Case File
efta-efta01091908DOJ Data Set 9OtherEFTA01091908
Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
efta-efta01091908
Pages
17
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available
Extracted Text (OCR)
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
EFTA01091908
F Rare Opportunity
Mitchell Holdings LLC & Aurify Brands have signed a
Letter of Intent to purchase one of New York's most
sought after and iconic brands.
Family-owned for generations, the company has worked
with us for over two years to create a purchase scenario
that will allow the brand to flourish.
The brand is poised for significant value creation
through development and licensing opportunities.
I
Few opportunities exist in the restaurant industry with
similar brand equity and untapped growth potential.
EFTA01091909
Carnegie Deli
A History...
►
1937: Carnegie Deli opens across from Carnegie
Hall at 854 7th Avenue.
►
1938-75: Known as a local eatery for midtown
office & stage professionals.
►
1976: Purchased by Milton Parker and Leo
Steiner.
►
1979: Modern day Carnegie craze sparked by
famed NY Times critic Mimi Sheraton.
►
1980-2002:
► Parker's & Steiner's innovative efforts establish
Carnegie as "the" NYC deli.
► Popularity flourishes, deli becomes a favorite of
celebrities, dignitaries and tourists alike.
►
2002: Ownership transfers to Parker's daughter,
Marian Levine, and her husband, Sandy.
►
2005: Termed "Most Famous Deli in the United
States" by USA Today.
►
2010-2012: Continues to enjoy limelight,
releasing "The Melo" and "The Jetbow"
sandwiches to honor new NYC arrivals.
►
Present day: Its iconic status solidified, Carnegie
serves up to 15,000 lbs of corned beef and
pastrami to customers each week.
EFTA01091910
The Carnegie Brand
We seek to utilize Carnegie's strong brand equity
to expand and scale the business from a well-run
"mom & pop" operation to a professionally-
managed, global restaurant & food company.
Key to the success of this expansion will be the
ability to scale distinct, defining aspects of the
Carnegie Deli brand, while maintaining its
underlying integrity.
A
Distinguishing Brand Elements
1. NYC lineage and legacy
2. Signature Jewish deli food items
3. Interior decor: wood, photos, etc.
4. Brand ambassador as host
in
5. Dining experience with waitstaff
6. The spectacle of the sandwich
7. Celebrity & notable sandwiches
Unique to Carnegie
EFTA01091911
Current Business
Flagship Carnegie Restaurant
► Iconic NYC Location
► Long-term lease in place
► Experienced, dedicated staff
► Low estimated capex req'ts
2011 Revenue = $12.9MM
2011 EBITDA = $1.8MM
Wholesale Food Products
► NJ Real Estate & Factory
► Excess production capacity
► Commissary for NYC, LV & PA
► Select existing distribution:
MJ Comerford: Supermarkets
United Pickle: Costco
Thumann, Inc: Packaged proteins
2011 Revenue (Total) = $9.9MM
2011 EBITDA = $0.9MM
viwirreto
Licensed Restaurant Deals
► MGM Mirage (LV)
► Sands (PA)
► Madison Sq Garden
► US Open
2011 Revenue = $0.7MM
2011 EBITDA = $0.7MM
Solid Existing Business, Exceptional Brand Equity & Myriad of
Untapped Growth Opportunities
EFTA01091912
Fetter of Intent
The LOI with current Carnegie ownership includes:
►
$27MM Purchase Price (Businesses)
►
Purchase of NJ Manufacturing Facility and Real
Estate, estimated at $2MM
►
3-Year Seller Note of $6MM
►
2-Year Employment Contract with Sandy Levine, the
current owner/operator
►
Purchase of all patents, trademarks and proprietary
materials (e.g., recipes, etc.)
►
Usage and/or reproduction of key assets
(e.g., pictures, etc.)
MAKE OUR MIN **TRIES. NEAT% PICKLES KOK DE
t
EFTA01091913
Growth Principles &
Pillars
Embrace the Brand
Remain committed to the core principles of the
Carnegie brand, built over the past 75 years
Stay true to company culture, signature products and
true differentiators of the Carnegie "experience"
Immediate focus on nurturing NYC operations &
customer experience - "The Flagship"
Leverage Expertise from All Sides
Research and digest vast knowledge base of existing
ownership and management teams
Integrate our seasoned central corporate team and
infrastructure to enable intelligent scaling of operations
Allocate combined pool of human capital efficiently and
to areas of greatest impact
Systematically Realize Potential
►
Formalize the unique "DNA" of company and infuse it
into growth scenarios
►
Guide expansion plans with 15-year company vision
► Allocate capital to optimal "brand building"
opportunities
Guided by these principles, we intend to significantly expand the
Carnegie business across four units...
The 4 Pillars of Carnegie Growth
1. NYC Flagship Restaurant & Catering:
Expand & systematize the existing business
"behind the scenes"
2. Big Box Licensing: License mid- to full-
scale Carnegie Deli restaurants in select
markets through synergistic and strategic
partnerships (e.g., hospitality groups, etc.)
3. Carnegie Express: Develop & operate and/
or franchise small-scale, fast casual
Carnegie Deli boxes in select markets
4. Wholesale Product Lines: Develop and
expand wholesale product partnerships with
retailers
EFTA01091914
New York City
Flagship Restaurant
Key Financials (2012 Pro-forma)
► $12.9MM Annual Net Sales
► 14.0% Operating Margin
► 10,000 Customers per Week
Immediate Focus
► Accept credit cards
► Install networked POS system
► Migrate to payroll processing system
► Digitize and integrate inventory management
► Implement repair and maintenance procedures
► Cleaning and repair cosmetic needs
► Audit financials
Growth Opportunities
► Exploit all day parts (breakfast, etc.)
► Focus on corporate sales & catering initiatives; develop
catering menu; create house accounts
► Expand delivery radius & improve delivery operations
► Grow hotel & concierge outreach
► Build nostalgic event schedule
Strategic Considerations
► Union labor & contracts
► Consistency of customer experience through transition
EFTA01091915
Big Box Licensing
Opportunity
o
License operating locations
o
Target tourist-rich, high-traffic and captive audience locations for licensing
opportunities (e.g., casinos, hotels, large theme parks, etc.)
►
Heighten regional U.S. awareness of brand; prep for follow-on introduction of
Carnegie Express and/or wholesale product lines
►
Expand footprint to international markets via trusted operating partners
(discussions progressing with multi-site hoteliers)
Target Unit Metrics
►
$6.00MM Annual Revenue (Avg)
►
License Fee = 6% of Revenue or $0.36MM of Royalty Income
►
Incremental Wholesale Revenue of $900K & EBITDA of $100K
Strategic Considerations
►
Premier real estate & operating partners (past Carnegie "lessons learned")
►
Market timing vis-a-vis other growth efforts (CD Express, wholesale lines)
•
Focus Markets
1. Los Angeles
2. Miami
3. Orlando
4. Washington, DC
5. Boston 1
EFTA01091916
Opportunity
►
Develop authentic, small-scale "grab-and-go" style restaurants
►
Limited menu offering of key products & favorites, more on-the-
go sizing & packaging, and a lower price point
►
Design would encapsulate key features of Carnegie Deli
flagship, yet entail a more repeat visit, less "tourist-centric"
layout & operating model
►
Multiple boxes per market, expanding beyond tourist-rich
centers targeted For Big Box Restaurants
Target Unit Metrics
►
$1.50MM Annual Revenue (Avg)
►
$0.75MM Build-out Cost
►
$0.27MM EBITDA (18%)
Strategic Considerations
►
Development of effective and efficient franchise operations
►
Balance between operating locations vs. franchised locations
►
Hub-and-spoke expansion, beginning in NYC Metro market
►
Prime real estate and locations catering to quick-service
migration patterns and population
EFTA01091917
Wholesale Supply & Product Lines
Opportunity
►
Following (or in conjunction with) brick-and-mortar restaurant
presence, establish wholesale relationships with regional
retailers
►
Expand & modernize current product distribution, while adding
new products to the line (breads/bagels, condiments, etc.) via
new subcontractor relationships.
►
Establish wholesale supply chain for operating locations, as well
as licensed and franchised locations.
Target Metrics
►
10% YOY Revenue Growth
►
12% Operating Margin
Strategic Considerations
►
Prioritizing products with high-margin + high-volume potential
►
In-house vs. 3rd party production of key, signature items
►
Master license program for regions and/or cities
EFTA01091918
Sources & Uses
►
$30.4MM will be needed at closing with an approximate 60/40 split of debt/equity.
►
Close to 90% of this capital will be used to purchase the businesses.
Sources
Acquisition Financing
$6,000,000
19.7%
Real Estate Mortgage
1,500,000
4.9%
Seller Note
6,000,000
19.7%
Mezzanine Financing
5,000,000
16.4%
Equity Investment
12,000,000
39.3%
Total Sources
30,500,000
100.0%
Uses
Purchase of The Businesses
$27,000,000
88.5%
Purchase of the NJ Real Estate
2,000,000
6.6%
Closing Costs
500,000
1.6%
Growth Capital
1,000,000
3.3%
Total Uses
30,500,000
100.0%
EFTA01091919
Development &
►
Careful & deliberate development schedule with moderate
ramp-up occurring in Year 2.
Development Schedule
Year
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
New License Deals
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
►
$1.2MM incremental revenue from New Business in Year 1,
Total License Deals
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
increasing to $50MM by Year 7.
New Express Boxes (Operate)
1
3
4
4
4
4
4
►
2.0x current revenue by Year 4 and 3.0x by Year 7.
New Express Boxes (Franchise)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Total Express Boxes
1
4
8
12
16
20
24
Wholesale Growth
10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10%
Key Assumptions
Revenues (In Thousands)
Pro-forma
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Existing
• Open 1 significant license location per year.
The Deli
512,961
$13,L50
513,221
$13,353
$13,487
513,622
513.758
$13,896
•
Ramp up development & openings of CD
Existing Licensing Fees
721
743
765
788
811
836
861
887
Express locations to 4 per year; own &
Existing Wholesale
9,875
10,369
10,887
11,431
12,003
12,603
13,233
13,895
operate 100% of locations.
Existing Revenue
23,557
24, 202
24,873
25,573
26,302
27,061
27,852
28,677
•
Existing & new business grows at 3% / yr.
New
•
License Deals entail 6% revenue license fee.
license Deals
0
180
551
933
1,326
1,731
2,1=9
Ex press Boxes (Operae)
750
3,795
9,226
15,593
22,151
28,905
35,863
•
All new locations (Big Box Licensing,
Express Boxes) open on 1-July of each year.
Ex press Boxes (Franchise)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
olemle
c
Lso
1,640
3,515
5,511
7,555
9,649
11,793
•
Annual Revenue: Big Box Licensing =
New Revenue
1.230
5,615
13,292
22,037
31,032
44286
49,804
$6MM; Express = $1.5MM.
•
New Wholesale includes (1) commissary for
Total Revenue
23,557
25,432
30,488
38,865
48,339
58,093
68,138
78,482
Big Box Licensing & Express Boxes and (2)
10% growth of distribution business per
year ($4.1MM of $9.9MM total pro-forma).
EFTA01091920
Express Boxes as primary contributor by Year 4, surpassing NYC Deli location; attractive unit-level economics & ability to develop.
License Deal cash flow entails minimal overhead & minimal finance/development capital outflows.
EBITDA (In Thousands)
Pro-forma
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Exi sting
The Deli
$1.816
$1,834
$1,853
$1,871
$1,890
$1,909
$1,928
$1,947
Existing Licensing Fees
7Oi
743
715
738
761
786
811
837
Existing Wholesale
980
1,037
1,082
1,143
1 2)0
1,260
1,323
1,390
Existing EBITDA
5500
3,614
5655
3,752
3,852
3,955
4,062
4,173
New
License Deals
0
0
120
551
933
1.326
1,731
2,149
Express Boxes (Ope rate )
0
135
633
1,661
2,807
3.987
5,203
6,455
Express Boxes (French se i
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Wholesale
C
58
197
422
661
907
1,158
1,415
New EBITDA
0
193
1,060
2,633
4,401
6,220
8,092
1Q019
Total Ea ITDA
3.50C
3.806
A 7:6
6,385
8,252
10,175
12,154
14192
SG&A
0
(509)
( 610)
(967)
(1,162)
(1,363)
( t 370)
(777)
De preciat ion & Amortiza ion
0
(1,700)
(1,925)
(2,225)
(2,525)
(2,825)
(3,125)
( 3,425)
Interest Expense
0
(1,138)
(1,210)
( 1, 300
(1,376)
(1,417)
(1,427)
( 1,404)
Income Taxes
0
(161)
( 340)
(727)
(1,185)
(1,67Q
(2,184)
(2,728)
Net Income
0
299
631
1,350
2,200
3,101
4,056
5,066
Key Assumptions
• Existing Business Operating Margins:
Deli = 14%; Wholesale = 10%
• New Business Operating Margins:
Big Box Licensing = 100%; Express = 18%;
Wholesale = 12%
• Corporate SG&A = 4%
• All Depreciation uses 10-year, straight line
method
• Income Taxes = 35%
EFTA01091921
Balance Sheet
Balance Sheet (In Thousands) Pro-forma
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Assets
Cash
$1,000
($669)
($1,872)
($2,546)
($428)
$2,490
$5,731
% 318
Accounts Receivable
0
966
1,123
1,357
1,605
1,860
2,123
2,394
bci sting Business Assets
29,000
28,050
26,8)0
25,150
23,700
22,250
21,300
19,850
New Express Boxes
0
675
2,625
5,025
7,125
8,925
10,425
11,625
Other Assets
0
75
150
225
300
375
450
525
Total ,:,.:,:sts
30.000
29,097
28.E5
29.211
32.302
35.900
40,029
39.712
Liabs & Equity
Accounts Payable
0
991
1,139
1,372
1,631
1,898
2,173
2,456
Senior Bank Financing
6.0)0
5,307
4,565
3,771
2,922
2,013
1,040
0
Real Estate Mortgage
1,500
1,469
1,436
1,401
1,365
1,326
1,286
1,244
Mezzanine Financing
5,030
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
0
Seller Note
6.000
4,000
2,000
0
0
0
0
0
CC/Express Financing
0
532
2,056
3,888
5,404
6,581
7,392
7,808
Total Liabilities
18.500
17,298
16,195
15,431
16,321
16,818
16,892
11,509
Preferred Stock
12,000
12,000
12,000
12.000
12,000
12.000
12,000
12,000
Retained Earnings
(500)
(2011
430
1,780
3,980
7,082
11,137
A203
Total Equity
11,500
11,799
12,430
13,780
15,980
19.082
23,137
28203
Total Liabs & Equity
30,030
29,097
28,E5
29,211
32,302
35,900
40,029
39.712
EFTA01091922
Cash Flow
Year
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Cash Flow (In Thousands)
Net I ncorre
$299
$631
$1,350
$2,200
$3,101
$4,056
$5,066
Depreciation & Amortization
1,700
1,925
2,225
2,525
2,825
3,125
3,425
Changes i n Operating Activities
25
(9)
(2)
12
12
12
12
Changes i n Financing Activiti es
(2,792)
(3,051)
(3,397)
(1,769)
(2,170)
(2,602)
(4066)
Changes in Investment Activities
(900)
( X0)
(850)
(850)
(850)
(1,350)
(850)
Beginning Cash Balance
1,000
(669)
(1,872)
(2,546)
(428)
2,490
5,731
Total Change in Cash
(1,669)
(1,204)
(674)
2,117
2,918
3,241
(413)
Ending Cash Balance
(669)
(1,872)
(2,546)
(428)
2,490
5,731
5,318
EFTA01091923
Our Team
David Mitchell
John Rigos / Andy Stern
Entrepreneurs
•
Over 30 years of finance, =
and real estate
investment experience.
•
10+ companies founded.
•
President of Mitchell Holdings LLC, completing
over $3.7B in transactions since 1991.
•
40 combined years investment and operations
experience.
Owner / Operators
•
16 combined years in the restaurant /
hospitality industry.
•
Managing Partner of Las Vegas Land Partners
LLC, developing the new Las Vegas Civic Center.
Investors
•
48 stores owned, developed and operated
across 6 brands.
•
Experienced owner & operator of multiple
businesses in the hospitality & gaming industries.
•
4 Board of Director seats across 3 non-profit
organizations.
• Operators of Acquired, Franchised & Original Concept Businesses
•
Broad Experience with Development & Growth Capital
• Robust Real Estate Investment Record
• Extensive Network of Industry Advisors & Experts
• Operational Focus on Human Capital
•
NYC Market Expertise (site selection, labor pool, unit-level =
EFTA01091924
Forum Discussions
This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.