ROY BLACK

ROY BLACK HOWARD M. SREDNICK SCOTT A. KORNSPAN LARRY A. STUMPF MAFIA NEYRA JACKIE PERCZEK MARK A.J. SHAPIRO JARED LOPEZ BLACK SREBNICK KORNSPAN STUMPF PA April S, 2010 DELIVERY BY ELECTRONIC MAIL Assistant Untied States Attorney 500 South Australian Avenue West Palm Beach, FL 33401-6223 Dea RE: Jeffrey Epstein JESSICA FONSECA-NADER KATHLEEN P. PHILLIPS AARON ANTHON MARCOS BEATON, JR. MATTHEW P. O'BRIEN JENIPER J. SOULIKIAS NOAH Fox E-Mail: We are in receipt of the letter authored by you on April 2, 2010. Although we respectfully disagree with your conclusion that a civil pleading which challenges a Complaint for its facial legal deficiencies and seeks only to raise substantial and unresolved legal issues regarding 18 USC §2255 (which, if allowed, would lead only to the plaintiff amending her filing rather than having it dismissed with prejudice) could constitute a breach of Mr. Epstein's NPA obligations, we appreciate your having reviewed the draft p