Case 1:16-cv-03989-RJS Document 9 Filed 06/07/16 Page 1 of 2

Case 1:16-cv-03989-RJS Document 9 Filed 06/07/16 Page 1 of 2 THE MINTZ FRAADE LAW FIRM, P.C. COUNSELORS AT LAW 271 MADISON AVENUE, 12th FLOOR NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10016 TELEPHONE OF COUNSEL (212)4864500 EDWARD C. KRAMER JON M. PROBSTEIN SEYMOUR RE1TKNECHT TELECOP1ER JOSEPH J. TOMASEK (212) 486-0701 June 7, 2016 Via E-mail Hon. Richard J. Sullivan, D.J. United States District Court Southern District of New York Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse 40 Foley Square, Room 2104 New York, New York 10007 ([email protected]) Re: Steven Jude Hoffenberg v. Jeffrey E. Epstein, et al. (Index No. 1:16-cv-039891 Dear Judge Sullivan: Our firm represents Mr. Steven Jude Hoffenberg, the Plaintiff in the above-referenced matter. The Complaint in the above-referenced matter (the "Complaint") was filed on May 27, 2016, as a Related Action to United States of America v. Steven Hoffenberg, 94 Cr. 213 (RWS), 95 Cr. 321 (RWS), 1997 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2394 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 4, 1997) ("Hoffenberg"). Honorable Robert W. Sweet, D.J. was presiding Judge in Hoffenberg, in which Mr. Hoffenberg was convicted of conspiracy to violate securities laws by fraudulently selling securities, mail and wire fraud, conspiracy to obstruct justice and tax evasion. Although Mr. Hoffenberg was the sole Defendant named in Hoffenberg, Judge Sweet made it clear in the Sentencing Opinion dated March 4, 1997, that several other individuals, i.e. "co-conspirators," operated and executed the fraudulent securities activities, along with Mr. Hoffenberg. According to Mr. Hoffenberg, one of such "co-conspirators" was Mr. Jeffrey E. Epstein, the Defendant in the above-referenced matter. Accordingly, the Complaint sets forth how Mr. Epstein was integrally involved in the fraudulent securities activities for which Mr. Hoffenberg was convicted. Mr. Hoffenberg was ordered by Judge Sweet to pay restitution in the sum of $475,157,340 plus interest (the "Restitution Order"). Since this lawsuit is for the purpose of collecting from the Defendant the "ill-gotten" monies directly attributed to and part of the crime, which include monies which have been transferred to the Defendant. It is respectfully suggested 1 EFTA00601555 Case 1:16-cv-03989-RJS Document 9 Filed 06/07/16 Page 2 of 2 that this action is properly before Judge Sweet, who is still overseeing restitution issues, as they arise. Mr. Epstein and the claims brought against him in the Complaint are pertinent and of consequence to Hoffenberg, and vice versa. In addition, although not raised as a Related Action, there is a civil action brought by Ms. [REDACTED] against Ghislaine Maxwell filed on September 21, 2015, in which Ms. Giuffre alleges that she became a victim of sex trafficking and repeated sexual abuse after being recruited by Ms. Maxwell and Mr. Epstein when she was under the age of eighteen. Ms. Giuffre's civil action is currently pending before Judge Sweet (Index No. 1:15-cv-07433-RWS). Currently at issue in such proceeding pending before Judge Sweet is the liquidation of an asset valued at $15,000,000 owned by Ms. Maxwell from funds provided by Mr. Epstein, which we believe is subject to the Restitution Order and subsequent proceedings before Judge Sweet in 2013, which specifically referred to Mr. Epstein. Based upon the foregoing, we respectfully request that the Court consider that the instant matter be transferred to Judge Sweet, if he is willing to preside over this matter. Respectfully submitted, The Mintz Fraade Law Firm, PC APFAlk Cc: Gary H. Baise, Esq. By; Alan P. Fraade 2 EFTA00601556