From: Richard KahnCase 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 326 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/15/2015 Page 1 of 16
Case File
efta-efta01203754DOJ Data Set 9OtherSubbase Drydock
Date
Unknown
Source
DOJ Data Set 9
Reference
efta-efta01203754
Pages
3
Persons
0
Integrity
No Hash Available
Extracted Text (OCR)
Text extracted via OCR from the original document. May contain errors from the scanning process.
Subbase Drydock
PO Box 4429/ Parcel 162 Subbase
St. Thomas, USVI, 00803
T:(340) 776-2078 Fax:(340)779-8426
Name / Address
LSJ,LLC
Aryan McGuiness
775-8109
690-1487
Casey
Estimate
Date
Estimate #
4/14/2015
762
Terms
Project
Upon Complc...
Big N/LSJ Barge
Description
Qty
Cost
Total
Subbase and Island Rigging and Hydraulics reviewed projects that were on your "to do list" this
morning. I will list all projects that l can with a quote for each repair but first I would like to
comment on the condition of the LSJ Barge.
This vessel was hauled out at our yard three years ago . During that haul out Subbase quoted on
most of the items you have in this current list. It was surprising to see that our recommendations
were not completed and as a result the current condition of the vessel is not seaworthy. The overall
appearance of the vessels is that it looks neglected and repairs that were essential were cobbled
together in an effort to get by.
The LSJ Barge needs a major overhaul to make her seaworthy and to ensure an extended service
life.
Subbase in not interested in making any repairs that will not be done properly; nor are we interested
in patching anything together for a temporary fix.
I understand that some projects may be more important then others so I will try to list each project
individually.
Drydock hauling fees
I
1,500.00
1,500.00
Laydays: Approx 12
12
350.00
4,200.00
Electricity Fee: Hook Up
1
75.00
75.00
Electricity Fee: per day
12
60.00
720.00
5000 psi pressure wash
I
327.00
327.00
I & 2 ) Rudders: Subbase personnel examined the rudder room and we were able see major
corrosion on the transom. The hull plating has holes where sea water is seeping into the vessel.
I 20,000.00
20,000.00
The steering components need to be removed and cleaned, the rudders need to be removed and
serviced. The lower Pintle and gudgeons need service as well as the rudder stuffing box. I would
reserve 10k to 20k for this project. I have included pictures of this compartment.
Total
Signature
Page 1
EFTA01203754
Subbase Drydock
PO Box 4429/ Parcel 162 Subbase
St. Thomas, USVI, 00803
T:(340) 776-2078 Fax:(340)779-8426
Name / Address
LSJ,LLC
Arran McGuiness
775-8109
690-1487
Estimate
Date
Estimate #
4/14/2015
762
Terms
Project
Upon Comple...
Big N/LSJ Barge
Description
Qty
Cost
Total
3-A) Install two cylinders with stainless steel shafts; including all hoses back to engine room, with
stainless steel ends on all hoses. We will re-evaluate the valving and other engine room
components to see what can me reused vs. replaced.
1 45,000.00
45.000.00
We have been informed that the present pump is in good condition so we are not quoting on
replacement of pump. Labor and Materials will be S35-45,000.
3-B) "Ilte steel boxes that secure the cylinders to the hull are deteriorated and will need
replacement. Subbase recommends using stainless steel to eliminate the corrosion. Three years ago
we quoted S16,000.00 for both boxes and we will still honor this quote.
I 16.000 00
16.000 00
4) The exhaust system is in a non-repairable condition and needs replacement from the main engine
to the hull outlet. Our quote will include all new piping, flex joints, exhaust mixers, and new
exterior aluminum outlet. When system is complete it will be wrapped with a removable wire mesh
hi-temp blanket. The new system will be much quieter than the existing exhaust system. Labor and
material $21,000.00.
I 24.500 00
24,500.00
5) Engine mounts need to be de-scaled of rust. Bolts holding mounts need to be cleaned or
renewed and alignment from coupling to shaft needs to be checked and adjusted for proper
tolerances. An extensive review was completed of this drive train back in 2012 with repair
recommendations made at that time. I do not know if this problem was solved so to budget for this
I would reserve 5k to 7k for this project. (before exhaust system is finalized this alignment must be
done).
I
',000.00
7,000.00
6) Stuffing boxes: Subbase was informed that new stuffing boxes arc on hand and will be owner
supplied, after haulout removal of hose joining stuffing box to shaft log will reveal the condition of
shaft log. I would reserve 5k for this project.
1
5,000.00
5,000.00
Total
Signature
Page 2
EFTA01203755
Subbase Drydock
PO Box 4429/ Parcel 162 Subbase
St. Thomas, USVI, 00803
T:(340) 776-2078 Fax:(340)779-8426
Name / Address
LSJ.I.LC
Arran McGuiness
775-8109
690-1487
casey
Estimate
Date
Estimate #
4/14/2015
762
Terms
Project
Upon Comple...
Big N/LSJ Barge
Description
Qty
Cost
Total
Cutless bearings require removal of main shafts and propellers: After removal of coupling, shafts
and props a condition report will follow if drive train is serviceable the routine maintenance for
renewing cutless bearing will only need attention. Labor and material for this is (both port and
starboard) $4,150.00.
I
4,150.00
4,150.00
8) Engine Cooling Grid: Pressure test system and issue report for this service. Reserve $1,200.00
I
1,200.00
1,200.00
9) Bottom paint and barrier coat: Labor and material $7,500.00.
I
7,500.00
7,500.00
10) Engine and marine gear - Review upon haul out — QUOTE WILL BE ISSUED --
0.00
0.00
I I) Fuel tank: Cleaning and disposal
1 2,800.00
2,800.00
Items I2 thni 18 will need more time to evaluate -- QUOTES WILL BE ISSUED ---
19) Clean engine room: Before any repairs are started clean and degrease entire engine room,
dispose of oily water. After repairs are complete clean and paint engines and any other areas that
were painted. Remove engine hatch covers and assess condition. Make necessary repairs and
reinstall after all. Labor and material $5,500.00
I
5,500.00
5,500.00
20) Hydraulic Tank: Due to severe corrosion of the steel hydraulic tank, Subbase reccomends
replacing tank with new marine grade aluminum tank complete with all necessary finings and sight
glass to view levels. Labor and Materials.
1
5,000.00
5,000.00
Total
1150,472.00
Signature
Page 3
EFTA01203756
Technical Artifacts (5)
View in Artifacts BrowserEmail addresses, URLs, phone numbers, and other technical indicators extracted from this document.
Fax
Fax:(340)779-8426Phone
(340) 776-2078Phone
(340)779-8426Phone
690-1487Phone
775-8109Forum Discussions
This document was digitized, indexed, and cross-referenced with 1,400+ persons in the Epstein files. 100% free, ad-free, and independent.
Annotations powered by Hypothesis. Select any text on this page to annotate or highlight it.