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20198319 Y Y ST-22-13709 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20200568 Y Y ST-22-13709 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20200568 Y Y ST-22-13740 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20203549 Y Y ST-22-13740 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20203549 N N/A ST-22-13802 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20206535 N N/A ST-22-13802 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20206535 Y N P007796-031024-000444 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 35 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14120 A Spokane Police Dept 2022-20209689 Y Y ST-22-14120 B Spokane Police Dept 2022-20209689 Y Y ST-22-13108 A Spokane WSP 22-018223 N N/A ST-22-13108 B Spokane WSP 22-018223 N N/A ST-22-13109 A Spokane WSP 22-018568 Y N ST-22-13109 B Spokane WSP 22-018568 Y Y ST-22-13110 A Spokane WSP 22-018434 Y Y ST-22-13110 B Spokane WSP 22-018434 Y Y ST-22-13111 A Spokane WSP 22-018533 N N/A ST-22-13111 B Spokane WSP 22-018533 N N/A ST-22-13112 A Spokane WSP 22-018427 N N/A ST-22-13112 B Spokane WSP 22-018427 Y N ST-22-13113 A Spokane WSP 22-018273 N N/A ST-22-13113 B Spokane WSP 22-018273 N N/A ST-22-13550 A Spokane WSP 22-019342 N N/A ST-22-13550 B Spokane WSP 22-019342 N N/A ST-22-13552 A Spokane WSP 22-019162 N N/A ST-22-13552 B Spokane WSP 22-019162 N N/A ST-22-14221 A Spokane WSP 22-019585 Y Y ST-22-14221 B Spokane WSP 22-019585 Y Y ST-22-14222 A Spokane WSP 22-020076 N N/A ST-22-14222 B Spokane WSP 22-020076 Y Y ST-22-14224 A Spokane WSP 22-019777 N N/A P007796-031024-000445 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 36 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14224 B Spokane WSP 22-019777 N N/A ST-22-14225 A Spokane WSP 22-019105 Y Y ST-22-14225 B Spokane WSP 22-019105 N N/A ST-22-12959 A Tacoma Police Dept 22-30300372 Y Y ST-22-12959 B Tacoma Police Dept 22-30300372 N N/A ST-22-13323 A Tacoma Police Dept 2230700252 Y Y ST-22-13323 B Tacoma Police Dept 2230700252 Y Y ST-22-13773 A Tacoma Police Dept 2231901686 N N/A ST-22-13773 B Tacoma Police Dept 2231901686 N N/A ST-22-14202 A Tacoma Police Dept 2231800069 N N/A ST-22-14202 B Tacoma Police Dept 2231800069 N N/A ST-22-14203 A Tacoma Police Dept 2232401641 Y Y ST-22-14203 B Tacoma Police Dept 2232401641 Y Y ST-22-13417 A Tacoma WSP 22-018928 N N/A ST-22-13417 B Tacoma WSP 22-018928 N N/A ST-22-13420 A Tacoma WSP 22-018289 N N/A ST-22-13420 B Tacoma WSP 22-018289 N N/A ST-22-13422 A Tacoma WSP 22-018673 Y Y ST-22-13422 B Tacoma WSP 22-018673 N N/A ST-22-13425 A Tacoma WSP 22-018296 Y Y ST-22-13425 B Tacoma WSP 22-018296 N N/A ST-22-13427 A Tacoma WSP 22-018454 N N/A ST-22-13427 B Tacoma WSP 22-018454 N N/A P007796-031024-000446 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 37 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13428 A Tacoma WSP 22-018946 N N/A ST-22-13428 B Tacoma WSP 22-018946 N N/A ST-22-13429 A Tacoma WSP 22-018872 N N/A ST-22-13429 B Tacoma WSP 22-018872 N N/A ST-22-13430 A Tacoma WSP 22-018831 N N/A ST-22-13430 B Tacoma WSP 22-018831 N N/A ST-22-13431 A Tacoma WSP 22-018945 N N/A ST-22-13431 B Tacoma WSP 22-018945 N N/A ST-22-13554 A Tacoma WSP 22-019325 N N/A ST-22-13554 B Tacoma WSP 22-019325 N N/A ST-22-13555 A Tacoma WSP 22-019288 N N/A ST-22-13555 B Tacoma WSP 22-019288 N N/A ST-22-13556 A Tacoma WSP 22-019133 N N/A ST-22-13556 B Tacoma WSP 22-019133 N N/A ST-22-13557 A Tacoma WSP 22-019199 N N/A ST-22-13557 B Tacoma WSP 22-019199 Y Y ST-22-13558 A Tacoma WSP 22-019245 N N/A ST-22-13558 B Tacoma WSP 22-019245 N N/A ST-22-13559 A Tacoma WSP 22-019283 Y Y ST-22-13559 B Tacoma WSP 22-019283 Y Y ST-22-13560 A Tacoma WSP 22-019324 N N/A ST-22-13560 B Tacoma WSP 22-019324 Y Y ST-22-13777 A Tacoma WSP 22-019473 N N/A P007796-031024-000447 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 38 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13777 B Tacoma WSP 22-019473 Y N ST-22-13022 A Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05618 N N/A ST-22-13022 B Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05618 Y N ST-22-13023 A Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05650 Y N ST-22-13023 B Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05650 Y N ST-22-13024 A Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05568 N N/A ST-22-13024 B Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05568 N N/A ST-22-13025 A Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05579 N N/A ST-22-13025 B Thurston Co Sheriff 22-05579 N N/A ST-22-13978 A Thurston Co Sheriff 22-06014 Y Y ST-22-13978 B Thurston Co Sheriff 22-06014 N N/A ST-22-12931 A Tukwila WSP 22-018555 N N/A ST-22-12931 B Tukwila WSP 22-018555 N N/A ST-22-12936 A Tukwila WSP 22-018211 N N/A ST-22-12936 B Tukwila WSP 22-018211 N N/A ST-22-12937 A Tukwila WSP 22-018173 N N/A ST-22-12937 B Tukwila WSP 22-018173 N N/A ST-22-12938 A Tukwila WSP 22-018402 Y Y ST-22-12938 B Tukwila WSP 22-018402 Y N ST-22-12939 A Tukwila WSP 22-018449 N N/A ST-22-12939 B Tukwila WSP 22-018449 N N/A ST-22-12940 A Tukwila WSP 22-018589 N N/A ST-22-12940 B Tukwila WSP 22-018589 N N/A P007796-031024-000448 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 39 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-12941 A Tukwila WSP 22-018524 N N/A ST-22-12941 B Tukwila WSP 22-018524 Y Y ST-22-13215 A Tukwila WSP 22-018632 N N/A ST-22-13215 B Tukwila WSP 22-018632 N N/A ST-22-13217 A Tukwila WSP 22-018688 Y Y ST-22-13217 B Tukwila WSP 22-018688 Y N ST-22-13219 A Tukwila WSP 22-018638 N N/A ST-22-13219 B Tukwila WSP 22-018638 N N/A ST-22-13220 A Tukwila WSP 22-018649 N N/A ST-22-13220 B Tukwila WSP 22-018649 N N/A ST-22-13221 A Tukwila WSP 22-018868 Y N ST-22-13221 B Tukwila WSP 22-018868 N N/A ST-22-13437 A Tukwila WSP 22-019032 N N/A ST-22-13437 B Tukwila WSP 22-019032 Y Y ST-22-13438 A Tukwila WSP 22-019119 N N/A ST-22-13438 B Tukwila WSP 22-019119 Y N ST-22-13439 A Tukwila WSP 22-019035 N N/A ST-22-13439 B Tukwila WSP 22-019035 N N/A ST-22-13440 A Tukwila WSP 22-019211 N N/A ST-22-13440 B Tukwila WSP 22-019211 Y Y ST-22-13441 A Tukwila WSP 22-018944 Y Y ST-22-13441 B Tukwila WSP 22-018944 Y Y ST-22-13442 A Tukwila WSP 22-019214 Y Y P007796-031024-000449 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 40 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13442 B Tukwila WSP 22-019214 Y Y ST-22-13443 A Tukwila WSP 22-019239 N N/A ST-22-13443 B Tukwila WSP 22-019239 N N/A ST-22-13787 A Tukwila WSP 22-019632 N N/A ST-22-13787 B Tukwila WSP 22-019632 N N/A ST-22-13788 A Tukwila WSP 22-019584 N N/A ST-22-13788 B Tukwila WSP 22-019584 Y Y ST-22-13789 A Tukwila WSP 22-019374 Y Y ST-22-13789 B Tukwila WSP 22-019374 Y Y ST-22-13790 A Tukwila WSP 22-019645 Y Y ST-22-13790 B Tukwila WSP 22-019645 N N/A ST-22-13964 A Tukwila WSP 22-019984 Y Y ST-22-13964 B Tukwila WSP 22-019984 Y Y ST-22-13965 A Tukwila WSP 22-019749 N N/A ST-22-13965 B Tukwila WSP 22-019749 N N/A ST-22-13968 A Tukwila WSP 22-020012 Y Y ST-22-13968 B Tukwila WSP 22-020012 N N/A ST-22-13969 A Tukwila WSP 22-019987 Y Y ST-22-13969 B Tukwila WSP 22-019987 N N/A ST-22-13970 A Tukwila WSP 22-019925 N N/A ST-22-13970 B Tukwila WSP 22-019925 N N/A ST-22-13971 A Tukwila WSP 22-019844 N N/A ST-22-13971 B Tukwila WSP 22-019844 N N/A P007796-031024-000450 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 41 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13972 A Tukwila WSP 22-019761 Y Y ST-22-13972 B Tukwila WSP 22-019761 N N/A ST-22-13973 A Tukwila WSP 22-020086 Y Y ST-22-13973 B Tukwila WSP 22-020086 N N/A ST-22-14264 A Tukwila WSP 22-020163 N N/A ST-22-14264 B Tukwila WSP 22-020163 N N/A ST-22-13805 A Tulalip Police Dept 22-3257 N N/A ST-22-13805 B Tulalip Police Dept 22-3257 N N/A ST-22-13561 A Tumwater WSP 22-018416 N N/A ST-22-13561 B Tumwater WSP 22-018416 N N/A ST-22-13778 A Tumwater WSP 22-019134 N N/A ST-22-13778 B Tumwater WSP 22-019134 N N/A ST-22-12947 A Union Gap WSP 22-017220 N N/A ST-22-12947 B Union Gap WSP 22-017220 Y N ST-22-13665 A Vancouver Police Dept 2022-027409 N N/A ST-22-13665 B Vancouver Police Dept 2022-027409 N N/A ST-22-13666 A Vancouver Police Dept 2022-27814 Y Y ST-22-13666 B Vancouver Police Dept 2022-27814 N N/A ST-22-13668 A Vancouver Police Dept 22-28234 N N/A ST-22-13668 B Vancouver Police Dept 22-28234 Y Y ST-22-13277 A Vancouver WSP 22-018866 N N/A ST-22-13277 B Vancouver WSP 22-018866 N N/A ST-22-13279 A Vancouver WSP 22-018795 N N/A P007796-031024-000451 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 42 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13279 B Vancouver WSP 22-018795 N N/A ST-22-13280 A Vancouver WSP 22-018743 N N/A ST-22-13280 B Vancouver WSP 22-018743 Y Y ST-22-13282 A Vancouver WSP 22-018799 N N/A ST-22-13282 B Vancouver WSP 22-018799 N N/A ST-22-13469 A Vancouver WSP 22-019089 N N/A ST-22-13469 B Vancouver WSP 22-019089 N N/A ST-22-13751 A Vancouver WSP 22-019476 Y Y ST-22-13751 B Vancouver WSP 22-019476 N N/A ST-22-13776 A Vancouver WSP 22-019546 Y Y ST-22-13776 B Vancouver WSP 22-019546 N N/A ST-22-13954 A Vancouver WSP 22-019796 N N/A ST-22-13954 B Vancouver WSP 22-019796 Y Y ST-22-13955 A Vancouver WSP 22-020046 N N/A ST-22-13955 B Vancouver WSP 22-020046 N N/A ST-22-13957 A Vancouver WSP 22-020015 N N/A ST-22-13957 B Vancouver WSP 22-020015 N N/A ST-22-14125 A Vancouver WSP 22-020161-001 N N/A ST-22-14125 B Vancouver WSP 22-020161-001 N N/A ST-22-12948 A Walla Walla WSP 22-017886 Y Y ST-22-12948 B Walla Walla WSP 22-017886 N N/A ST-22-12949 A Walla Walla WSP 22-018259 N N/A ST-22-12949 B Walla Walla WSP 22-018259 N N/A P007796-031024-000452 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 43 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-13267 A Walla Walla WSP 22-018734 N N/A ST-22-13267 B Walla Walla WSP 22-018734 N N/A ST-22-13268 A Walla Walla WSP 22-017784 N N/A ST-22-13268 B Walla Walla WSP 22-017784 Y Y ST-22-13222 A Wenatchee Police Dept 22w19338 N N/A ST-22-13222 B Wenatchee Police Dept 22w19338 N N/A ST-22-14199 A Wenatchee Police Dept 22w20742 N N/A ST-22-14199 B Wenatchee Police Dept 22w20742 N N/A ST-22-13672 A Wenatchee WSP 22-019304 N N/A ST-22-13672 B Wenatchee WSP 22-019304 N N/A ST-22-13981 A Whatcom Co Sheriff 2022A31633 N N/A ST-22-13981 B Whatcom Co Sheriff 2022A31633 N N/A ST-22-13982 A Whatcom Co Sheriff 2022A31590 Y Y ST-22-13982 B Whatcom Co Sheriff 2022A31590 N N/A ST-22-13769 A Whitman Co Sheriff 22-S3217 N N/A ST-22-13769 B Whitman Co Sheriff 22-S3217 N N/A ST-22-14238 A Yakima Co Sheriff 22C18808 N N/A ST-22-14238 B Yakima Co Sheriff 22C18808 Y Y ST-22-14239 A Yakima Co Sheriff 22C19064 Y Y ST-22-14239 B Yakima Co Sheriff 22C19064 N N/A ST-22-14240 A Yakima Co Sheriff 22C17781 N N/A ST-22-14240 B Yakima Co Sheriff 22C17781 N N/A ST-22-14241 A Yakima Co Sheriff 22C18646 N N/A P007796-031024-000453 Washington State Patrol Toxicology Laboratory Division Page 44 of 44 9/27/23 Case ID Item Submitting Agency Agency Case # Evidence Container Visibly Damaged Evidence Transferred to New Container 2023-TLD-04: Case List - Evidence items stored in the Federal Way Toxicology Laboratory Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C) For additional information on a specific case, contact the laboratory at toxlab@wsp.wa.gov. Evidence Transferred to New Container - indicates if evidence was able to be transferred to new container. Y = transfer complete; N = no transfer possible; N/A = no damage to original container NOTE: List includes cases with evidence items stored in the Vault-Fridge Bulk on September 25, 2023 when it was discovered that the temperature was outside of the Laboratory's range of acceptability (average 2-8 ⁰C). On discovery, the refrigerator temperature was -21 ⁰C and contained evidence items from cases currently unassigned (no Test Report issued). Toxicology Division personnel evaluated each evidence item container for any damage and/or breakage due to the change in temperature. Where possible, evidence from damaged containers was transferred to a new labelled vacutainer tube. This table is provided for informational purposes only. ST-22-14241 B Yakima Co Sheriff 22C18646 Y N ST-22-14242 A Yakima Co Sheriff 22C19253 Y Y ST-22-14242 B Yakima Co Sheriff 22C19253 Y Y ST-22-13356 A Yakima Police Dept 22Y035956 N N/A ST-22-13356 B Yakima Police Dept 22Y035956 N N/A ST-22-13357 A Yakima Police Dept 22Y030570 N N/A ST-22-13357 B Yakima Police Dept 22Y030570 N N/A ST-22-13358 A Yakima Police Dept 22Y035454 Y Y ST-22-13358 B Yakima Police Dept 22Y035454 N N/A ST-22-13360 A Yakima Police Dept 22Y035061 N N/A ST-22-13360 B Yakima Police Dept 22Y035061 N N/A ST-22-13361 A Yakima Police Dept 22YY034339 Y Y ST-22-13361 B Yakima Police Dept 22YY034339 Y N ST-22-12950 A Yakima WSP 22-017841 N N/A ST-22-12950 B Yakima WSP 22-017841 N N/A P007796-031024-000454 January 14, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Detective Sergeant Aaron M. Westbrooke, Badge Number 128 Dear Mr. Brown: On December 10, 2021, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Sergeant abused and/or neglected a foster child in his care.” We are writing to notify you no factual information of a policy violation was identified, and the complaint was rejected. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Roger D. Wilbur, Investigative Assistance Division P007796-031024-000455 December 10, 2021 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Detective Sergeant Aaron M. Westbrooke, Badge Number 128 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Sergeant abused and/or neglected a foster child in his care.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Assistant Chief Marc W. Lamoreaux, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Roger D. Wilbur, Investigative Assistance Division P007796-031024-000456 May 18, 2017 Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Reginald Woods, Badge Number 789 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged the Trooper failed to activate the front/rear COBAN recording device during violator stops/contacts. It is further alleged the Trooper failed to comply with written procedures and expectations for reporting events/instances/arrests occurring on the Capitol Campus. It is also alleged that Trooper's behavior, performance and statements made during a violator contact, were unprofessional and inconsistent with training and expectations. EXPANDED DATES: JANUARY 5, 2017 - APRIL 28, 2017. EXPANSION: IT IS ALSO ALLEGED THE TROOPER ENTERED INACCURATE AND MISLEADING INFORMATION ON HIS TIME AND ACTIVITY REPORTS.” If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Tyler Drake, at (360) 704-2346. Sincerely, Captain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPTA Assistant Chief Randy F. Drake, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Johnny R. Alexander, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000457 JAY I LEE Gov•rnor I " TATE OF WA HI GTO WASH! GTON TAT PATROL JOH R. BATI T hi f PO Bo 42(,11 • 01 mpia, Washington 98504-2611 • 360-704-4220 • www. sp.wa.gov Mr. Tom McBride Executive Secretary Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 June 5, 2017 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness - Trooper Reginald Woods, Badge Number 789 Dear Mr. McBride: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) is providing notification regarding the above named employee: "It is alleged the trooper was untruthful when he reported an on-duty injury to a supervisor. It is further alleged the trooper knowingly entered untruthful information on an injury report and falsely submitted a Labor and Industries claim. " If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Tyler Drake, at (360) 704-2346. MSS:rng cc: Trooper Jeffrey Merrill, WSPT A Sincerely, ~ ~ -;::;?~ aptain Michael S. Saunders Office of Professional Standards Assistant Chief Randy F. Drake, Investigative Services Bureau Captain Johnny R. Alexander, Special Operations Division P007796-031024-000458 February 9, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tanya K. Wright, Badge Number 526 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged Trooper failed to fulfill her mandatory reporting requirements.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau P007796-031024-000459 March 7, 2022 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Update - Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – Trooper Tanya K. Wright, Badge Number 526 Dear Mr. Brown: On February 9, 2022, the Washington State Patrol (WSP) provided notification regarding the above named employee: “It is alleged Trooper failed to fulfill her mandatory reporting requirements.” We are writing to notify you no factual information to support the allegations was identified, and the complaint was not accepted. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Pete Stock at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Tyler M. Drake Office of Professional Standards TMD:hdh cc: Mr. Spike Unruh, WSPTA Dr. Fiona J. Couper, Forensic Laboratory Services Bureau P007796-031024-000460 January 23, 2024 Mr. Russell Brown Executive Director Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys 206 10th Ave SE Olympia WA 98501 Subject: Potential Disclosures concerning Government Witness – CO 2 Brianna L. Zingleman, Badge Number X189 Dear Mr. Brown: The Washington State Patrol (WSP) Office of Professional Standards is conducting an administrative investigation for the following allegation(s): “It is alleged CO 2 Zingleman engaged in acts of domestic violence towards her husband.” Upon conclusion of the administrative investigation, an updated disclosure letter will be sent with the outcome. If you need additional information, please contact Lieutenant Aaron Westbrooke, at (360) 704-2344. Sincerely, Captain Neil O. Weaver Office of Professional Standards NOW:hdh cc: Ms. Alexis Young, PTE LOCAL 17 Commander Vanessa C. Barnes, Communications Division P007796-031024-000461 P007796-031024-000462 P007796-031024-000463