Case File
efta-02705481DOJ Data Set 11OtherEFTA02705481
Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 11
Reference
efta-02705481
Pages
12
Persons
0
Integrity
Extracted Text (OCR)
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
Akin Gump
---
...„.
Privileged and Confidential
Draft 3/3/16
Death/Disability Analysis
Summary Slides
March 2016
EFIA_RI_02095822
EFTA02705481
LB Death/Disability Analysis - Slide 1 of 31
Akin Gump
STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP
Summary Flow Chart Regarding Certain Consequences of Mr. Black's Death or Disability
(primarily pursuant to the Agreement Among Principals dated July 13, 2007 (the "AAP"))
Mr. Black is
healthy
Mr. Black • asses awa
Mr. Black is disabled
CONTROL RIGHTS:
Mr. Black's estate will lose a
number of control rights that are
better viewed as personal to him
under the AAP (see next slide).
CONTROL RIGHTS:
Mr. Black will lose a number of
control rights under the AAP
that require he remain employed
by Apollo or on the Executive
Committee (see next slide).
REG RIGHTS/EXCHANGE:
Mr. Black's personal
representative is entitled to
cause exchanges of AOGs
(AAP §2.4(a)) and exercise
registration rights (AAP
§2.4(e)).
EMPLOYMENT:
Mr. Black's employment with
Apollo is deemed terminated
(AAP §3.1(b)).
APOLLO BOARD:
Messrs. Rowan and Harris
(and their groups) are not
obligated to elect Mr. Black to
the board of Apollo (§5.2(c)).
CERTAIN EQUITY:
Mr. Black's replacement on the
Executive Committee will
receive Mr. Black's equity in
BRH Holdings GP automatically
(AAP §5.1(a)).
1 All matters described in these slides are qualified in their entirety by the underlying documents.
Please see the back-up chart for additional detail and a list of documents reviewed.
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE:
Mr. Black is no longer entitled to
sit on Apollo's Executive
Committee (AAP §5.1(a)).
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
REPLACEMENT:
Mr. Black (or his personal
representative) is entitled to
appoint a new senior
professional from Apollo to the
Executive committee after
consultation with the committee
and approval of one member
(AAP §5.3(b)). This right
(including subsequent
replacements) continues until
Mr. Black's group is not the
single largest beneficial owner
of Apollo (but can also terminate
for certain bad acts by Mr.
Black, if it arose due to Mr.
Black's disability).
O2016 Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
EFTA R1_020951323
EFTA02705482
LB Death/Disability Analysis - Slide 2 of 3
Akin Gump
STRAUSS HAUER & FELO LLP
Effects of Death or Disability on Certain Control Rights under the Agreement Among Principals2
1.
Key
Rights
2.
Lost
3.
4.
5.
1.
Key
2.
Rights
Retained
3.
Mr. Black is Disabled
MFN with Messrs. Harris and Rowan on investment terms
for new Apollo funds (§2.1(e)).
Rights to disregard transfer limits and require exchanges to
pay taxes, in the event of the receipt of additional
economics forfeited by other Apollo investment
professionals besides Principals (§4.2(b)).
Right to be one of the two required Principal votes needed
to approve most Executive Committee actions (§5.2(a)).
Veto over decisions regarding employment of senior
investment professionals or consultants (§5.2(b)(i)) (though
Mr. Black's replacement appointee to the Executive
Committee would retain this right).
Veto over board appointments (O.2(c)).
Right to approve the dissolution of BRH Holdings, L.P. or any
actions or transactions that result or could result in non-pro
rata treatment or effect upon a Principal (§5.2(b)).
Veto over, or (with the approval of the independent members
of the Board) right to cause a sale of all or substantially all or
Apollo, or a transfer of a ratable interest in each entity that is
part of an AOG (§5.4).
Right to cause exchanges of AOGs (AAP §2.4(a)) and
exercise registration rights (AAP §2.4(e)).
Mr. Black is Deceased
1. Items 1 through 5 under the "Mr. Black is Disabled"
column.
2. Assuming the threshold in §5.2(b)(iii) is intended to apply
to §5.2(b)(ii), the right to veto any delegation of authority
of the Executive Committee (§5.2(b)(ii).
3. Veto over the dissolution of BRH Holdings or other acts
that would result in an non pro-rata treatment of a
Principal (Messrs. Black, Rowan or Harris) (§5.2(b)(iii)).
4. Veto over, or (with the approval of the independent
members of the Board) right to cause a sale of all or
substantially all of Apollo, or a transfer of a ratable
interest in each entity that is part of an AOG (O.4).
5. Inspection/information rights for matters related to Mr.
Black's interest in BRH Holdings, L.P. (O.7).
1. Cause exchanges of AOGs (AAP §2.4(a)) and exercise
registration rights (AAP §2.4(e)).
2 Please see note on interpretive issues in back-up chart. This summary chart represents Akin's view of the better reading of these provisions.
EFTA_R1_02095824
EFTA02705483
LB Death/Disability Analysis - Slide 3 of 3
Akin Gump
STRAUSS HAUER & FELO LIP
Certain Other Key Provisions Related to or Consequences of Mr. Black's Death or Disability
Document
Agreement Among Principals
(please see note on
Interpretive issues in
back-up chart)2
Apollo Global Management
Shareholders Agreement
BRH Holdings GP
Memorandum and Articles
Black Family Partners - LPA
Black Family GP — LLCA
Section
Definitions
5.2(b)
53
5.6
6.10
5.9(d)
2.2(f)
7.1
8.8(a)
Generally
48
9.3
N/A
Provision
"Disability" requires a board determination that Mr. Black is unable to perform "all or substantially
all" of his duties under his employment agreement for 180 consecutive days or 8 in 12 months.
After the death of a Principal (including Mr. Black) Apollo may not be able to take actions
requiring consent of all Principals - clause (iii), the dissolution of BRH Holdings L.P. or any
actions that could result in non-pro rata treatment of a Principal, and likely clause (ii), delegation by
the executive committee. After the death of two principals, the Executive Committee may not
be able to act.
The Executive Committee may appoint a temporary replacement for Mr. Black to handle his
duties to Apollo pending a determination of his Disability, but he isn't removed until a determination.
Mr. Black's group remains subject to drag and tag rights in certain other documents.
Amendments require approval of Principals (or their legal representative, if applicable).
Demand rights owed to BRH are exercisable by the Principals through BRH, but see AAP §2.4(e).
Despite his death or disability, Mr. Black's group (spouse, descendants, controlled charities,
trusts, legal or personal representatives) remains subject to drag and tag obligations in the
Lender Rights Agreement and Roll-up Agreements.
Indemnity for fund incentive compensation claw back is owed to Mr. Black's group.
Amendments require approval of Principals (no reference to representatives here, but there is a
slightly better argument to include Mr. Black's estate as successor, by the interpretive provisions).
The entity's operations, generally (and most sections, specifically), are subject to the AAP
Directors must be appointed and removed to match the Executive Committee.
Upon his death or disability, Mr. Black's economic rights will devolve to his legal representative.
Mr. Black is sole member and manager. The agreement is silent on consequences of his death
or disability, but §18-705 of the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act permits a member's
personal representative to exercise the member's rights under an LLC agreement. Here, the
representative could exercise Mr. Black's rights as member to amend the operating agreement to
appoint a new manager.
2 Please see note on interpretive issues in back-up chart. This summary chart represents Akin's view of the better reading of these provisions
EFTA_R1_02095825
EFTA02705484
AGSH&F DRAFT 3/3/16
LB Death/Disability Analysis — Summary of Analysis by Document'
1.
Agreement Among Principals (the "AAP"), dated as of July 13, 2007
Parties
Messrs. Black, Rowan and Harris; Black Family Partners, L.P., MJR Foundation LLC, AP
Professional Holdings, L.P. and BRH Holdings, L.P.
Key
Definitions
"LB" - Mr. Black.
"Principals" — Messrs. Black, Rowan and Harris.
"Disability" — a physical or mental incapacity such that there is an Apollo board
determination that a Principal is unable to perform all or substantially all of his duties under
the applicable employment agreement, for 180 consecutive days or 8 in any 12 months.
Please note certain additional definitions under the heading "Certain Other Definitions"
Employment
Upon his death or Disability, Mr. Black is deemed terminated from the Apollo Employer
(§3.1(b)).
Executive
Committee
If deemed terminated for death or disability, Mr. Black is no longer has a right to serve on
the Executive Committee because he is deemed no longer employed by Apollo (§5.1(a)).
Executive
Committee -
Short Term
Substitute
The Executive Committee may appoint a temporary replacement for Mr. Black to handle his
duties to Apollo pending a determination of his Disability in certain circumstances, but Mr.
Black will remain on the Executive Committee unless and until a final determination is made
or he is otherwise prohibited from participating (e.g.. he undertakes an action constituting
Cause or dies, while a disability determination is pending) (§5.5).
Executive
Committee -
Long-Term
Replacements
If deemed terminated for death or Disability, Mr. Black (or his personal representative, as
applicable) is entitled to nominate a Senior Professional to replace Mr. Black on the
Executive Committee, after consultation with the committee and with the consent of one
member (§5.3(b)). That replacement right will continue for all section §5.3(b) appointees
(i.e., in perpetuity) until such time as Mr. Black's group is not the largest beneficial owner of
Apollo series A shares, or if the appointment right arose due to Mr. Black's disability, if he
subsequently takes actions that would have permitted him to be terminated for Cause if he
were still employed at the time he took the actions (§5.3(b)).
Apollo Board
Following deemed termination from Apollo for death or Disability, Messrs. Rowan and
Harris (and their groups) are not obligated to elect Mr. Black to the Board of Apollo because
he is no longer eligible to participate in the Executive Committee. (§5.2(c))
Exchanges
and
Registration
Rights
After his death or Disability, Mr. Black's personal representative would still be entitled to
cause Exchanges (§2.4(a)) and exercise Registration Rights (§2.4(e)). If cut-backs are
applied after Mr. Black's death, Mr. Black's estate will be allocated 3 times the normal
portion allocated to it from BRH Holdings (presumably to the detriment of Messrs. Rowan
and Harris and their respective groups) (§2.4(e)).
Future Fund
Investments
After his death or Disability, Mr. Black would lose his MFN with Messrs. Harris and Rowan
on investment terms for new Apollo funds (§2.1(e)). This right only accrues to "Continuing
Principals."
Exchanges to
Pay Taxes
After his death or Disability, in the event an Apollo professional other than a Principal
forfeits AOG Units or other economic interests, and they are distributed to Principals and
' The document summaries contained herein are intended to address the most significant issues raised by Mr. Black's death
or disability, and are qualified in their entirety by the underlying documents. This summary may not address all provisions relevant to
a particular question that arises after Mr. Black's death or disability.
EFTA_R1_02095826
EFTA02705485
their groups. Mr. Black would no longer have a right to disregard transfer limitations when
causing registrations and exchanges to pay taxes. (§4.2(b)). This right only accrues to
"Continuing Principals."
Effects on
Certain
Control
Rights2
Following removal from the Executive Committee due to death or Disability. Mr. Black
would no longer have the rights:
o to be one of the two required Principal votes needed to approve most Executive
Committee actions (§5.2(a));
o to veto decisions regarding employment of senior investment professionals or
consultants, which requires unanimous Executive Committee approval ((§5.2(b)(i));
o to veto board appointments, which falls away if Mr. Black is no longer on the
Executive Committee (§5.2(c)).
Following his death, neither Mr. Black or his personal representative will be able to exercise
certain other rights as a Principal (but please see Key Interpretive Issue below):
o to veto the dissolution of BRH Holdings or other acts that would result in an non
pro-rata treatment of a Principal ((§5.2(b)(iii);
o assuming the threshold in (iii) is intended to apply to (ii), to veto any delegation of
authority of the Executive Committee (5.2(b)(ii).
Extraordinaq
Transactions'
Mr. Black's rights with respect to certain extraordinary transactions would likely remain in
place despite a Disability, but fall away on death. While he is alive, Mr. Black is entitled to
veto (or with consent of a majority of the independent members of Apollo's board, cause) a
sale of all or substantially all of Apollo or a transfer of a ratable interests in the AOGs. (§5.4)
BRH Holdings
GP Equity
When Mr. Black is no longer entitled to a seat on the Executive Committee (so upon Mr.
Black's death or disability), his equity in BRH Holdings GP will automatically transfer to his
successor on the Executive Committee (§5.1(a)).
Certain
Limitations on
Mr. Black's
Group
Mr. Black's Group will remain subject to a variety of covenants after his death, including
limitations regarding ownership of Apollo series A shares subject to the exchange agreement
(§2.4(c)), drag-along and tag-along rights in other documents (§5.6(a)) and arguably
disparagement and competition limitations in Mr. Black's employment agreement and the
roll-up agreements. Although the Group concept is already so broad that it likely creates
some compliance challenges (e.g., how can Mr. Black prevent his children's spouses from
disparaging), his death could further complicate exercising control over his Group members.
Information
Rights
Following Mr. Black's death, he will not be entitled to inspection rights with respect to
matters related to his interest in BRH Holdings, L.P. (§5.7).
Amendments
Amendments require approval of Principals (or their legal representative, if applicable)
(§6.10(a)).
Successors
and Assigns
Assignment requires consent of the other parties to the AAP, and rights inure to the benefit of
successors and permitted assigns (§6.11). Delaware counsel has advised there is very
limited case law on the application of successor provisions to shareholder agreements and
similar documents in the event of death of an individual (except as it relates to solely
economic rights), but certain rights are typically viewed as personal (for example, a right of
first refusal).
Certain Other
Definitions
"Apollo" — Apollo Global Management, LLC.
"Apollo Employer" — Apollo Global Management, LLC or any successor.
"Cause" — (i) a final, non-appealable conviction of or plea of nob contendere to a felony
2 Please see the interpretive issues described at the end of this summary chart. The summary in this row describes Akin's
view of the better reading of these provisions.
2
EFTA_R1_02095827
EFTA02705486
prohibiting such Principal from continuing to provide services as an investment professional
to Apollo due to legal restriction or physical confinement; or (ii) ceasing to be eligible to
continue performing services as an investment professional on behalf of Apollo or any of its
material subsidiaries, in each case, pursuant to a final, non-appealable legal restriction (such
as a final, non-appealable injunction, but expressly excluding a preliminary injunction or
other provisional restriction).
"Continuing Principals" — Principals employed by the Apollo Employer as of a forfeiture
date.
"Group" — with respect to each Principal, such Principal and (i) such Principal's spouse, (ii) a
lineal descendant of such Principal's parents, the spouse of any such descendant or a lineal
descendent of any such spouse, (iii) a Charitable Institution solely controlled by such
Principal and other members of his Group, (iv) a trustee of a trust (whether inter vivos or
testamentary), all of the current beneficiaries and presumptive remaindermen of which are
one or more of such Principal and Persons described in clauses (i) through (iii) of this
definition, (v) a corporation, limited liability company or partnership, of which all of the
outstanding shares of capital stock or interests therein are owned by one or more of such
Principal and Persons described in clauses (i) through (iv) of this definition, (vi) an
individual mandated under a qualified domestic relations order, or (vii) a legal or personal
representative of such Principal in the event of his death or Disability. For purposes of this
definition, (x) "lineal descendants" shall not include individuals adopted after attaining the
age of eighteen (18) years and such adopted Person's descendants; and (y) "presumptive
remaindermen" shall refer to those Persons entitled to a share of a trust's assets if it were then
to terminate. No Principal shall ever be a member of the Group of another Principal.
"Senior Professional" — any executive officer of Apollo or any of the investment
Professionals (who is not a Principal) who provide services (either as partners or employees)
to Apollo or any of its Subsidiaries whose "total income" for the most recent preceding fiscal
year is among the 25 highest (excluding the Principals from the 25 employees); provided,
that any such individual must provide services to Apollo or any of its Subsidiaries on a
substantially full-time basis.
Key
Interpretive
Issue
•
The key interpretive issue that runs through the AAP is whether control rights (described
above in the rows titled "Effects on Certain Control Rights" and "Extraordinary
Transactions") are (a) personal to Mr. Black (or for the Principals) and fall away when
Mr. Black (or the other Principals) die, or (b) are exercisable by an estate (or legal
representative) and/or transferrable by the estate. This should be considered in
connection with the Successors and Assigns provision described above. Because there are
a few instances where the AAP expressly contemplates succession, or exercise by
personal representatives, and a defined term for surviving Principals ("Continuing
Principals"), we believe the better reading is that rights stated as personal do fall away.
However, the effect of the successor clause and the effect of these terms is open to
interpretation and may ultimately be determined on a clause by clause basis. Often,
agreements address this more expressly to eliminate ambiguity. as was done in the AAP
with respect to the right to cause exchanges and registration and Mr. Black's (or his
estate's) rights to appoint his replacement to the Executive Committee.
•
What we believe to be the "better reading" may create some problematic results or other
ambiguities for certain provisions in the document, that could undermine this
interpretation:
o Certain matters requiring unanimous approval of the Principals in §5.2(b) if read
literally arguably cannot be taken following Mr. Black's (or any single Principal's)
death. Alternative readings of these provisions include requiring only the approval of
3
E FTA_R 1_02095828
EFTA02705487
Continuing Principals, assuming Mr. Black's estate's appointee (or other successor
Executive Committee members) would take on the role of "Principal" for the
purpose of satisfying this requirement or interpreting this as instead requiring
unanimous approval of the members of the Executive Committee.
o The general requirement in §5.2(a) that Executive Committee action requires the
approval of two Principals if read literally limits the powers of Mr. Black's estate's
appointee (that is. Messrs. Rowan and Harris must still agree) to the Executive
Committee, and if two Principals are deceased, paralyzes the committee (and so
potentially Apollo. unless the Executive Committee provided sufficient delegation to
Apollo's board prior to the time there was only one surviving Principal). Two
alternative readings that could address these concerns are interpreting this language
as instead stating a more general rule on Executive Committee action (i.e., that acts
require the approval of two members of the Executive Committee, or treating
replacement Executive Committee members as taking on the role of "Principal" for
the purpose of satisfying this requirement).
o Courts generally disfavor dead hand provisions, so it is also possible that provisions
requiring unanimous consent of the Principals will be read as requiring only
Principals that remain alive to consent. A party arguing against this interpretation
may point out that there is a separate defined term in the AAP for Principles that are
alive, not disabled and still working at Apollo, "Continuing Principles." Mr. Black's
right to remain on the Executive Committee after his retirement would complicate
that argument.
Other
Interpretive
Issues
•
§5.2(b)(ii), regarding delegation of authority of the Executive Committee, does not have
an approval threshold, while §5.2(b)(i) and §5.2(b)(iii) do. Assuming this provision is
not disregarded completely, something will have to be read in.
o Although no single reading is clearly correct, the most likely intent of the parties
was to impute the threshold in §5.2(b)(iii), "unanimous consent of the Principals." to
§5.2(b)(ii).
o Another potential interpretation would be to read the threshold in §5.2(b)(iii) as
applying to §5.2(b)(i) and §5.2(b)(ii) as well, causing the actions in §5.2(b)(i)
(decisions regarding employment of senior investment professionals or consultants)
to require both unanimous consent of the Principals and unanimous consent of the
Executive Committee.
•
§5.5 states that the definition of "Disability" is used solely in connection with vesting of
equity. However, Mr. Black has certain other rights on Disability, described above.
•
The AAP uses the term "personal representative" in most instances, but uses "legal
representative" in reference to amendments, and both terms in the definition of "Group."
o It is not clear if these terms are intended to be substitutes. They are not defined.
o The AAP also does not address how those titles should pass if any such
representative dies or becomes disabled, relinquishes their role or has their
authorization revoked.
o We should confirm Mr. Black's estate planning documents appropriately address
these roles directly, to maximize the likelihood his wishes are respected and the
associated rights under the AAP are maintained.
r
II.
Apollo Global Management LLC — Amended and Restated LLC Agreement — Nothing relevant.
III.
Apollo Global Management LLC — Shareholders Agreement, as Amended
4
EFTA_R1_02095829
EFTA02705488
Key
Definitions
"Restricted Party" — any Principal and members of such Principal's Group.
"Principals" — Messrs. Black, Rowan and Harris.
"Group" — with respect to any Person, such Person's and (i) such Person's spouse, (ii) a
lineal descendant of such Person's parents, the spouse of any such descendant or a lineal
descendent of any such spouse, (iii) a Charitable Institution controlled solely by such Person
or other member of his Group, (iv) a trustee of a trust (whether inter vivos or testamentary),
all of the current beneficiaries and presumptive remaindermen of which are one or more of
such Persons described in clauses (i) through (iii) of this definition, (v) a corporation,
limited liability company or partnership, of which all of the outstanding shares of capital
stock or interests therein are owned by one or more of such Persons described in clauses (i)
through (iv) of this definition, (vi) an individual mandated under a qualified domestic
relations order, or (vii) a legal or personal representative of such Person in the event of his
death or Disability. For purposes of this definition, (x) "lineal descendants" shall not include
individuals adopted after attaining the age of eighteen (18) years and such adopted Person's
Transfer
Restrictions
Transfer restrictions (by percentage in (§2.2(a)) and for drag-along and tag-along rights in
other documents (§2.2(f)) apply to Mr. Black's Group, and would continue to apply after his
death or Disability.
Registration
Rights
The agreement expressly contemplates that Principals can exercise registration rights
through BRH Holdings, L.P. (§5.9(f). See AAP §2.4 regarding exercise after Mr. Black's
death or disability.
Indemnity for
Clawbacks
Even after Mr. Black's death or disability, his group is still entitled to indemnification for
guaranties of obligations to repay incentive compensation to investment funds (§7.1).
Amendments
Amendments require the consent of the Principals (§8.8). After Mr. Black's death, this
would have to include his estate as successor, or his assignee, or the agreement cannot be
amended. However, the interpretive provisions in §1.2 note that a reference to a person
includes successors and assigns.
IV.
AGM Management LLC — Amended and Restated Operating Agreement — Nothing relevant,
except that Mr. Black was the initial President and would have to be replaced upon his death.
V.
BRH Holdings, L.P. — Amended and Restated Partnership Agreement — Nothing relevant, except
that amendments will require a majority consent of Mr. Black's Group (defined the same way as in
the Shareholders Agreement) (§8.1). This would remain after Mr. Black's death.
VI.
BRH Holdings GP, Ltd. —Articles of Association
General
Framework
The agreement generally requires directors and members act consistently with the AAP. In
addition, most sections of the articles are expressly "subject to the provisions of the AAP."
Executive
Committee
If a member or director ceases to be a member of the Executive Committee, their shares
transfer automatically to their successor on the Executive Committee, once identified (BL4).
Directors
The company's business is managed by directors, subject to the AAP (BL54). The directors
are removed and appointed based on the AAP, assuming the company's board is the
Executive Committee (BL48). So upon Mr. Black's death, his replacement on the Executive
Committee would join the board.
Transfers on
Death
There is some discussion of transfer of equity upon death (BL17), but it is superseded by the
AAP (§5.1(a)), which requires the automatic transfer of BRH Holdings GP equity to an
5
EFTA_R1_02095830
EFTA02705489
former Executive Committee member's successor on the committee.
VII.
AP Professional Holdings L.P. — 2nd Amended and Restated Partnership Agreement — Nothing
relevant.
VIII. Black Family Partners, L.P. — Agreement of Limited Partnership, as amended — Nothing relevant
except that upon Mr. Black's death or disability, his rights to economics will pass to his legal
representative, but that representative won't become an partner without GP consent (§9.3).
IX.
Black Family Partners GP, LLC — Operating Agreement — Nothing material, except that Mr.
Black is sole member and manager. The agreement is silent regarding effect of death or disability,
but § 18-705 of the Delaware LLC Act permits a member's personal representative to exercise the
member's rights under a limited liability company agreement, for purposes of settling the estate.
This would permit the personal representative to exercise Mr. Black's right to amend the operating
agreement to appoint a new manager.
6
EFTA_R1_02095831
EFTA02705490
AGSH&F DRAFT 3/3/16
LB Death/Disability Analysis — Summary of Analysis by Document
I.
Tax Receivable Agreement (the "TRA"), dated July 13, 2007
Parties to
Agreement
APO Corp.. Apollo Principal Holdings II, L.P., Apollo Principal Holdings IV. L.P.
and Apollo Management Holdings, L.P.
Key
Definitions
"Basis Adjustment" -- means, as a result of an Exchange and the payments made,
the adjustment to the tax basis of an asset under... Sections 743(6) and 754 of the
Code (in situations where, following an Exchange, a Partnership remains in
existence as an entity for tax purposes).... The amount of any Basis Adjustment
resulting from an Exchange of one or more Partnership Units shall be determined
without regard to any Pre-Exchange Transfer of such Partnership Units, and as if
any such Pre-Exchange Transfer had not occurred. (Emphasis Added)
„Pre-Exchange Transfer" -- means any transfer (including upon the death of a
Holder) an interest in any of the Partnerships (i) that occurs prior to an exchange
made pursuant to the Exchange Agreement, and (ii) to which Section 743(b) of the
Code applies.
"Partnerships" — means Black Family Partners, L.P., BRH Holdings, L.P. and AP
Professional Holdings. L.P.
Post-Death
Transfer
A subsequent exchange by Mr. Black's heirs of the AOG units received at Mr.
Black's death are treated as if Mr. Black owned the AOG units and the Pre-
Exchange Transfer is disregarded for purposes of determining the tax benefit
under the TRA. (See italicized portion of definition of "Basis Adjustment" ).
Successors
Rights
All the terms and conditions of the TRA shall be binding upon, shall inure to the
benefit of and shall be enforceable by Mr. Black's successors, assigns, heirs,
executors, administrators and legal representatives. (TRA Section 7.6(d))
II.
Transfers at Death
Basis Step-
up
Upon the death of Mr. Black, Mr. Black's heirs will receive property, including
the interests in the Black Family Partners, with an adjusted basis equal such
property's fair market value pursuant to Section 1014 of the Code, which will
include the value of BRH Holdings and AP Professional Holdings.
Section 754
Election
basis
Upon receiving such property, the Partnerships will be entitled to make an
election under Section 754 of the Code, which provides that an adjustment to the
basis of a partnership's property (i.e., the "inside basis") is available upon the
death of a partner. Upon making such election, Mr. Black's heirs would receive a
step-up in the Black Family Partners assets, including the basis in the
assets of both AP Professional Holdings and AMH Holdings. The basis step-up
in the assets of AMH Holdings, resulting from the Section 754 election, would
produce a tax benefit for Mr. Black's Heirs based upon the amortization of the
AMH Holdings assets.
EFTA_R1_02095832
EFTA02705491
AGSH&F DRAFT 3/3/16
Please note that the Section 754 election must be made at each partnership
down-the-chain (e.g., Black Family Partners, L.P., BRH Holdings, L.P. and AP
Professional Holdings, L.P.) for Mr. Black's heirs to receive a basis step-up in
the assets of AMH Holdings, L.P. In the BRH Holding's LPA, a partner can
require the partnership to make a Section 754 election upon a transfer of an
interest, but in the AP Professional Holdings LPA, the partnership will make a
754 election if directed by the general partner.
HI.
Tufts Gain
Tax
Treatment
The transfer of the interests in the Partnerships that occurs at the time of Mr.
Black's death could result, pursuant to Section 752 of the Code and the
applicable Regulations. in (i) a deemed distribution of Mr. Black's share of the
non-recourse liabilities of AMH Holdings and (ii) the recognition of gain (what
we have referred to as "Tufts gain") to the extent such deemed distribution
exceeds Mr. Black's adjusted tax basis in AMH Holdings. However, while not
free from doubt, such deemed distribution should not be triggered at death, and
neither Mr. Black nor the estate should be required to recognize the Tufts gain on
the transfer of the Partnerships to his heir. Furthermore, a tax basis step-up in
the AMH Holdings (and the other intervening Partnerships), which would occur
through the series of Section 754 elections described above, should include the
amount of the non-recourse liabilities of AMH Holdings, such that the amount of
any potential Tufts gain that would be recognized on a subsequent transfer or
exchange by the heirs would be eliminated or significantly reduced.
IV.
Exchange Agreement, dated 03/04/2016
Successors
The Exchange Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of Mr.
Black's successors, executors, administrators, heirs, legal representatives and
assigns. (See Exchange Agreement Section 3.4).
EFTA_R1_02095833
EFTA02705492
Technical Artifacts (18)
View in Artifacts BrowserEmail addresses, URLs, phone numbers, and other technical indicators extracted from this document.
Phone
2705481Phone
2705482Phone
2705483Phone
2705484Phone
2705485Phone
2705486Phone
2705487Phone
2705488Phone
2705489Phone
2705490Phone
2705491Phone
2705492Wire Ref
Transfer
RestrictionsWire Ref
Transfer restrictionsWire Ref
referenceWire Ref
transfer automaticallyWire Ref
transfer limitationsWire Ref
transfer limitsForum Discussions
This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.